Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our buyer is really out of order.

259 replies

PrincelySu · 19/05/2023 11:36

We are selling our property, it's a detached cottage in a rural location, and was valued at £750k. We need a fairly quick sale due to our circumstances, we got an offer of £725k, we countered with £735k, and the buyer agreed. The cottage has lovely original features and is very quirky.

On the initial viewing, before they'd even made an offer, we pointed out a couple of things that may need to be looked at, one of those being the roof. Due to this, the buyer got a surveyor round, who agreed that the roof should be looked at. That is the only thing that has been flagged on the survey. The buyer organised a roofer to come and have a look, and the roofer said it's a quirky cottage and roof, but there is nothing wrong with the integrity. There are no leaks, damage, the felt is fine. There are a few tiles missing and it doesn't look great, but this is only cosmetic. The roofer said it is optional to replace the roof, and you'd probably want to at some point, but it's fine.

In between all of this, the buyer also came back to view the house twice more, to measure up for their furniture, plan where to paint and how to redesign the house, both of these visits totalling 4 hours. Which we were happy to do and accommodated.

The buyer has now decided they want the roof replacing and wants £10k off the house price! We said no, the roof doesn't need replacing, the roofer said it was optional and we've already given you a £15k discount from the listed price. The buyer has come back saying that they 'only wanted to pay £725k in the first place and they are fed up to be honest.'

AIBU to think they are being really out of order?! I feel like saying they can't have the house out of principle.

OP posts:
JenWillsiam · 19/05/2023 15:30

PrincelySu · 19/05/2023 15:12

We were there whilst the roofer was up there and heard his feedback (the buyer also sent us the quote afterwards).

He complimented the cottage and the roof, acknowledging that it was quirky and in keeping with the rest of the build. It was built in the 16th century, it's a traditional stone built detached cottage, not brick. He said there was nothing wrong with the integrity, there were no leaks, he said in his own words that he 'didn't see any need to replace the felt or roof, just a few tiles that had come dislodged.' The comment about replacing it at some point was in relation to it being a quirky-style cottage, which naturally has older period features anyway, it was in no way him saying there were issues that needed to be done imminently or in the near-future.

As soon as a person says something might need doing or you may want to in the future you’re in the territory of negotiating price down. It’s really that simple.

DollyParkin · 19/05/2023 15:30

I think what's really pissed me off is the fact the buyer said they 'only wanted to pay £725k in the first place.' It's as though they planned the whole time to try and claw money back to get what they wanted in the first place.

YABU, and you're investing far too much emotion. If that's what they wanted to pay, that's what they wanted to pay. If you don't want to accept that price, find another buyer. It's business.

DollyParkin · 19/05/2023 15:27

A house is only worth what someone's prepared to pay for it. You say your house was "valued" at a certain price, but that is irrelevant.

Find another buyer, but this potential buyer is not out of order.

MissConductUS · 19/05/2023 15:26

The property is worth what someone is ready, willing, and able to pay for it. This buyer is only ready to pay 725k. If that doesn't suit you, relist it and find another buyer.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/05/2023 15:16

neilyoungismyhero · 19/05/2023 11:54

The roof might not be dodgy but sometimes matching original tiles can be a nightmare and nothing less than a complete renewal will suffice.

The easiest thing to do in that case is to bung the tiles on a place, which doesn’t show so much and bring the original intact tiles to the front. We’ve done that with our house. The new tiles are very similar in colour but we wanted the front of the house to be uniform.

bignosebignose · 19/05/2023 15:15

OP, we had a similar situation a few years ago when selling a small London flat (worth half the price of your house) in order to buy a house we really wanted in another area of the country. I knew the buyers, but not as friends, and they did more or less the same thing, work needed, £10k off. I threw my toys out of the pram for five minutes, reminded myself that we had had no other sensible offers in the two months it had been on the market, and accepted it - but on the clear understanding that there was no possibility of any future drop in price and we would simply pull out if they chanced their arm again. It all went through, and we now live in a place we love. It's not worth pulling out unless you really can't afford that £10k drop - particularly since you say that you are in a hurry to sell. I was furious at the time but am so glad I didn't cancel.

alwaysmovingforwards · 19/05/2023 15:14

The reason for the reduction and emotional response is to look at this all wrong.

Buyers try and buy low, sellers try and sell high. It's a business transaction not a relationship. If the seller is 'annoyed' at them, the buyer won't give a shit. Beyond this transaction they'll never see each other again.

As a seller you either accept the offer or you decline and risk sitting on the market. It's that simple. To invest time stewing on it is utterly futile and pointless waste of energy.

PrincelySu · 19/05/2023 15:12

We were there whilst the roofer was up there and heard his feedback (the buyer also sent us the quote afterwards).

He complimented the cottage and the roof, acknowledging that it was quirky and in keeping with the rest of the build. It was built in the 16th century, it's a traditional stone built detached cottage, not brick. He said there was nothing wrong with the integrity, there were no leaks, he said in his own words that he 'didn't see any need to replace the felt or roof, just a few tiles that had come dislodged.' The comment about replacing it at some point was in relation to it being a quirky-style cottage, which naturally has older period features anyway, it was in no way him saying there were issues that needed to be done imminently or in the near-future.

OP posts:
Hairpinleg · 19/05/2023 15:10

Hankunamatata · 19/05/2023 13:43

Roofer said the roof will want replacing at some point. So u can kind of see their point that they want to put a new roof on

Every roof will need replacing at some point!

If it doesn't need to be done right now, it's just an excuse to get down to a lower price.

Bluebells1970 · 19/05/2023 15:06

Tell the EA that you're not negotiating further with them, end of. They buy or they walk away.

You shouldn't be dealing with it, the EA should. Let them earn their fee.

TheStarofCountyDown · 19/05/2023 15:06

I feel your pain, OP. A buyer of our old house had a survey, which showed no issues, but wanted a reduction to offset the cost painting the front (it didn't need painting; it was pure aesthetics). In the end, we decided the £5k hit was worth it to move on with our lives. And 10 years later Im certain we did the right thing.

My advice is to offer a £5k drop (or other figure you're comfortable with). You tell them (i) they either take it or the house goes back on the market tomorrow/Monday; and (ii) if they choose to proceed its conditional on exchange by xx date and completion by yy date.

I think this gives them a "win" but also demonstrates that you wont be dicked around.

Good luck. Its a very stressful process.

EmmaEmerald · 19/05/2023 15:03

GoodChat · 19/05/2023 14:56

He wouldn't have said they'll probably want to replace the roof at some point if there was nothing wrong with it.

Um....yes, if he wants a different looking roof?

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 19/05/2023 15:01

It's as though they planned the whole time to try and claw money back to get what they wanted in the first place. you are probably right. In the scale of things £10k isn't a lot of money when talking about a £700k + house. The thing is to remember is that this is business. How much you love the house or how offended you might feel is irrelevant. The game is they try to take as much as possible off the asking price whilst you try to get as much for your house as you can. In your position I would fix the roof to put the debate to bed.

GoodChat · 19/05/2023 14:56

He wouldn't have said they'll probably want to replace the roof at some point if there was nothing wrong with it.

AxolotlEars · 19/05/2023 14:50

They just want it for less and they happen to throw the issue of the roof at you. Say no. Don't stop them buying it because you are narked.

Mirabai · 19/05/2023 14:49

Either you will accept 725 or you won’t. If you won’t tell them the state of the roof (needing repair only) was factored into the asking price so you won’t accept less than the agreed price.

10k won’t put a dent in a roof replacement so that’s not why they’re asking.

Tellmeimcrazy · 19/05/2023 14:48

No stick to 735k.

