Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cut DD's beautiful hair short?

229 replies

Eurydice84 · 20/05/2023 08:48

DD (4yo) has beautiful blonde hair, down to her bottom. It has lovely curls but she absolutely hates having it brushed, so the result is often a tangled mop of knots. We also go swimming two or three times a week in the pool, and despite using a swimming cap and hair masks the chlorine is not very kind to her hair. We decided to cut it in a French bob (think Amelie from the movie) and donate to the Little Princess Trust, but I am getting a lot of "oh poor her" comments. People saying it might be easier to have long hair for reception next year, as it can be tied in a ponytail? I am planning to use Alice bands and barrettes but not sure whether they are allowed at primary school?

OP posts:
Chipperfish · 20/05/2023 09:40

Do you have curly hair yourself? How curly is her hair - is it waves or coils?

Ive always had curly hair that was long and badly handled when I was a kid (not deliberately but it wasn't really thought about/a thing to deal differently with curly hair then, standard family shampoo etc, daily brushing) I was always miserable with it being brushed/styled and hated it as a teen because I always looked frizzy and scruffy, because it was dry and badly handled. Curly products and methods totally changed how I feel about it.
I have used them with both DS and DD (shes currently got waist length curls she wants to keep for now and DS has had all sorts of lengths from his waist length corona hair to chopping it for a 'meet me at mcdonalds' look. I decided I had to teach them to look after and embrace their curls early so they didnt grow up like me, unhappy with their natural look, feeling it was a problem and wasting time and money on pointless styling that only ever made me look frizzier and tangle worse.

I would suggest looking up the curly girl method, (paraben sulphate and silicon free products). There are some great advice threads on here and other sites. What works for DD is not washing every day, tonnes of conditioner, wet combing and detangling spray (wet conditioner comb for nit check, shes never yet had any) and no dry brushing, air or turban to dry. Plaits when shes most active and swimming. It will never look or be like straight hair, always a bit more difficult to manage but there are ways to make it much easier for both her and you - work with the curl rather than against it.
By all means have it trimmed to neaten the ends, it can get straggly and of course if your daughter really wants it cut shorter then do it but its not an either/or - and badly handled curly hair doesnt become miraculously easier because its cut shorter.

SarahAndQuack · 20/05/2023 09:40

Definitely do it. When she was 5 my DD had her hair cut from well below shoulder length to above her ears and she's never looked back. It makes mornings so much easier. I did have a slight concern she might hate it and then be sad it'd take so long to grow, but she loved it. And a bob is a recognisable 'girl' cut so there's no 'she looks like a boy' bit to negotiate (we negotiate this bit but DD doesn't care so it doesn't matter).

hereistopositiveenergy · 20/05/2023 09:39

Sounds similar to my DSD at that age. To be honest, a lot of the tats when brushing was due to not using the correct hair products for her hair so we brought her specifically for curly hair ones.

I use cantu leave in conditioner mixed in a spray bottle with water. This is spritzed into her hair every day before brushing and styling even if it's being kept down. On swimming or club days, I just spray a little bit extra on after she's out the pool for example so if it starts drying before we get home to do a proper hair wash, it isn't dry as such. For the showering/washing of it, I just just the cantu again - tried the kids specifically one but found the adult one was just as good and more value for money. With conditioner I brush through once applied, scrunch up and then very loosely rinse. Use a microfibre towel for hair wrapping, touch drying and change her pillow case to a silk pillowcase.

On nights her hairs either in a very loose bun at the top of her head or plaited quickly. She's now 9 and does this all herself and still use the cantu products - the grape seed gel is fantastic for school as it stops flyaways when in a pony and if plaited or curly, I just spritz the water with conditioner then run a little through to stop any friction. Never had an issue since with her crying at brushing except when she's not put any leave in conditioner in for a few days and her hairs dried out despite not feeling as such.

CoffeeYes · 20/05/2023 09:34

Cantthinkofaname2203 · 20/05/2023 09:17

Why is a bob “really extreme”

lots of girls, women, and even boys have bob styles.

nothing even slightly extreme about it.

I have long hair so yes, if I cut my hair into a Bob then it would be really extreme. It’s a huge change. Obviously different if you’ve always had mid length hair and then cut it into a Bob.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 20/05/2023 09:32

That said, I'd still probably cut it - maybe shoulder length first to see how you get on before full on bob?

StepAwayFromGoogling · 20/05/2023 09:31

You don't need to brush curly hair, OP. Look at the curly girl method, can't think why you can't use it on a child. Just loads of conditioner and only brush when wet with loads of conditioner in.

TheFallenMadonna · 20/05/2023 09:30

A bob is a great style for a small child.

Mutabiliss · 20/05/2023 09:28

If she has very curly hair it might be easier to manage with some length, rather than a short bob. But if she doesn't care, why have you let it get so long in the first place? I've had bum-length hair, it's a total pain to manage and mine is pin-straight.

Just cut it!

KimberleyClark · 20/05/2023 09:28

I'm surprised that so many think a bob is such an extreme cut and it's very tiresome to see the same nonsense trotted out about long princess hair being the most desirable.

Not only tiresome but really depressing. It seems it’s fine for boys to buck gender stereotypes and wear their hair long, but for girls to wear their hair short shock horror nooooooo! I had a pixie cut at intervals as a child and it was just so freeing being able to run and jump and climb without a load of hair flapping about and getting caught.

GetTheTrain · 20/05/2023 09:27

She hates having her long hair brushed. So cut it short. Why do other people’s opinions matter so much to you? IRL and on MN.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 20/05/2023 09:26

As a child I had waist length hair which constantly got tangled. My DM trimmed it and when I was 9 cut too much off by accident so my best friend’s DM who used to be a hairdresser was roped in in a hurry that evening to give me a long bob to my shoulders!

My DNephew who’s almost 5 has hair to his shoulders (I think a bit below this). It’s a pain for his parents as he hates having it washed and blow dried but they and him like it being long. However he has said he’d be fine with it being like Harry Potter.

I’d cut your daughter’s hair and see how she gets on with it.

Similar to a few PPs here I’ve known a few children with shorter hair when they were younger and there wasn’t much choice in the matter, it was that way because it was easier to handle.

JaninaDuszejko · 20/05/2023 09:23

Boys with short hair get nits too. Small children get nits from each other because they put their heads together when playing or working together. Hair length has nothing to do with it, the nits live near the root of the hair, not down at the ends.

HagsGlen · 20/05/2023 09:22

Sounds like a no-brainer to lose some length, and definitely not something that needs to be discussed with other people.

To be honest, OP, given that she hates having it brushed, and doesn’t seem at all attached to the idea of long hair, I’m wondering whose idea it was to grow it so very long — yours, presumably?

Pot8ohs · 20/05/2023 09:22

Some people are just weird. It’s not cruel or sad to cut her hair to a manageable and practical length. She’s not a pretty doll just to be looked. Having to sit through detangling is unpleasant for both of you!

A bob will be lovely. I would have it just long enough that at least half can be tied back off her face.

MuffinToSeeHere · 20/05/2023 09:21

Mrsmillshorse · 20/05/2023 09:18

You just need to spend on proper hair care products to get rid of the knots and keep it moisturised.

The John Frieda de frizz range is amazing and worth the money IMO. The serum is brilliant and doesn't dry out the hair. Lasts to the next wash.

Or you know just cut the hair. She doesn't need to buy expensive products when cutting the hair will solve the issue.

I'm surprised that so many think a bob is such an extreme cut and it's very tiresome to see the same nonsense trotted out about long princess hair being the most desirable.

Mrsmillshorse · 20/05/2023 09:19

Also recommend the preventative nit spray detangler you can get from Boots, expensive but works!

So nit spray x2 wk and john frieda serum 1-2x week

gannett · 20/05/2023 09:19

I don't see the problem. You've decided with your daughter on a new hairstyle that sounds lovely and will be much more convenient for her. If she decides she actually liked it long, the hair will grow back. Everyone butting in with "oh poor her" comments is being weird and needs to butt back out again.

Onelifeonly · 20/05/2023 09:18

One of mine has thick, dry, easily tangled hair. Brushing it was a nightmare when she was young - even when wet and plastered in conditioner. She also used to screech at every tangle making the process even more painful. Having it collar / shoulder length was so much easier.

As a teen she got better at brushing it herself and keeping it tangle free (and faffing with it for hours became one of her hobbies!) so she then could have it very long and it looks amazing.

Cut your dd's hair - it will grow again and when she can look after it herself, she can have it long.

Mrsmillshorse · 20/05/2023 09:18

You just need to spend on proper hair care products to get rid of the knots and keep it moisturised.

The John Frieda de frizz range is amazing and worth the money IMO. The serum is brilliant and doesn't dry out the hair. Lasts to the next wash.

DyslexicPoster · 20/05/2023 09:18

Sorry I read it as its cut now? As someone with long hair and a dd with long hair I find it's easier to manage by cutting a few inches off and regularly trims so long can work. Dd has hair tied up at school and has less nits than he brothers with very short hair. I get a £1.60 hair oil from Tesco and even it was un brushed for days I could brush waist length hair it in under two minutes. Long hair takes effort that's true but the nits thing and attraching them I haven't found to be true

Oysterbabe · 20/05/2023 09:17

Definitely chop it, it's just hair.
Long hair is probably the first thing where little girls are exposed to pain and inconvenience for the sake of their appearance. Later they'll have plucking, waxing, heels, dye, control underwear, botox etc etc. Give her a practical haircut and tell anyone who comments to mind their own business.

Cantthinkofaname2203 · 20/05/2023 09:17

CoffeeYes · 20/05/2023 09:15

Maybe have it cut to the middle or bottom of her ribs. Still long enough to tie up and style, but easier to maintain than bum length hair. I wouldn’t opt for a Bob as that’s really extreme.

Why is a bob “really extreme”

lots of girls, women, and even boys have bob styles.

nothing even slightly extreme about it.

BelindaBears · 20/05/2023 09:16

Pippylongstock · 20/05/2023 09:13

Just cut it. Others are projecting, it’s her hair and she doesn’t want to be in pain every day. I get that.

This. Waist length “Disney” hair is wholly impractical on a 4 year old who hates having it brushed and styled. Make life easier for everyone.

Effieswig · 20/05/2023 09:16

If she is happy to have it cut then have it cut.

Personally I would go a bit longer to tie up. DDs school had a real problem with nits. She was the only one that didn’t get them multiple times. I used to spray her hair with tea tree in some water and then tie it up, after she got them the first time. Did the trick.

Swipe left for the next trending thread