Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Students, stress and anxiety

112 replies

Jourdain11 · 19/05/2023 19:31

I work in a university and it's the middle of exam season. For most universities this is the first year returning to in-person exams, but actually not for the one I work in.

These last few weeks have been a constant flood of deferrals, issues in exams, requests to cancel their attempt and retake in August. Some are very well justified, others not so much. Unless there has genuinely been a breakout of gastroenteritis in student halls which has incapacitated every student for a full two weeks.

Since Covid, there seems to be an accepted get-out clause on everything. If you don't want to do it, you just don't! Yet I worry that it is not helping students in the long- or even short-term. They are backing up assessments and at some point they run out of road and it's even more stressful. And meanwhile, workloads are unmanageable.

What can be done about it? Do universities just need to be tougher? Everyone is worried about possible harm being caused, but I do worry that by trying to alleviate stress for the few, we're creating a ridiculously permissive situation for the many, which is not to their advantage.

Or, if so many students are genuinely so stressed and anxious that they cannot do a single exam - what needs to change?

OP posts:
DollyParkin · 20/05/2023 14:46

but living through Covid deprived young people of many important experiences and I believe some of the effects of that are now being seen. It also taught that cohort that nothing is set in stone. If a whole set of national exams can be ditched overnight, and schools be closed for months, what's the big deal about an essay extension?

Thing is, we ALL lived through COVID. We all had to adjust & had our own challenges and struggles. I found myself thinking about my parents and grandparents living through WW2 - my father lost his father - my grandfather was a highly decorated war hero, but that is no compensation for losing your father at age 11. They all just got on with it, and adjusted and lived through it (or died).

But what I find now - and indeed in the middle of all the lockdowns - is the resentment by students about COVID and all the adjustments we made. They visited their fear & resentment at constraints on university staff - and they still do.

We were following the laws - although I had students who tried to demand (quite rudely) that we teach them in-person when it was actually illegal to do so. I think this is what sticks in my throat - that there is still a proportion of undergrads who won't take responsibility for just getting on with things. Not all students, by the way! My cohort last year were amazing.

We've all gone through something huge & challenging - it was nobody's fault, but some students still direct a weird kind of resentment, as if it's the university's fault!

DollyParkin · 20/05/2023 14:30

If I was Prime Minister (unlikely, I admit), my number one priority would be education (in all forms, from Primary school to post-grad to apprenticeships). No matter what the cost, I would make our schools the envy of the world. Education is key to everything: health, GDP, crime...all of them can be improved through education. The better educated a society is, the wealthier, healthier and more civilised it tends to be.

@JaneyGee for PM!!!!! I'd work for you.

DollyParkin · 20/05/2023 14:27

I will agree that university is not for everyone. However, I think we should be catching more people in their last couple of years of school to identify those students and educate them on different, equally valid career paths.

And I wish we had an education system where it was easier NOT to go at 18 to university if you & your parents & teachers recognise you're not ready, but to be able to re-enter formal education in your late 20s, or 30s - whenever you're ready to work hard and gain the extra education to get you further on in life. And that this was normal.

DollyParkin · 20/05/2023 13:57

Anxiety is very real and debilitating for him.

Anxiety about what, if you don't mind me asking @Minervia ?

I find it not particularly constructive if a student says they "have anxiety." The best way to deal with anxiety is to work out what it's about, and to break down the catastrophising into rational, doable steps.

There are things I'm anxious or scared about doing (even at my old age!) but I think it through. I try to work out what specific thing bothers me, and then try to plan around that.

Why aren't we teaching our DC this?

BananaPalm · 20/05/2023 13:55

JudgeJ · 20/05/2023 13:50

Mostly because students get stressed about an assignment, get an extension, hand in something that isn't meaningfully better than what they would have handed in on time, and then are behind for the next deadline.

Then maybe they're wasting their time being at University or do they intend going through the rest of their lives making excuses for their own inadequacies? Maybe they've left mummy's apron strings too soon.

Couldn't agree more. It got to the stage that if I'm ever in a position to be a recruiting manager in my workplace, I'll make sure that the probationary period is as long as possible HR-wise. I'll want to make sure that any fresh uni leavers that could end up with us can withstand the pressure of a workplace.

DollyParkin · 20/05/2023 13:54

but SOME anxiety is a normal human emotion and, as someone said above, it’s not setting students up for real life.

I think this is very apposite @Airdustmoon - difficulty, pain, anxiety about the unknown, finding stuff hard to do - these are all NORMAL. A bit of stress can be good for people - stimulating and energising. We actually learn by tackling difficult things and working our way through them, and also we learn from failure.

Where I do have sympathy for my students is that they are now an over-examined and over-tested population. They start with SATS at age, what 6 or 7? and although SATS are supposed to test the efficacy of the school's teaching, we all know that SATS are proxies throughout a child's education for her ability.

There's little or no space to fail.

This focus on teaching also takes the focus on learning as a separate activity. I'm a good teacher - I offer my undergrads opportunities to work through complex material, and I offer several different ways to approach materials (for different ways that people learn best). But if the students do not do the work ... If they come to seminars having not read the required reading, if they are not prepared to contribute to discussions, if they do not spend 40 hours a week on their studies (many are shocked when I say this is what we assume - a full-time load!), if they do not even attend. Then I'm not a bad teacher - they're not taking up opportunities offered them to learn.

JudgeJ · 20/05/2023 13:53

We've also never seen such high levels of childhood anxiety, self-harm, eating disorders and depression. We're also seeing these things occurring in younger children than before.

If the posts on this site from parents who are in a constant state of 'anxiety' it's not surprising that these levels exist, it seems that 'anxiety' is highly contagious.

JudgeJ · 20/05/2023 13:50

Mostly because students get stressed about an assignment, get an extension, hand in something that isn't meaningfully better than what they would have handed in on time, and then are behind for the next deadline.

Then maybe they're wasting their time being at University or do they intend going through the rest of their lives making excuses for their own inadequacies? Maybe they've left mummy's apron strings too soon.

Minervia · 20/05/2023 13:45

My son is in his first year and leaving. He has found it too stressful. He was the year that didn't do GCSEs. He's clever. I never thought he would struggle but he seems to have no confidence or resliance. Anxiety is very real and debilitating for him. He is coming home anyway. Enough is enough for him.

DollyParkin · 20/05/2023 13:40

Totally agree @Jourdain11

I've been teaching students all year some of whom seem incapable of turning up to seminars on time, incapable of speaking up in a seminar (although they'll chat to each other while I'm talking), incapable of handing work in on time, and incapable of following simple directions or finding out information when we signpost them to it.

I've cut them slack this year, as they have been COVID-affected for the last few years.

But I'm worried that this lack of discipline & resilience, and the constant "What do I have to do to get a First?" or "I need a powerpoint slide to tell me what I'm supposed to learn" or "I have anxiety" (anxious about what specifically??) will become the new normal.

And I teach a competitive subject at an RG university.

I really worry for some of these young people who will get a rude shock in the workplace. I would love to be tougher with them, but I can't stand the level of bitching, complaints, and impact on MY mental health (and my career) that this would have.

And my university has the referred/deferred (including the kids who didn't get their act together during term time, as well as those with genuine impediments to doing as well as they can) deadlines in the middle of August - so the only time I can take more than 2 or 3 days' leave in a row is interrupted by marking.

neverbeenskiing · 20/05/2023 13:39

England is now ranked fourth in the world for childhood literacy, behind only Hong Kong, Singapore and Russia. We've never been ranked so high. I know teachers (and parents) dislike league tables, homework, constant testing, and so on, but it works.

We've also never seen such high levels of childhood anxiety, self-harm, eating disorders and depression. We're also seeing these things occurring in younger children than before. I'm a secondary school DSL and whereas it used to be quite unusual for kids to present with diagnosable mental health issues until year 9 or 10 we've seen a big increase in kids coming to us from primary school already self harming, having panic attacks or eating issues. My best friend is a GP and is seeing 10 and 11 year olds with genuine clinical level anxiety triggered by the pressure of SATS or preparing for the 11+. Maybe constant testing "works" but at what cost?

RampantIvy · 20/05/2023 13:27

it's all geared to going to Uni or apprenticeships for those who have practical skills. The children who aren't really skilled in either area still get driven towards Uni and then can't cope,

I agree. Schools and 6th form colleges want to look good so they can publish the destinations that the pupils went on to. They especially focus on Oxbridge and RG universities as being the gold standard.

I think schools should also fensure that 6th formers know full well that they will not get the hand holding at university that they do at school. If you are in a cohort of 300 for your course your lecturers won't know you from Adam. This was certainly true in DD's case.

The problem is that some people simply shouldn't be at uni. Perhaps it's too much for them emotionally or academically but in any case the unis should be able to say "look, we've tried to help you in so many ways - it's time to think whether uni is for you or not". But in this day and age, obviously no one will have the courage to say that.

Totally agree.

DD's university was pretty strict about extensions. DD applied for a PEC when she had covid in the middle of writing her final year dissertation, and it was refused. Her dissertation tutor even agreed that it wasn't fair.

Flowers @toddlermom99. I hope your baby is recovering well.

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 20/05/2023 13:19

@JenniferBarkley That's really interesting to see how the various year groups at uni are coping. My DD is year 2.

toddlermom99 · 20/05/2023 12:35

I can't even fathom that all of these students are getting exam dates moved, extensions etc due to minor issues. It's alot more strict in my university! I'm a young mom and my baby had to have his leg amputated and the amount of evidence and justification I had to go through in the middle of his recovery just to get my assignment due dates moved to the summer period was insane. Confused

Jourdain11 · 20/05/2023 12:26

@andifeelfine
I wouldn't assume all students are taking the piss. Just because you haven't been badly scarred from lockdown doesn't mean others haven't been. Don't underestimate how long it's going to take for everyone to really heal.

Firstly, I don't assume that all students are taking the piss. Secondly, who's to say I'm not scarred from lockdown? However, we've been out of restrictions for a year at this point.

OP posts:
Jourdain11 · 20/05/2023 12:18

I really feel for the students, and I don’t think they’re making it up or mistaking normal anxiousness for anxiety disorders.

Sorry, but in some cases they really are!

OP posts:
BuffyTheCat · 20/05/2023 11:32

I really feel for the students, and I don’t think they’re making it up or mistaking normal anxiousness for anxiety disorders. They’ve missed out on so much during covid, at a critical time of development. I don’t think resilience is something people usually develop during catastrophic circumstances. Our young adults have been through something most of us can’t imagine.

I have two DC at university at the moment. One started before covid and is managing ok. The other started during covid and is really not managing and is one of the students who has asked for multiple extensions. She was always quite resilient as a child, but covid pretty much broke her. She has no confidence about anything. It’s incredibly sad.

Tyrannosaurusdrip · 20/05/2023 11:12

I'm anxious about an essay due Monday and have procrastinated because of it. Now both kids have chicken pox and my essay is still due. Could I defer? Probably. Will I? No.
But I'm older and slightly wiser than your average fresher.

Movinalong · 20/05/2023 11:09

BananaPalm · 19/05/2023 21:37

The problem is that some people simply shouldn't be at uni. Perhaps it's too much for them emotionally or academically but in any case the unis should be able to say "look, we've tried to help you in so many ways - it's time to think whether uni is for you or not". But in this day and age, obviously no one will have the courage to say that.

The problem is that universities are not going to do this as they are paid by number of students. This system also means that they have to pay a lot of attention to student course assessments as they don't want to put students off so they give high grades for shoddy work and or dumb down courses. The conservatives user pays system has abjectly failed once again.

Toomuchmarking · 20/05/2023 11:00

I think we also need to appreciate the level of anxiety generated by Whatsapp. Only last week I had an argument with a student who was challenging my explanation of what was required in order to pass their assignment. Apparently another student in the group was encouraging them to approach the assignment in a certain way which would, in my humble opinion, result in a fail. The student insisted that I was wrong and that the WhatsApp interpretation was the correct way to go.
Who am I to question the veracity of WhatsApp? I'm only the person who wrote the course, created the assignment, compiled the reading list, will be marking the assignment, and have two chapters in the key textbook on the subject! Since I put out an announcement challenging WhatsApps version of the truth I have received a flurry of extensions (granted by the centralised university system that doesn't know the students and is unable to differentiate between those in genuine need and those who are taking the piss) on the grounds that I had not explained the assignment to them. Why didn't any of these people book a tutorial ?😡😡

JenniferBarkley · 20/05/2023 10:27

I'm very old fashioned, but I'm increasingly suspicious of any assessment that doesn't take place on pen and paper in an invigilated exam hall. Luckily that works ok for my subject.

Good exams ask open ended questions that require students to write something creative rather than just regurgitate facts, but it's easier in some subjects than others.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 20/05/2023 10:15

Exams are very artificial and don't measure the appropriate skills. There is no need for people to mug up information that they will forget a week later. It would be better to assess people in more realistic settings than have it all be about performance in written tests over a short period of time. Increasingly, the best at that sort of activity is AI. And AI has zero understanding. That tells you all you need to know about the significance of exams.

That is not to say that a modest degree of stress can't be motivating. Some stress is a fact of life and would inevitably be part of any alternative form of assessment but undergoing a more natural form of assessment would be a better training experience than exams.

JenniferBarkley · 20/05/2023 10:06

TooBored1 · 20/05/2023 10:03

Exercising legal rights to industrial action to, in part, protect educational standards, is not being lazy.

Plus there's every chance OP isn't taking part in the boycott. I haven't heard of a single person in our large school who is.

TooBored1 · 20/05/2023 10:03

nighthawk99 · 19/05/2023 22:52

I think your post is a bit rich OP given the marking boycott! You are criticising students for not doing exams you lazy beggars cant be bothered to mark!

Exercising legal rights to industrial action to, in part, protect educational standards, is not being lazy.

JenniferBarkley · 20/05/2023 09:59

redspottedmug · 20/05/2023 08:42

Sorry but that's untrue. Current First years were the most affected cohort. It's my DC.

That hasn't been our experience at all. Things have started to turn around ever so slightly with our current first years, they had real exams for A Levels and came in with real grades. Only in person uni, last year of school in person. They're more or less where we expect, although attendance is down.

Current second years have only had in person uni which helps, but they came in on predicted grades so there's a heavy left tail that frankly shouldn't be on the course. They're doing ok, but definitely a covid cohort.

Current third years have been most affected in our experience. No exams from GCSEs to second year uni, first year uni online so when they turned up in second year they were nowhere near the norm, either socially or academically, and level two just doesn't have space for them not to be on it. Plus they also came in on predicted grades, so again they aren't all up to scratch. Some of them missed key topics in their final months of school - I teach a mathematical subject and have come across students who didn't cover integration at school. I really do feel for this group of students, even though it's frustrating to explain things like "you need to bring pen and paper so that when I write things on the board you can copy it down".