Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the school does not decide when your child can walk home alone

383 replies

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 09:25

I keep seeing this on threads and I don’t want to derail what the thread is about.

But the school cannot decide this. You do as parent. It may be you are broadly in agreement with the school and I am but this is your choice and not the schools.

It irrationally annoys me when people claim ‘the schools don’t allow …’ Not up to the school!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2023 17:01

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:48

@cantkeepawayforever , if you are a teacher surely you know what the correct procedure is.

What you don’t / can’t do is say ‘you aren’t going because of my opinion.’

Well, properly speaking it’s ‘I’m not letting you go for a few minutes because I just have something I would quickly like to check with Ms X [designated safeguarding lead]’ ( because in my professional opinion there is something that needs investigating ).

Which is sort of ‘I’m not letting you go because of my opinion’, but in a rather mire procedural form.

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 17:01

@cantkeepawayforever of course and rightly so

but it isn’t down to the opinion of the teacher. A teacher may say ‘I am concerned that jake is not going to be safe at home’ and the DSO would follow set procedure then. This isn’t really the same though.

OP posts:
GneissGuysFinishLast · 19/05/2023 17:00

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:48

@cantkeepawayforever , if you are a teacher surely you know what the correct procedure is.

What you don’t / can’t do is say ‘you aren’t going because of my opinion.’

You absolutely can!

You say “sorry John, I can’t let you go home until I know you are safe. Come get a biscuit in my office until I try and get a hold of someone”

Then you call family to come for John. If someone comes, great. If they don’t come, you phone social work for guidance.

If someone eventually does come collect John, you may still give social work a call, but that would be done at a time when John is already at home.

You can’t let a child leave when they are at risk of “immediate harm” (ie suspected abuse/neglect which could endanger life, and so on) but you can let them leave and still report if you feel a child’s needs aren’t being met outwith the scope of immediate harm (ie emotional neglect without abuse)

Whether John is being put at risk of immediate harm would very much depend on the specific circumstances of him walking home alone.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/05/2023 16:58

The usual procedure is to keep the child in school while a decision is sought from social work / safeguarding teams outside the school.

99% of the time it doesn’t even get that far.

In 20 years I’ve seen the “rule” challenged at least a dozen times I can think of off the top of my head. Only twice was social work contacted.

Once because it was part of a wider pattern. And once again when the school was over ruled and told it was absolutely fine.

Every other time the school had the parents sign a form and the child walked as the parents wished.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 19/05/2023 16:56

@cantkeepawayforever agreed you need to keep child safe until decision reached but you must admit that SS will only consider the safe guarding risk they will not consider that the headteachers school tule / preferred option is no child in y4 can go home alone regardless of risk even if they live nextdoor

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/05/2023 16:54

The insistence of people on here to compare extreme examples - 3 year olds in nursery, alcoholic neglectful parents etc - to the rest of the school population really isn’t enhancing the argument in the way you think it is.

it’s just daft.

cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2023 16:51

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:37

There is no social work instruction to keep children at school without an accompanying adult.

As confirmed by at least two social workers here!

There is a requirement to keep a child safe while investigating a potential safeguarding issue - wanting a child to walk home alone is not by itself a safeguarding issue but it can be part of one.

The usual procedure is to keep the child in school while a decision is sought from social work / safeguarding teams outside the school. Once resolved one way or another, the child may be collected (probably most usual); may walk home alone after everything has been resolved, or may be picked up by someone approved by social services (rare but not unknown). The child remains in school - a known and safe place. - until the decision is reached.

Ultimately, the initial decision to report a safeguarding concern about release to walk home IS my opinion - a trained opinion, and one then passed to a safeguarding lead and from them to the wider safeguarding team. I am required to have professional curiousity, and I am required to act on my observation/ opinion through reporting it.

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:48

@cantkeepawayforever , if you are a teacher surely you know what the correct procedure is.

What you don’t / can’t do is say ‘you aren’t going because of my opinion.’

OP posts:
Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 19/05/2023 16:48

the child would remain at school until SS replied but if SS agreed that it was reasonable for John to walk home alone 400 metres and there were no other concerns then the school would need to let him go home alone, they could not repeat the process the next day at 3pm when John's parents did not collect him
I am not talking about cases like @cantkeepawayforever mentioned but a simple case of parents deciding that John can perfectly easily walk home 400 metres now he is 8 as Dad works from home but can't leave work to pick up John due to being on conference calls, he will be in when John arrives home. John's parents have decided that John is old enough now to be at home with a parent in home office not lounge so he doesn't need childcare This is not a safeguarding concern and the fact the headteacher prefers this year group to be collected is irrelevant

GneissGuysFinishLast · 19/05/2023 16:41

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:37

There is no social work instruction to keep children at school without an accompanying adult.

As confirmed by at least two social workers here!

As a teacher, yes there is. I’m in Scotland and the child would remain with whoever the lead in child protection is until such time that social work make a decision, providing the schools concerns meet the criteria for a child protection issue. Which would depend on the individual circumstances of the child, the local area, etc.

cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2023 16:38

Do I, for example, let the 8 year old child go home alone when I know that the lone parent has been in court, and may have been imprisoned but the school have heard nothing?

Do I let the 7 year old child go home to be in sole charge of 3 younger siblings for a couple of hours, where the whole family has been referred to SS but there’s wrangling over whether they meet threshold?

Do I let the child go home when they may find their parent passed out from drugs or drink, as has happened 3 times in the past fortnight but again has not yet met threshold?

Teachers are surprisingly familiar with the seamier side even of the nicest communities (all the above are from my personal experience: luckily the one where the question was ‘do I let the child go home to the adult who may have inflicted those bruises’ DID meet SS threshold). Of course, being collected from school is no guarantee against abuse at home, but it generally means they do get home.

Turn it round the other way - 7 year old child dies or is horrendously hurt on the way home alone or after returning hone to a locked door and thus wandered off or a younger child us hurt when in the 7 year old’s care. Doe society say ‘oh, school is blameless, the parents gave permission?’. No. They say ‘the school was irresponsible to let the child go home alone, especially as they were aware of the family circumstances’.

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:37

There is no social work instruction to keep children at school without an accompanying adult.

As confirmed by at least two social workers here!

OP posts:
GneissGuysFinishLast · 19/05/2023 16:36

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:28

@cantkeepawayforever it doesn’t really depend how shit, no. No volunteer or teacher can say ‘actually we don’t think your parenting is good enough, your child isn’t going home tonight!’ What they can absolutely do is escalate any safeguarding concerns and some will be a matter of urgency. But that decision won’t ultimately be the schools, or the volunteers.

In practice, what happens is the school doesn’t let the child leave until they get further guidance from social work. The school isn’t keeping a child on their own say so, they are acting on social work instructions. It’s not the schools fault if it takes a while to get a decision from social work.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 19/05/2023 16:34

@cyncope except it won't take till 6pm as when school ring you at 3.10 you would say I gave you a written permission, I have already told you and headteacher I would not be collecting John so this is not a surprise, you knew already that we want John to walk home, if you ring his father he will confirm this as we both signed the letter, so please let him leave now. the school say we won't we are ringing SS unless you come in next 20 minutes, if you then say I have given permission for him to leave you have no good reason to continue keeping him at school but if you ring social services we will tell them what we have told you that John is perfectly capable of walking 400 metre son his own when there are no busy roads to cross, Social servives are really not going to back school up on a 8-9 year old walking 400 metres

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:28

@cantkeepawayforever it doesn’t really depend how shit, no. No volunteer or teacher can say ‘actually we don’t think your parenting is good enough, your child isn’t going home tonight!’ What they can absolutely do is escalate any safeguarding concerns and some will be a matter of urgency. But that decision won’t ultimately be the schools, or the volunteers.

OP posts:
Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:27

Not quite. I’m saying it’s up to the parent, and that includes how far they will take it.

There is no sense of any judgement from me or what I think you ‘should’ do. I just think that many people do genuinely believe that the school makes this call and I don’t know that is a good thing.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 19/05/2023 16:24

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:05

It doesn’t matter whether the parent who wanted the kids to walk home was making regular appearances on Benefits Street or was Kate Middleton. She is the parent, you are not.
you can’t refuse to let a child go because you think their mum is shit!

Well, it depends HOW shit, doesn’t it?

As I understand it, many of those who have posted here who want schools to allow children to walk home alone ion the say-so of parents do have an exception for ‘except if there are significant known safeguarding concerns around the family’.

So there is sone level of ‘shit parenting’ that people DO want schools to respond to?

cyncope · 19/05/2023 16:20

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:14

I wouldn’t but it is still your choice.

So when posters say things like ‘the school don’t allow …’ what they mean is ‘the school prefer.’ Which might be pedantic but not sure how comfortable it is so many are convinced the school can make parenting choices on their behalf.

If you are saying in theory it is up to the parent, but in practice you will have to abide by school policies then I agree with you.

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:14

I wouldn’t but it is still your choice.

So when posters say things like ‘the school don’t allow …’ what they mean is ‘the school prefer.’ Which might be pedantic but not sure how comfortable it is so many are convinced the school can make parenting choices on their behalf.

OP posts:
cyncope · 19/05/2023 16:11

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 14:42

the problem comes when people think ‘something I wouldn’t do personally’ is ‘safeguarding.’

I have no issue personally with guidance being year 5/6. In any case, when my children start school they will have to be taken and collected by car so they clearly can’t drive themselves 😅 but that’s not what I’m about here. I’m simply explaining the school does not decide, the parent does.

In theory, but how does it work in practice?

If you say - "I want my 8 year old to walk home alone" and the school says our policy is to only release to an adult, what do you do?

You could refuse to collect and demand they let your child walk home.
School would then call you at the end of the day. You'd refuse to collect.
Then they'd call the other parent.
Then they'd call the emergency contacts.
If all those people were prepped to refuse to collect then the school would call social services and/or the police.
Maybe once those agencies had got involved, school would be told they do have to release your now very distressed 8 year old at (by now) 6pm to walk themselves home.
Maybe that would be the end of it or maybe police/social workers would have concerns now about your parenting decisions.

Who honestly would put their child through all that?

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 16:05

It doesn’t matter whether the parent who wanted the kids to walk home was making regular appearances on Benefits Street or was Kate Middleton. She is the parent, you are not.
you can’t refuse to let a child go because you think their mum is shit!

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 19/05/2023 15:51

+Okay, I'll put it from a different angle - only 2 parents have ever asked me to let their child walk home. Parent 1 was one of those women who kept having more and more children and claiming more benefits for each one until the government put a cap on it (and eventually forced her and her husband to do some work rather than replying on the state).*

Thats just dripping with judgement, being on benefits, or having a lot of children, doesn’t make you a neglectful parent. Awaiting the drip feed now that’s her 20 kids were running about the streets half naked at midnight.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/05/2023 15:48

But "in loco parentis" means that the school is the parent whilst the children are with them, and are responsible for any decisions, including whether a child can walk home on their own or not.

The school is not the parent while children are with them, the school has limited duties and powers ie those required to allow them to undertake the task of educating your child, they don’t have parental rights and responsibilities for your child and can’t make decisions for them out with those needed to fulfil their education duties.

Id have a lot of concern if parents really thought “that’s them in school, the teacher is now their parent”.

underneaththeash · 19/05/2023 15:48

NewNovember · 19/05/2023 15:31

Then unless your children have a relevant disability you are doing them no favours by refusing to allow them to mature It's benign neglect to refuse to give your children the opportunities they need to develop independence.

They're older than 9 now (obviously) and all independent older teens. So that's clearly bollacks.

Okay, I'll put it from a different angle - only 2 parents have ever asked me to let their child walk home. Parent 1 was one of those women who kept having more and more children and claiming more benefits for each one until the government put a cap on it (and eventually forced her and her husband to do some work rather than replying on the state).
Parent 2's excuse was that it was her evening to go to the pub, the 9 year old would have been going back to an empty house.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/05/2023 15:47

Sartre · 19/05/2023 15:40

But they do. My DC’s school wouldn’t let them leave without an adult until year 5.

They’d very likely back down (or indeed as I’ve seen multiple times say “oh yes, that is just our guidance” when they know they’ve presented it as a rule) if challenged as most know it’s not their call ultimately.

Swipe left for the next trending thread