Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the UK needs to think about the role of the religion and the State given that that only 1/3 of people say they are religious

217 replies

cakeorwine · 19/05/2023 20:02

Interesting survey results

lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf (kcl.ac.uk)

1/3 of people are religious, 46% aren't religious and 20% are atheist (not sure of the difference)

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

About half of people believe in life after death and about half don't

Interesting survey - the UK is one of the least religious countries in the world. Something you might not have believed if you think of our anthem and also the recent Coronation.

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/policy-institute/assets/lost-faith-the-uk's-changing-attitudes-to-religion.pdf

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 15:14

So who are you to mandate that for everyone else

We don't have a school system that teaches that God does not exist,
We don't have an anthem that says "God does not exist so he can't save the King"
We don't have a law that states that schools must have a lesson daily that expects all children to attend where they are told that God does not exist.

We don't have a Head of State who is supposed to be someone who is an atheist.

Can you imagine the outcry if those things was suggested.

OP posts:
MasterGland · 20/05/2023 15:12

Idiosyncratic does not mean that it has to be exclusive, just not widely practiced. Hence peculiar. Many people can be described as having idiosyncratic behaviours, for instance. This does not mean those behaviours can be found exclusively in that one person and no one else.

Are you seriously suggesting that if I asked an Australian, for instance, to name the country where cheese rolling and maypole dancing were traditions, they would be able to reel off a list of several countries from around the world?

Cornettoninja · 20/05/2023 15:11

AxolotlOnions · 20/05/2023 15:01

If they didn't originate here and they are done elsewhere they're not idiosyncratic to English life. They can't be that unique or peculiar if they're practiced worldwide!

Are you referring to specific traditions? A tradition isn’t necessarily practiced routinely in its country of origin but may have been adopted by another country.

I genuinely can’t pinpoint any tradition that’s worldwide.

Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 15:09

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:39

@DdraigGoch all faith schools have faith admissions criterion. Other people only get in if there are spaces.

I don't know any parent or any CofE school where parents have been questioned about their faith practices before a space has been allocated.

Coxspurplepippin · 20/05/2023 15:07

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:16

OK - because many people don't believe God exists. Some people also believe that a belief in God and religion itself has caused a lot of harm and destruction over the centuries. So singing God save the King is asking (for some) that a being they don't believe in should save the King.

Separating the C of E and the State. Religion is personal. Belief is personal. The Bishops should not be appointed by the Prime Minister (even though it is on recommendation, they can still be blocked). Thatcher blocked the appointment of a Bishop she thought was too political.

Faith should be for personal life just as many other beliefs are. We don't need a State Religion anymore than we need a State sport or a State dietary system such as vegetarianism or veganism.

'Belief is personal '. So your belief that there is no god and your belief that there should be separation of church and state is personal. So who are you to mandate that for everyone else.

I think faith goes a tiny way to combat capitalism. I'm OK with that. I see countries where there has been an attempt to abolish religion (Russia and China spring to mind) and remove any religious influence. Don't particularly like what I see.

AxolotlOnions · 20/05/2023 15:01

MasterGland · 20/05/2023 12:45

Christianity has origins outside of England. I never said all our traditions originated here. I don't see why they should have to originate here.

If they didn't originate here and they are done elsewhere they're not idiosyncratic to English life. They can't be that unique or peculiar if they're practiced worldwide!

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:50

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:39

@DdraigGoch all faith schools have faith admissions criterion. Other people only get in if there are spaces.

I don't know of any primary school, even "St Swithin's CofE Primary" which selects its intake. When I went to school (obviously pre-academies), all state schools apart from one religious secondary in the city centre just had pupils sent to them by the local authorities according to the usual criteria of special needs, siblings and walking distance (with due reference to the list the families entered on the form).

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:45

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:35

But you will see that that affects your argument to send children to a non faith school when for some people, the only local school is a faith school.

And maybe some parents don't want their children to in a faith school and don't want to have to make the child seem different by asking them to withdraw from collective worship.

But I can't see the C of E giving up its faith schools and I can't see the state building more secular schools in such villages.

A third of schools are "faith schools". Less than a quarter of schools are compliant with the 1998 act. In between there are clearly a number of faith schools who are so strong in their faith that they don't bother to have a daily (it's not actually required to be that frequent in the law) act of worship. It's such a non-issue. Your kids sitting bored in a hall while someone waffles on about loaves and fishes (though with a few good messages about helping other people) will not turn them into evangelical zealots.

I don't really care if you do amend the 1998 act, though I consider it to be a waste of time to rewrite something that everyone was ignoring anyway. I don't however see why the Coronation ceremonies and traditions should be torn up. The King being Defender of the Faith doesn't impact upon my life (or yours frankly) in the slightest. It's just a sweet old tradition.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:44

@cakeorwine There are no secular schools in the UK.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:39

@DdraigGoch all faith schools have faith admissions criterion. Other people only get in if there are spaces.

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:36

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:34

@DdraigGoch

I don't know how you think that you're going to enforce that."

Easy. If they choose to apply for a faith school, they can't apply to a non faith school.

Are you specifically talking about selective faith schools? The sort where mothers pretend to be religious to get their kids in? I had in mind the ordinary local primary that just happens to be CofE but still gets attended by pupils of all faiths and none.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/05/2023 14:36

50% believe in God and 48% don't - so that's a bit weird if you think about the previous survey

Not really; after all there's a big difference between faith and organised religion

Completely agree with you about the need to separate church and state though, but it won't happen easily while some are thoroughly enjoying their preferential positions

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:35

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:31

As I said, I went to a CofE school and it did me no harm.

But then I don't follow the contemporary philosophy that exposure to ideas that you might disagree with is a bad thing.

But you will see that that affects your argument to send children to a non faith school when for some people, the only local school is a faith school.

And maybe some parents don't want their children to in a faith school and don't want to have to make the child seem different by asking them to withdraw from collective worship.

But I can't see the C of E giving up its faith schools and I can't see the state building more secular schools in such villages.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:34

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:31

Which begs the question:

Should the Prime Minister appoint Bishops?

I think that Thatcher blocked the appointment of Jim Thomson. And yes - I have seen Yes Prime Minister. It's a pick a card trick, and they ensure the right card gets picked.

Surely the C of E should decide who its Bishops and ArchBishops are.

Maggie Thatcher is ancient history. There has been a precedent since Tony Blair's time that instead of choosing between the two "cards", the PM always selects the one on top. So in the de facto sense, the PM hasn't chosen a bishop in decades.

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:34

@DdraigGoch

I don't know how you think that you're going to enforce that."

Easy. If they choose to apply for a faith school, they can't apply to a non faith school.

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:31

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:28

Much easier said than done in some places.

Villages often have just the one school and often it's a faith school because the Churches built schools.

As I said, I went to a CofE school and it did me no harm.

But then I don't follow the contemporary philosophy that exposure to ideas that you might disagree with is a bad thing.

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:31

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:28

I am sceptical that half the country believe that Jesus was the son of God and that they follow the teachings of Christ given that only a third of people say they are religious.

I'm not sure that every bishop believes that Jesus was the son of God. Have you ever watched Yes, Prime Minister? There's an episode in that devoted to the appointment of a bishop and the idea that believing in God was an optional extra in the Anglican Communion was clearly a running joke even in the '80s.

Which begs the question:

Should the Prime Minister appoint Bishops?

I think that Thatcher blocked the appointment of Jim Thomson. And yes - I have seen Yes Prime Minister. It's a pick a card trick, and they ensure the right card gets picked.

Surely the C of E should decide who its Bishops and ArchBishops are.

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:28

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:24

Send your kid to one of the two-thirds of schools that isn't a faith school. Even many of those who are faith schools aren't in your face about it.

Much easier said than done in some places.

Villages often have just the one school and often it's a faith school because the Churches built schools.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:28

I am sceptical that half the country believe that Jesus was the son of God and that they follow the teachings of Christ given that only a third of people say they are religious.

I'm not sure that every bishop believes that Jesus was the son of God. Have you ever watched Yes, Prime Minister? There's an episode in that devoted to the appointment of a bishop and the idea that believing in God was an optional extra in the Anglican Communion was clearly a running joke even in the '80s.

Cornettoninja · 20/05/2023 14:26

Absolutely fine. So long as they aren't allowed to apply to non faith schools. That would be fine. It wouldn't be a problem if a faith based education is so important to them

sorry, are you arguing for segregation based on faith/no faith?

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:24

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:10

@DdraigGoch Also-what about my fight to a secular education for my children?

Send your kid to one of the two-thirds of schools that isn't a faith school. Even many of those who are faith schools aren't in your face about it.

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:23

CurlewKate · 20/05/2023 14:00

@DdraigGoch "I believe that parents should have the right to choose how their kids are educated, so if they want to send their kids to a faith school then they should be able to."

Absolutely fine. So long as they aren't allowed to apply to non faith schools. That would be fine. It wouldn't be a problem if a faith based education is so important to them.

I don't know how you think that you're going to enforce that.

"Our Jeremy Kyle lie detector says that you once prayed that your husband would come back safe from Iraq*. Therefore you're not permitted to send your child to Generic High School.

*People who don't really believe in god and have never been to church will often grasp at any straws when their lives or those of their loved ones are in peril.

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 14:17

Lifeinlists · 20/05/2023 13:47

The 26 bishops in the HoL are never there together, they have a rota, so probably a maximum of 4 or 5 will be there on average. They do have other things to do. Their influence is minimal to non existent.

If I had to choose between Nadine Dorries and a senior bishop (as they all are) taking a seat in the Lords, it wouldn't be a difficult choice.

I'd go further. In the Lords reform I'm proposing I'd appoint the Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, the Chief Rabbi, and leaders of the other major religions in the UK to the Lords. I'd also appoint the former heads of the services, former senior police officers, presidents of the Royal Colleges and any other professional institution with a Royal Charter. It would ensure a broad range of talents. That's the crossbenchers done.

Then I would allocate the remaining 50% to the political appointees (because many retired MPs/ministers do have lots of experience to bring), restricting the number of new appointees to a quota based on the vote share at the last GE - so party leaders will have to be a bit more choosy about who they appoint because they can't stuff the house any more. This brings some proportionality to parliament without yet more elections, the last thing we want is another chamber of politicians kissing babies to win a few votes - as I said before, I want the upper house to be composed of people who want to do what's right, not what's popular; I want them to be answerable to no one. The Commons should provide enough representative democracy, the role of the Lords is to improve legislation by using their experience to send amendments to the Commons.

Cornettoninja · 20/05/2023 14:17

Ok.

I just don’t agree with you and don’t perceive the problem to be serious or big enough to warrant changing.

cakeorwine · 20/05/2023 14:16

Cornettoninja · 20/05/2023 14:04

Can you argue why there should be a link between Church and State (except for saying it would be complicated to separate them)

Can you argue why we should have God save the King as our anthem when many people don't believe in God?

There’s no requirement for anyone to have an argument for either. If the proposal is to remove them it’s on the proposer to present a convincing argument.

OK - because many people don't believe God exists. Some people also believe that a belief in God and religion itself has caused a lot of harm and destruction over the centuries. So singing God save the King is asking (for some) that a being they don't believe in should save the King.

Separating the C of E and the State. Religion is personal. Belief is personal. The Bishops should not be appointed by the Prime Minister (even though it is on recommendation, they can still be blocked). Thatcher blocked the appointment of a Bishop she thought was too political.

Faith should be for personal life just as many other beliefs are. We don't need a State Religion anymore than we need a State sport or a State dietary system such as vegetarianism or veganism.

OP posts: