Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the school does not decide when your child can walk home alone

383 replies

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 09:25

I keep seeing this on threads and I don’t want to derail what the thread is about.

But the school cannot decide this. You do as parent. It may be you are broadly in agreement with the school and I am but this is your choice and not the schools.

It irrationally annoys me when people claim ‘the schools don’t allow …’ Not up to the school!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
GneissGuysFinishLast · 19/05/2023 11:21

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/05/2023 11:18

There will be legislative reasons and that's when you can see if you can negotiate. The plan then has to be written by an appropriate staff member to be put in place.

There is no legislation to dictate the age a child can walk home from school, in the same way there is no legislation to say the age a child can be left home alone. It’s for parents to assess the capacity of their child and make decisions accordingly, for which they are accountable. School policy, local authority guidance etc isn’t legislative.

The thing is, parents aren’t always the best at addressing the capacity of their children to walk home. A 14-15 year old May still not have capacity to walk home safely, or a 7 year old May have the capacity. It isn’t about age per se. It’s about keeping the child safe.

BogRollBOGOF · 19/05/2023 11:21

When DS2 started walking home at the start of y5, they rang to confirm the arrangement. I reassured them that it was a very short, simple walk, and that I'd be home within 5-10 mins after picking autistic y7 from his new secondary school.
I don't mind clarifying that he's going safely with my permission to a safe environment. However they would not have a basis to refuse. I don't have spare £££ to blow on 15 mins in the after school provision or local family or avaliable friends to impose on.

The reality was in y4 that I'd turn up at the playground, and send DS2 off ahead anyway lest DS1 have a post-school meltdown. DS2 much prefers the new arrangement!

It needs to be a case by case judgement as children mature at different rates, have different journeys and provision at home. Blanket bans become very shakey to enforce through the junior years. It's normal practice for y7s to walk/ transport themselves to secondaries that are further away and it's healthy to build that up at the child's pace rather than a big gear change because it's the summer that they turned 11. With DS1 that social confidence has been much slower and needed little steps. That doesn't mean other children should be held back to his pace.

SarahSmith2023 · 19/05/2023 11:20

FrogsWormsandButterflies · 19/05/2023 09:39

School doesn’t bother me too much, year 5/6 can walk home alone which is fine.

I do have an issue with my older DC. She goes to a club weekly and has done since she was 5, she is now 16. Last week they went bowling, she wasn’t allowed to meet me in the carpark without an adult escorting her to the car. She had flown alone but couldn’t be trusted to walk 10m across a carpark in broad daylight

Bloody stupid isn't it.

JustanothermagicMonday1 · 19/05/2023 11:20

“@JustanothermagicMonday1 I do understand that for some people this would be too risky to challenge. But if you are in a position to challenge it, I think you should. It makes me angry that schools make these rules and act as if they can enforce them. They are not parents.”

Yes, but sometimes schools have more information. In our area, London, there have been multiple abduction attempts in recent years of young children and older, secondary aged children too. The schools all know this and are told straight away, they keep a clear log. Some schools even had to get police escort on school trips. Not all parents are aware of every incident.

So there is just not one size fits all for all primary schools.

SarahSmith2023 · 19/05/2023 11:18

TattiePants · 19/05/2023 09:39

Of course she didn't have to be 'that parent'. She could have left the dog at home.

@TattiePants

why should she?

id rather be 'that parent' or THE parent of the child, than do something 'pointless' just to comply with a daft school rule trying to parent my child. Back in box!

GneissGuysFinishLast · 19/05/2023 11:18

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:13

The school may say this, but in your shoes, I would have sent DS, and if they refused to release her phone them and tell them they need to drop her home then. Or keep her overnight and feed her.
Schools say these things, but they can only enforce them if you let them.

In this case, the school would phone social work who would advise. Social work may indeed say to release them; or may come and collect the child themselves.

Telling someone in charge of child protection just to keep your child overnight isn’t a great idea.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/05/2023 11:18

There will be legislative reasons and that's when you can see if you can negotiate. The plan then has to be written by an appropriate staff member to be put in place.

There is no legislation to dictate the age a child can walk home from school, in the same way there is no legislation to say the age a child can be left home alone. It’s for parents to assess the capacity of their child and make decisions accordingly, for which they are accountable. School policy, local authority guidance etc isn’t legislative.

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:16

@Ponoka7 The only legislative reasons are vague safeguarding. It is bullshit. No one is saying a 5 year old should be left to cross busy roads alone and walk back home. But schools do not get to decide if a 9 year old say can walk home alone.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 19/05/2023 11:15

There is a reason that most schools don’t have a blanket rule on this.

My daughters school is urban, centrally located in a fairly large town. Catchment area is probably around a mile all round; lots of busy roads but also lots of safe crossing points.

They don’t have a set age where kids can walk to/from school, because obviously individual children’s walks can be very different. My daughters is around half a mile, through “nice” areas, with no roads. Her friends is closer; but with several roads to cross.

Also, individual maturity and abilities of children can differ. For example, a neurotypical child may navigate their commute more successfully than a non neurotypical child, due to perception of danger. A “rule follower” may be safer than a child who likes to push boundaries. The level of practice that a child has plays a part too - my daughter is too young to walk herself, but we are already “training” her (eg we ask what she would do if the pavement was blocked? What if someone offers you a lift?)

Basically, you could have 30 children of the same age in a class, and for some of them, walking home alone would be a safeguarding concern, but for others it would not be.

I have reported a safeguarding concern about this exact situation, and it was taken seriously. The child was 7; and was running across a busy road without looking several times (then crossing back over to the same side - there was actually no need for them to ever cross a road) - several cars had to stop for them.

The report wasn’t because they were only 7 - the report was because they were unsafe in their behaviours. Had they not been playing on the road; I wouldn’t have called (although I certainly wouldn’t have let my child do the same walk at that age)

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:15

@JustanothermagicMonday1 I do understand that for some people this would be too risky to challenge. But if you are in a position to challenge it, I think you should. It makes me angry that schools make these rules and act as if they can enforce them. They are not parents.

Ponoka7 · 19/05/2023 11:14

"Ask them to give you the legal basis for refusing to release him against his parents wishes. They won’t be able to do that because there isn’t one."

There will be legislative reasons and that's when you can see if you can negotiate. The plan then has to be written by an appropriate staff member to be put in place.

toomuchlaundry · 19/05/2023 11:14

I'm sure there are studies that show children under 8 aren't as good as older children/adults at judging speed of cars when crossing roads etc. So I do wonder how that works in countries where very young children are walking to school. However, I assume those countries are more set up to enable young children to walk to school safely. Also, there will be safety in numbers and fewer cars around at school run time

Dumbphone · 19/05/2023 11:14

@Jellycatspyjamas there are parents who’ve tried this and school got furious, child was caught up in it.

Didtheythough · 19/05/2023 11:14

Seems like there's a lot of anti school feeling on here. Im pretty sure at our school it's Y5 & Y6 can just go home, with no extra admin, y4 and below would need written permission from parent to release them without an adult. Schools have to have some sort of rule to cover their own backs, and prevent parents going:"I was only 5mins late but they let my child out unsupervised and he walked home alone and anything could have happened etc etc etc"

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:13

Dedodee · 19/05/2023 10:59

That’s ridiculous. I often sent ds to pick up dd. She was 8 and he was 15.

The school may say this, but in your shoes, I would have sent DS, and if they refused to release her phone them and tell them they need to drop her home then. Or keep her overnight and feed her.
Schools say these things, but they can only enforce them if you let them.

JustanothermagicMonday1 · 19/05/2023 11:13

If you are rich, educated, privileged, sure - you can take that position. You have money, you have a clean house, your child is well looked after and fed, how dare they tell you what to do?

However, if you are vulnerable and you go against the school’s advice, then you might worry about Social Services referrals and the like?

Dumbphone · 19/05/2023 11:12

Ponoka7 · 19/05/2023 11:09

They've got to keep a primary aged child, if that is the school policy. A school has to have policy and procedures documents which is approved by the LEA. All organisations do. That includes safeguarding and what happens if a parent doesn't physically turn up. I'm surprised that Teachers haven't jumped on this thread and explained this. There's greater coverage about children under 12, it extends to supermarket security guards, if primary aged children are about to leave the store. Very few staff members would make this decision, they are personally responsible. There was a teacher not long ago sacked and put on the barred list.
It would take a meeting with the Head and safeguarding lead to override school policy. Then the decision can be made if that school is an appropriate setting for that family.

So are you saying if I insist on walking home in yr5 the school will withdraw the place?

Ponoka7 · 19/05/2023 11:12

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:08

What would they actually do though? They might threaten this, but they can't keep the kid hostage. Amd Social Services won't give a shit. So just stand up to them. They don't get how to decide how you parent your child.

Schools can oversee a CP to level two and have family support involved. SS isn't needed, as such. My DD was allowed to leave school and walk with other children. There were lollipop crossings, because my youngest was getting dropped off by SN transport and I couldn't be in two places at once. But there has to be good reason. As there does why young children are left alone.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/05/2023 11:11

I want to be that parent, any ideas how I can challenge this without my child getting caught up in a storm and having to wait for ages with upset teachers/ss referrals?

Just tell them that you are happy your child is able to make his own way home and therefore you expect them to facilitate this. Don’t ask, don’t explain, you’re the child’s parent and have the right (and the responsibility) to make those decisions. Social services isn’t going to be interested in a capable 10 year old walking home from school. Ask them to give you the legal basis for refusing to release him against his parents wishes. They won’t be able to do that because there isn’t one.

Beginningless · 19/05/2023 11:11

I agree OP and think it is helpful to point out to people in general that public agencies have a lot of control over our lives and that they make mistakes. I’m not saying they are in respect of this issue, but there are many examples of terrible policies blindly followed by schools and other bodies. If more people understood their rights and had more agency, these poor decisions would be more easily challenged. The power should not be in so few hands.

See also my personal bugbear, pregnant women saying/being told ‘I’m not allowed to go beyond x weeks’. It may well be that following that advice is the best for baby but the whole language of being ‘allowed’ is wrong. It’s your body and your baby. Let’s discuss options and take advice like a grown up.

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:09

@Zodfa I agree that for many children school is less safe than the walk home.

Ponoka7 · 19/05/2023 11:09

YouWonJayne · 19/05/2023 09:40

It’s unlikely they’d keep a child when a parent has got in touch to say “just get them to walk home”.

They've got to keep a primary aged child, if that is the school policy. A school has to have policy and procedures documents which is approved by the LEA. All organisations do. That includes safeguarding and what happens if a parent doesn't physically turn up. I'm surprised that Teachers haven't jumped on this thread and explained this. There's greater coverage about children under 12, it extends to supermarket security guards, if primary aged children are about to leave the store. Very few staff members would make this decision, they are personally responsible. There was a teacher not long ago sacked and put on the barred list.
It would take a meeting with the Head and safeguarding lead to override school policy. Then the decision can be made if that school is an appropriate setting for that family.

callingeveryone · 19/05/2023 11:08

febrezeme · 19/05/2023 09:27

Beg to differ.....but my school won't release pupils from the classroom below a certain age group unless a parent/guardian/childcare provider is there to collect them

Might get away with mornings as they can just walk straight in but not home time

What would they actually do though? They might threaten this, but they can't keep the kid hostage. Amd Social Services won't give a shit. So just stand up to them. They don't get how to decide how you parent your child.

silverfullmoon · 19/05/2023 11:08

RoseBucket · 19/05/2023 09:35

It’s not false imprisonment, don’t be daft.

The school are acting in loco parentis. A child can walk home against guidance of the school absolutely, however if they feel that child is at risk they can equally engage social services. If the parent is happy with their decision they can equally push that decision.

This. I dont think anyone is saying the school have the legal right to do this, just that its a rule to keep kids safe.

Whats wrong with that? I was almost dragged into a car by some man when I was 10 and walking home alone. It was horrible and upset me for ages after

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/05/2023 11:08

I’ve been looking in vain for our school’s policy and can only find one about children up to year 2 being handed over at the classroom door on drop off. Nothing about going home. General opinion with parents seems to be the school ‘allows’ it from year 5, but I hope that the lack of policy on the website means it isn’t a hard and fast rule.

I totally agree that schools have a safeguarding responsibility, but I think that a previous poster already said that good safeguarding isn’t applying blanket rules to all regardless of circumstances. We live in a rural village. Some children live next door to the school, or opposite on a housing estate. Some live within walking distance but down National speed limit roads with no pavement. I really hope that the school wouldn’t apply the same blunt ‘from year 5 only’ rule to all. Apart from anything else, my child is almost a year older than some of the other children in his class!