NoraBattysCurlers · 19/05/2023 14:48

SoVerySophie · 19/05/2023 14:24

I don't understand why you don't just say no - only the agreed sum is acceptable, either take it or leave it, the property will have to go back on the market within 48 hours if you decide not to proceed.

It's very simple.

The OP needs a quick sale due to their circumstances. She is not in a position to just say no.

Pluvia · 19/05/2023 14:47

Generally higher prices people negotiate harder. 725 from 750 is a very very good offer.

I think so too. Not much for sale around here at the moment because prices have dropped, but there's one on for £410,000 that started at £450k, then down to £425 before the latest reduction. There's nothing wrong with it, it's just that the market has dropped.

Meili04 · 19/05/2023 14:46

PrincelySu · 19/05/2023 12:24

I think what's really pissed me off is the fact the buyer said they 'only wanted to pay £725k in the first place.' It's as though they planned the whole time to try and claw money back to get what they wanted in the first place. Especially now they know we have invested time and money into our solicitors. I'm not even sure they genuinely want to replace the roof and that this all isn't all an attempt just to get the house for what they wanted in the first place.

People have fixed price they are willing to pay in their mind. Buyers are a lot more cautious and flaky it's not personal.

whynotwhatknot · 19/05/2023 14:45

I think its the way its been said has pissed off the op and rightly so-we only wanted to pay 725 means theyre thinking of any excuse to knock it down

id pull out they'll only think of something else they dont like

Meili04 · 19/05/2023 14:42

Generally higher prices people negotiate harder. 725 from 750 is a very very good offer.

Pluvia · 19/05/2023 14:41

I think dropping £10k on a £750k house is nothing. If you want to sell and move on, take it, OP. The market is falling slowly, mortgage rates remain high and I think lots of people with large mortgages for homes at your level are struggling. My best guess is that more properties will be coming on the market and driving prices down further.

Saying the roof's fine and then that there are tiles missing is contradictory and doesn't help your case. As others have said this is a business transaction, it's not about being friends or nice to each other.

The horrible thing about the UK system is that right up to completion the purchaser can undercut you without any penalty. I've had it happen. My buyer strung me along till the last minute and then demanded 5% on completion day. In your case it's 1-2%. Don't get antsy about such a small reduction and lose out big-time if the market drops.

In your position I'd consider getting the roof repaired for £1k and offering them that. It begs the question of why you haven't had it fixed before now.

Iguanainanigloo · 19/05/2023 14:39

Like pps have said, I'd say no. What they offered was based on what they'd seen, the roofer has confirmed it is just cosmetic, and if they wanted to fix that, it would be in the region of £1000, so a £10k price reduction is non negotiable, and cosmetic work, is their choice and responsibility to fund, like redecorating would be. I'd also say, you need to know whether they intend to go ahead at the agreed price by the end of the day, as if not, you will be remarketing the house Monday, at the original asking price. What are they going to do next, try and negotiate the price of a tub of Dulux off you as they don't like the colour on the walls?! And then, they want a new kitchen put in, because aesthetically, it's not to their taste... so is that at your expense too?! I think not. The house is sold "as seen", and no major issues to warrant a renegotiation emerged on the survey, so to suddenly be asking for a price reduction is ridiculous, and I bet they're just trying their luck. Fine, if the survey brought up that actually the boiler is fucked, the windows and doors all need replacing, it needs an entire brand new roof, and there are structural issues that need to be addressed, but this isn't the case. It's an old character property, and clearly it will require ongoing maintenance and general upkeep, as all older properties do, but the buyer needs to fund that, not you.

EsmeSusanOgg · 19/05/2023 14:37

Beautiful3 · 19/05/2023 14:28

They sound like the kind of people my grandma had. They offered less, the day before the exchange! The whole chain fell through. It was ridiculous. Perhaps you ought to relist the property.

This makes sense. Reopen viewings. They have no exchanged and sound like they will mess OP around.