Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not applaud Emma Willis for putting her children through hell?

207 replies

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 21:19

I don't understand how these people can be absolutely celebrated for putting their own children through something so awful.

Does anyone else understand where I'm coming from?

I have always put my child first and I don't get the adoration they're getting?

I left someone who was addicted in order to put my child first.

OP posts:
Gtsr443 · 19/05/2023 23:22

CuriousMoe · 19/05/2023 23:16

As a child growing up with one alcoholic parent, I have to say I am forever thankful to my father for his constant support and sticking with my mum through her darkest times.
Yes, there were scary moments that will stay with me but I would have been far more damaged if I had been severed from my mother.
My Dad’s enduring love and support kept us all together as a family, supported my mum through her addiction and taught us all valuable lessons of tolerance and understanding about mental health which has made us all capable and emotionally aware young women. He’s a hero… as is my Mum who has been sober many years now. Obviously all situations are different but it definitely isn’t black and white and people should feel empowered to make their own decisions on what is best for their respective families.

Exactly my experience but the alcoholic parent was my father.
It wasnt easy but we came through it - all of us together.
Not all families are the same OP.

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 23:19

helloword

Not at all: have you read the thread? The associated publications and the voices of survivors? Or not?

There is a point where any parent has to protect their children from harm by the other and this is what this is about. She is being celebrated for tolerating unacceptable behaviour. I don't agree with the entire sentiment.

No woman should be applauded for tolerating , and exposing their children to, druggies and alcoholics.

Unless you disagree?

Off to bed now. Night all.

OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 19/05/2023 23:17

Jeez where is the compassion for someone who made a different choice. It doesn’t make her a worse person or parent.

I was/am an addict (alcohol) I think for me anyway it’s an easier position to be in than the family member, I feel for her.

CuriousMoe · 19/05/2023 23:16

As a child growing up with one alcoholic parent, I have to say I am forever thankful to my father for his constant support and sticking with my mum through her darkest times.
Yes, there were scary moments that will stay with me but I would have been far more damaged if I had been severed from my mother.
My Dad’s enduring love and support kept us all together as a family, supported my mum through her addiction and taught us all valuable lessons of tolerance and understanding about mental health which has made us all capable and emotionally aware young women. He’s a hero… as is my Mum who has been sober many years now. Obviously all situations are different but it definitely isn’t black and white and people should feel empowered to make their own decisions on what is best for their respective families.

Dumbphone · 19/05/2023 23:14

@Royalbloo I watched the beginning today. Felt he gave lip service - ‘everyone talks about the addict, not the pain they cause’ then spoke about himself at length, glamourising boozing/partying while she buried everything away, quite literally in a sock drawer. I didn’t watch the rest, too sad.

I too, left an addict and took my children somewhere safe. It wasn’t easy, but was essential for all of us.

what is right for their children I truly don’t know, but agree that the programme showed the parents going through this heavily unresolved issue and a dad clinging on to sobriety for dear life, very sad.

Helloword · 19/05/2023 23:13

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:19

maybeejubesoon

He wasn't when I married him - she was about 2.5yrs when his actions and behaviour became intolerable and so I made a choice for my daughter. She was getting upset and increasingly agitated and it was the right thing to do.

Sounds like you created this thread to feel better about yourself. Maybe you do need that validity but it should not be by putting someone else down.

Maybe you need therapy to come over this.

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 23:13

mayjoobsoon

Why the negative and awful messages if you're doing exactly what I said and 100% taking this all on for the benefit of your babies? Sounds like you're doing a brilliant (but difficult) job all on your own?

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 19/05/2023 23:12

but she did leave when he child was yong and he went to rehab

he hasnt relapsed since

what hell are they being put tbro9ugh

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 23:11

maybejubesoon

That sound absolutely horrendous.

OP posts:
Boomshock · 19/05/2023 23:03

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:19

maybeejubesoon

He wasn't when I married him - she was about 2.5yrs when his actions and behaviour became intolerable and so I made a choice for my daughter. She was getting upset and increasingly agitated and it was the right thing to do.

What if she wasn't getting upset and increasingly agitated though?

I left an addict too, I should have left sooner but was stuck between a rock and a hard place as he would threaten suicide and manipulated me that way so I thought I can leave so they don't have to witness this, but there's a very real chance he's going to kill himself and then my kids would have no dad and all the trauma from that.

Blendintothebackground · 19/05/2023 23:01

I know it’s easier to have an addict than love them, it’s a self preservation thing, but I also agree with other responses that there seems to be lots of bitterness and resentment here. I’m sorry; you are clearly hurting OP.

the documentary must have been triggering for you.

I spent a long time hating people who went to rehab as my father didn’t want to stop. I always wondered why we weren’t enough.
could this be where some of your feelings are coming from?

Moveoverdarlin · 19/05/2023 22:59

He was sober for 8 years of their lives. When his youngest was 10 weeks old he fell off the wagon whilst on tour. Emma said she did not know he had relapsed that last time, and missed the signs, so I very much doubt young children will have seen the signs. Their youngest is 5 or 6 now and he’s been sober for 5 years, so it was only a short amount of time he was drinking whilst the kids have been around. I’m not excusing it, but it wasn’t years of destructive behaviour. I watched it and admired her for sticking by him. I would much rather have my parents together and working as a team than my Mum tossing my Dad out on the street. I think if she had done that it would have destroyed him and thus there would be no family anyway.

Blendintothebackground · 19/05/2023 22:57

My father was an addict and died very recently.
My Mother stayed loyally by his side throughout. Are we damaged because of it? Probably.
Do we also have lots of wonderful childhood memories that weren’t shrouded with addiction? Yes.

Addiction isn’t always black and white. Like what Matt Willis said, at the root of every addict is pain.
Ive always thought that if the addict is trying to get clean/better, then I will try.
If they are not actively trying then I would walk away.

People often forget that it’s a chronic mental illness. Just like depression or anxiety, even if it presents to some as a selfish, active choice
No one CHOOSES to be an alcoholic, even if it appears that they are choosing drink over their family, it’s just not the case.

Whilst I applaud your decision to put your children first, that must have been very hard, I also think credit should be given to those who are also trying to stand by and support the addict in recovery. After all, they are in recovery.
I don’t think Emma’s choice makes her a ‘bad mother’ and I think it’s incredibly judgemental to say so.
With the complexities of addiction, it’s not a ‘one size fits all’.

Im really glad my father felt loved and supported by us in his last days.

ghostyslovesheets · 19/05/2023 22:53

I haven't called her a hero - I think she's a strong woman who safeguarded her child by LEAVING

you keep mentioning her children - plural - but he has not used drugs since she left when the first child was a baby?

her child was 6m old when he relapsed???????????? - and - she LEFT - so again what are your actual concerns - what risks did she expose her child to?

You seem very angry at her - for basically not having your life?

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 19/05/2023 22:53

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 21:45

I suppose I just really do not understand why that behaviour would be at all tolerable (I'm sure she had some idea of when he was off his face - anyone who has been there does), and why this is being lauded as incredible behaviour.

I understand why she stayed but to be this isn't something to be celebrated.

In my opinion (perhaps mine only), we should protect our children from drunks, drug addicts and other such harms even if we lose someone we love.

It's a tricky one. Addiction is a mental health problem. My dad has bipolar and has had some crazy manic highs that I have witnessed as an adult, very distressing/impossible behaviour to manage. He developed bipolar 10 years ago so I didn't have to deal with any of this as a child, but it has made me so much more understanding of people with mental health issues. My brother is also a reformed alcoholic. When in the thick of it as a carer you feel responsible for looking after them, and getting them the required help. Do you know how difficult it is to get a mental health patient a bed on the NHS or even privately? It's a nightmare situation which leaves loved ones with very limited options, even when they are wealthy. Of course we are going to want to look after our loved ones. I need to watch the documentary.......

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:50

ghostyslovesheets · 19/05/2023 22:46

@Royalbloo I honestly think you are projecting your own experience on to her - with no understanding that all families/dynamics are different.

You left because he didn't change - she left and he DID change and is no longer a drug user

You seem very angry at her because you did something different - but her relationship is not yours - your partner was addicted throughout your child's early life - hers was not - and hasn't been bar on relapse after the first child was born

You are resolutely ignoring people asking you questions that challenge your view - you can not give examples of how her children where at risk or abused - you just seem very very cross about it - which, frankly, is not healthy or helpful

Her child was 6m old when he relapsed????????????

OP posts:
Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:49

ghostyslovesheets · 19/05/2023 22:46

@Royalbloo I honestly think you are projecting your own experience on to her - with no understanding that all families/dynamics are different.

You left because he didn't change - she left and he DID change and is no longer a drug user

You seem very angry at her because you did something different - but her relationship is not yours - your partner was addicted throughout your child's early life - hers was not - and hasn't been bar on relapse after the first child was born

You are resolutely ignoring people asking you questions that challenge your view - you can not give examples of how her children where at risk or abused - you just seem very very cross about it - which, frankly, is not healthy or helpful

Absolutely not - I just do not understand a woman being applauded for putting up with this behaviour toward her, or her children.

This "hero" nonsense about standing by him should not be the rhetoric we should herald.

OP posts:
ghostyslovesheets · 19/05/2023 22:46

@Royalbloo I honestly think you are projecting your own experience on to her - with no understanding that all families/dynamics are different.

You left because he didn't change - she left and he DID change and is no longer a drug user

You seem very angry at her because you did something different - but her relationship is not yours - your partner was addicted throughout your child's early life - hers was not - and hasn't been bar on relapse after the first child was born

You are resolutely ignoring people asking you questions that challenge your view - you can not give examples of how her children where at risk or abused - you just seem very very cross about it - which, frankly, is not healthy or helpful

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 19/05/2023 22:41

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:23

RTFT and also read the messages from survivors of these situations. It's no laughing matter and children deserve our protection.

I have read the full thread and I have no idea why you think I'm laughing.

He's the addict yet you've started a thread to attack her.

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:40

KittyAlfred · 19/05/2023 22:36

I agree with you OP.
If she’d posted on here about having a drug addicted partner and that she wanted to stand by him despite having young kids, she’d have been told firmly that she was abusing her kids by staying with an addict. People would have come with their experiences of addict parents who were “supported” by their spouses, at the expense of the kids. It would have been unanimous.
I guess because they’re celebs people see it differently.

Amen - I wonder how many women here are a standing by their shit men whilst putting their children at risk or damage.

I've genuinely never thought about it and thought I was in the minority but judging by the comments, I think there are more Thani ever considered possible.

OP posts:
Madamecastafiore · 19/05/2023 22:40

Grandchild of an alcoholic here who grew up in his household. He wasn't abusive or anything more than a lovely caring grandfather to me. Not all addicts have a detrimental affect on the children in their care.

SemperIdem · 19/05/2023 22:39

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:33

superldem

Maybe not a better wife, but definitely a better mother.

I find it easier, instinctively, to understand the women who leave because a line has been crossed, to keep their children safe from behaviour that is not acceptable, whatever that might be.

I spend a lot more time considering the motivations of women who stay, particularly ones who on the face it, should be able to leave with considerable ease.

Madamecastafiore · 19/05/2023 22:38

You have no idea what her children were exposed to. For all you knew they know nothing pf his issues and were well sheltered from the fall out of his relapse. I think she is a very strong woman for staying when most of us, me included, would have thrown in the towel. Unless you know that the children had knowledge of his drug taking then it's a huge leap to say that they're affected in any way and she is anything more than a great mother who has protected her children from the one relapse he has had since becoming a father.

ghostyslovesheets · 19/05/2023 22:38

KittyAlfred · 19/05/2023 22:36

I agree with you OP.
If she’d posted on here about having a drug addicted partner and that she wanted to stand by him despite having young kids, she’d have been told firmly that she was abusing her kids by staying with an addict. People would have come with their experiences of addict parents who were “supported” by their spouses, at the expense of the kids. It would have been unanimous.
I guess because they’re celebs people see it differently.

she did leave - when they had ONE child and he relapsed - since then he has been clean -

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:37

maybejunesoon

You know absolutely nothing. My child is protected and happy and wonderful but thank you for your concern. She's untouched by the one incident she witnessed aged two which is the only horrible thing she will ever ever see if it's up to me.

I couldn't stop that one thing, nor could I predict it was coming, but I know, as her Mum, I took immediate steps from it ever happening again.

Biscuit
OP posts: