Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK needs to think about the role of the religion and the State given that that only 1/3 of people say they are religious

217 replies

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:02

Interesting survey results

lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf (kcl.ac.uk)

1/3 of people are religious, 46% aren't religious and 20% are atheist (not sure of the difference)

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

About half of people believe in life after death and about half don't

Interesting survey - the UK is one of the least religious countries in the world. Something you might not have believed if you think of our anthem and also the recent Coronation.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/policy-institute/assets/lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:10

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:09

Only technically. Ofsted said way back in the early 2000s that they didn't enforce the law, and that 76% of schools don't bother anyway. It's probably even less now.

So that's a simple law change

Shouldn't take too much time to implement.

No Bishops in the Lords

Easy to implement.

So where is the time being spent on implementing this?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:09

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 19/05/2023 22:02

Schools would not have to have a daily act of worship.

Do they have to do this? I never did this.

Only technically. Ofsted said way back in the early 2000s that they didn't enforce the law, and that 76% of schools don't bother anyway. It's probably even less now.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:09

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:06

And you've just wasted a load of parliamentary and civil service time to no real gain.

Inflation is rocketing, everything is on strike, the planet is fucked, and a mad dictator armed with nuclear weapons is blowing up a sizeable chunk of Europe and you want to waste government time on something that won't make a difference to anyone's lives? Fiddling while Rome burns...

So you are suggesting that there must be a lot of link between Church and State if so much time was taken up?

Why would it take so much time?

Why do you think it would take so much time to disestablish Church and State?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:07

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 19/05/2023 22:02

Schools would not have to have a daily act of worship.

Do they have to do this? I never did this.

That's the law

Collective worship in schools - Wikipedia

Collective worship in schools - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_worship_in_schools#:~:text=The%20nature%20of%20the%20required%20daily%20act%20of,It%20should%20normally%20take%20place%20on%20school%20premises.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:06

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:01

So it would make no change so we could disestablish, ensure that Bishops weren't automatically in the House of Lords, the Head of State was not the Supreme Leader of the C of E and life would carry on.

Good.

And you've just wasted a load of parliamentary and civil service time to no real gain.

Inflation is rocketing, everything is on strike, the planet is fucked, and a mad dictator armed with nuclear weapons is blowing up a sizeable chunk of Europe and you want to waste government time on something that won't make a difference to anyone's lives? Fiddling while Rome burns...

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 19/05/2023 22:02

Schools would not have to have a daily act of worship.

Do they have to do this? I never did this.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:01

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:00

Little. So that's why there's no need to meddle. As a PP said, be careful what you wish for, it could well be the fact of having an established church that saves us from the American-style batshittery. After all, anything associated with the state is mistrusted so people mistrust the church too.

So it would make no change so we could disestablish, ensure that Bishops weren't automatically in the House of Lords, the Head of State was not the Supreme Leader of the C of E and life would carry on.

Good.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:00

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:50

I take it that you didn't actually watch the coronation you're frothing about then? It was very much multifaith in nature, with the leaders of many different religions involved. The PM is a Hindu, that's how much influence the CofE actually has in day-to-day government.

I watched it because it is history.

It does seem strange that by definition, the Head of State is also the Supreme Leader of the C of E. You would have thought that the Supreme Leader would be someone who was once Archbishop.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:00

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 21:56

So what would happen if it was disestablished?

What change would it make to people's lives?

Little. So that's why there's no need to meddle. As a PP said, be careful what you wish for, it could well be the fact of having an established church that saves us from the American-style batshittery. After all, anything associated with the state is mistrusted so people mistrust the church too.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 21:57

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:56

Your final paragraph sums up my objection better than I did. Most people aren’t religious, but many still want to hold weddings in churches because they like tradition.

OP, why don't you commission a poll to find out whether people think that the coronation should be officiated by a registrar in Westminster Register Office. Can't hold it in an Abbey as that's a religious building, can we?

The USA holds its inaugauration in public in Washington.

I am sure we could use our imagination.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 21:56

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:19

So a few kids belting out songs each morning, that's as much as you can think of in terms of how it affects people's lives? Three-quarters of schools don't bother anyway.

Bishops in the Lords are few in number so they don't exactly carry a disproportionate amount of influence. I'd reform the Lords anyway, more cross-benchers (including other faiths and experts in various fields) and fewer has-been politicians. That would be a much better use of time than fretting about some oil at a ceremony.

The national anthem has no legal significance, it's got nothing to do with the state, it's simply been adopted by custom and practice.

So what would happen if it was disestablished?

What change would it make to people's lives?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:56

MasterGland · 19/05/2023 21:31

The national anthem was widely adopted around the time of the Jacobite rebellion, it has no significance now other than tradition, a tenuous like to our national story.
I find it disheartening that there is this drive to expunge any hint of benign tradition from British life.

Your final paragraph sums up my objection better than I did. Most people aren’t religious, but many still want to hold weddings in churches because they like tradition.

OP, why don't you commission a poll to find out whether people think that the coronation should be officiated by a registrar in Westminster Register Office. Can't hold it in an Abbey as that's a religious building, can we?

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:50

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 21:05

It seems like the C of E has a good hold on society despite fewer people who are religious and so having fewer people who are C of E.

Head of State as its leader.
Gets to lead the nation when it comes to State occasions
Gets daily worship in school (not C of E but still daily worship)
Helps to influence Parliament

I wonder how it would argue to keep such influence despite falling numbers who are religious?

I take it that you didn't actually watch the coronation you're frothing about then? It was very much multifaith in nature, with the leaders of many different religions involved. The PM is a Hindu, that's how much influence the CofE actually has in day-to-day government.

greenspaces4peace · 19/05/2023 21:49

people's lives would be improved if more people had faith and hope.

ToK1 · 19/05/2023 21:46

@CurlewKate

Exactly lol.

If it doesn't affect anyone and has no significance all the more reason to get rid

PuffinsRocks · 19/05/2023 21:41

PlatBilledDuckypuss · 19/05/2023 21:39

It is having an established church as part of the State that protects us from the raving idiocy of the fundamentalist Christian types that plague the US revoking Roe v Wade and opposing the teaching of evolution.

Be very careful what you wish for. I can see where you're coming from OP but I am very afraid the alternative will be worse.

Absolutely. It's like all these people who want rid of the monarchy, but absolutely wouldn't have wanted a President Truss or Johnson with a 4 year mandate.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:39

Sissynova · 19/05/2023 20:55

You’re being disingenuous, having an established church is not remotely the same as it being tied to the country politically.
Only 7% of children in NI are educated in a mixed faith school, it has a massive impact on things socially and politically.

There is space in the political landscape to discuss separate issues issues at once unless you’re incredibly limited in capacity. Trains are an entirely different topic, feel free to start a post if that’s what you’re interested in but this faux ignorance to sweep discussion under the rug because X, Y or Z unrelated issue is pathetic.

You specifically said that "lots of people's lives would be improved" by this proposed change to the constitution. I'm asking how. All four nations of the UK have the same basic constitution, so if England Scotland and Wales manage to avoid religious batshitery taking hold, there clearly must be another reason why it's an issue in NI.

Would you compare the situation in NI to the situation in the US? There are a few common themes after all. If so, how do you think that changing the constitution here will make a difference, when the US has the strictest separation in the world and yet religious batshitery is off the scale?

PuffinsRocks · 19/05/2023 21:39

Literally no one can answer the question "how would it affect you" because it doesn't
I'd rather get all the Tory "donors" out of the Lords sooner than some bishops who at least know what a day's work looks like. And I'm not religious before anyone makes assumptions, I just think out of all the problems in the world this isn't one... unless anyone can answer the bloody question.

PlatBilledDuckypuss · 19/05/2023 21:39

It is having an established church as part of the State that protects us from the raving idiocy of the fundamentalist Christian types that plague the US revoking Roe v Wade and opposing the teaching of evolution.

Be very careful what you wish for. I can see where you're coming from OP but I am very afraid the alternative will be worse.

MasterGland · 19/05/2023 21:31

The national anthem was widely adopted around the time of the Jacobite rebellion, it has no significance now other than tradition, a tenuous like to our national story.
I find it disheartening that there is this drive to expunge any hint of benign tradition from British life.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:31

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:50

What difference would it make if we did not have the Church of England and the State interlinked?

If there was separaration, what difference would it make to your life?

Did you know the King appoints Bishops on the advice of the Prime Minister

Leadership and Governance | The Church of England

Our two archbishops and 24 other bishops sit in the House of Lords, making a major contribution to Parliament's work. They are known as Lords Spiritual.
His Majesty the King is the Supreme Governor of the Church of England. The King appoints archbishops, bishops and deans of cathedrals on the advice of the Prime Minister.

The King also approves all laws. Another old tradition that doesn't affect anyone's life (except his). The PM no longer chooses new Bishops, there's a commission for that, the PM just rubber-stamps their recommendation.

Still waiting for an answer to the question of how changing the constitution in this would "improve the lives of lots of people". The best that you've come up with is that a minority of children (who are probably mostly at religious schools anyway, you do get to choose) sing a few songs each morning.

SmurfHaribos · 19/05/2023 21:26

Happy with things as they are.

CurlewKate · 19/05/2023 21:25

As usual. "I don't know why you're bothered, religion plays no significant part in any aspect of British society." then you won't mind if any reference to it in legislation is removed then." "Oh, no. We can't do that!"

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 21:19

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:46

How would people's lives be improved? Would the trains run on time? Would housing become affordable? Exactly what difference to people's lives is made by having an established church

Schools would not have to have a daily act of worship. If parents wanted their children to worship, they could do it in their own time and in their own religious venue.

There would be no need to have Bishops in the House of Lords. They could get in their but on their own terms. not because they are Bishops.

God would be kept out of the State. You would just not need to even mention God.

Our anthem could be for all. Not just for people who believe on God.

So a few kids belting out songs each morning, that's as much as you can think of in terms of how it affects people's lives? Three-quarters of schools don't bother anyway.

Bishops in the Lords are few in number so they don't exactly carry a disproportionate amount of influence. I'd reform the Lords anyway, more cross-benchers (including other faiths and experts in various fields) and fewer has-been politicians. That would be a much better use of time than fretting about some oil at a ceremony.

The national anthem has no legal significance, it's got nothing to do with the state, it's simply been adopted by custom and practice.

Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 21:15

Daily worship in schools? Not in any of the schools I've ever taught in , apart from an RC one. The nearest it's come to anything like worship was 'quiet thinking time' lasting less than a minute.

Otherwise it's either form time or a full or partial gathering in the hall and matters of a parochial nature are on the agenda, definitely not religion.

The 1944 Act may require it but I know it doesn't happen in reality in many, many schools.One of the reasons so few people know any hymns any more!!