Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the school does not decide when your child can walk home alone

383 replies

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 09:25

I keep seeing this on threads and I don’t want to derail what the thread is about.

But the school cannot decide this. You do as parent. It may be you are broadly in agreement with the school and I am but this is your choice and not the schools.

It irrationally annoys me when people claim ‘the schools don’t allow …’ Not up to the school!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sartre · 19/05/2023 15:40

But they do. My DC’s school wouldn’t let them leave without an adult until year 5.

SparklyBlackKitten · 19/05/2023 15:36

"If they won’t release your child with explicit instruction from you then that is false imprisonment "

🤣🤣

NewNovember · 19/05/2023 15:31

underneaththeash · 19/05/2023 14:39

Safe guarding in the context of me as a brownie leader means keeping a child safe from harm and also protecting me as a volunteer again claims of neglect or abuse. Neglect and abuse can take many forms, including benign neglect from parents.

No, I wouldn't let any of my 3 children walk 1/2 mile home from an activity alone at the age of 9. Nor will I let any of my 9 year old brownies leave without being collected and this is completely in line with the training and advice we are given.

Then unless your children have a relevant disability you are doing them no favours by refusing to allow them to mature It's benign neglect to refuse to give your children the opportunities they need to develop independence.

CaptainMyCaptain · 19/05/2023 15:17

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/05/2023 14:39

It’s actually relatively new that parents of perfectly able children have had to collect them. It wasn’t the case when my elder children were at school, nor when I started working in schools.

And it’s not up to the school. Hence why schools have to change their position 99.9% of the time when a parent states they wish their child to walk home alone.

This.

RavenclawDiadem · 19/05/2023 15:15

I think what some people are not understanding is the difference between in school, and out of school.

I have no problem with sending my child in the right uniform, making sure they've done their homework, being polite and respectful, turning up to school on time. What happens in school between 9am and 3pm is absolutely determined by the school rules and the school absolutely DOES have the right to set rules about what happens or doesn't happen on their premises, within school time.

However, school does not have the right to determine what happens between 8am and 9am or 3pm and 4pm. That is my responsibility as a parent. School's responsibility and rights to set the "rules" ends when the bell rings at 3pm.

As other Scottish parents have said, when the bell rings at 3pm, children as young as 5.5 in P2 are sent out into the playground to find their own way home. Maybe there's someone there to meet them, maybe there's not. Maybe they are going home with older siblings or friends. Teacher doesn't know what is going on as it is not her/his responsibility. This is common practice in Scotland and last time I looked there was not an epidemic of Scottish 7 year olds coming to harm walking to school.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 19/05/2023 15:03

@JenWillsiam ultimately the school would have to give in unless they could prove it was a risk, if you send a signed letter giving John permission to leave school alone and then you do not collect him the next day so school ring you and say you haven't collected John, you reply I have given you written permission he is allowed to walk home just send him home, they say we will call SS , you say i consider John capable of walking home alone it's a short distance and he's sensible, they refuse to let him go and they ring social services saying John hasn't been collected , Social services ask have you managed to contact parent? school say yes, SS ask what was their response ? oh parent says to allow him to leave, social services ask so why won't you let John, school answer he is in Y4 we don't allow Y4 to leave alone, SS reply that's not a good enough reason why isn't John capable of walking home alone,? do you have parents phone number? then SS decide actually school is right it is unsafe for John to walk even that short distance and he is absent minded and unaware of danger and a risk taker rather than sensible or SS decide that 400 metres on small well lit roads with no crossings is not a risk and tell school to allow John to leave. SS will not be impressed if this was repeated several days running, in the end school will have to let John go home every day alone

Chickychoccyegg · 19/05/2023 14:57

Yes, I'm in Scotland too, and couldn't agree more with your post

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 14:47

I’m not trying to be argumentative but no, they don’t.

OP posts:
JenWillsiam · 19/05/2023 14:44

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 12:52

@Nordicrain so in a hypothetical sort of sense, if you refused to collect a three year old then the preschool would probably call SS who would then take whatever action they deemed necessary.

Where you seem to be misunderstanding is the role of the school within that. Parents have the right to make decisions that they believe to be right for their child. These do not include (obviously) neglect, abuse and so on and schools play a part in protecting children from this and rightly so - this doesn’t include making parenting decisions for them.

See above re I decide when I think it’s right for my child to walk home. If the school say ten but I think ‘not ready yet’ that’s my call, not the schools.

You really aren’t getting it. School are permitted to decide when they will permit children to leave school grounds unsupervised. Because that’s ultimately what this is. You aren’t consenting to them walking home. You’re consenting to them leaving the grounds without an adult. That’s an agreement between parent and school. School are within their rights to refuse to allow a child to leave unsupervised.

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 14:42

the problem comes when people think ‘something I wouldn’t do personally’ is ‘safeguarding.’

I have no issue personally with guidance being year 5/6. In any case, when my children start school they will have to be taken and collected by car so they clearly can’t drive themselves 😅 but that’s not what I’m about here. I’m simply explaining the school does not decide, the parent does.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/05/2023 14:39

adriftinadenofvipers · 19/05/2023 14:06

What a load of utter bollocks.

Yes, of course it fucking is up to the school as they are responsible for your child's safety until they hand them over to your care.

Just do what other parents have been doing for years and make proper arrangements for your child to be collected, instead of winding yourself up on a ridiculous crusade against a perfectly reasonable school rule!!

It’s actually relatively new that parents of perfectly able children have had to collect them. It wasn’t the case when my elder children were at school, nor when I started working in schools.

And it’s not up to the school. Hence why schools have to change their position 99.9% of the time when a parent states they wish their child to walk home alone.

underneaththeash · 19/05/2023 14:39

NewNovember · 19/05/2023 13:56

Can you really not see that its ludicrous but to let a 9 year old walk 1/2 mile home at 7pm in the spring summer? What do you think safeguarding means?

Safe guarding in the context of me as a brownie leader means keeping a child safe from harm and also protecting me as a volunteer again claims of neglect or abuse. Neglect and abuse can take many forms, including benign neglect from parents.

No, I wouldn't let any of my 3 children walk 1/2 mile home from an activity alone at the age of 9. Nor will I let any of my 9 year old brownies leave without being collected and this is completely in line with the training and advice we are given.

Shelefttheweb · 19/05/2023 14:36

Schools are legally responsible for your children. If the parents are willing to sign a legal waiver accepting that they are responsible for their children and everything that happens to them until the cross the school gates in the morning and after they leave them at the end of the school day, then that's fine - parents can decide.

Schools are not legally responsible for children outside school hours. There is no way my primary school would think of themselves as responsible for what happens to a child in the normal course, until the child is both on the school premises AND within school hours. And why should they? Do you think school should be responsible if they took their dog for a walk on their own before school? Or while they are attending cubs? Or on holiday?

if a school is concerned that there may be abuse or neglect outside school then they flag this up with social services who take responsibility to checking on the child outwith school hours.

Quveas · 19/05/2023 14:19

Schools are legally responsible for your children. If the parents are willing to sign a legal waiver accepting that they are responsible for their children and everything that happens to them until the cross the school gates in the morning and after they leave them at the end of the school day, then that's fine - parents can decide. But "in loco parentis" means that the school is the parent whilst the children are with them, and are responsible for any decisions, including whether a child can walk home on their own or not. If some parents weren't so keen to blame schools for everything that goes wrong, perhaps they wouldn't be so cautious, buit if you are a headteacher responsible for that 10 year old child, are you going to carry the can when they are grabbed off the street by a predator? It may not be something that happens often, but it happens. If it's your child it happens to you will be screaming for blood - someone else's blood.

Falt · 19/05/2023 14:18

Chickychoccyegg · 19/05/2023 09:34

At my dc primary school, only p1 need handed over to a parent, so age 4 and 5 years, all other year groups either meet their parents in the playground/gate/at home.

Same here (assuming like me you're in Scotland). There is literally no universe where I'd accept the school telling me what I can and can't do with my child. The fact we (as a society) have got ourselves to the stage where (like pp said) we have to ask permission to take them out for a funeral is insane. But then again we let "the state" ban us from hugging our family and seeing our partners and walking down a street without a good excuse for months on end just a couple of years ago...

Whenever people bring up "safeguarding" and "social worker" I always think... what are they going to do? They barely have the resources to remove children who're living in crack dens ffs. They are fed, clothed, clean, happy, loved and thriving, and if I want them to walk home themselves after school or stay home for a couple of hours without me or take them to fucking disneyland for the week I'll be doing it. I'm the parent.

CadburyDream · 19/05/2023 14:16

This isn’t a new thing my brother is 24 and I remember his primary school refusing to let him walk home alone. My mum argued and argued with them about it saying the same thing that it’s her child so her choice but they wouldn’t allow it and refused to let him go unless an adult came to pick him up, he was not allowed to leave the school. In the end my mum use to make me walk round to collect him then once out of the school I could go and he could walk home, it was just so the school could see me.

ejbaxa · 19/05/2023 14:12

It is up to the school whether they will release a child to walk home alone. Our school absolutely will not simply release a child under a certain year group if the parent says so.

CaptainMyCaptain · 19/05/2023 14:09

Oneborneverydecade · 19/05/2023 13:15

I remember contacting the school to say that my then yr 5 would be walking home (his choice & 5 min walk). Reception said they would have to check with the Head. I was a bit bemused.

The Reception teacher was right to check with the Head to cover her own back. Presumably, as you have not said otherwise, the school complied with your wishes.

Shelefttheweb · 19/05/2023 14:08

adriftinadenofvipers · 19/05/2023 14:06

What a load of utter bollocks.

Yes, of course it fucking is up to the school as they are responsible for your child's safety until they hand them over to your care.

Just do what other parents have been doing for years and make proper arrangements for your child to be collected, instead of winding yourself up on a ridiculous crusade against a perfectly reasonable school rule!!

Does that include my 14 year old son?

adriftinadenofvipers · 19/05/2023 14:06

What a load of utter bollocks.

Yes, of course it fucking is up to the school as they are responsible for your child's safety until they hand them over to your care.

Just do what other parents have been doing for years and make proper arrangements for your child to be collected, instead of winding yourself up on a ridiculous crusade against a perfectly reasonable school rule!!

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 14:06

There is a massive difference between what can be demanded in an employment context and a parental one.

I am honestly surprised some have got so annoyed about it, or haven’t understood at all and just reply saying no, at our school the rule is … 😂

OP posts:
Moveoverdarlin · 19/05/2023 14:00

False imprisonment? Jesus, have a day off.

Waspie · 19/05/2023 13:57

At my son's primary the parental agreement we signed committed to collecting in person at the end of the school day. "In person" could be parent, carer, child minder, other authorised adult (e.g. grandparent) or after school club. This is standard for all primary schools in our borough.

At Year 4 children are allowed to walk home alone with written permission from the parent/s with PR.

StraightOuttaContext · 19/05/2023 13:57

I'm just here waiting for Godwin's Law tbh

NewNovember · 19/05/2023 13:57

*not