Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what Philip Scofield did wrong?

263 replies

redroseq · 20/05/2023 20:20

I’m not a fan of Phil or Holly and have never watched This Morning. However, I’ve read about the issues the show has been facing in the news recently and am at a loss to understand why Phil had to step down. What did he actually do wrong?

I know his brother has been imprisoned for a heinous crime but obviously that’s nothing to do with Phil. So I don’t understand why he decided to resign.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Willmafrockfit · 21/05/2023 06:16

the boy was 16 so PS was told
should he have gone to the police on his brother?
would you go to the police?
either way i guess he knew it was his downfall

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 03:16

TommyNever · 21/05/2023 02:18

Get a grip please people, Telly Land isn't real life. "Phil & Holly" are celebs playing a role for the cameras.

What they're really like is anyone's guess (and of no real interest) and what the gossip columns say is unlikely to be trustworthy.

It isn't about them playing a role on TV. It's about court transcripts and written reports, neither of which have anything to do with presenting.

SargentSagittarius · 21/05/2023 02:23

TommyNever · 21/05/2023 02:18

Get a grip please people, Telly Land isn't real life. "Phil & Holly" are celebs playing a role for the cameras.

What they're really like is anyone's guess (and of no real interest) and what the gossip columns say is unlikely to be trustworthy.

Well, clearly it is of real interest to very many people. Like it or not.

TommyNever · 21/05/2023 02:18

Get a grip please people, Telly Land isn't real life. "Phil & Holly" are celebs playing a role for the cameras.

What they're really like is anyone's guess (and of no real interest) and what the gossip columns say is unlikely to be trustworthy.

slore · 21/05/2023 02:11

As far as I can tell, rumour is that Philth has a preference for barely legal very young men. One was apparently groomed, probably with the promise of breaking into TV.

Rumour is that Scofield especially and Willoughby are horrible behind the scenes, and they've clearly upset many lowlier ranking celebrities in their reign at the top of ITV, hence all the cryptic tweets from celebs.

It shows how ruthless and fake Holly is that she has just thrown him under the bus now that his presence is too damaging for her. She knew what he was like and didn't mind being friends with him when it benefitted her.

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/05/2023 01:17

redroseq · 20/05/2023 21:21

Apparently he’s still gonna be working for ITV - just not on This Morning!

Give it a couple of weeks. Scofe is TV history.

SargentSagittarius · 21/05/2023 01:17

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:35

I don't know what's true, like you I can only read, what's reported by the papers.
Moral compass or not, the legal age of consent is 16. Its an individual choice whether you cut off a family member because of the age of there partner. I think there is a lot more too it.

It’s perfectly legal to have an affair. To emotionally abuse your partner. To bully people. And yes, to embark on a relationship with a 16YO when you’re in your 60s. But they’re all kind of frowned upon by society.

So don’t be surprised when people do exactly that.

Otherland · 21/05/2023 01:08

SeaWitchly · 20/05/2023 23:25

Both Phil and Hol are a pair of wrong 'uns.,, for all the reasons stated above but I was massively turned off the pair of them for the blatant bias demonstrated in the general election. They hectored the leader of the Labour party, Jeremy Corbyn, and then cosied up with Boris Johnson taking selfies. Manipulative, fame hungry, sycophants the pair of them.

Exactly. I could never stand PS or HW, never could understand their appeal or how they got these jobs, but the horrible behaviour to JC, vs fawning over the vile BJ made them irredeemable to me.

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 01:01

SargentSagittarius · 21/05/2023 00:57

Incredible it needs explaining @Aaaaandbreathe, but here we are.

Isn't it just!

SargentSagittarius · 21/05/2023 00:57

Incredible it needs explaining @Aaaaandbreathe, but here we are.

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 00:53

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:35

I don't know what's true, like you I can only read, what's reported by the papers.
Moral compass or not, the legal age of consent is 16. Its an individual choice whether you cut off a family member because of the age of there partner. I think there is a lot more too it.

