Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To judge these parents

212 replies

BaggyJumpersandLeggings · 19/05/2023 21:36

Currently on holiday abroad.
I've noticed a family here, kids are I'd say - one is around 20 months and the other about 4, if not younger. Mum looks around 7months pregnant.
Our room overlooks kids club where there is a park and soft play and other activities. The sign on kids club says it's open 9:30-12:30 then 14:00-17:30. Now this couple drop their kids off there after breakfast not long after it's opened, they must get them for the lunch break but then they drop them back off as we've seen them collecting them around 16:00ish.
In the meantime, the parents sunbath at the pool all day.
Aibu to think this is just shit!? Why book a family holiday if you're just gonna pack them off to kids club for strangers to look after your kids pretty much all day in another country?!

Today I took my DC in there to use the park for an hour whilst I remained there and I noticed the 1 child sat on the swing looking really sad, just sat there with nobody pushing the swing and their shoes were on the wrong feet, clothes dirty from where they'd been running about/colouring in, just sat there with the tabard on showing that they're there without parents and was looking so sad and down. My heart broke when I saw that child, the younger sibling was being carried about by the staff. I went over and said hello and asked name and offered to push the swing whilst I pushed my DC. Their little face lit up just to have someone talking to them for a short while.
I just don't understand how some can do this, I couldn't ? I get maybe some need an hour or so peace here and there especially if they're live wires - and maybe some kids like it and ask to go...but for hours everyday?? I've seen those kids round the pool once all holiday, and that was late in the day, around 16:30 for an hour. Apart from that never seen them round the pool since. Poor kids.
Aibu to disagree with this holiday parenting?

OP posts:
barmycatmum · 20/05/2023 04:09

The one I think is unreasonable is the one watching and keeping tabs / writing on the internet.
this poor innocent woman isn’t spying on you, is she.
all you learned here is about yourself: what you would and would not do, in all instances, and how far you’re willing to go to broadcast your opinion without any information except observation.

you still have zero facts about her or her family, so there’s no conclusion to be drawn.

glad she’s getting a rest in the sun.

you might take up a hobby ?

NumberTheory · 20/05/2023 04:08

Lots of kids do love these sorts of kids clubs. When we took ours to places with clubs when they were 3 to 8 ish, they would beg to go to the club and much preferred it to doing family stuff (which we did most weekends anyway).

If the kids are sad (and agree with PP that it’s possible you just saw them at a time they were over tired after an energetic session) then I agree it’s sad. Maybe the parents kind of need some down time before the new baby comes. This is how they can manage it and they’ll be way better parents after the holiday than if they didn’t get some relaxation. But it’s not great if the kids don’t want to be there.

AuraBora · 20/05/2023 04:04

I agree with you, OP, and would have felt sorry for the child too. Clearly he's not enjoying himself much if his face lit up when a total stranger offered to push him on the swing...!

I think it's one thing to make use of the holiday club for a few hours a day maybe. All day every day so the parents can lie by the pool..not so much.

If the parents can't cope with actually being with their children and enjoying times together on holiday, I'd actually question why they're having another one...!

Scirocco · 20/05/2023 02:45

YABU for judging the parents.

What you're seeing / what you've seen is a snapshot of a few days in their lives. You don't know their circumstances or anything about their parenting approach beyond that their children go to a club you wouldn't personally use.

It's fine to say "that's not for us", but it's not fair to judge other parents harshly based on a different but still mainstream approach to one bit of parenting.

Have you always been a perfect parent? Have you never needed a break? Do you not think there may be aspects of your parenting that other people might do differently?

The safety measures of this club don't seem robust enough if a complete stranger (you) can get access to a lone child. I'd maybe flag that up to the club, or even to the parents directly.

H0p3 · 20/05/2023 02:38

Haven’t RTFT but I love how for everyone commenting so far (of what I have read) this is the norm. I have never been on a holiday with my kids that involved a kids club. And if I did, after 6 years of parenting full time, all the time except when I’m working, I feel like I might, just might, send them to that kids club as much as I possibly fucking could. Maybe just enjoy the fact that is even a choice you have rather than judging others for taking it? I don’t judge anyone for using the options available. I judge people for lamenting the fact that others use those options when so many of us don’t even have them. What a privileged world we live in and what a shame that we choose not to see it.

Notjustabrunette · 20/05/2023 02:26

I think it depends on the quality of the kids club. We went to a resort that had one at Easter. We took the kids there one morning with the plan to have family beach time in the afternoon. Well, they loved the club so much they went through the schedule of activities and were disappointed went I told them they couldn’t go to all of them and needed to spend sometime with their parents.

Aaaaandbreathe · 20/05/2023 02:11

YABU

I loved the kids clubs on holiday when I was a child. You may have gotten the child on a bad day or maybe the kids club staff aren't good there. Maybe complain about the service if you've notice something off when you are supposedly spending your holiday concentrating on your children?

I'd definitely complain that you were able to approach and befriend a child while they were in their care though.

Hope your kids were being safely looked after while you did this.

JudgeRudy · 20/05/2023 02:09

We all judge at some level even if we think we don't, but posting on MNs indicates this wasn't a casual critique. Your question 'Why book a family holiday if...?' Well, it's quite probable that they weren't in a position to take a holiday without the kids. This was the one and only holiday they'd get and everyone got something out of it. The parents (one pregnant) got a few uninterrupted hours of relaxation each day and the children got a bit of fun and sun at the 'holiday club'. The parents weren't getting blind drunk or leaving the hotel all day.

Different people have different priorities at different times. Maybe they play football at the park every weekend and go on picnics, treasure hunts, themeparks and 'adventures' with their kids back home, spent evenings reading together, doing crafts and gardening together....but this week they want to relax in the sun.

Groutyonehereagain · 20/05/2023 01:55

I know everyone is different but I loved having holidays with my children. We did everything together as a family. We swam in the sea, played frisbee, tennis, football, cricket, I loved it and I have so many happy memories.

MrsMikeDrop · 20/05/2023 01:55

For all you know she may be a SAHM and this is literally her only chance for a break. She might spend alot more time with her kids than you do, maybe best not to judge

Womencanlift · 20/05/2023 01:50

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotMen · 20/05/2023 01:45

Maybe their parents do spend loads of time with them.
Maybe they are there after school every day, every weekend doing lots of activities together all the time.
Maybe they home school.
There are lots of maybes
Which is why it’s wrong to judge other peoples choices.

Exactly! Interesting that all these posts indicate what the posters want to do and not necessarily what their kids want.

They may want to just run around with a bunch of other kids rather than just sit at the pool with their mum and dad all day or go out on excursions that they have no interest in

Nobody knows what is going on in other families. The only type of parents I will judge are the ones that leave their kids to sleep in their room themselves while they go and have tapas out of sight with their friends. But we are not allowed to judge parents like that are we 🤷‍♀️

suburbophobe · 20/05/2023 01:46

You have no idea what stress/illness/bereavement/mental health issues this family have gone through. Maybe they just need a break

Exactly.

I am focusing on my own family. We've had an amazing time, done lots as a family it's been great.

Makes you sound rather smug OP.

The kind of person I would avoid at home. Cos they'll probably gossip.....

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotMen · 20/05/2023 01:45

TakeMeDancingNakedInTheRain · 20/05/2023 01:26

But holidays are a time to spend quality time together as a family, when everyone works/are in school etc time together is something you don't have. I used to love my family holidays when I was younger, not because we went to some lovely places (we did) but because our parents gave us their undivided attention, they weren't completely shattered from working and would actually have the time and energy to play with us. It's sad that people chose to have kids but then want to revert back to pre kid holidays, it makes me wonder why people have children if they don't want to actually spend time with them when you have the opportunity?

Maybe their parents do spend loads of time with them.
Maybe they are there after school every day, every weekend doing lots of activities together all the time.
Maybe they home school.
There are lots of maybes
Which is why it’s wrong to judge other peoples choices.

user1492757084 · 20/05/2023 01:35

My children begged to go to snow kids care - all day.
You don't know everything about the family.

Maybe the Mum is having a rough pregnancy.
Perhaps the kids say they love it.

The kids are safe, the parents are happy and resting up for a very busy period around the corner. There is sadness and joy in every day for every one.

letthemalldoone · 20/05/2023 01:31

I never used a kids' club because if I was on holiday, I wanted to spend that time with my children - who were in childcare afterschool as we both worked fulltime.

You have absolutely no idea though OP, as to why these parents have made the decision to make full use of kids' clubs.

DemiColon · 20/05/2023 01:30

There are parents who pretty much neglect their kids, they just outsource care and feeding. Of course you can't really know in a situation like this, but when you suspect it's what is going on, it does seem sad.

I went to university with a lot of kids who went to boarding school, and then in the summer their parents sent them to camp. I thought at first they meant a one week type camp, like the one my parents sent me to - no, it was all summer. They had a week at home on both ends.

They lived very separate lives from their parents from a young age.

TakeMeDancingNakedInTheRain · 20/05/2023 01:26

JandalsAlways · 20/05/2023 01:04

I thought the same thing pre-kids about how great it would be, although now I have kids I'm reluctant but only from a safety point of view (although I'm sure it's fine!). I don't see what's wrong with it, if anything the kids will probably enjoy it more anyway!

But holidays are a time to spend quality time together as a family, when everyone works/are in school etc time together is something you don't have. I used to love my family holidays when I was younger, not because we went to some lovely places (we did) but because our parents gave us their undivided attention, they weren't completely shattered from working and would actually have the time and energy to play with us. It's sad that people chose to have kids but then want to revert back to pre kid holidays, it makes me wonder why people have children if they don't want to actually spend time with them when you have the opportunity?

Circlesandtriangles · 20/05/2023 01:20

Wow you're such an amazing mum! Your kids are having a great holiday! Well done you OP, and tut tut, shame on those other parents... utilising the kids club, what pricks!

Such a regressive post. Stop judging other parents. Your holiday must be very boring that this is how you spend your time. How did your kids manage when you were busy stalking and judging the neighbours comings and goings? Surely this wasn't how you are passing the quality time you should be enjoying together 😂

nomoremsniceperson · 20/05/2023 01:12

Agree, it sucks.
I don't know why people have kids if they don't want to actually spend time with them. Yeah we don't know the family's exact circumstances but I don't think there's much that can excuse ignoring your children's existence to this extent.

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 20/05/2023 01:09

@BaggyJumpersandLeggings

I don't get it either.

Holidays are about quality time together as a family, building memories. Also about giving children nourishing experiences.

Its a very sad situation that so many kids get dumped in kids clubs for so long.

Womencanlift · 20/05/2023 01:09

Some of my favourite memories of being on holiday as a kid was in the kids club. Big T Club was what it was called when you went with Thomsons

Loads of activities, took you to the beach and out for ice cream, made loads of friends that became best friends for that week. Don’t remember for a minute feeling neglected

Stop being so judgmental and focus on #makingmemories during your own “family time”

NotMeSecretFormular · 20/05/2023 01:08

When we went on holiday when I was little, I always wanted to be included in the kids club and do activities, but DM said no "it's common to palm kids off". My siblings and I would've had much more fun. To this day I don’t want to bloody sunbathe. Sounds like a pretty shit kids club to leave a little one sitting there in their own, and also to allow a random adult (you) to be able to approach and interact with them. You could've been any kind of scumbag. Don’t judge others but if you think you've found a safeguarding issue then act on it. That way you can protect the 'neglected' kids while remaining upright on your high horse. Or y'know feel secure that you've done the right thing.

JandalsAlways · 20/05/2023 01:04

TakeMeDancingNakedInTheRain · 20/05/2023 00:45

I always remember my brother (who doesn't have children) telling my friend and I (we have 3 kids each) about how we should go on a cruise as its amazing they have a kids club that is open from first thing in the morning until late and then you can pay this extra service for them to be looked after into the night. He was enthusiastically telling us how he'd seen people do this and that it'd be a great holiday for us as we could leave our kids there all day and all night and go off and enjoy ourselves. We just nodded at his suggestion then when we left we both said what a sad holiday for the poor kids, we both said we go in holiday to spend time with our children not dump them in a club with strangers. I feel very sad for the children who are shipped off their entire holiday, can't be fun, especially if you have a shy child.

I thought the same thing pre-kids about how great it would be, although now I have kids I'm reluctant but only from a safety point of view (although I'm sure it's fine!). I don't see what's wrong with it, if anything the kids will probably enjoy it more anyway!

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotMen · 20/05/2023 01:00

I’m surprised no one spoke to you OP about approaching someone else’s child to push them on the swing.
Think you need to accept not everyone is the same as you and not judge.
Not everyone goes on holiday for the same reason and lots of kids like the independence to do their own thing.

Throughalookingglass · 20/05/2023 00:55

Many kids are dropped into daycare - breakfast club before school and after school care - isn't it the same thing?

My kids liked kid's club when they were a bit older although it was generally an hour in the morning and an hour in the evening. Personally I wouldn't have left my kids in holiday daycare for hours every day but they certainly enjoyed being in it for shorter time intervals. If the mum is heavily pregnant, then she is probably using the time to sleep!

Swipe left for the next trending thread