Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK needs to think about the role of the religion and the State given that that only 1/3 of people say they are religious

217 replies

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:02

Interesting survey results

lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf (kcl.ac.uk)

1/3 of people are religious, 46% aren't religious and 20% are atheist (not sure of the difference)

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

About half of people believe in life after death and about half don't

Interesting survey - the UK is one of the least religious countries in the world. Something you might not have believed if you think of our anthem and also the recent Coronation.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/policy-institute/assets/lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf

OP posts:
Otherland · 19/05/2023 23:17

I completely agree with you, OP. Thank you for keeping on with this, despite the ridiculousness of some of the replies.

I absolutely hate religion being imposed on me and my children.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:13

BibbleandSqwauk · 19/05/2023 20:33

America has one of the strictest divisions between church and state. Officially religion plays no role in politics yet we all know the reality is completely different. In the UK we have bishops in the house of Lords offering considered and long term thinking that doesn't have to worry about being popular. They advocate caution in debates around euthanasia, genetic research etc, but rarely mention God or spiritual aspects such as souls. They focus instead on the sanctity of human life. A UK politician makes v little if any mention of their own religious position, whereas an American presidential candidate would never ever get near being elected if they did not make their faith clear and look what's happening over there.

God isn’t rarely mentioned in the USA.
Every school day, every American child pledges allegiance to the flag of the United States of America in every public school with the words

“I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.”

Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 23:12

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:05

So who gets them back then?

The Roman Catholic Church. How's your English ecclesiastical history?
See, it's an even bigger can of worms than you thought, though I assume you're not planning to abolish the CofE yet.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:11

neslop · 19/05/2023 23:08

I dont know any non-church state schools that have a daily act of worship

So I guess that if the Government made it official that schools did not have to have a compulsory daily act of worship, there would be no complaints from the various Churches?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:10

UWhatNow · 19/05/2023 23:05

This thread is totally batshit. There is far more daily collective worship going on in schools (over a third of the primary sector is C of E) than people realise and engagement with churches and their associate charities/outreach is huge even if church attendance isn’t. You’re atheist and hostile to religion, we get it. But you clearly have no idea about how entwined religion in all its forms is in Britain today. It’s quietly cracking on in the background while you’re bitching about how irrelevant it is.

And yet only a 1/3 of people are religious.

So it's relevant in some people's lives - but it's not an argument for having an Established Church.

The only argument has been that it's complicated to disestablish

There has been no religious argument.

OP posts:
neslop · 19/05/2023 23:08

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:46

How would people's lives be improved? Would the trains run on time? Would housing become affordable? Exactly what difference to people's lives is made by having an established church

Schools would not have to have a daily act of worship. If parents wanted their children to worship, they could do it in their own time and in their own religious venue.

There would be no need to have Bishops in the House of Lords. They could get in their but on their own terms. not because they are Bishops.

God would be kept out of the State. You would just not need to even mention God.

Our anthem could be for all. Not just for people who believe on God.

I dont know any non-church state schools that have a daily act of worship

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:05

Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 23:03

If they're CofE then the CofE does. Fairly obviously. And the state doesn't pay for their upkeep.

If they're RC, Orthodox etc then they belong to those denominations.

So who gets them back then?

OP posts:
UWhatNow · 19/05/2023 23:05

This thread is totally batshit. There is far more daily collective worship going on in schools (over a third of the primary sector is C of E) than people realise and engagement with churches and their associate charities/outreach is huge even if church attendance isn’t. You’re atheist and hostile to religion, we get it. But you clearly have no idea about how entwined religion in all its forms is in Britain today. It’s quietly cracking on in the background while you’re bitching about how irrelevant it is.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:05

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:02

How much parliamentary time and civil service manpower do you want to devote to reading the code? The government have just announced that they don't have the parliamentary time to reform the railways - something that actually affects people - so I don't know how you could justify devoting time to pointless constitutional tinkering.

That's an argument for doing nothing.

Can you think of any potential issues?

OP posts:
Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 23:03

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:57

Sorry - who has the Cathedrals at the moment?

If they're CofE then the CofE does. Fairly obviously. And the state doesn't pay for their upkeep.

If they're RC, Orthodox etc then they belong to those denominations.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:02

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:54

So you don't think we can disestablish the Church of England and the State because "something might break" in the code.

Maybe we do need to "read the code" and see what the actual link is.

Anyway - it will be seen as an archaic link - hopefully in my life time.
And Christianity will carry on.

I wonder if our anthem will ever change to reflect a changing society?

How much parliamentary time and civil service manpower do you want to devote to reading the code? The government have just announced that they don't have the parliamentary time to reform the railways - something that actually affects people - so I don't know how you could justify devoting time to pointless constitutional tinkering.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:01

Same argument that I've got for keeping the monarchy. It isn't broke so don't fix it. I'd rather have a system that seems a bizarre set up but works

Works for some people.
Not others.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:59

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:45

It is going to happen.

Fewer and fewer people are religious.

It's going to look archaic to have the link between Church and State.

Most modern countries don't have this link.

Your argument is that it's complicated and there are more important things to do. Fair enough - but can you argue why we should have an Established Church?

Same argument that I've got for keeping the monarchy. It isn't broke so don't fix it. I'd rather have a system that seems a bizarre set up but works, than one that makes sense on paper but doesn't. Becoming a strictly secular republic doesn't appear to be helping the US keep religion out of lawmaking.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:57

Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 22:55

MasterGland
Ooh, we might get the cathedrals back though.

Steady on now!! Besides, some of them are post Reformation; you can't just nab the pretty ones back, you know 😉

Sorry - who has the Cathedrals at the moment?

OP posts:
Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 22:55

MasterGland
Ooh, we might get the cathedrals back though.

Steady on now!! Besides, some of them are post Reformation; you can't just nab the pretty ones back, you know 😉

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:54

So you don't think we can disestablish the Church of England and the State because "something might break" in the code.

Maybe we do need to "read the code" and see what the actual link is.

Anyway - it will be seen as an archaic link - hopefully in my life time.
And Christianity will carry on.

I wonder if our anthem will ever change to reflect a changing society?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:48

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:40

So it's quite entwined in our laws then, isn't it?
Despite fewer and fewer people being religious.

It is going to happen. Religion and the C of E will still carry on as long as people want to follow such beliefs.

But it won't have its political power or influence.

Yes, it's entwined in our laws. So are lots of things that don't actually do anything. It's like old software, lines of code left in that are obsolete but going through to remove them would be one hell of a job because if you're not careful you'll end up reintroducing a few bugs.

The CofE doesn't have any political power or influence. I thought that I'd made that clear.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:45

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:42

I don't think that you quite understand what is involved in changing primary legislation, particularly something as large as this.

Yes, you can amend the 1998 education act. That'll take quite a lot of parliamentary time (nothing is ever quick) considering that most heads ignore it anyway.

The Lords should be reformed from the ground up rather than tinkering at the edges. Anything constitutional won't be quick though, it'll bounce between the two houses with amendments galore.

What would you remove from the parliamentary timetable in order to fit this pointless tinkering in?

It is going to happen.

Fewer and fewer people are religious.

It's going to look archaic to have the link between Church and State.

Most modern countries don't have this link.

Your argument is that it's complicated and there are more important things to do. Fair enough - but can you argue why we should have an Established Church?

OP posts:
BMW6 · 19/05/2023 22:44

I am Agnostic.

As matters stand it makes no difference to me - those who have Belief, good for them. Those who don't - in what way are you being harmed?

The Church has no influence on the State in real terms that I can see.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:42

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:10

So that's a simple law change

Shouldn't take too much time to implement.

No Bishops in the Lords

Easy to implement.

So where is the time being spent on implementing this?

I don't think that you quite understand what is involved in changing primary legislation, particularly something as large as this.

Yes, you can amend the 1998 education act. That'll take quite a lot of parliamentary time (nothing is ever quick) considering that most heads ignore it anyway.

The Lords should be reformed from the ground up rather than tinkering at the edges. Anything constitutional won't be quick though, it'll bounce between the two houses with amendments galore.

What would you remove from the parliamentary timetable in order to fit this pointless tinkering in?

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:40

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:34

Because someone would have to comb through every bit of legislation dating back hundreds of years to remove all references to religion. Even the simple act of taking a straightforward bill through parliament takes ages, never mind constitutional stuff.

So it's quite entwined in our laws then, isn't it?
Despite fewer and fewer people being religious.

It is going to happen. Religion and the C of E will still carry on as long as people want to follow such beliefs.

But it won't have its political power or influence.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 22:34

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 22:09

So you are suggesting that there must be a lot of link between Church and State if so much time was taken up?

Why would it take so much time?

Why do you think it would take so much time to disestablish Church and State?

Because someone would have to comb through every bit of legislation dating back hundreds of years to remove all references to religion. Even the simple act of taking a straightforward bill through parliament takes ages, never mind constitutional stuff.

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 19/05/2023 22:27

Only technically. Ofsted said way back in the early 2000s that they didn't enforce the law, and that 76% of schools don't bother anyway. It's probably even less now.

Oh ok, that makes sense. I was born in 1992 and my school definitely did not do this - my mum would 100% have withdrawn me and I was never removed from any part of the school day so there was definitely not even any subtle "collective worship" (what does that even mean?) that I was oblivious to.

I had no idea that was the law.

MasterGland · 19/05/2023 22:20

If the church of England was 'disestablished' the constituent parishes would form new modes of governance. Many Anglo-Catholic parishes would return to communion with Rome, some low church evangelical types would form evangelical unions akin to the US-style sola scriptura obsessives. Maybe some would join the Baptists, who seem to be having a bit of a resurgence recently.

It would be a bit of a mess, from a theological perspective.

To some extent, this is already happening in slow motion as the Anglican union is fracturing on matters of doctrine.

Bishops would be appointed by the Pope, and wouldn't sit in the House of Lords....which many want to get rid of altogether anyway.

Political life would go on, religious life would be... interesting.

Ooh, we might get the cathedrals back though.

Freshfoods · 19/05/2023 22:12

Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 21:15

Daily worship in schools? Not in any of the schools I've ever taught in , apart from an RC one. The nearest it's come to anything like worship was 'quiet thinking time' lasting less than a minute.

Otherwise it's either form time or a full or partial gathering in the hall and matters of a parochial nature are on the agenda, definitely not religion.

The 1944 Act may require it but I know it doesn't happen in reality in many, many schools.One of the reasons so few people know any hymns any more!!

This.