I agree with you there. It is an individual choice, and his individual choice means a lot of people don't like him because we consider 16 to be barely the age of consent. I might be wrong, but I would hazard a guess the age of consent is so sexually active 16 years aren't charged with an offence for having sex with other teenagers when they have reached puberty. Doubt the reason was for middle aged men. This is a reason children are in care until 18, and can't (not sure if this has changed) get married without parents permission until 18, as they are vulnerable.

Focusing solely on legislation does not change the fact most people think it's abhorrent. It wasn't a 16 year old and a 22 year old (which a lot would still disagree with), it's a middle aged man taking advantage of a teenager. That goes for both of them. PS just won't get charged because, as you say, the legal age of consent is 16. Lucky him.

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:41

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:27

If you read the transcripts of the case I think you wouldn't have much doubt that PS knew how old the boy was and the circumstances around the abuse.

I've looked for them previously but all I get is newspaper stories even when I specify court transcripts.
Do you have a link?

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:35

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 00:16

Some people may not believe it's true, not sure I do, but I am going by the facts and 16 is as bad as 15 or 14 if you have a moral compass.

I don't know what's true, like you I can only read, what's reported by the papers.
Moral compass or not, the legal age of consent is 16. Its an individual choice whether you cut off a family member because of the age of there partner. I think there is a lot more too it.

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:27

If you read the transcripts of the case I think you wouldn't have much doubt that PS knew how old the boy was and the circumstances around the abuse.

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:26

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:04

And he didn't cut ties until it came out 3 years later in Court. That's the facts, not a media shit storm.

When he learnt the truth?
If PS is to be believed he was told the boy was 16.
Wouldn't you like to think that your family member was telling the truth rather the alternative of the being a scum of the earth?

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:23

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 00:09

'but of age'?

Yes it is gross and a few months before he would have been under age. Absolutely nothing wrong with vilifying him for that.

If your 16 year old son had a sexual relationship with a man (or woman) decades older, would that not concern you? Some children don't leave school until 18. Do you not think that is an abuse of power? This isn't hearsay.

Legally he may not have been able to report it as 16 is the age of consent (if it's to be believed he didn't know it was younger), but morally he should have cut him off right there and then...unless he also thinks 16 year olds are fair game for a man of his age.

Sickening people would defend this.

Yes of age, that is the age of consent.

I'm not in anyway condoning the actions of PS brother. Its sickening and he needs castrating but vilifying PS for not reporting what he was told was a consensual relationship with a person of age (according to him).
If he went to the police and said my brother is with a 16 year old there isn't much the police could have done, potentially a wellbeing check but no guarantee.

I know several gay couples with large age gaps. There's plenty of celebrity couples too Google it.

You can believe I'm sickening all you like. Age gaps exist, like it or not.

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:20

He was 13 when sexual contact started, hence his 12 year prison sentence. We have all been around long enough to know 12 years are not given out for a bit of inappropriate behaviour. And PS knew about the underage contact. He has admitted it in Court, but his arrogance lead him to believe people would understand why he didn't report it. Like plenty before, he believes in an inate indestructibility because he has become arrogant and entitled, facilitated by a fawning employer.
His lack of self awareness became very obvious when he 'came out' as it was all about him and how brave he was. His statement about his friendship with H another failure to read the room. It will be interesting to see if he really does present the new prime time show ITV said he is working on.

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 00:16

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:10

I didn't dispute the age of the brothers victim, just what PS had been told. According to PS he was told the boy was 16 which is over the age of consent.
People are choosing to believe this untrue but it's speculation.
I guess only time will tell if the police believe he was enabling a sex offender they will seek to charge him. He's not exactly loved by the public right now, it wouldn't be any backlash on the police. If anything right now the public would praise the police because the hate him.

Some people may not believe it's true, not sure I do, but I am going by the facts and 16 is as bad as 15 or 14 if you have a moral compass.

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:10

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:02

The boy was well underage when sexual contact was initiated and PS was told by his brother a d he stated it in a sworn statement. These are facts established in Court. Hence the 12 years imprisonment, which you don't actually get for having sex with someone above the age of consent.

