Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK needs to think about the role of the religion and the State given that that only 1/3 of people say they are religious

217 replies

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:02

Interesting survey results

lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf (kcl.ac.uk)

1/3 of people are religious, 46% aren't religious and 20% are atheist (not sure of the difference)

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

About half of people believe in life after death and about half don't

Interesting survey - the UK is one of the least religious countries in the world. Something you might not have believed if you think of our anthem and also the recent Coronation.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/policy-institute/assets/lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:10

@DdraigGoch Also-what about my fight to a secular education for my children?

DownNative · 20/05/2023 14:04

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/05/2023 20:25

There should be separation of Church and State even in countries where most people ARE religious. Posting the stats is meaningless.

The Church has no real meaningful power in the UK in actual practice, especially since we do have a tangible separation of powers between The Commons, Lords and Supreme Court.

This contrasts with the Republic of Ireland where the Catholic Church still has considerable power and influence. E.g., the church still owns 95% of primary schools and 50% of secondary schools.

This is clearly not the case in the UK itself.

The UK is only a theocracy in name whereas the Republic of Ireland is a theocracy in practice.

Cornettoninja · 20/05/2023 14:04

Can you argue why there should be a link between Church and State (except for saying it would be complicated to separate them)

Can you argue why we should have God save the King as our anthem when many people don't believe in God?

There’s no requirement for anyone to have an argument for either. If the proposal is to remove them it’s on the proposer to present a convincing argument.

Lifeinlists · 20/05/2023 14:03

But I'm not sure why you would choose this particular hill to die on, OP.
Why do you feel so strongly about a matter which is largely symbolic and has no measurable effect on our daily lives?

Believe in God, don't believe in God, not sure to believe in God. In this country, so what? No one will persecute you or give a toss to be honest. If you don't like the national anthem, don't sing it but, above all, don't be too literal about every bit of symbolism.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:00

@DdraigGoch "I believe that parents should have the right to choose how their kids are educated, so if they want to send their kids to a faith school then they should be able to."

Absolutely fine. So long as they aren't allowed to apply to non faith schools. That would be fine. It wouldn't be a problem if a faith based education is so important to them.

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 13:49

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 12:15

@DdraigGoch Any school not holding a daily act of collective worship "of a broadly Christian nature" is not fulfilling its statutory duty, and a new head could-and should- reintroduce it immediately.

The HOL is a largely corrupt institution which should be abolished. However, this thread is about the impact of religion on public life. The Lords Spiritual are in the legislature automatically, and are likely to hold very similar views on health and social issues. Business men,although equally reprehensible, aren't.

I notice you didn't mention faith schools.

A new head could rebadge the toilets as "gender neutral" overnight, which does actually affect the privacy and dignity of your children. I'm not going to be worried about an obsolescent law that the overwhelming majority of schools (and Ofsted) happily ignore.

I believe that parents should have the right to choose how their kids are educated, so if they want to send their kids to a faith school then they should be able to. I went to one (it happened to be the nearest primary). I don't recall it being particularly in-your-face about religion.

Lifeinlists · 20/05/2023 13:47

The 26 bishops in the HoL are never there together, they have a rota, so probably a maximum of 4 or 5 will be there on average. They do have other things to do. Their influence is minimal to non existent.

If I had to choose between Nadine Dorries and a senior bishop (as they all are) taking a seat in the Lords, it wouldn't be a difficult choice.

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 13:45

Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 13:15

But why does that mean we don't need the Lords Spiritual? Obviously you're happy with people of faith in parliament. It works both ways too - members of the Lords Spiritual have many qualities besides their religious positions. Highly educated, probably far more experience of people from all walks of life due to the nature of their work than many MPs

If the Lords Spiritual are there because they of the fact they are Church of England representatives, so they bring a spiritual element (well, a C of E element), then we have plenty of people in faith in Parliament already so no need for that.

We also have people who are educated in there and who have a wide range of experience.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 13:42

Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 13:18

'If you don't believe in God, then there's a message in this that makes me feel like I don't belong in this country.'

That's a very, very extreme response. So, if 2/3 aren't religious do 2/3 of the population feel they don't belong? Of course not.

Christianity, if you don't want it to, impacts your life in precisely zero ways.

It's not Christianity.

It's the link between Church and State.

There is a difference.

Can you argue why there should be a link between Church and State (except for saying it would be complicated to separate them)

Can you argue why we should have God save the King as our anthem when many people don't believe in God?

OP posts:
Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 13:18

'If you don't believe in God, then there's a message in this that makes me feel like I don't belong in this country.'

That's a very, very extreme response. So, if 2/3 aren't religious do 2/3 of the population feel they don't belong? Of course not.

Christianity, if you don't want it to, impacts your life in precisely zero ways.

Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 13:15

But why does that mean we don't need the Lords Spiritual? Obviously you're happy with people of faith in parliament. It works both ways too - members of the Lords Spiritual have many qualities besides their religious positions. Highly educated, probably far more experience of people from all walks of life due to the nature of their work than many MPs

Cornettoninja · 20/05/2023 13:12

DdraigGoch · 19/05/2023 23:32

Doing nothing is precisely what I'm advocating. Political meddling for its own sake is seldom a good thing.

Completely agree.

on a far more superficial level, I find arguments for the abolition of links to religion or becoming a republic utterly devoid of an understanding of the need for joy, tradition and celebration in society.

England managed to get rid of one king only to end up reinstating the monarchy which was in no small part due to the fact that puritans made the country a completely joyless place to live.

It does not make me feel like I belong. It feels like a club for people who have faith and is not inclusive. If you don't believe in God, then there's a message in this that makes me feel like I don't belong in this country

to be brutally honest that sounds like a you problem. I’m a first generation, agnostic at best, person who has no issue with whether or not I belong in the UK. It’s a collection of diverse countries with history dating back centuries. To not be able to identify with any of it.

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 13:09

The people involved in the approval of legislation who are only involved because of their faith...... What about other MPs and members of the Lords. Do you not think it possible that their faith (or lack of faith) has a distinct bearing on their response to legislation? The Hindus, Muslims, Jews who serve in parliament? None of them swayed by their faith? Christians who aren't Lords Spiritual

So we don't need the Lords Spiritual then as we have people of faith in their already.

OP posts:
Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 13:09

'I am sceptical that half the country believe that Jesus was the son of God and that they follow the teachings of Christ given that only a third of people say they are religious.'

Many people are 'cultural Christians'. We live in a country where the tenets of Christianity are the bedrock of our society. People may say they're not religious, but the society they live in, the mores, culture etc are associated with Christianity.

A third of people may say they're religious but there's nothing in these surveys to say whether people associate being religious as going to church, tithing income, fasting etc. Many people who are cultural Christians may not claim to be religious. Many people have a faith or spirituality but wouldn't claim to be religious.

Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 13:04

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 11:55

@DdraigGoch "I'm still waiting to hear how much influence it has over my life."

OK. Here are a few to be going on with.You may not think these things are important, but I do.

In order to take a full part in the life of any state school, you have to be at least a nominal Christian.

People of faith have a choice of a third more schools than people without faith

Any legislation-and this is particularly relevant to health and social policy-has to be approved by a group of people who are only involved in the process at all because of their faith.

According to you, a minority in the UK are Christian so that doesn't square with your claim that 'In order to take a full part in the life of any state school, you have to be at least a nominal Christian.'

The people involved in the approval of legislation who are only involved because of their faith...... What about other MPs and members of the Lords. Do you not think it possible that their faith (or lack of faith) has a distinct bearing on their response to legislation? The Hindus, Muslims, Jews who serve in parliament? None of them swayed by their faith? Christians who aren't Lords Spiritual?

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 12:55

Maybe we could make a start by getting rid of Good Friday, Easter Monday and Christmas Day as official bank holidays and giving people the chance to have more annual leave instead.

So if people wanted to take those days off for religious or because they want to celebrate family at Christmas they could. Or they could have extra leave instead to use when they wanted to. .

People of other faiths could use this extra annual leave to take days off for their religious days.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 12:51

Xenia · 20/05/2023 12:12

Despite the first post more people than not support keeping things as they are and about half the UK is Christian, 2m+ are muslim etc so I don't think religion is going away from the UK any time soon. I think most of us are happy to live in a Christian nation.

How about we live as a nation?

There are plenty of people who are religious.

I am sceptical that half the country believe that Jesus was the son of God and that they follow the teachings of Christ given that only a third of people say they are religious.

Keep religion and the State separate.

What difference will it make to people's lives if their was to be separation? I am sure the Church of England will survive.

OP posts:
MasterGland · 20/05/2023 12:45

AxolotlOnions · 20/05/2023 12:39

Half the traditions you mention have origins outside of England so i would question whether they really are idiosyncratic of English life. But anyway, you are welcome to follow any tradition you wish that does not impact or harm others. But I think tradition for tradition's sake is extremely dangerous and is used to justify some horrific practises so I'll not join you thanks.

Christianity has origins outside of England. I never said all our traditions originated here. I don't see why they should have to originate here.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 12:44

"I shall pray, dance round the maypole, roll cheese down a hill, go to a bottle kicking match, salute magpies and think naught of a king being anointed with oil, until the bitter end." I don't actually think anyone is trying to stop you. What you do in your own time with your own money is entirely up to you.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 12:43

"But in any case, that's not really a separation of church and state issue. Even the most secular state would have some provision for religious observance and organised religion by the state - Bank Holidays, equality laws, charitable status etc."

Of course it would. But it would, one hopes, not use faith as a criterion for access to tax payer funded services. If you're in favour of faith schools, how would you feel about faith hospitals?

AxolotlOnions · 20/05/2023 12:39

MasterGland · 20/05/2023 11:10

The Vatican has deep pockets!

Joking aside, I am often downhearted about this undercurrent in contemporary culture to remove everything idiosyncratic about English life.

I shall pray, dance round the maypole, roll cheese down a hill, go to a bottle kicking match, salute magpies and think naught of a king being anointed with oil, until the bitter end.

Half the traditions you mention have origins outside of England so i would question whether they really are idiosyncratic of English life. But anyway, you are welcome to follow any tradition you wish that does not impact or harm others. But I think tradition for tradition's sake is extremely dangerous and is used to justify some horrific practises so I'll not join you thanks.

EuripidesEumenides · 20/05/2023 12:34

@CurlewKate

If 70% of faith schools are C of E then that sounds about right when you consider the percentage split of faiths among people who follow an organised religion in the UK.

But in any case, that's not really a separation of church and state issue. Even the most secular state would have some provision for religious observance and organised religion by the state - Bank Holidays, equality laws, charitable status etc.

Anonymouseposter · 20/05/2023 12:30

I don’t think the two surveys are incompatible. I think there are problems with organised religion but I do believe in God. I thought the part of the coronation service where the king had to state that he was a true Protestant was very medieval and out of date. I’m in favour of the disestablishment of the Church of England but still in favour of promoting a spiritual aspect in the life of the country. I prefer defender of faith to defender of the faith.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 12:22

@EuripidesEumenides "Not sure I really follow the faith school thing. There are faith schools for most major religions in the UK. We've got two Catholic ones by us. They aren't reserved for the Church of England in its capacity as the formal state religion."
70% of faith schools are CofE. But the point is-faith should not be a requirement of admission to any tax payer funded school.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 12:15

@DdraigGoch Any school not holding a daily act of collective worship "of a broadly Christian nature" is not fulfilling its statutory duty, and a new head could-and should- reintroduce it immediately.

The HOL is a largely corrupt institution which should be abolished. However, this thread is about the impact of religion on public life. The Lords Spiritual are in the legislature automatically, and are likely to hold very similar views on health and social issues. Business men,although equally reprehensible, aren't.

I notice you didn't mention faith schools.