Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher telling 4 year old her work is *No good

114 replies

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 19:10

We live abroad, Dh and I are British but speak the language we reside in now, I’m not great, Dh speaks fluently.
Dd is 4 and has been at Pre school since September, she speaks a small amount, but not fluently yet.
Majority of people where we are speak English also, her teacher doesn’t really (obviously don’t expect her to speak English at all)
Dd came home upset today, she said she had painted her picture wrong and painted inside a heart instead of around it, but that she didn’t know. She said her teacher said to her it was No good and moved it out of the way, she said she didn’t shout it at her but didn’t let her do another etc. I asked my Dd what she did and she said she just sat there. She then said that she also did a picture of people wrong as she painted their faces black and the teacher also moved it and said it was *No good. Dd then said she drew the boy with a striped t-shirt and that it was okay and that wasn’t wrong.
From what I can gather, having seen todays display on the wall, it was a heart with a picture of your family inside, I guess Dd wasn’t meant to paint inside the heart as the picture was meant to be there and I’m guessing her painting the faces black was wrong, because we don’t have black skin.
Dd didn’t understand what to do, I realise it’s not the teachers fault she doesn’t speak English, but is saying that her pictures are no good and moving them the correct thing to do? Am I being over sensitive in feeling sad for Dd?
Also in her reports it’s says that Dd needs a lot of extra assistance with her work and can’t do things independently (at home she’s so good, really bright, confident and independent) I asked the teacher about it and I asked wasn’t that because she doesn’t speak the language fully yet, she looked embarrassed and said yes and now always writes this on her report.
Aibu to also expect her to be shown how to do things and to have help being taught her new language?

OP posts:
Sometimeswinning · 19/05/2023 21:15

powerpufff · 19/05/2023 21:05

In lots of countries in the EU there isnt the same ultra nurturing approach which you will find in UK nurseries and primary school- this can be a shock to expat UK parents.
I worked in a UK nursery in the preschool room where we always had to use positive guidance - even if the children were behaving really badly) I am a foreigner and I agree that nursery in other countries ( particularly France ) are more strict with a tough love approach and will tell children off for not following instructions whereas in the UK we value" childrens work" more than anything which is wonderful.
I agree more with the UK style although

I agree completely with this! The nurturing at primary is second to none. I had a polish teacher once who described a child as not being stupid. To her it was praise to the parents it was weeks of repairing a relationship!!

ButterCrackers · 19/05/2023 21:14

Find a babysitter, student that will do activities with your child in the local language. The understanding will be fast. Perhaps ask the teacher what topics and activities they’ll be doing the next weeks and ask the babysitter/student to do this with your child.

Haywirecity · 19/05/2023 21:11

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:28

@Haywirecity This was just a craft/art lesson in class 🤷🏻‍♀️I don’t really have any idea what they do normally tbh

They'll have lesson plans for everything they do. It'll contain what the children are to do in each lesson. Most won't be necessary for you. But you could ask to see any in which the teacher thinks she'll be working independently,

Just an idea. I teach EFL so I meet lots of children of new arrivals. She'll pick up the language amazingly quickly so these problems are really very short lived. Start speaking the language at home. It will help improve yours too. (Tell your husband NOT to correct every mistake! 🙄😄)

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 21:07

@saraclara She could have physically showed my Dd fairly easily, she would point, show her, do a version herself, use Portuguese, Dd understands the colours etc and is bright, it can be done.
I’m an ex class teacher myself and have taught children from different nationalities.

OP posts:
powerpufff · 19/05/2023 21:05

In lots of countries in the EU there isnt the same ultra nurturing approach which you will find in UK nurseries and primary school- this can be a shock to expat UK parents.
I worked in a UK nursery in the preschool room where we always had to use positive guidance - even if the children were behaving really badly) I am a foreigner and I agree that nursery in other countries ( particularly France ) are more strict with a tough love approach and will tell children off for not following instructions whereas in the UK we value" childrens work" more than anything which is wonderful.
I agree more with the UK style although

saraclara · 19/05/2023 21:03

Isthisexpected · 19/05/2023 20:24

I think she is a rubbish teacher and/or used the wrong English expression to try to explain "you haven't understood the task" basically!

So you'd think a teacher in the UK is a rubbish teacher because she can't speak the language of a child who doesn't speak English?

I had a child in my class who came straight here from China with not a word of English. She was 11. I didn't know where to start. I couldn't even have said good, or not good.

You can't judge a teacher for not being able to communicate sensitively in another language

saraclara · 19/05/2023 21:00

AgrathaChristie · 19/05/2023 19:39

I don’t think the language or lack of a language matters. Who in their right mind tells a 4 year old their picture is not good? That is crap teaching in any culture. Your daughter must have felt crushed.

Who tells a 4 year old that their picture is not good? A teacher who doesn't speak English remotely well.

It's ridiculous to expect someone who's English is very poor to be able to communicate sensitively with a four year old who doesn't speak her language at all. I travel a lot, and when people whose English is quite poor (or even fair) speak to me, they often sound quite abrupt. Because they only have a very basic vocabulary.

I speak a little French, so if a french child with no English apart from greetings, colours and numbers was in my class and didn'get something right, I simply wouldn't have the vocabulary to explain what had gone wrong in a gentle way.

Sugargliderwombat · 19/05/2023 20:49

Are there many children / people in the area new to the language ? We get so much training on working with children who have English as an additional language but I wonder if in some places they just have no clue ? I would mention it because if they don't speak the same language your daughter won't be able to let her know she was confused and sad she didn't know what to do.

Is it spain? My friends kids had trouble in Spanish schools 😑

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:35

@mathanxiety Very good point, we will teach her this weekend and go through it with her

OP posts:
Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:32

@mathanxiety We do that, but obviously not 24/7, lots of British people we know don’t speak the language or really have friends from the country (it’s a very ex pat area) we’re the exception to that…their children now speak fluently after attending school, so I’m confident that she will be fluent with more time, but she does also need help at school with it surely 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 19/05/2023 20:32

One phrase DD needs to be taught as a matter of urgency is, "I didn't understand what you said. Can you show me, please"

mathanxiety · 19/05/2023 20:30

You need to make a huge effort to fully immerse your child in the language she will need for school and socialising..

Your DH needs to start speaking to her in the language. You need to let her watch TV in the language, and you need to learn songs she can sing with you and DH in the language.

Nomowmay · 19/05/2023 20:29

Having worked abroad myself and struggled with the language, I do think this is a language issue. I would just ask the teacher to double check that your DD has understood instructions for any tasks she is asked to do in future so it doesn't happen again.

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:28

@Haywirecity This was just a craft/art lesson in class 🤷🏻‍♀️I don’t really have any idea what they do normally tbh

OP posts:
Haywirecity · 19/05/2023 20:25

I am a pretty tough teacher - my students would agree with that. 😄 But i have to say this makes me go, awww. Because she's only 4!

As these projects come up, could you get them to send you the lesson plan in advance so you could explain to her what she's got to do? That might help with her confidence. Other than that, could you get her pictures back from the teacher and stick them on your fridge, telling her how good they are?

Don't worry, she'll be picking the language up in no time and leaving you well behind. She'll be accompanying you to appointments and translating for you. It happens all the time. 😁

Crispyturtle · 19/05/2023 20:25

Do you think maybe the teacher didn’t know how to explain in English that your daughter hadn’t done it correctly, and so simplified it to ‘no good’? Meaning no good for what they are trying to achieve (picture of their family inside a heart) rather than lacking in skill.

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:24

I’m reluctant to up root her to a new school because of one teacher, she has ) weeks left to go until summer and I’m hoping she doesn’t have her next year too

OP posts:
Isthisexpected · 19/05/2023 20:24

I think she is a rubbish teacher and/or used the wrong English expression to try to explain "you haven't understood the task" basically!

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:22

Not Greece, no.

It could be a language thing, from the teachers side, but I don’t know, surely you know those words aren’t good?
Would you mention it or leave it?

OP posts:
WinedropsOnMoses · 19/05/2023 20:21

OP no need to say if it's too outing, but is your DC in Greek school by any chance? Very tough adjustment if so. Translations can come across VERY bluntly. Agree though that teacher's response is not okay at all.

jannier · 19/05/2023 20:15

Totally inappropriate comments to such young children you shouldn't be damaging their self esteem as a teacher let alone an early years teacher is this your only school option?

Floralnomad · 19/05/2023 20:13

I think you need to see how things progress as you are taking a 4 yo word for exactly what was said and I’m sure everyone knows that sometimes people do relay stories differently to how it actually went . FWIW if you are planning on sending your child to a school where they speak a different language I think you need to predominantly speak that language at home until she is fluent .

BattingDown · 19/05/2023 20:07

When the teacher said no good, was that her trying to explain in English? Or is it just the only bit your daughter understood? It sounds like she simplified the language to help her understand and it just came across harsh to English ears. I’m guessing this might be where we used to live from the school age and it’s just culturally much more blunt. Your daughter is adjusting to the culture as well as the language.

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 20:00

She plays with her best friend at the weekends, who speaks no English yet and we do teach her bits at home, but we obviously don’t speak it all the time.
I just feel so sad for her.
I’m worried this could be a regular thing, do I speak to the teacher or just leave it?
Dd even said she didn’t know what to do as the teacher didn’t explain it, if I didn’t know and was given a heart cut out and red paint, I’d paint the heart red too!
She told me hater that she painted her friend in the class, who has a black face and gave him a striped t-shirt, she had no idea what to do, to then he told it was no good, it wasn’t her fault!

OP posts:
JustHowItIs · 19/05/2023 19:44

Poor wee DD.

what language is it?

I think, at 4, it should be easy enough to show her what needs to be done. Surely DD understands the words for picture, your family, etc

the language barrier was probably the cause of the 'no good' but coukd also be cultural. lots of cultures are more direct, less softly softly.

I don't think the school should be responsible for teaching the language to get her to the same level as the other kids. They're there to teach the curriculum in that language, not to teach the language.

I wonder if any of the children doesk both fluently so they can explain the tasks to DD?

she'll pick it up playing IF the children aren't speaking to her in English. Is there a group she can join at the weekend where she'll mix with native speakers

DH needs to step up too and only speak to her in the native language.

After 8 months I'd expect a 4yo to be pretty much fluent if exposed to the language enough.