Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the school does not decide when your child can walk home alone

383 replies

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 09:25

I keep seeing this on threads and I don’t want to derail what the thread is about.

But the school cannot decide this. You do as parent. It may be you are broadly in agreement with the school and I am but this is your choice and not the schools.

It irrationally annoys me when people claim ‘the schools don’t allow …’ Not up to the school!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 18:01

I'm sorry but that is incorrect. I have worked in 2 different schools who both have the policy a child will not be released without a parent/Carer etc until year 6.

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 17:08

@gingercat02 i do agree that no one should be a dickhead for the sake of it. It’s a good rule of thumb for life actually!

But making the choice not to be a dickhead is making a choice. I am simply trying to be informative and to say ultimately the choice is yours (general yours.) Not the schools.

OP posts:
Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 15:40

@gingercat02 for the sake of it no but there maybe good legitimate reasons why a parent may need their child to walk home alone, maybe it is temporary an illness or broken leg, and they simply can't afford with that parent not working to pay someone to collect or mind child when it is actual a safe decision I would hope no school was so regimented about their rules that they were unwilling to consider an amendment for necessity. on the other hand no school should deliberately make a parents life difficult especially in cost of living crisis because of an arbitary rule when altering it when no safeguarding risk is evident would be so helpful

Natsku · 20/05/2023 15:38

gingercat02 · 20/05/2023 15:18

Yeah but no one should want to be that dickhead parent

The dickhead parent that makes a valid parenting choice? How's that being a dickhead parent?

Natsku · 20/05/2023 15:37

Barbie222 · 20/05/2023 14:09

So if the 5 year old child (youngest that could be in preschool) has an accident on the way to or home from school, even though the parents gave written permission, they can (and should) claim on the school's insurance.

Why would any school, or business, leave themselves exposed in this way? It doesn't make sense.

Its the law, schools are legally obliged to have insurance that covers accidents on school grounds, on school trips and on children's direct (so if they take a detour to a friend's house or the shop they won't be covered, only the direct route between home and school) journeys to and from school. Its to cover the medical costs of any injury as healthcare isn't completely free at point of use here, so if you go to a&e for an accident they ask if its covered by a relevant insurance like school or sports club and if so you fill out a form so you don't pay the fees.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/05/2023 15:28

gingercat02 · 20/05/2023 12:53

Our school wouldn't "release" them until Y5 with seeing the adult collecting them. Not even to an older sibling. So, yes they can and do decide.

They’d have had no choice if challenged. Unless it was a safeguarding issue to the point of SS involvement.

Thats the point of the OP - they don’t actually have the authority to decide.

gingercat02 · 20/05/2023 15:18

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 13:16

@gingercat02 yes that maybe true but if a parent challenged it and they went through with allowing school to call SS and then SS said they did not think it was a safeguarding risk, the school could not then refuse to release child the next day after it was agreed by SS that the child in question could walk to and from school alone

Yeah but no one should want to be that dickhead parent

GneissGuysFinishLast · 20/05/2023 14:54

MagpieSong · 20/05/2023 13:38

Fair enough and yes, cities are cities. Actually, thinking about it, I think I’m way off the mark statistic-wise on how much of the population lives rurally, so yes definitely wrong on the reason there! There is likely to be reason behind why the decision has differed, though. English schools must have reasons that they’ve put that rule in place. It doesn’t mean parents who want to can’t question it, but I doubt they all chose to do it based on making parents who want that time to teach independence annoyed.

The majority of the population of Scotland lives in the central belt, which is really densely populated. 83% of Scotland’s population lives on 2% of its land.

adriftinadenofvipers · 20/05/2023 14:39

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 02:38

@adriftinadenofvipers it isn’t about challenging it for the sake of challenging it. It’s simply about knowledge, which is as they say, power.

Most people are happy to go along with most things most of the time and indeed I am, but I do think wording is important. Quite a lot of posters genuinely believe that this is the schools decision to make and it is not. Ultimately, it is up to the parent(s) how the child travels to and from school. If the school has reasonable grounds for believing that the child will be unsafe then there are procedures that can be followed but these aren’t ongoing. In other words, if the school choose to involve social services and it is concluded the child is not at risk the school aren’t then in a position to refuse to allow the child to leave every day until SS have OKd it.

As for not being churlish or rude

Are you just determined to be difficult? Knock yourself out, give your kid a phone - but don't be surprised if it gets confiscated during the school day. I pity the teachers who have to deal with you

What a load of utter bollocks. Yes, of course it fucking is up to the school as they are responsible for your child's safety until they hand them over to your care. Just do what other parents have been doing for years and make proper arrangements for your child to be collected, instead of winding yourself up on a ridiculous crusade against a perfectly reasonable school rule

are two of your posts from this thread. I get you feel strongly about this but they are very aggressive posts, littered with swearing and assumptions that I am demanding things for the sake of it. It’s admirable that you want to support teachers, so do I. It isn’t about challenging things for the sake of it, it’s just about knowing where we stand as parents. If someone says - well, I live two doors down but actually it’s no big deal to me getting my Year 4 aged child so I’ll roll with it - fine. That’s a choice. If someone says I live two doors down but I’ll have to continue with collection of my child because that’s what the school rules say then that isn’t a choice and we have the right to exercise that choice.

As with many things, knowledge is power. This thread is purely about sharing that knowledge. It is not about what I believe to be personally right or wrong: there are many things I abhor which are legal and will remain legal and rightly so.

When my children start school, they will be taken by me by car and collected by me by car at the end of the day. I don’t have a personal dog in this race Smile

Maybe you should have a word with my children's post-primary, who have strict rules about how their uniform should be travelling to and from school.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 14:26

it maybe the Swiss are just less likely to be claiming, I am not sure exactly about Switzerland but this is true in Sweden
I have friends in Sweden they have trees in school playground which the kids are allowed to climb, I am told if a child fell out of tree and broke arm ( it happens) and the school took them to the Swedish equivalent of A & E and the arm was in plaster cast and a sling the most likely parental repsonse would be a grateful thank you from the parents for taking them to hopsital, it simply would not really occur to them that stopping kids climbing trees or chopping them down or putting a fence around the tree in case their was an accident was a reasonable response, as the Swedes in general believe the benefits of tree climbing and other such activities outweigh the risks of an accident. Primary school children are supposed to have clothes waterproof and wind proof enough to go outside upto -25C sliding on ice is encourraged not banned

Barbie222 · 20/05/2023 14:09

So if the 5 year old child (youngest that could be in preschool) has an accident on the way to or home from school, even though the parents gave written permission, they can (and should) claim on the school's insurance.

Why would any school, or business, leave themselves exposed in this way? It doesn't make sense.

MagpieSong · 20/05/2023 13:38

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 13:10

Glasgow and Edinburgh are about as densely populated as Birmingham and manchester, small highland village no different to small Cornish or Herefordshire village, of course overall Scotland is much less densely populated as it is 2/3rd area of England with about 9% of the population and a lot of children in remote areas are travelling by school bus and also most children go to local school
However there is no overall difference between Scotland and England in terms of risk of car accidents or stranger danger

Fair enough and yes, cities are cities. Actually, thinking about it, I think I’m way off the mark statistic-wise on how much of the population lives rurally, so yes definitely wrong on the reason there! There is likely to be reason behind why the decision has differed, though. English schools must have reasons that they’ve put that rule in place. It doesn’t mean parents who want to can’t question it, but I doubt they all chose to do it based on making parents who want that time to teach independence annoyed.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 13:16

@gingercat02 yes that maybe true but if a parent challenged it and they went through with allowing school to call SS and then SS said they did not think it was a safeguarding risk, the school could not then refuse to release child the next day after it was agreed by SS that the child in question could walk to and from school alone

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 13:13

the walking home in P4 is general and applies in inner city Glasgow as well as outer hebrides, in fact when my DD started school 7 years ago in a village it was only P1 that were handed over specifically to parent /child minder etc the P2 and P3 teacher just stood near gate to keep a general eye that they were going to a pick up person, the new head teacher now has teachers from P1-3 at gate to make sure child has seen their parent/ granny etc

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 13:10

Glasgow and Edinburgh are about as densely populated as Birmingham and manchester, small highland village no different to small Cornish or Herefordshire village, of course overall Scotland is much less densely populated as it is 2/3rd area of England with about 9% of the population and a lot of children in remote areas are travelling by school bus and also most children go to local school
However there is no overall difference between Scotland and England in terms of risk of car accidents or stranger danger

MagpieSong · 20/05/2023 13:07

Nicknacky · 20/05/2023 12:52

😂😂😂How exactly is Scotland sparely populated?!

We do have roads, cities and cars, you know.

I worded it in a stupid way. I just mean it’s just got a lower population than England, Wales (where I live) also does. I’m not saying there are no cities etc, obviously 😂🙈 Sorry! I’m just saying depending on location, the schools may be taking these things into account. If the school is rural with a simple route to it, it might be easier to have a walking home alone rule than to say no walking home alone.

gingercat02 · 20/05/2023 12:53

Our school wouldn't "release" them until Y5 with seeing the adult collecting them. Not even to an older sibling. So, yes they can and do decide.

Nicknacky · 20/05/2023 12:52

MagpieSong · 20/05/2023 12:48

Could partly be location and road safety, depending on area? Scotland is sparsely populated. Also, simply individual schools and areas having different experiences that mean they have brought a no walking home alone rule into play.

Switzerland is a very different country, so difficult to compare the two. Much like when people bring up Japan in these threads, it’s a different country with different issues and strengths and it doesn’t directly compare.

😂😂😂How exactly is Scotland sparely populated?!

We do have roads, cities and cars, you know.

MagpieSong · 20/05/2023 12:48

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 12:18

there is no intrinsic difference between Scottish and English children but in Scotland most children leave on their own in P4 (y3) there may be someone to collect there may not, they are generally told if they are expecting someone to be there and they are not to go back into the school, so why is a English childjudged to be incompetent of doing this until 3 years later in Y6?

Could partly be location and road safety, depending on area? Scotland is sparsely populated. Also, simply individual schools and areas having different experiences that mean they have brought a no walking home alone rule into play.

Switzerland is a very different country, so difficult to compare the two. Much like when people bring up Japan in these threads, it’s a different country with different issues and strengths and it doesn’t directly compare.

NewNovember · 20/05/2023 12:32

Barbie222 · 20/05/2023 12:14

Allowing a competent child to leave, with parental permission, isn't going to interest either social care, the police or Ofsted

Who's competent, though? Would a 5 year old be, if parents gave permission? There are parents who would argue that. There will always be grey areas, and with questions like this, where things could go badly wrong and because of the setup in the UK there'd be a considerable impact on insurance / livelihoods / people's jobs, communities like schools need policies and a line in the sand rather than judging every case individually.

Children in Europe walk because there's not the same litigation culture.

My friends five year old walks home with friends in Switzerland.

Natsku · 20/05/2023 12:19

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 12:18

there is no intrinsic difference between Scottish and English children but in Scotland most children leave on their own in P4 (y3) there may be someone to collect there may not, they are generally told if they are expecting someone to be there and they are not to go back into the school, so why is a English childjudged to be incompetent of doing this until 3 years later in Y6?

Good question, are English children inherently less capable? Doubt it.

Natsku · 20/05/2023 12:19

Children in Europe walk because there's not the same litigation culture

Interestingly, the journey to and from school is covered by school's insurance in my country, where children walk alone. So if the 5 year old child (youngest that could be in preschool) has an accident on the way to or home from school, even though the parents gave written permission, they can (and should) claim on the school's insurance.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 12:18

there is no intrinsic difference between Scottish and English children but in Scotland most children leave on their own in P4 (y3) there may be someone to collect there may not, they are generally told if they are expecting someone to be there and they are not to go back into the school, so why is a English childjudged to be incompetent of doing this until 3 years later in Y6?

Barbie222 · 20/05/2023 12:14

Allowing a competent child to leave, with parental permission, isn't going to interest either social care, the police or Ofsted

Who's competent, though? Would a 5 year old be, if parents gave permission? There are parents who would argue that. There will always be grey areas, and with questions like this, where things could go badly wrong and because of the setup in the UK there'd be a considerable impact on insurance / livelihoods / people's jobs, communities like schools need policies and a line in the sand rather than judging every case individually.

Children in Europe walk because there's not the same litigation culture.

RosaGallica · 20/05/2023 12:07

Pragmatic and practical details of life haven’t been high in public agendas for a long time in fact, our entire culture has been shifted towards power games imo.

Swipe left for the next trending thread