I didn't dispute the age of the brothers victim, just what PS had been told. According to PS he was told the boy was 16 which is over the age of consent.
People are choosing to believe this untrue but it's speculation.
I guess only time will tell if the police believe he was enabling a sex offender they will seek to charge him. He's not exactly loved by the public right now, it wouldn't be any backlash on the police. If anything right now the public would praise the police because the hate him.

Aaaaandbreathe · 21/05/2023 00:09

Chickenballsandcheese · 20/05/2023 23:56

This is what I genuinely hate about the media, the absolute shit storm of rumours.
If it's true, PS was told by his brother the boy was 16, gross but of age. He cut ties when he discovered the truth according to what he said in court.
The Queens coffin, sure they weren't the only media there but others aren't in the firing line of the press or public? And David Beckham is a hero for been patient?
He came out as gay, many people do it, even when they've been married. If you believe the press his wife (yup still married) supports him.
Phil and holly fall out. Shock horror!!! People can fall out, grow apart etc.
Rumours of grooming the runner are just rumours. Until it's proven, it's just click bait. Maybe David Beckham can give us a few hints on been patient till the proof of the super injunction are actually provided. I've read about it, see videos about it etc never actually seen a copy of the proof it exists.

I'm not even a this morning fan, it's all a bit dull but I bloody hate the media. It fires out rumours as gospel. If you see it enough you start believing it.

'but of age'?

Yes it is gross and a few months before he would have been under age. Absolutely nothing wrong with vilifying him for that.

If your 16 year old son had a sexual relationship with a man (or woman) decades older, would that not concern you? Some children don't leave school until 18. Do you not think that is an abuse of power? This isn't hearsay.

Legally he may not have been able to report it as 16 is the age of consent (if it's to be believed he didn't know it was younger), but morally he should have cut him off right there and then...unless he also thinks 16 year olds are fair game for a man of his age.

Sickening people would defend this.

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:09

Lampzade · 20/05/2023 22:00

Phil has burnt his bridges. He is unpopular with many of his fellow celebrities , was involved in a dodgy relationship with a young runner and did not report a pedo to the police.
Furthermore, he is an arrogant twat of a man who treats people like shit .
I have never liked him.
Good riddance to bad rubbish

I think that about sums it up

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:04

And he didn't cut ties until it came out 3 years later in Court. That's the facts, not a media shit storm.

ClareBlue · 21/05/2023 00:02

Chickenballsandcheese · 20/05/2023 23:56

This is what I genuinely hate about the media, the absolute shit storm of rumours.
If it's true, PS was told by his brother the boy was 16, gross but of age. He cut ties when he discovered the truth according to what he said in court.
The Queens coffin, sure they weren't the only media there but others aren't in the firing line of the press or public? And David Beckham is a hero for been patient?
He came out as gay, many people do it, even when they've been married. If you believe the press his wife (yup still married) supports him.
Phil and holly fall out. Shock horror!!! People can fall out, grow apart etc.
Rumours of grooming the runner are just rumours. Until it's proven, it's just click bait. Maybe David Beckham can give us a few hints on been patient till the proof of the super injunction are actually provided. I've read about it, see videos about it etc never actually seen a copy of the proof it exists.

I'm not even a this morning fan, it's all a bit dull but I bloody hate the media. It fires out rumours as gospel. If you see it enough you start believing it.

The boy was well underage when sexual contact was initiated and PS was told by his brother a d he stated it in a sworn statement. These are facts established in Court. Hence the 12 years imprisonment, which you don't actually get for having sex with someone above the age of consent.

Chickenballsandcheese · 21/05/2023 00:01

Say the NDA is actually coming to an end for the show runner and he comes out and says actually it was a completely innocent relationship, he's not commented because of the NDA. He left TM for loose women cause the hours were better and he wanted a bit of variety.
what then will the public stop hounding PS?

There's no actual proof a romantic relationship, inappropriate of otherwise as far as I can see on my Google searching. Just proof the knew/worked together and pots of rumours.

ClareBlue · 20/05/2023 23:59

redroseq · 20/05/2023 20:29

And how does anyone know for a fact that he was aware of what his brother did but didn’t go to the police? That seems unlikely?!

He said it in a sworn statement, if that helps

Swipe left for the next trending thread