Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK needs to think about the role of the religion and the State given that that only 1/3 of people say they are religious

217 replies

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:02

Interesting survey results

lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf (kcl.ac.uk)

1/3 of people are religious, 46% aren't religious and 20% are atheist (not sure of the difference)

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

About half of people believe in life after death and about half don't

Interesting survey - the UK is one of the least religious countries in the world. Something you might not have believed if you think of our anthem and also the recent Coronation.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/policy-institute/assets/lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 08:18

Why does it feel archaic?

There have been other religions and belief systems in the UK over the centuries. Some have been prominent and then have gone.

We don't have Druids sitting in the House of Lords.
Our schools don't have to have a collective act of worship to the Viking Gods.
Our Head of State does not have to have a service linked to the Roman Gods.
Our anthem does not ask Odin to save the King.

The argument is that it's too much effort. It may well be.

But on a theoretical argument - can anyone give a reason why we should have an Established Church, a State Religion, given the fall in belief in God and fewer people who identify as Christian, let alone C of E.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 08:11

It's also important to consider that the bishops in the HOL are likely to hold more traditional views on matters of health and social policy. They are, for example, a guaranteed block vote against progressive legislation on assisted dying. It's not all about wearing various charming hats.....

Simianwalk · 20/05/2023 08:02

KiwiMum2023 · 19/05/2023 20:16

You clearly have a not so hidden agenda. Meanwhile, the majority of us will carry on believing.

Definitely not the majority! Come on most people know it's made up. A lot of religious people do it for cultural rather than spiritual reasons.

YukoandHiro · 20/05/2023 08:01

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 20:28

OP, no one cares.

The role of the established church in the state is almost entirely symbolic. Some ceremonies at the coronation are just old traditions, nice to have but of no practical meaning, while the handful of bishops in the Lords are so few that they carry little real weight.

It's not like (supposedly secular) America where Republican politicians bang on about god while restricting the right to abortion or claiming that the Second Amendment is a "god-given right".

It's not symbolic though, is it? It grants bishops a seat in the lords and they scrutinise and approve the laws which affect every element of our lives.
You might be generally quite happy with how they perform that function now, but that doesn't mean it isn't massive overreach.

YukoandHiro · 20/05/2023 08:00

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/05/2023 20:25

There should be separation of Church and State even in countries where most people ARE religious. Posting the stats is meaningless.

This

EuripidesEumenides · 20/05/2023 07:57

Parliament can only debate so much legislation. Civil servants can only sort so much. If I were starting with a blank sheet of paper, yeah, there'd be full separation of church and state. But I really don't think that right now it's even close to the top one thousand things that the government needs to fix in the country.

Plus there's zero chance that any replacement national anthem dreamt up today won't be completely naff.

Nordicrain · 20/05/2023 07:22

I agree there should be a separation between religion and state. I think it's utterly bizarre the church - an updated and unsubscribed institution - has so much influence over how we live our lives. It's undemocratic.

I don't care if believers want to "keep believing" - crack on! Just don't make me live according to your (make believe?) rules.

guineacup · 20/05/2023 07:15

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:02

Interesting survey results

lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf (kcl.ac.uk)

1/3 of people are religious, 46% aren't religious and 20% are atheist (not sure of the difference)

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

About half of people believe in life after death and about half don't

Interesting survey - the UK is one of the least religious countries in the world. Something you might not have believed if you think of our anthem and also the recent Coronation.

The change in society over the past couple of generations in terms of religion has been marked. I agree with you that now QEII has passed away and Charles has had his coronation, that it's time to actively start this debate.... even more so given that many of those who are religious will be Muslims, Sikhs, Hindus, Jews etc.

As for not knowing what the difference between non-religious and atheist, lots of people's beliefs are fuzzy and uncertain.... they still think some kind of god does or may exist, yet aren't sure enough or don't care enough to associate with any religion. These are the non-religious but not atheists of which I would probably describe myself.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:51

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:36

Because it does not make me feel like I belong in my country.

Our anthem has God save the King.
Our Head of State is annointed by an ArchBishop.

It does not make me feel like I belong. It feels like a club for people who have faith and is not inclusive. If you don't believe in God, then there's a message in this that makes me feel like I don't belong in this country.

It's great if you believe in God. You have God in the anthem and God and the Church in the key ceremonies of the country.

I don't even want to sing our anthem. Yet I love my country.

I don't believe in god. I only ever set foot inside a church for a wedding or a funeral.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:46

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:42

Sounds like a you problem because you can avoid all mention of God & CofE quite easily in the U.K. It’s not like the bad old days where you could be arrested for not attending church.

I am looking forward to when we have a new National Anthem.

God save the King is meaningless when half the population don't believe in God.

I am sure people who believe in God would object to Ra save the King or Jupiter save the King - but that' what it feels like.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:42

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:30

Or maybe they can get voted in and they should represent the general population?

Other groups might also demand professional representation and a similar proportion as well in the House of Lords.

Having representation from a variety of groups would be a good thing I'm pretty sure that there is some representation from other religions, even if not the formal status of the CofE.

I don't want an elected Lords though, I want people who are in there to do what's right, not what's popular. I'd keep the system where members are appointed for life but cap their numbers, have half as crossbenchers (appointed because they are experts in their field, spiritual leaders etc.) and the other half from political parties but new members only able to be appointed when that party's representation falls below the proportion of votes they got at the last GE.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:42

Sounds like a you problem because you can avoid all mention of God & CofE quite easily in the U.K. It’s not like the bad old days where you could be arrested for not attending church.

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:40

As I said, given the way society is changing, I can see that the C of E will eventually not be the established Church - but who knows when.

I am sure that Christianity will carry on and will bring comfort to those who believe and who have faith. It will just be separate to the State.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:36

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:30

How doesn't it work for you? What aspect of your life is different because a bloke in a funny hat dribbled some oil in the shape of a cross on the king's chest?

Because it does not make me feel like I belong in my country.

Our anthem has God save the King.
Our Head of State is annointed by an ArchBishop.

It does not make me feel like I belong. It feels like a club for people who have faith and is not inclusive. If you don't believe in God, then there's a message in this that makes me feel like I don't belong in this country.

It's great if you believe in God. You have God in the anthem and God and the Church in the key ceremonies of the country.

I don't even want to sing our anthem. Yet I love my country.

OP posts:
ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:33

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:30

Or maybe they can get voted in and they should represent the general population?

Other groups might also demand professional representation and a similar proportion as well in the House of Lords.

HoL is by appointment not election.
Yes we could copy the USA and then you’d really know what corruption is.

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:32

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:05

That's an argument for doing nothing.

Can you think of any potential issues?

Doing nothing is precisely what I'm advocating. Political meddling for its own sake is seldom a good thing.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:31

William would just edit out the bits he doesn’t like and delegate head of CofE to the Archbishop of Canterbury

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:30

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:01

Same argument that I've got for keeping the monarchy. It isn't broke so don't fix it. I'd rather have a system that seems a bizarre set up but works

Works for some people.
Not others.

How doesn't it work for you? What aspect of your life is different because a bloke in a funny hat dribbled some oil in the shape of a cross on the king's chest?

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:30

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:21

So 26 members of the 798 members of the House of Lords are professional religious…that’s 3% of the House of Lords.

The King isn’t actually the State Sovereign anyway, so his role as head of C of E is about the only thing left to the monarch.

If anything we need some Imans and Rabbis and Lamas and Sikhs and Catholic bishops and so on so that the HoL can be 1/3rd religious & properly represent the 1/3rd of the population that is religious.

Or maybe they can get voted in and they should represent the general population?

Other groups might also demand professional representation and a similar proportion as well in the House of Lords.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:28

I wonder what would happen if William said "Sorry, I don't believe in God" - as is possible and then didn't want to go say the Coronation oath as it's a little bit religious. I guess he doesn't have much choice.

Sir, to keep you ever mindful of the law and the Gospel of God as the Rule for the whole life and government of Christian Princes, receive this Book, the most valuable thing that this world affords. Here is Wisdom; this is the royal Law; these are the lively Oracles of God.

The Moderator receives the Bible and places it before The King. The King stands and the Archbishop says:

Our Majesty, the Church established by law, whose settlement you will swear to maintain, is committed to the true profession of the Gospel, and, in so doing, will seek to foster an environment in which people of all faiths and beliefs may live freely. The Coronation Oath has stood for centuries and is enshrined in law.
Are you willing to take the Oath?

The King replies
I am willing.

The King places his hand on the Bible, and the Archbishop administers the Oath
Will you solemnly promise and swear to govern the Peoples of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, your other Realms and the Territories to any of them belonging or pertaining, according to their respective laws and customs?

The King replies
I solemnly promise so to do.

The Archbishop says

Will you to your power cause Law and Justice, in Mercy, to be executed in all your judgements?

The King replies
I will.
The King kneels at the Chair of Estate. The Archbishop says
Will you to the utmost of your power maintain the Laws of God and the true profession of the Gospel? Will you to the utmost of your power maintain in the United Kingdom the Protestant Reformed Religion established by law? Will you maintain and preserve inviolably the settlement of the Church of England, and the doctrine, worship, discipline, and government thereof, as by law established in England?

And will you preserve unto the Bishops and Clergy of England, and to the Churches there committed to their charge, all such rights and privileges as by law do or shall appertain to them or any of them?

The King replies
All this I promise to do.

The King places his hand on the Bible and says
The things which I have here before promised, I will perform and keep. So help me God.
The King kisses the Bible. The Archbishop says

Your Majesty, are you willing to make, subscribe, and declare to the statutory Accession Declaration Oath?

The King replies
I am willing.

I Charles do solemnly and sincerely in the presence of God profess, testify, and declare that I am a faithful Protestant, and that I will, according to the true intent of the enactments which secure the Protestant succession to the Throne, uphold and maintain the said enactments to the best of my powers according to law.

The King signs copies of the Oaths, presented by the Lord Chamberlain, whilst the choir sings
Prevent us, O Lord, in all our doings with thy most gracious favour, and further us with thy continual help; that in all our works begun, continued, and ended in thee, we may glorify thy holy name, and finally by thy mercy obtain everlasting life; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

OP posts:
ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:26

It's going to look archaic to have the link between Church and State. Most modern countries don't have this link.

How far back in time do you want to go?! The Roman Republic had Gods and State separated, and then it became the Roman Empire with Gods and State linked by a deified Emperor.

Examples abound back as far as records go of civilisations with church and state linked or separated. Neither structure is more archaic than the other.

ReleasetheCrackHen · 19/05/2023 23:21

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:52

Not at all annoyed.

1/3 of people are religious. A figure that's declined over time.

Be religious. Fine by me.

But why should the Prime Minister recommend Bishops and the ArchBishops?

Surely that should be up to the Church?
Why should the Head of State be the Supreme Governer of the C of E?

So 26 members of the 798 members of the House of Lords are professional religious…that’s 3% of the House of Lords.

The King isn’t actually the State Sovereign anyway, so his role as head of C of E is about the only thing left to the monarch.

If anything we need some Imans and Rabbis and Lamas and Sikhs and Catholic bishops and so on so that the HoL can be 1/3rd religious & properly represent the 1/3rd of the population that is religious.

neslop · 19/05/2023 23:21

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:11

So I guess that if the Government made it official that schools did not have to have a compulsory daily act of worship, there would be no complaints from the various Churches?

Im not aware of the various churches complaining about the fact that the current law is basically ignored, so I don't think they would start complaining if the law were updated to reflect the reality of what is actually happening.

neslop · 19/05/2023 23:17

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:05

So who gets them back then?

Presumably the Catholic Church, as it owned them before Henry VIII split from Rome and C of E was established?

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 23:17

Lifeinlists · 19/05/2023 23:12

The Roman Catholic Church. How's your English ecclesiastical history?
See, it's an even bigger can of worms than you thought, though I assume you're not planning to abolish the CofE yet.

Why would disestablishing Church and State lead to abolishing the Church of England? They might want to rebrand themselves though.

OP posts: