Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not applaud Emma Willis for putting her children through hell?

207 replies

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 21:19

I don't understand how these people can be absolutely celebrated for putting their own children through something so awful.

Does anyone else understand where I'm coming from?

I have always put my child first and I don't get the adoration they're getting?

I left someone who was addicted in order to put my child first.

OP posts:
LennyBalls · 20/05/2023 08:12

@Irritateandunreasonable except the documentary said that he went into rehab when they'd only been together three months so she knew early on.

Irritateandunreasonable · 20/05/2023 08:11

kitsuneghost · 20/05/2023 08:04

Absolutely agree. Why would you marry and have kids with a drug addict.

What is also annoying is many of these situations end up with divorce and the women seems to absolve themselves from responsibility because it was HIM that was the addict.

Make good choices people

Most marriages end up in divorce.

Most addictive using doesn’t look like addiction at first it’s a progressive illness, so likely only noticeable when it’s late in the day. there’s nothing that can be done to stop it until it’s so bad you realise it’s a problem.

You should try to research properly before you judge.

LennyBalls · 20/05/2023 08:10

I watched the documentary and I'm afraid I felt that it was only a matter of time before he relapses. It seemed like his sobriety is hanging by a thread. That must be horrendous for Emma and the children to live with day to day.
They clearly absolutely adore each other but I agree with OP the children have to come first. They can not protect them from their dad's addiction and will be scarred in some way from it.

Irritateandunreasonable · 20/05/2023 08:08

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 21:19

I don't understand how these people can be absolutely celebrated for putting their own children through something so awful.

Does anyone else understand where I'm coming from?

I have always put my child first and I don't get the adoration they're getting?

I left someone who was addicted in order to put my child first.

Addiction is a disease.

Are there any other diseases you would leave you partner over? Or is it just the stigma and your misunderstanding of this illness that has led you to this judgement.

Sirzy · 20/05/2023 08:07

There seems to be a lot of projecting going on here. Just because the OP had the right response for her personal situation doesn’t mean that is the right response for every situation no matter what the similarities are.

Freefall212 · 20/05/2023 08:04

YouWonJayne · 20/05/2023 07:42

Women are to blame for everything it seems.

And there is zero evidence she has put her children though hell. That is OP projecting her own guilt about what she put her own kids though it seems.

kitsuneghost · 20/05/2023 08:04

Absolutely agree. Why would you marry and have kids with a drug addict.

What is also annoying is many of these situations end up with divorce and the women seems to absolve themselves from responsibility because it was HIM that was the addict.

Make good choices people

Lightningrain · 20/05/2023 08:00

None of us know what the impact has been on their children (and how could we know that separating them from the dad and the associated upheaval would have been a better result?)

My assumption from watching it was that Emma has done everything she can to support her husband and keep the family together. I imagine losing his family would have sent Matt on a downward spiral and I would definitely have felt guilt around that if it were my husband. What would the impact be on the kids if their dad had ended up on the streets/in prison/with serious associated medical conditions (or even dead)?

They’re not like the average family. They can afford to spend money and time on the best rehab. Surely it’s worth fighting to keep the family together if he’s a good dad on the whole?

Ladykryptonite · 20/05/2023 07:55

Well quite, I'm sure kids of popstars get used to alot worse 'Internet gossip'

Freefall212 · 20/05/2023 07:53

LindorDoubleChoc · 20/05/2023 07:48

I can't understand why they both, as a couple, thought that making this documentary was a good thing from the pov of their children.

It might be cathartic or a "coming clean" thing for the adults. But the resulting publicity and internet gossip can only deeply damage their children.

Ther reality is that 'somebody' has to bring these things into the open. We can't keep mental illness and addiction as dirty taboo secrets. Likely this documentary will lead to others getting help.

They already live fairly public lives as both Emma and Matt are public figures which means that their kids are already exposed in some ways AND they probably as parents know how to protect them. Additionally they may have talks to the kids about why they were doing it and will continue to ensure their understading of the documentary as they age. Nothing they shared is shameful or humiliating to their kids. Their two older kids are old enough to have potentially been consulted or agreed to it.

