Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the school does not decide when your child can walk home alone

383 replies

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 09:25

I keep seeing this on threads and I don’t want to derail what the thread is about.

But the school cannot decide this. You do as parent. It may be you are broadly in agreement with the school and I am but this is your choice and not the schools.

It irrationally annoys me when people claim ‘the schools don’t allow …’ Not up to the school!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
RosaGallica · 20/05/2023 12:04

It sounds op as if, like me, you are a bit concerned about how much power schools have over children, relative to parents, now.

The school staff are also concerned from the other direction, that they have too much responsibility now.

It seems to me there is scope for discussion and improvement, but such details haven’t been high on public agendas for a long time.

Bluemuf · 20/05/2023 12:01

Barbie222 · 20/05/2023 11:58

If you refuse to collect your child then the school will call SS, and police, to reunite you with them. Schools may have a policy of allowing children above a certain age to walk home, which you are welcome to avail yourself of. If they don't, you may need to find an establishment with another policy. There wouldn't be anything a parent could lay out in front of me which would make me listen as much as a safeguarding fail which would get up to Ofsted, tbh!

Allowing a competent child to leave, with parental permission, isn't going to interest either social care, the police or Ofsted

Barbie222 · 20/05/2023 11:58

If you refuse to collect your child then the school will call SS, and police, to reunite you with them. Schools may have a policy of allowing children above a certain age to walk home, which you are welcome to avail yourself of. If they don't, you may need to find an establishment with another policy. There wouldn't be anything a parent could lay out in front of me which would make me listen as much as a safeguarding fail which would get up to Ofsted, tbh!

Ladykryptonite · 20/05/2023 11:54

Op, if your school is within walking distance, could you walk or cycle so as not to add to the traffic

Natsku · 20/05/2023 11:00

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/05/2023 08:48

Dd ( yr 7) had a medical appointment a few weeks back. School wouldn't let her leave even though id emailed to give permission. She cycles and i cant get the bike in the car so she had ti have the whole day off in the end as I didnt have time with work to pick her up amd drop her back off. Then they moan about attendance. Make your bloody mind up.

That's utterly ridiculous, they have no right to refuse to let a child leave for a medical appointment.

When DD has an appointment I just message her teacher to say she'll be late/leaving early/has to leave for a while during school. I know he'll never say no she can't. Once her dentist called and rescheduled her appointment from the next day to the current day and I had to call her teacher during lessons to tell him to tell DD to leave and bike to the dentist in half an hour (which he had zero issue with). Then had to call back 5 minutes later after the dentist called again to cancel! Embarrassing for me but at least I knew that there would be no complaints from the school about her leaving.

MagpieSong · 20/05/2023 10:41

I don’t see this to be a big enough issue to be causing problems about it. If my school says no (which it does), I’d respect they’ve come up with that for a reason and find other ways to encourage independence. It’s not really a risk of SS being involved for the majority imo, they don’t have the capacity to deal with a single issue about school run between the school and the parent. If it’s on top of other concerns, that’s very different. However, it’s not an issue I’d argue with the school with.

Our school do only release to a list of people and you have to prewarn if someone else is collecting (state village primary school). They will let them go if you phone up - for example, if a meeting overruns and you’ve said ‘so and so’s mum might collect today’. If no one turned up, they’d keep your child back and call you (we got a club wrong once and they called). As I’ve never tried, I don’t know what would happen should you say they had to be released to walk home alone. They do list being brought to and collected from school by a responsible, known adult in their rules, so I assume parents who have an issue with that talk to them. As the school is responsible for the child until they leave the premises and I’ve chosen for my child to attend the school, I think they could argue they do have a say because they’re choosing how to hand over their part of responsibility. I’d hold them accountable for my dc seeing something inappropriate during their time of responsibility or being hurt, so equally they are passing that responsibility back at the end of the day (or taking it in the morning), which is fair. Children at our school are released individually from their classroom door or the hall door or the staircase door for classrooms that don’t back onto the ground floor.

I do think part of it is regularly seeing a responsible adult as a pointer for home situations to add to any concerns for vulnerable children. Obviously, this doesn’t apply to the majority, but I’d imagine it has value when a child is suspected of being neglected as part of the picture. I also think the sheer volume of cars on the street at school run time and people’s drives to walk past has played in part in our school’s decision (so I’d assume school’s location makes a difference). Equally, if local residents complain of issues from school children walking home, this would influence the school’s decision. I do know that Y6 from our school had apparently caused issues for one older lady and I imagine a select few from different schools do act badly, which then makes it less possible for the rest to access the school run as time to learn independence.

Hairyfairy01 · 20/05/2023 09:36

I had to write a note saying that I was allowing my dc to walk home alone once they started year 3. School were surprised I think but didn't express any issues. From year 3 school doors were thrown open and all the kids poured out as one anyway 🤷‍♀️.

Dumbphone · 20/05/2023 09:33

Ponoka7 · 20/05/2023 08:33

You assumed that the parent is going to go home and use. In this case the child would have been going home to an empty house, which would have stayed empty until her Parents returned from the Mother brassing it. The parent showing up to school meant that the school could see what state the parent in. You as a ex SW should know the crucial role schools play in safeguarding. It's someone who sees both parent and child everyday. Most people now realise because of all the child abuse cases, which have resulted in deaths that happened solely because of lockdown. Also as a ex SW you know that cases are judged individually, as I said I got permission for my primary aged child to be allowed to go alone. You know that if anything had have happened to your child the first question would have been why was he traveling alone. You wasn't in Haringey, was you? That would explain why you'd send your ND ten year old out to learn by his mistakes.

My point is that the risk comes from the parent/the home environment NOT the walk home. Pretty straightforward actually. so because some kids have a difficult home life, all kids should not have freedom? That is the end result to your ridiculous assertions.

if a child has a parent who is using drugs and in year 5 isn’t allowed to walk home but in year 6 is… well are you really saying it’s ok for an 11 yr old but not a 10 yr old? No! It’s not ok for either of those children, but the walk home is not the risk. It’s the parent using drugs. You haven’t actually pinpointed the risk of the actual walk home!

are you seriously saying a school needs to see a parent every day to keep a child safe? My younger son’s school sees me infrequently, in the chaos of pickup time and lets my boy out as soon as they see me, they don’t smell my breath, check my appearance. They know and have risk assessed me by coming to my home when he started, by engaging with me at parents evenings, trips and meetings throughout the year.

and my older son is doing great, he is independent, loves getting about alone, feels extremely grown up and has learnt what to do if there’s a tube strike, how to manage a stopped Oyster card, has been stopped by police and dealt with it like a champ, knows how to manage trouble from other kids. He is amazing, and capable and it’s my job as a parent to nurture that in him, to teach him he’s capable and encourage his confidence. Not to tell him he needs mummy by his side because some parents use drugs.

the lack of logic is totally astounding actually. I’m almost shocked - but then I remember, risk is actually a difficult concept to understand, though application of logic usually helps.

cansu · 20/05/2023 09:10

If you give your child a phone and the school has a no phones rule. They can confiscate it and ask you to collect it.

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/05/2023 08:48

Dd ( yr 7) had a medical appointment a few weeks back. School wouldn't let her leave even though id emailed to give permission. She cycles and i cant get the bike in the car so she had ti have the whole day off in the end as I didnt have time with work to pick her up amd drop her back off. Then they moan about attendance. Make your bloody mind up.

SweetSakura · 20/05/2023 08:45

Needmorelego · 19/05/2023 09:34

If that's the rule of the school then that's the rule.
The same if the rule is your child has to be there by 8.50 am and be wearing a red sweatshirt.
Don't like the rules either don't send your child to that school or just suck it up.

Nope. If the rules are stupid it's reasonable to challenge them.

I'm not a fan of blind obedience and I don't encourage it in my children.

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/05/2023 08:45

When dd was at primary school ( she left in September) i was stunned at the number of parents of year 6s who still picked up /walked their children to school. Schools should be encouraging parents to let their kids be a it more independent. Instead they make it difficult then promptly moan about all the inconsiderate parking.

You cant have it both ways.

Ime its not just the schools that are difficult though. Parents need to let go a bit. Perhaps of they'd actually walked by themselves once in a while you'd not be worrying they won't be able to get to high school in year 7.

Even secondary schools have the parking issues and when you look at the admissions information and no ones outside 1.3 miles got in then in theory there's no one there that shouldn't actually be able to walk.

I think its all become a vicious circle. The roads get dangerously, clogged and kids aren't safe walking so parents akd schools don't allow it , cue lots more cars and lots more dangerously and kids incapable of walking as they've never been allowed to do it. Round and round it goes

JustDanceAddict · 20/05/2023 08:40

When my DCs were younger you had to register them as an independent traveller in year 6 (so 10-11) if you weren’t taking them to school. I expect this was for safeguarding as if they didn’t turn up they would know you hadn’t dropped them
off. I used to let them do the last 5 mins or so on their own as it was past the last busy road. I think that’s fair enough.
Year 3 and beyond they were released from the classroom in a normal manner / parents waited in playground or older kids walked home themselves (when my youngest was that aged we’d moved so he could safely walk home alone if he wanted to - we’d agree in it the morning). I’m infants children released when the teacher saw the parent or you’d write/phone if they were being collected by another parent/person ie, grandparent.
Schools need a duty of care, but it needs to be sensible too.

Ponoka7 · 20/05/2023 08:33

Dumbphone · 19/05/2023 11:50

I was a child protection social worker for 12 years, including in lockdown, so do know a thing or two about child safeguarding. How is a child walking home from school alone more risky than being in their home with a parent who is addicted to drugs? This doesn't make sense. It's the parent's behaviour while using drugs - not the walk home, that causes harm to the child. Safeguarding is used as a guise for authoritarianism, and it's pathetic, frankly. I put this in bold as it's come up again and again. Safeguarding cannot be a word that is inserted into every conversation to avoid children ever being exposed to any risk. Your post shows me you don't understand risk, and it's sad to see someone working in schools just not getting it.

Surely the only reason to not allow a child to walk alone is if there is an unmanageable risk from cars on the roads, or there is a peado rehab unit on the route for example. Once a child is capable and sensible enough they should be able to travel alone. My SEN kid has been travelling across London by tube since he was just turned 10, he made some mistakes and has had some tricky times, but has learnt from them and is very independent now.

You assumed that the parent is going to go home and use. In this case the child would have been going home to an empty house, which would have stayed empty until her Parents returned from the Mother brassing it. The parent showing up to school meant that the school could see what state the parent in. You as a ex SW should know the crucial role schools play in safeguarding. It's someone who sees both parent and child everyday. Most people now realise because of all the child abuse cases, which have resulted in deaths that happened solely because of lockdown. Also as a ex SW you know that cases are judged individually, as I said I got permission for my primary aged child to be allowed to go alone. You know that if anything had have happened to your child the first question would have been why was he traveling alone. You wasn't in Haringey, was you? That would explain why you'd send your ND ten year old out to learn by his mistakes.

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 07:37

So you understand that it is not for the school to decide, but the parent?

I know you don’t agree with it, but that is the correct information.

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 20/05/2023 07:15

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 12:52

@Nordicrain so in a hypothetical sort of sense, if you refused to collect a three year old then the preschool would probably call SS who would then take whatever action they deemed necessary.

Where you seem to be misunderstanding is the role of the school within that. Parents have the right to make decisions that they believe to be right for their child. These do not include (obviously) neglect, abuse and so on and schools play a part in protecting children from this and rightly so - this doesn’t include making parenting decisions for them.

See above re I decide when I think it’s right for my child to walk home. If the school say ten but I think ‘not ready yet’ that’s my call, not the schools.

The school isn't forcing a 10 year old that isn't ready to walk home. That would of course be ridiculous. But turning the scenario around doesn't "prove" you right. It's nonsensical.

And - again - you can keep repeating I don't "understand" but I do. I just disagree with you.

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 02:38

@adriftinadenofvipers it isn’t about challenging it for the sake of challenging it. It’s simply about knowledge, which is as they say, power.

Most people are happy to go along with most things most of the time and indeed I am, but I do think wording is important. Quite a lot of posters genuinely believe that this is the schools decision to make and it is not. Ultimately, it is up to the parent(s) how the child travels to and from school. If the school has reasonable grounds for believing that the child will be unsafe then there are procedures that can be followed but these aren’t ongoing. In other words, if the school choose to involve social services and it is concluded the child is not at risk the school aren’t then in a position to refuse to allow the child to leave every day until SS have OKd it.

As for not being churlish or rude

Are you just determined to be difficult? Knock yourself out, give your kid a phone - but don't be surprised if it gets confiscated during the school day. I pity the teachers who have to deal with you

What a load of utter bollocks. Yes, of course it fucking is up to the school as they are responsible for your child's safety until they hand them over to your care. Just do what other parents have been doing for years and make proper arrangements for your child to be collected, instead of winding yourself up on a ridiculous crusade against a perfectly reasonable school rule

are two of your posts from this thread. I get you feel strongly about this but they are very aggressive posts, littered with swearing and assumptions that I am demanding things for the sake of it. It’s admirable that you want to support teachers, so do I. It isn’t about challenging things for the sake of it, it’s just about knowing where we stand as parents. If someone says - well, I live two doors down but actually it’s no big deal to me getting my Year 4 aged child so I’ll roll with it - fine. That’s a choice. If someone says I live two doors down but I’ll have to continue with collection of my child because that’s what the school rules say then that isn’t a choice and we have the right to exercise that choice.

As with many things, knowledge is power. This thread is purely about sharing that knowledge. It is not about what I believe to be personally right or wrong: there are many things I abhor which are legal and will remain legal and rightly so.

When my children start school, they will be taken by me by car and collected by me by car at the end of the day. I don’t have a personal dog in this race Smile

OP posts:
adriftinadenofvipers · 19/05/2023 22:19

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 19:08

@adriftinadenofvipers , I am not being difficult at all - to be honest, I’ve been perfectly polite. The one being surly and rude is you!

In any case, you don’t need to pity the teachers. I don’t have school aged children and I AM a teacher!

I've been neither surly nor rude.

If you actually are a teacher, I'm shocked you would seek to challenge this. I'd have thought you and your colleagues would have better things to do than figure out who's allowed to walk home and who isn't.

Vgbeat · 19/05/2023 22:00

I'm a teacher and our children can only walk home if they have written permission, I teach year 4 and I hate that a couple of my kids are allowed to walk home alone. Lots of year 5 and 6 walk home which I feel is OK as getting ready for high school.

If I just let any child wander off on there own and something happened I would be devastated and in the reverse if I just let your child go off and something happened we would never be forgiven.

KnickerlessParsons · 19/05/2023 19:49

I had the same re cycling. DD wanted to cycle to school (and I wanted her to too), but school "wouldn't allow it" until she'd passed her cycling proficiency test. I asked if they would turn her away and not allow her to attend school if she turned up on her bike, they reluctantly said no.

Honestly, it's no wonder we have an obesity problem in young children.

Mamamia32 · 19/05/2023 19:48

The op's point may be true but I agree with my son's school policy and have absolutely no desire to challenge it. He will be allowed to walk home alone in year 6.

StraightOuttaContext · 19/05/2023 19:44

I just find binary 'debates' - where people back themselves into ridiculous corners to the extent they come out with batshittery like the things I've quoted upthread rather than consider that life isn't black & white, or that it's not actually terrible to change one's mind - entertaining. I bloody love the internet. God bless Tim Berners-Lee!

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 19:20

I think some people genuinely believe I am advocating sending four year olds home alone and I’m not, it really was intended to be informative rather than a discussion based thread. So they think I am trying to cause trouble which couldn’t be further than the truth.

I do think it is just worth knowing, though. So to give my example of the friend with the dog, going back a few years but I think what happened was that she worked overlapping shifts with her DH, so the dog was only ever alone for the recommended No of hours. She could get home, walk the dog to school and pick up her DD, go the long way home, happy, exercised dog, or the alternative was to go home, have an overjoyed dog then upset when she went out again in the car and it is a funny place where school traffic takes longer to navigate than walking.

So made sense for everyone but there was a refusal to let the child leave even though said child was pointing at her mum and waving.

Yes the dog could have been left home but the point was, it was a good solution that worked and no child was at risk! To blindly accept rules isn’t always wise. I definitely don’t think we should fight then for the sake of fighting but it’s also fine to sometimes say hey hang on - that’s silly. It’s the parents’ judgement call, not that of the school.

OP posts:
StraightOuttaContext · 19/05/2023 19:12

@Itisuptoyou the false equivalences, spite and frothing from some quarters on here are batshit!

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 19:08

@adriftinadenofvipers , I am not being difficult at all - to be honest, I’ve been perfectly polite. The one being surly and rude is you!

In any case, you don’t need to pity the teachers. I don’t have school aged children and I AM a teacher!

OP posts: