Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher telling 4 year old her work is *No good

114 replies

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 19:10

We live abroad, Dh and I are British but speak the language we reside in now, I’m not great, Dh speaks fluently.
Dd is 4 and has been at Pre school since September, she speaks a small amount, but not fluently yet.
Majority of people where we are speak English also, her teacher doesn’t really (obviously don’t expect her to speak English at all)
Dd came home upset today, she said she had painted her picture wrong and painted inside a heart instead of around it, but that she didn’t know. She said her teacher said to her it was No good and moved it out of the way, she said she didn’t shout it at her but didn’t let her do another etc. I asked my Dd what she did and she said she just sat there. She then said that she also did a picture of people wrong as she painted their faces black and the teacher also moved it and said it was *No good. Dd then said she drew the boy with a striped t-shirt and that it was okay and that wasn’t wrong.
From what I can gather, having seen todays display on the wall, it was a heart with a picture of your family inside, I guess Dd wasn’t meant to paint inside the heart as the picture was meant to be there and I’m guessing her painting the faces black was wrong, because we don’t have black skin.
Dd didn’t understand what to do, I realise it’s not the teachers fault she doesn’t speak English, but is saying that her pictures are no good and moving them the correct thing to do? Am I being over sensitive in feeling sad for Dd?
Also in her reports it’s says that Dd needs a lot of extra assistance with her work and can’t do things independently (at home she’s so good, really bright, confident and independent) I asked the teacher about it and I asked wasn’t that because she doesn’t speak the language fully yet, she looked embarrassed and said yes and now always writes this on her report.
Aibu to also expect her to be shown how to do things and to have help being taught her new language?

OP posts:
BellaJuno · 20/05/2023 06:44

You’re taking as gospel the word of a 4 year old, regardless of the language issue that is bonkers to get upset without hearing the teacher’s version of the interaction.

Talapia · 20/05/2023 06:36

I've heard from a Portuguese staff member at my work that the Portuguese education is highly pressured and not geared toward the mental wel being of young people

I think this sentence sounds lost in translation though. Does the teacher have access to an iPad. We usually try various translation apps to help EAL kids.

MerryMarigold · 20/05/2023 06:34

I work with 4 year olds and there is no way we would have such a prescriptive art class! We complain our children start school early here but I don't think even in Reception that they'd do something like this. We are not allowed to intervene too closely and give lots of help and guidance (a situation like this would likely be 1:1 if it was supposed to be that specific) which is very possible with EAL kids, of which I have many. I'm not sure of their ratios with 4 year olds but ours is 1:8 until Reception. Part of the joy of 'teaching' them is seeing how they interpret and apply their own ideas. The instruction could have been 'paint your family' and then you would get everyone's interpretations even if it was a blob of green and purple.

OP, maybe you need to look at different provision for September, something like Montessori? Where she can learn through play which is less prescriptive.

It's all very well for saying the culture is different etc. but that doesn't make it less damaging and there are good reasons the culture in preschools/ Reception here is the way it is.

Quinoawoman · 20/05/2023 06:32

Have a look at this website - scroll down to 'primary phase' and 'new arrivals good practice guide' which gives you an idea about what teachers in the UK do for children who speak no English. https://www.hants.gov.uk/educationandlearning/emtas/primary-secondary-phase

MRex · 20/05/2023 06:31

Your DD is going to come across a lot of people in life whose actions aren't ideal; this time it was a teacher and next week it'll be a kid. We have had issues from time to time, but we find it easiest to focus on building up DS's resilience. Just talk to your DD and pick a path that's most useful at the time depending on what will build her confidence:
"if you don't know what to do, you say XYZ".
"I think your pictures were great, they just weren't the task she wanted you to do. Can I put this one on the fridge? And do you want to do the task at home so you can take it in?"
"That doesn't sound like she was fair to you. When someone isn't fair to me I feel really frustrated, how did you feel?"

Quinoawoman · 20/05/2023 06:27

I think this is probably just a language barrier thing - could be that your daughter has misinterpreted what the teacher said, could be that the teacher was attempting to speak English and didn't do a great job of it, which she can't reallt be blamed for.

I have worked with a few 'new arrivals' to the UK recently who speak no English. They do pick up the language very quickly just through school and ultimately being bilingual is really, really good for them once they get past this first bit so please don't worry about doing loads in the local language at home. My FIL spoke only Polish at home as a child and English at school and went on to be head of department for English at a secondary school, then an educational consultant.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 20/05/2023 06:18

saraclara · 19/05/2023 21:00

Who tells a 4 year old that their picture is not good? A teacher who doesn't speak English remotely well.

It's ridiculous to expect someone who's English is very poor to be able to communicate sensitively with a four year old who doesn't speak her language at all. I travel a lot, and when people whose English is quite poor (or even fair) speak to me, they often sound quite abrupt. Because they only have a very basic vocabulary.

I speak a little French, so if a french child with no English apart from greetings, colours and numbers was in my class and didn'get something right, I simply wouldn't have the vocabulary to explain what had gone wrong in a gentle way.

Point is, it's not the teacher abroad's job to learn and speak the language of their non-native speaker kids, is it?

I'd definitely clarify with the teacher what was actually said @Itiswhatitisamilliontimes as 4 year olds (working in a language that isn't their own to boot) aren't the most reliable witnesses.

Then you need to really get moving to get your daughter immersed in the new language. As her father is fluent and you're actually living there, it won't take long.

RequiresUpdating · 20/05/2023 06:12

Your DH needs to take over communication with the school for this. Find out what exactly happened and what the teacher said.

I'd be very concerned, if I were you. Your post seems to describe something that could happen after a month or so of kindy. However, I've just re-read she's been there since September and she has exposure outside of school. She really should be able to keep up by now. You and your husband should continue speaking English to her, but really she should have picked up a lot more of Portuguese by now. Do the school have any other concerns?

My DC and several others I know have been in the situation of different home language and new school language. The only one who had such issues towards the end of one year was the child who has other SN. One year immersion should really be enough to follow kindy instructions and be able to ask if she doesn't understand. And frankly, as you've described it draw, mummy, daddy and pointing should convey the task and she should be able to follow it.

SD1978 · 20/05/2023 04:04

Did sue says this in English or Portuguese? Either way- she was either A) simplifying it in Portuguese so that your daughter understood she hadn't done the assignment correctly or B) she said it in simple English because that's not her native language. On the basis of that I think you're overreacting- she will be communicating with a child who basically doesn't understand her and vice versa. Unless she's been shouting at your daughter or otherwise singling her out, whilst I understand the interaction upset your daughter, a very short, no good, without the context wouldn't be something I'd be dwelling on and would try to explain to your daughter people may speak shortly to her until the language is more natural.

Bubblesoffun · 20/05/2023 03:55

BlueBlue72 · 20/05/2023 01:18

I'm an early years teacher and can't imagine a situation where it's ok for a teacher to tell any child their art work is no good. Also can't imagine where an art lesson is as prescribed as this as that's not art.

Did you see the part where the teacher doesn’t speak much English? From another early childhood educator. I think everyone is reading way too much into this. Op is in another country, with different ideas and different values. I’m pretty sure that some of you would balk at the way things are done in my country. In the same way I roll my eyes at the way you lot do things. It doesn’t mean that either way is wrong it’s just different.

BlueBlue72 · 20/05/2023 01:18

I'm an early years teacher and can't imagine a situation where it's ok for a teacher to tell any child their art work is no good. Also can't imagine where an art lesson is as prescribed as this as that's not art.

7eleven · 20/05/2023 01:02

I think you need to work very hard on you and your child’s language skills, so that misunderstandings don’t happen in school. It’s your responsibility to speak the language of the country you chose to live in, not put additional burden on the teachers to speak English.

MyEyesHurt · 20/05/2023 01:00

I think there is an element of lost in translation that we can't know without knowing the language and what exactly was said in that language. Would it out you to say which language?
For example if the teacher said in German, das is nicht gut, she would have reason to be more upset than if the teacher said in french, c'est pas bien ça or in Spanish eso no es bueno, both of which can convey sort of it's not right as well as it's not good. If french, the teacher might also have said c'est pas correct, which also implies it wasn't right rather than actually bad. I can see how she would interpret any of those phrases as negative feedback.
Then not being allowed to do another could be a time issue.

Remaker · 20/05/2023 00:41

I’m a bit surprised by some of the responses saying the teacher is uncaring. Have you never conversed with someone who doesn’t speak English? ‘No good’ means everything from I’m not feeling well/am in pain (while pointing to the affected area), it means no that’s not what I wanted when handed something, it can mean anything! You’re expecting a non English speaker to be able to praise a child’s efforts and also explain the task. You’re also expecting another culture to adapt to your preferences.

I really don’t think a painting is a big enough issue to complain about. I would however come up with a plan on how you’re going to improve your DD’s language so she can enjoy school more.

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 20/05/2023 00:36

@saraclara Some of the assistants speak English, it’s a nerve wracking thing, but a very normal thing to do where I am. It feels horrendous at first as though we were throwing her in at the deep end, but it’s apparently the way to do it. My Dd has a native speaking babysitter, lots of friends who speak the language and us also.
It isn’t Dh’s language, we are both British, but he has learnt the language and is now fluent

OP posts:
saraclara · 19/05/2023 23:49

it's unfair to say the teacher is unreasonable for not being conversant in your child's language when you are the one that decided to put your child in a classroom where she doesn't speak the language the class works in.

...And where the teacher doesn't speak the child's language either (beyond the very basic).

To be honest, I wouldn't dream of putting my four year old in this situation. It must be anxiety inducing to be in a situation all day where you can neither understand or be understood.

PinkPlantCase · 19/05/2023 23:42

I think your DH needs to step up much more in all of this.

I agree that the interaction shouldn’t have happened the way it did. I would probably mention to the teacher that it made your daughter upset.

But your husband really needs to spend much more time focusing on language with her. Frankly it’s a great shame that he didn’t speak his language to her from the beginning because then you wouldn’t be in this position now.

nosyupnorth · 19/05/2023 23:32

I think by sending your child to a class that isn't second language provision without having got her set up with more than the basics of the local language you have set her up to fail and need to take some responsibility for that, not be expecting the school to teach her unless teaching the language to international students is something they specifically offer - which most pre-schools don't.
It's not a pre-school's job to teach her the language and expecting your child to just pick it up passively will not equip her in a timely manner for handling the situation you've put her in of being in a classroom that operates in a language she doesn't know.
If it isn't a language teaching preschool or ex-pat schooling situation, then a pre-school teacher almost certainly won't have the training for teaching children who don't have a reasonable grasp of the local language. If they don't speak each other's lanuage then it's no suprise there is difficulty when trying to convey your child hasn't competed the activity correctly, but it's unfair to say the teacher is unreasonable for not being conversant in your child's language when you are the one that decided to put your child in a classroom where she doesn't speak the language the class works in.

caringcarer · 19/05/2023 23:17

When I was 5 I had very neat handwriting but could not draw. There was going to be a Parents Evening. We all had a sheet of paper with lines on the bottom to write a story on and the top of the page was blank to draw on. I did a picture then wrote a story underneath. The teacher cut my picture of whilst telling me it was not going on her wall. She then cut off a boy's handwriting telling him it could not be read. She then stuck his picture on the wall and pinned my hand writing underneath it. The picture was of a rocket and the story about a witch. I was hoping things were different in primary schools nowadays. I didn't really care but I remember my Mum was furious my picture was not allowed on the wall and the boy who's writing was not put up got told off by his parents for not trying harder. I can remember feeling sorry for him.

TheOriginalEmu · 19/05/2023 22:04

AgrathaChristie · 19/05/2023 19:39

I don’t think the language or lack of a language matters. Who in their right mind tells a 4 year old their picture is not good? That is crap teaching in any culture. Your daughter must have felt crushed.

Well it matters because ‘no good’ in English sounds harsh, but in another language it might be the way the concept of ‘not what was expected’ is expressed. So much nuance can be lost in translation that it’s impossible to say if the teacher was wrong or not.

cyncope · 19/05/2023 21:58

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 21:48

@JussathoB Yes, we do that naturally but I still don’t expect a teacher to say a 4 year olds work is no good and leave it at that

You don't actually know what happened though - you are relying on a 4 year old's recollection of what happened in a language she doesn't understand well.
Even when pre-schoolers are in their native language environment, what actually happened and how they have interpreted/remembered it is not always very similar.

Itiswhatitisamilliontimes · 19/05/2023 21:48

@JussathoB Yes, we do that naturally but I still don’t expect a teacher to say a 4 year olds work is no good and leave it at that

OP posts:
JussathoB · 19/05/2023 21:32

Hmm. I agree that the teacher could make more effort to be a bit more nurturing or at least more encouraging.
However another thing to consider OP is what sort of reactions do you think would help your child to develop resilience? If by any chance your child fails to achieve something, either because of the teacher not taking enough care or even just because your child doesn’t quite get it, do you think it helps your child if you or she think of this as a disaster?
Stop worrying about the teacher not being perfect. Just let your child develop her language skills, and think about your home environment and how you model recovering from mistakes, having another go, not getting too upset over little things, some people like one picture but other people may prefer a different one etc.

cyncope · 19/05/2023 21:25

I'd just mention to the teacher on Monday that DD was upset and didn't understand the instructions.

You're going to get loads of responses telling you the teacher is an evil witch and you should change schools, but no teacher is perfect.

The teacher didn't handle it well, your DD may not be remembering or communicating to you the exact nuances of what happened.
Just speak to the teacher.

anon12093 · 19/05/2023 21:20

My ds is 11 and remembers his teacher ripping his work up and binning it when he was 4.

People don't realise that kids can and do remember when things like this are said to them.