Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a buy to let a status symbol in the UK?

119 replies

socialmedia23 · 19/05/2023 19:35

I can't quite understand why everyone I know who has a little spare cash on the side (I am 30 so people I know are generally in that age group) talks about buying a buy to let. Even in today's economic circumstances (high mortgage rates) and unfavourable tax conditions. I live in London so most people in my age group would be paying 40% tax if they got a BTL though I guess they would be buying it under a corporation. However, they don't have years and years of savings or equity so would presumably not be buying in cash..

It doesn't make any sense to me but I realized that fairly flashy people I know always talk about their BTLs so it got me thinking, is it a status symbol in the UK? I am not originally from the UK so I really didn't know. I understand it made sense for a lot of older people in the past to supplement their pension. I am from a country which prizes home ownership (89% home ownership) and own my flat too so I understand this drive to 'own' property and of course your own home. But in my country, I hardly hear perfectly ordinary and average people 'aspire' to be landlords. And from a financial perspective, it doesn't really make sense these days with all the regulation so the only way to explain the public's obsession with it is that it is emotional

My dad was always a landlord but he does it as a full time thing and mainly invests in commercial property and is more into the 'development' aspect. And he certainly doesn't think of it as a status symbol more like his career, and he has had a life long interest in property. He would not do it as a side hustle and certainly not if it was as regulated/taxed as it is here.

OP posts:
jenandberrys · 26/05/2023 06:50

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 15:05

@pigsDOfly

what you re are missing is the general point, some specifically applies to you but in the main applies to the vast majority of private LLs, you seem far too heavily invested in being seen to be a good LL.

Yes i wonder why i am so upset? who'd have thought it eh!

As for finding another home, thats unlikely and even if i did, whats to say in a few months/years some else decides to sell up?

The new renters reform bill does nothing to stop this from happeningto many others all over again, private LLs are the new slave traders, making monies out of other peoples misery.

😂😂😂😂 landlords as slave traders! I suppose it’s a slight variation on Godwins Law.

You sound completely ridiculous

Doagooddeed · 26/05/2023 06:46

@RedRosette2023 So a few more families uprooted because your portfolio wasn't tax efficient i.e didn't make you enough money.

This is exactly why the majority of rented accommodation should be operated by councils.

RedRosette2023 · 26/05/2023 06:39

socialmedia23 · 19/05/2023 19:48

A lot of it is timing I guess. But now it's 40% tax unless you buy through a corporation, high mortgage rates and now rent reform means end to no fault evictions and the tenant can take you to tribunal if rent increase is too high. It's not that I don't support these measures but I am sure there are better ways of investing money at this moment than buying into something that is literal political dynamite.

All this is under a Conservative government. When labour gets in, there would be rent freezes in London because Sadiq khan has been asking it every year.

And then the whole EPC thing...

I am sure lots of landlord who have built up equity are still making a lot of money. But to aspire to a BTL when there is so much uncertainty means it can only be emotional or people haven't gotten the memo.

We had a small portfolio and sold them for this reason. Some were held in a company but that made them inflexible. The others just weren’t tax efficient.

Poopoolittlekitten · 26/05/2023 06:37

ichundich · 22/05/2023 11:10
Doagooddeed · 20/05/2023 15:44

Exactly, get some poor sod to buy you a house and a lifestyle and then make them homeless with just 2 months notice.

You sound lovely.
Show quote history
Blame the system not the landlords. In Germany section 466 of the civil code prevents landlords from kicking out tenants when they sell the property. It could easily be implemented here if there was a will.'

Ever heard of a moral compass? @ichundich BTL landords do get a bad rap, but comments like this are why... 'blame the system' okay then...

Mintyt · 26/05/2023 06:20

Not for us it's an investment, it's the house next door to us, the same young family are tenants for the past 8 years, we took no deposit.

Poopoolittlekitten · 26/05/2023 06:11

Agreed, BTL is much more demonised in the south shed rents are extortionate and many people are wondering how their kids will ever be able to afford to rent here never mind own a place

Knickerthief1 · 22/05/2023 21:33

So many attitudes towards BTL are from people in the South East. I'm a landlord in the North East. Up here you can buy a property for £45k. Generally speaking people have rented my property for a few years and then left to buy a property. We are selling up next year as new rules and a fixed rate mortgage ending mean we would have to put £400 a month in ourselves to cover the tax and additional mortgage payments. We told our tenants the other week (and gave them up to 12 months notice fwiw). They said everyone is pulling out of the rental market now and fortunately they are ready to buy. The new rules are addressing a problem that exists in London and not in other locations. There's also very little capital appreciation where I live! As a result right now for the first time ever there are no rental properties available in the immediate area on Rightmove. That is just crazy. I also work for a social landlord and we are expecting to take huge hits to our development programme due to costs of EPC by 2030 and carbon zero by 2050. It's the same across the country. The government has issued these targets but offered very little funding so far to assist. At a time when more social housing than ever is needed there is less being built.

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 21:06

CMZ2018 · 22/05/2023 19:27

Dry your eyes

Typical of the contempt many LLs hold their tenants in.

But well done for making this point so well.

Bookist · 22/05/2023 19:33

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 19/05/2023 19:49

It marks you out as a greedy immoral low life. Private landlords are typically despised.

How nice. We own 2 buy to lets and would like to think we're good landlords. You might find it hard to believe, but we still exchange Christmas cards with several tenants.

CMZ2018 · 22/05/2023 19:27

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 19/05/2023 19:49

It marks you out as a greedy immoral low life. Private landlords are typically despised.

Dry your eyes

HappiestSleeping · 22/05/2023 18:22

socialmedia23 · 22/05/2023 12:24

Not complaining about it but it does mean that it makes far less sense to rent out property if it's under your name..

Yeah, but that's like saying "I'm not going to take this promotion with increased salary because I'll have to pay more tax."

Of course there are tax efficient ways of doing things, but that is true of any income. Also, there's no such thing as a free lunch, so although it might be tax efficient, it isn't tax free.

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 17:59

ichundich · 22/05/2023 15:28

Great idea in a country where the Tories manage to run everything into the ground within years! Have you ever considered a move to North Korea?

No, have you? fyi i believe its hard to get a visa.

Plenty of perfectly normal western european countries have not put into private ownership the provision of housing for the least well off, have they Govts that voted down legislating to make rented housing habitable or have kids dying of mould related deaths.

We used to have a reasonably decent social housing sector, post war till the early 80s.

ichundich · 22/05/2023 16:59

Poopoolittlekitten · 22/05/2023 15:36

It’s more - seems like a safe investment as house prices have gone mad IMHO. That being said, I am starting to think people like this are wankers, as most of the ones I know who have gone down the landlord route are…

Another one of your lazy stereotypes. Is the private school thread getting a bit boring?

socialmedia23 · 22/05/2023 16:57

ichundich · 22/05/2023 15:28

Great idea in a country where the Tories manage to run everything into the ground within years! Have you ever considered a move to North Korea?

in my home country, singapore, the state builds the housing that 85% of Singaporeans live in. Its not North Korea, in fact its the opposite. We have 89% home ownership. Its sold to Singaporean citizens and permanent residents at a discounted rate. We actually inherited this housing system from the British and i guess at the start, it was quite similar to the council housing system. Unfortunately in the uk, it has become massively scaled back but in singapore it has expanded to the extent that 85% of the population live in it including the middle classes.

I do think that the way forward would be the state acquiring more housing to house the poor (as opposed to paying housing benefit to private landlords) but at the same time, we need to open it up to the middle classes so they have a vested interest. in singapore, even property developers like my father are supportive of the HDB project namely because he knows that it means that his children are practically guaranteed a property that they can afford and he doesn't need to give us any deposits. There are probably not many British parents of millennials who can say that they are sure that their children can afford to buy their own properties with zero help!

In fact, even if I never married or couldn't afford to buy a property in London (where I live), I would still be eligible to buy a government hdb flat in singapore as soon as I turned 35 which is only in 4 years. I can't buy it unless I sell my flat in London (and DH needs to get PR in Singapore or I need to buy it as a single in 4 years time) which I suppose is fair in the greater scheme of things.

OP posts:
Poopoolittlekitten · 22/05/2023 15:36

It’s more - seems like a safe investment as house prices have gone mad IMHO. That being said, I am starting to think people like this are wankers, as most of the ones I know who have gone down the landlord route are…

pigsDOfly · 22/05/2023 15:32

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 15:05

@pigsDOfly

what you re are missing is the general point, some specifically applies to you but in the main applies to the vast majority of private LLs, you seem far too heavily invested in being seen to be a good LL.

Yes i wonder why i am so upset? who'd have thought it eh!

As for finding another home, thats unlikely and even if i did, whats to say in a few months/years some else decides to sell up?

The new renters reform bill does nothing to stop this from happeningto many others all over again, private LLs are the new slave traders, making monies out of other peoples misery.

I'm not heavily invested in being seen as a good landlord. I don't know you or the posters on here and really couldn't care what you or they think of me.

l just find it ridiculous that all LLs are seen as 'evil', as has been stated in this thread.

It's a transaction, the landlord rents the property out, the tenant pays for that service. Sometimes certain services have to be terminated. If someone rents a house then they must accept that at some point the transaction may come to an end.

Many small landlords are selling now because they just can't manage to keep the properties in the rental market for whatever reason, one of those often being that tenants aren't paying their rent.

To get a tenant out through the courts takes around six month. The landlord still has to pay the mortgage even though no rent is being paid. Small landlords often can't sustain that amount of loss.

There are a huge number of tenants, I've had my fair share of them, that move into a perfectly decent house with decent landlord who then proceed to not pay any rent and leave the place wrecked.

There's a lot of bad landlords out there but equally there are a lot of bad tenants. Sometimes it's just not worth the landlords while to keep on renting out.

curtainsfringe · 22/05/2023 15:28

I think for older generations BTLs were seen as easy money. Easier to borrow, rising prices often meant big gains & its fair easier to understand than money markets or pensions.
It's defo not as profitable as it was though.

ichundich · 22/05/2023 15:28

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 14:10

What i would do is as LLs sell, the state buys the property at the avg market level in that area.
So should not be forced to keep on properties.

Funded by the rent collected, huge reduction in council temporary accommodation costs inc limiting children missing school, not too mention keeping people in the area, work etc, rents could then more closely matched to what people can afford.
Also, an appreciating asset on councils books.

Longer term, a move towards council housing, as this happens, private properties that were bought, would then be sold on the open market if people wanted to be in a newer council house, if not stay where they are, with secure tenancies.

Great idea in a country where the Tories manage to run everything into the ground within years! Have you ever considered a move to North Korea?

curtainsfringe · 22/05/2023 15:26

Lots of people who are dead against it would do it in a flash if they had the means imo and experience. I'm not sure why people are so against it other than envy

Younger people are against it because simply by being born later they often have to pay more in rent than they would on a mortgage.

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 15:05

@pigsDOfly

what you re are missing is the general point, some specifically applies to you but in the main applies to the vast majority of private LLs, you seem far too heavily invested in being seen to be a good LL.

Yes i wonder why i am so upset? who'd have thought it eh!

As for finding another home, thats unlikely and even if i did, whats to say in a few months/years some else decides to sell up?

The new renters reform bill does nothing to stop this from happeningto many others all over again, private LLs are the new slave traders, making monies out of other peoples misery.

pigsDOfly · 22/05/2023 14:59

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 11:00

@pigsDOfly

No i am not picking holes, i am stating the reality, LLs age, don't want the hassle and sell, which you also have said may well happen in your case.

That means someone who has made a home for many years gets booted out, its happening to me, its happening to friends i know, sect 21 notices are on the increase, changes to taxation, EPCs and aging LLs mean this will only go one way.

I'm sorry you cannot see the distress this is causing, we simply cannot all afford to buy a house, huge numbers of essential but very low paid workers will never earn enough, their security is at the whim of a private LL and his/her retirement plans.

Incidentally, i don't blame the LL's but a system encouraged by both Tory and Lab that has allowed this to happen.

There's not a lot of point in my responding to your above post as you're clearly not reading what I've actually written.

But what I would just say is, yes, I said that I might possibly sell the house at some time in the future. But as I also said that will not happen unless, or until, the current tenant decides to move out. I will not sell it until then so how would I be booting someone out of the home they've lived in for years?

Far from not being able to see the distress having to leave a home after years causes, I am very much aware of it, having had to move my three children out of the only home they'd known following my divorce, which is why I wouldn't ask my tenant to leave so I can sell the house; not that I have any plans to sell anyway.

If you want to have a sensible discussion it really helps to listen to, or in this case read, what the other person is saying, something you're clearly not doing with my posts.

You're, understandably, clearly very upset about having to leave your home. I hope you find another house that you can enjoy in the same way.

Dungaree · 22/05/2023 14:32

It is free money for those with no conscience.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 22/05/2023 14:24

I think for most small landlords it's a pension rather than a status symbol. We've considered it ourselves. According to some advisors every £100k in your pension pot gives you £4k pa pension. Where I live £300k buys you a 3/4 bed detached that will give a rental of £12k pa, so you have a continuous income plus the capital. Its a no brainer really.

Flunkey · 22/05/2023 14:14

TallulahBetty · 22/05/2023 14:02

And this is why you are a bad landlord. YOU ARE RUNNING A BUSINESS. Doesn't matter if it is profitable or not. Your poor tenants had better hope you're up to date with all the correct, current legislation and safety regs etc.

Pardon me? How do you know I'm a bad landlord? 😂

Nordicrain · 22/05/2023 14:12

Doagooddeed · 22/05/2023 14:10

What i would do is as LLs sell, the state buys the property at the avg market level in that area.
So should not be forced to keep on properties.

Funded by the rent collected, huge reduction in council temporary accommodation costs inc limiting children missing school, not too mention keeping people in the area, work etc, rents could then more closely matched to what people can afford.
Also, an appreciating asset on councils books.

Longer term, a move towards council housing, as this happens, private properties that were bought, would then be sold on the open market if people wanted to be in a newer council house, if not stay where they are, with secure tenancies.

Alright, well at the minute that's not an option for PP because the state is not offering to pick up all these properties. So it's a bit out of order to make out like she is some evil money grabbing capitalist LL because she says she wants to sell sometime in the future.

And in your position, you need LLs to exist. Because - as you say yourself - you can't buy and currently alternatives (other than private rentals) don't exist.