Ladykryptonite · 20/05/2023 07:48

Fml - i would say Emma willis was the opposite of a 'wet lettuce' after everything shes been through. And who knows maybe their kids are proud of the parents for publicising these struggles - expecially if it helps others

LindorDoubleChoc · 20/05/2023 07:48

I can't understand why they both, as a couple, thought that making this documentary was a good thing from the pov of their children.

It might be cathartic or a "coming clean" thing for the adults. But the resulting publicity and internet gossip can only deeply damage their children.

YouWonJayne · 20/05/2023 07:42

KateyCuckoo · 19/05/2023 21:23

Why is it the woman at the source of your anger?

Women are to blame for everything it seems.

Freefall212 · 20/05/2023 07:41

You are ignoring all the aspects of her situation that are different than your own and continuing to insist she act like you did or else she is an awful mother. Her husband is not your ex.

There is no necessity to dump or remove children immediately from any parent who is struggling in a way that is impacting the kids- be that with drugs, drinking, anxiety, depression, chronic illness etc. If there is a safety issue, the children need to kept from harm but there is no wrongdoing in supporting a spouse or coparent in getting help and getting better as happened in this case. He had one relapse based on what was said and immediately got help and got better again.

Kids also suffer harm from not having their father in their lives. Families suffer harm from being lone parent families. In some cases, those situations are unavoidable but this isn't one of them. It seems that for the vast majority of their lives, these kids have had an involved, loving, sober dad. That is a good thing.

sleeplessinsouthhampton · 20/05/2023 07:39

I agree as well OP.

my relationship out of university was with a wonderful man - adored by all because he was so fun. But took me a while to click he was actually an alcoholic and when he'd got past the life and soul of the party bit, came home and was a nasty drunk, broke things, scared me, risked his job, police, casual drug use started, scuffles with his dad at 3 in the morning

he was a lovely man when not drunk but as the drinking got worse the more his personality changed, the party friends started to see he took it too far, it tumbled over into his working life so his job on a knife edge, the shouting and throwing at me turned into pushing and grabbing

i got pregnant - he was going to change - stopped drinking immediately, happy families, i was overjoyed - his acting out as a young man phase over, he was going to be a grown up. Then he came home plastered smashed up my flat, nicked my car to drive to a friends and I couldn't get keys off him so he threw me across the room. He drove my car into a tree and fled the scene, police visited me.

The most awful thing i've ever done was terminate the pregnancy after that. Left him shortly afterwards. He went through a load of other women over the next 20 years all trying to save him. some had kids with him, he became ostracised from family and long term friends, couldn't hold a job down and eventually took his own life 3 years ago, alone and in a gritty flat. Im glad i don't have to support a child with that

i feel desperately sorry for the children

Ladykryptonite · 20/05/2023 07:22

I'm would assume the worst affects of his addiction was not seen by his kids, and to them he was just another dad who worked away

PurelyBelter · 20/05/2023 07:20

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 22:50

Her child was 6m old when he relapsed????????????

And yours was 2 before you bothered leaving!!!!!!!!!!

You’re attacking @MayBeeJuneSoon for saying the exact thing you’re saying about another mother. You can’t answer what abuse this child at 6 month old suffered but you’re dying from the rooftops how you’re an excellent mum but had an older child who had suffered not a jot! Bollocks. You’re projecting and just want to take a stab at a woman you know won’t see this. It’s pathetic.

AnnWithoutAnnie · 20/05/2023 07:04

LizzieSiddal · 19/05/2023 21:58

As someone who had an alcoholic mother, I do agree with you @Royalbloo

I felt so sorry for Matt but the children have to come first.

@LizzieSiddal I haven't seen the program, but if he's been 'clean' for 8 years, I don't see why supporting him to get clean again isn't putting the children first.

he had a relapse after eight years, none of us are perfect & kicking out a parent who has made a mistake seems to me like punishing the kids, not putting them first!

curtainsfringe · 20/05/2023 06:54

@Blendintothebackground I agree with you. Yes there was some shit that came with having an alcoholic parent but in other wars they were fantastic & I understand it was their way of coping with pain. I'm quite sanguine about it all, I don't know anyone who didn't have some issue/trauma with their family/parents though.

curtainsfringe · 20/05/2023 06:49

She is a deluded and foolish woman if she actually thinks he will stay drink and drug free for the rest of his life.

Why? One of my parents was an alcoholic, they went to rehab & got clean 30 yrs ago. Never touched anything since.

pompomdaisy · 20/05/2023 06:46

I thought she was amazing on the documentary. Matt seems to be trying to manage it in the best way possible. It may have been the best decision for you but it wouldn't necessarily be the best for them.

Would you also leave someone with a disability in the off chance it damaged your children?

Also let's not forget they probably earn a shed load more than you so he really can afford the best rehab. Every family is different.

AngeloMysterioso · 20/05/2023 06:38

Interesting OP that you’re ignoring all the posts asking specifically what “hell” Emma Willis is putting her children through and pointing out that her husband has had one relapse since becoming a father, that she actually did take steps to shield her children from.

Maybe you’re just too busy congratulating yourself on being a better mother than she is.

Personally I think shoring up your own superiority complex by beating down somebody who has done absolutely nothing wrong is a pretty disgusting thing to do, and if you’re looking for somebody whose actions you can proclaim to be morally questionable, I would suggest that you begin with yourself, starting a thread encouraging people on the internet to slag off a stranger who hasn’t done anything to deserve it.

TallerThanAverage · 20/05/2023 05:48

Royalbloo · 19/05/2023 21:31

There's no halo here. In fact, I blame myself for a lot of what my daughter witnessed.

This just smacks of, "stand my your man"

We should be there (as the competent parent) to protect our children from those who are addicted to drink and drugs and put them as their number 1 priority, no?

You say you took extreme steps to remove your child from his influence but then go on to say that you blame yourself for a lot of what your daughter saw. So you (as the competent parent) didn’t protect your child by your own admission. Pot/Kettle springs to mind.

Coyoacan · 20/05/2023 03:17

I haven't seen the programme and can't as I am not in the UK, but you have all my respect OP for putting your child first.

It's mad though comparing the two different threads on the subject, you wouldn't think it was the same programme they are talking about.

And yes, the parent who is not addicted should take action to protect the children if the addict does not remove themselves from the family of their own accord.

RunningUpThatMill · 20/05/2023 01:19

Blendintothebackground · 19/05/2023 22:57

My father was an addict and died very recently.
My Mother stayed loyally by his side throughout. Are we damaged because of it? Probably.
Do we also have lots of wonderful childhood memories that weren’t shrouded with addiction? Yes.

Addiction isn’t always black and white. Like what Matt Willis said, at the root of every addict is pain.
Ive always thought that if the addict is trying to get clean/better, then I will try.
If they are not actively trying then I would walk away.

People often forget that it’s a chronic mental illness. Just like depression or anxiety, even if it presents to some as a selfish, active choice
No one CHOOSES to be an alcoholic, even if it appears that they are choosing drink over their family, it’s just not the case.

Whilst I applaud your decision to put your children first, that must have been very hard, I also think credit should be given to those who are also trying to stand by and support the addict in recovery. After all, they are in recovery.
I don’t think Emma’s choice makes her a ‘bad mother’ and I think it’s incredibly judgemental to say so.
With the complexities of addiction, it’s not a ‘one size fits all’.

Im really glad my father felt loved and supported by us in his last days.

No one CHOOSES to be an alcoholic, even if it appears that they are choosing drink over their family, it’s just not the case.

Sorry for your loss.

I couldn't agree more with this. I also had an alcoholic dad who never once abused us physically or emotionally. My mum did leave him though, because he was emotionally abusive to her when he was drunk.

He died when he was 50, and it was at that point that I realised he didn't choose to be an alcoholic, he had an illness. I'm so glad that even though my parents separated, he was still a part of my life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread