Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there must be another way? Dog shelters

65 replies

Steppingintome · 20/05/2023 07:53

I get it. Some of these dogs have had a crap life. These guys see dogs in some right states and they must be paired with the right homes. I get it I do.

But some of the rules just seem so bizarre!

I grew up with dogs as did DH. We haven’t had a pet since the early days of our relationship and this pet passed away 8 years ago. We live in a large house. Our children are adults/older teens. We have a large secure garden. DH works from home so is in all day. We love animals.

We wanted to adopt a dog as we go walking a lot and thought we’d meet ideal criteria. Ideally the dog would be small to medium breed, we’d consider a bigger dog if it wasn’t too boisterous and ideally the dog would be older than a year old but again, not too fussy.

All seems ok right?

We applied to the shelter. They came to do a home check and said our home was lovely. They met the kids and agreed they were older and calm so most dogs would suit. Then they asked for a reference from a vet. I said we couldn’t provide this as we don’t have a pet. They asked for a reference from an employer but we are both self employed. They asked if we had employees? I said no.

Sorry we can’t let you adopt!! :( we asked if a friend or family member could give us a ref, no it can’t be from them. One of them is a dog groomer. No sorry

We applied to another rescue. Straight no because they are still building on our new build estate. Even though our street is finished and they are nowhere near us now.

Wtf am I being unreasonable to think something has to change? No wonder they are all overrun?

OP posts:
MayThe4th · 20/05/2023 09:46

And the reason why breed specific rescues work so well is because they’re actually dealing with specific breeds. So if you want to adopt a lab or a Maltese or a poodle you know that the lab or Maltese or poodle rescue isn’t going to be overflowing with unrehomeable staffies and Rottweilers and are going to concentrate on those dogs who actually do make decent pets.

It’s the same with cats though. I’ve been trying to adopt a cat for two years and I’m either rejected for no apparent reason or the rescues just never return my calls. And you can’t visit any of them without an appointment any more or without first passing a home check, so gone are the days when you could nip down to Battersea or RSPCA or any of the other cat rescues and have a look at the cats you might like to adopt.

It would actually be easier to just have a baby than it is to adopt a dog or a cat.

MayThe4th · 20/05/2023 09:40

All this talk of how dogs are so damaged they can’t be rehomed to this or that is just bollocks though.

We’re not talking about a baby here, we’re talking about a dog. If dogs are so damaged that they are almost impossible to rehome then they need to be put down. Sorry if it’s not politically correct to say that but there is nothing to be achieved by having a dog which either can’t be rehomed and is going to spend its life in kennels, or is so damaged that even on the off chance it is rehomed it is a risk to other people and animals around it.

Rescues aren’t overflowing because of the amount of unwanted puppies relinquished to them, they’re overflowing because of the amount of unrehomeable dogs they have, but because they want to stick to some kind of no kill agenda because of the potential for backlash, they hang on to the unsuitable dogs, meaning they don’t have the resources to take in the genuinely rehomeable ones.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 20/05/2023 09:39

I volunteer with a breed specific rescue and those rules sound bonkers.

elm26 · 20/05/2023 09:36

My friend has 2 rescues from the same place, she went to rescue a third 2 years later and they'd changed their policy to you have to be 30 or over to adopt. So they wouldn't let her adopt another for a year as she was 29 at the time, even though they got regular updates about how happy the other 2 were and what a lovely life they have. Very bizarre.

Ylvamoon · 20/05/2023 09:35

I'd do my research and get an ex breeding bitch or a puppy.

I get the home check to ensure you are who you say you are as well as helping with matching the right dog for your environment.

But the references thing is ridiculous... ok I get the vet but from your employer/ employees??? Sorry but some things are private and that includes my hobbies/ who I share my life with.

Blomonje · 20/05/2023 09:33

We also gave up trying to adopt from a shelter. They told us that it wasn’t possible to have a dog living with a child under 8. But we already had a dog living with our child until she passed away a few months ago, we said. So it’s nonsense to say that a dog can’t live with a child under 8. Surely it’s just a case of picking a dog which is ok with kids? Nope, they said. You can’t have a dog if your child is under 8. So we went and got a puppy instead. And the dog has happily lived with DC for two years, despite the fact that he is still under 8.

Lamelie · 20/05/2023 09:32

If I was rehoming a dog to someone who had had dogs before I’d be reassured to know he’d been taken to the vets. The vets would have (I can’t remember if they were out in touch with Battersea before we got new dog) we’d taken her regularly, sought treatment promptly.

MagicSpring · 20/05/2023 09:31

ThatAbsoluteFkr · 20/05/2023 09:01

Yes, my friend is looking for a 2nd small dog. She lives alone, no children, no other animal apart from her small, dog friendly dog.

She cannot get a rescue anywhere. They all say must be only dog in home. She also doesn't officially have a garden for dogs to go off lead but she has greenery all round and a park 5 mins away. Her dog is very happy with this but because she doesn't have an official fenced in garden she is rejected for that too.

One of the rescues I looked at recently had dogs that could only go to a home with an existing dog. If I can remember which one it was I’ll put it on the thread.

OP, I’m self-employed and our rescue were happy with a reference from a long-standing regular client (who was surprised but rather charmed to be asked).

redboxer321 · 20/05/2023 09:27

Lamelie · 20/05/2023 09:22

A vet reference for a second time owner is an excellent idea actually. But yes impossible for a first time owner.

Please show your workings.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 20/05/2023 09:26

Fandabedodgy · 20/05/2023 08:56

Rescue dogs are often damaged by their experiences.

These rules in in place so they don't place a dog where there is a risk of it being triggered and hurting or killing Simone.

I understand certain rules - secure gardens, no young DC or no cats, for example - but what benefit is it of it to anyone to ask for a vet reference, or an employer reference?

What does that prove?

Doggydarling · 20/05/2023 09:24

I used to volunteer as a home checker, we were independent but worked for numerous shelters, we'd a list of questions and had to take photos of the garden and ensure it was secure, all very sensible stuff but I quit recently because I couldn't understand the shelters procedures after the checks were done. I did a home check over a year ago, despite it being a long way from where I live it turned out I knew the people years ago, semi retired,one at home all the time, adult children, secure garden, experienced dog owners, family next door to pet sit if needed,vet references, every single box ticked off, no preference to male or female, just wanted a small dog of any age under 5 so I thought perfect, there's so many needing homes it'll take no time to match them up with a new pet. Over a year later they finally got a dog from the shelter that requested the home check be done, I spoke to the new owners, they were never given a reason, just left waiting, if they rang or emailed they were told someone will be in touch when a suitable dog is available despite the shelter constantly putting up pictures and videos of dogs needling homes and asking people to consider them. None of it makes sense to me so I've taken my name off the list of volunteers.

Lamelie · 20/05/2023 09:22

redboxer321 · 20/05/2023 09:18

In what way does a vet or employer reference stop a dog hurting or killing someone? Ditto living in an area where there is no building work going on.

A vet reference for a second time owner is an excellent idea actually. But yes impossible for a first time owner.

redboxer321 · 20/05/2023 09:18

Fandabedodgy · 20/05/2023 08:56

Rescue dogs are often damaged by their experiences.

These rules in in place so they don't place a dog where there is a risk of it being triggered and hurting or killing Simone.

In what way does a vet or employer reference stop a dog hurting or killing someone? Ditto living in an area where there is no building work going on.

HatchlingDragon · 20/05/2023 09:05

.....but cry poverty and lack of ability to help more dogs!

HatchlingDragon · 20/05/2023 09:04

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 20/05/2023 08:57

Very true.

Our rescue has permanent sponsor dogs - those which cannot be rehomed for a variety of reasons, so they live permanently at the rescue.

This is what I mean......I think I disagree these dogs should even be in rescue. Going to an event soon where I will actively avoid a certain dog charity who will be there, because they always want to push 'sponsoring' their dogs who will never be suitable to rehome.

Thesunwillcomeoutverysoon · 20/05/2023 09:03

It's a shame they can't vet for abusive men though. My friend had to wait til her dc were over 5. Fair enough.. Poor ddog she did get felt the wrath of a bastard man instead of an overzealous dc..
Thankfully my mate told me and I reported him to the rescue and ddog was removed. Hopefully soon enough it wasn't put off men forever..

ThatAbsoluteFkr · 20/05/2023 09:01

FrenchBoule · 20/05/2023 08:23

A couple of years ago I had a look at rescue centre. Every single dog had a note “ not suitable for home with children and other animals”

Yes, my friend is looking for a 2nd small dog. She lives alone, no children, no other animal apart from her small, dog friendly dog.

She cannot get a rescue anywhere. They all say must be only dog in home. She also doesn't officially have a garden for dogs to go off lead but she has greenery all round and a park 5 mins away. Her dog is very happy with this but because she doesn't have an official fenced in garden she is rejected for that too.

Name99 · 20/05/2023 08:58

I had the same with a local cat rescue.
I lived in a cul de sac that was near to a dual carriageway, the house backed on to woodland, fields a quarry and farmers land.
We were told no as too close to the dual carriageway, half of the people on the cul de sac had cats, never had one run over, I ended up buying 2 kittens privately but would have loved to have adopted.
The cats from the street had the sense to play in the fields rather than the dual carriageway.

Lamelie · 20/05/2023 08:57

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 20/05/2023 08:49

See, now while I think some rescues are OTT, this also strikes me as being pretty irresponsible.

The no home visit was 16 years ago, we had to provide proof of address and visit with everyone who’d be living with ddog. Having looked after that dog for so long they gave us another one. Both times the process was about a month, I guess ‘sticking with the process’ is some proof you’re going to be a diligent owner. 3 other families in our peer group were going through it the first time round and we were the only ones who got a dog Halo

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 20/05/2023 08:57

Fandabedodgy · 20/05/2023 08:56

Rescue dogs are often damaged by their experiences.

These rules in in place so they don't place a dog where there is a risk of it being triggered and hurting or killing Simone.

Very true.

Our rescue has permanent sponsor dogs - those which cannot be rehomed for a variety of reasons, so they live permanently at the rescue.

Shinyandnew1 · 20/05/2023 08:56

That’s crazy!

We had similar with trying to get a cat. We were ‘approved’ by one rescue-secure garden, someone working from home, older teens etc but they just didn’t have any kittens at the time so they recommended another rescue to try. The woman there was so rude. She was ‘gobsmacked’ that someone would possibly approve us when we lived on a busy road and they would never rehome to us! We do live on a busy road-we have always had cats and they don’t go out the front because it’s so busy-I have never had a cat hit in the road. My friend, on the other hand, lives on a nice quiet country lane and they have lost every cat they’ve ever had as they get used to wandering around there, and every now and again, a car comes down there very fast.

I still follow the rescue on social media and they are always saying they have so many cats that they can’t rehome. With a bit more flexibility, they might all have happy homes by now!

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 20/05/2023 08:56

PS the advice to look at breed specific rescues is sensible. Smaller independent rescues quite often don't have a huge online presence, but can be quite pragmatic and flexible (where appropriate) on their rehoming requirements. They also tend to be supportive for post-adoption care - i.e. if you are having teething troubles with settling in etc.

Fandabedodgy · 20/05/2023 08:56

Rescue dogs are often damaged by their experiences.

These rules in in place so they don't place a dog where there is a risk of it being triggered and hurting or killing Simone.

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 20/05/2023 08:54

I work in animal rescue.

I'm sorry that you've bumped up against these rules. The problem is that there are no consistent rules - because rescues set their own, so there is no consistency. One rescue might not mind you having children - another would say no children under 12 etc.

The requirement for vet and employer references are new to me and seem disproportionate. I suspect what's behind it is a desire to ensure that you have the means to care for the dog if it becomes ill (even with insurance, vet costs can be £££). Sadly it's very common for dogs to come back into rescues when they become ill because people can't - or won't - stand the cost of caring for them. That said, I don't think it's reasonable to insist on these as a requirement.

The best advice I can give you is to keep looking. There are lots of rescues out there who are genuinely committed to rehoming dogs. I know it can sometimes seem like rescues are looking for reasons not to rehome!! However try and remember that often the rescue is looking at it from the dog's perspective. Some of our dogs have come from the most horrendous cruelty and neglect situations and have taken months - or years - to rehab to the stage where they are ready for a forever home. Rescues want to make sure that the dogs are genuinely going to go to not just a loving home, but one which will be suitable and safe for the dog.

eurochick · 20/05/2023 08:49

There have been a number of threads on here with many posters reporting similar experiences. We had similar with cats. We ended up getting kittens from a breeder, but I would have preferred to adopt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread