Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you the school does not decide when your child can walk home alone

383 replies

Itisuptoyou · 19/05/2023 09:25

I keep seeing this on threads and I don’t want to derail what the thread is about.

But the school cannot decide this. You do as parent. It may be you are broadly in agreement with the school and I am but this is your choice and not the schools.

It irrationally annoys me when people claim ‘the schools don’t allow …’ Not up to the school!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Stewball01 · 03/06/2023 14:44

I'm a great worrier. Knowing (thinking) that my daughter walked home from school with her older brother, and phoned me at work when she arrived, I worried less. And they used to come home with a crowd if noisy children.

BluebellBlueballs · 21/05/2023 10:32

Picking up child 1 and child 2, I said my 10 year old (year 5) was walking home himself as I couldn't take a half hour out of work.

Headteacher tried to stop me but I stuck to my guns. Then the other parents started copying me. Nothing she could do about it.

BluebellBlueballs · 21/05/2023 10:30

During the pandemic times when I was supposed to wait 20 minutes between pivk

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 21/05/2023 10:28

Dumbphone · 21/05/2023 09:47

This - we need a conversation to happen sensibly. Schools are overwhelmed, parents unempowered.

It also turns everything into a battle.

Parents and schools are being set up to constantly feel undermined or antagonised by the other. Rather than as part of a team each with jobs to do in the child’s life.

Dumbphone · 21/05/2023 09:47

RosaGallica · 20/05/2023 12:04

It sounds op as if, like me, you are a bit concerned about how much power schools have over children, relative to parents, now.

The school staff are also concerned from the other direction, that they have too much responsibility now.

It seems to me there is scope for discussion and improvement, but such details haven’t been high on public agendas for a long time.

This - we need a conversation to happen sensibly. Schools are overwhelmed, parents unempowered.

Whatwouldscullydo · 21/05/2023 09:21

shammalammadingdong · 20/05/2023 19:05

Its not incorrect. Parents don't have to care about the policies of the school, is the point.

OP, I'm often agog at what I read on here...FINES for taking your kid out of school for a day? WTF? Not in my country. Needing permission from the school for a family funeral or wedding? Insanity. School telling you what age they can walk home at....I think fucking NOT.

The UK appears to have handed parenting decisions to schools wholesale. Ironic when your schools are doing a worse job all the time, you keep giving them more power.

So weird.

Indo worry about the amount of parenting we seem to be happy to outsource to schools. I mean its all very well when it works for you. Your kids have to havw schools means or the lunch box policy means you dont have make lunches or you dont have to explain why they can't have the same chocolate bar as Sammy. But when your kid has to get wet feet in flimsy shoes or cant possibly do something normal like walk home at an age where many children in many other places have already been doing it fir years it bites you on the arse.

The amount of power we let schools have over our children is beyond a joke. 14/15 year olds are old enough to baby sit. Like fuck should they not be able to grab their sister and walk 50 metres to their house. Who do they think they are.

SStarlet · 21/05/2023 09:19

It seems to me with some recent experiences that parenting and indeed schooling is getting increasingly polarised. Schools have got a lot of pressure from outside to ensure they're operating appropriately - OFSTED deeming you have safeguarding issues can lead to requires improvement grading in a flash I hear. Understandably I think schools will look to protect themselves, hopefully in most cases without alienating their parents. Same goes for attendance, schools are under huge pressure from LA and government because so many children are not attending school (a whole range of reasons for this and many threads will have discussed this), so parents are getting daft responses from school (like refusing a funeral) - the whole thing is broken.
Our school had a safeguarding incident where a year 1 child took it upon themselves to leave the playground on their own and walked home, crossing a number of busy roads, while the parent was still in the playground waiting for them. Consequently school then overhauled the process for children leaving and arriving on the premises - adults on the gates at start and end of school to monitor anyone arriving/leaving alone, Adults on the classroom door who have to dismiss the child to a waiting adult, who is listed with school at start of the year. If they're going home with someone different school has to be notified.
Year 5 and 6 are allowed to be independent travellers - parents give permission at the start of the year that their child can be dismissed at the end of the day or arrive at school on their own.
I am sure our school would be supportive if I someone needed a variation to these ways of operating. I think it's easier to be flexible by exception, rather than firmer by exception. I can imagine there could be instances of children with challenging parental/family situations where you would not want the child to be picked up by others, even if known to the child.
There's a fine line between being respectful and responsible of boundaries and rules and teaching our kids that they can't just do whatever they like (the rules don't apply to them) and making sure you've got critical thinkers who can make good decisions.

EasterBreak · 21/05/2023 09:10

Completely agree. Our school had always made you think it wasn't allowed. Then a year 5 in my childs class starting collecting their year 1 sibling to walk home and the mum had to basically demand they let the kids leave.

hungrypanda2008 · 21/05/2023 09:04

I think you have may have bigger annoyances with your school and therefore it might be better looking for one that fits you better. For most teachers whether they agreed or not, there are bigger issues. And as a parent who works full time, letting my child walk home would have saved £1000s over the years but I get the school stance on it. A school doing this is only worried about repercussions if something happens to a child. Apart from the concern about what could happen, there are some parents that would sue a school for less. A school where its staff are not paid past 3/3:30 apart from
a scheduled meeting, are not holding onto kids for the fun of it - it’s a major inconvenience. So why don’t you ask your head why the rule is in place and suggest otherwise if you feel the answer isn’t good enough. I never know why a few teachers are so opinionated against their school and fellow colleagues and will choose to go outside the organisation to complain rather than sort things out properly or move

Alizzle · 21/05/2023 00:53

SomePosters · 19/05/2023 09:32

You can fight against basic safeguarding for your kids, of course, but don’t be surprised when that means the school are concerned about your ability to safe guard your kids.

I was sexually assaulted walking home from school. Targeted by someone who saw I walked alone and followed me to a place with no witnesses.

Just this week another kid was killed by a car walking home from
school.

My high school was regularly targeted by flashers but by that age we were big enough to run away and confident enough to point and laugh rather than be intimidated.

Can you tell me exactly what you have taught your less than 10yo to do if they find themselves in any of the above situations?

Do you think that under the stress of a real situation they would remember with no support?

Agree, this totally. Yes it may be "just down the road" but your child is walking the same route, the same time every day, is easily over powered and has no experience to get themselves out of that situation. I have a very mature 10 year old, I'd leave him at home when I pop to the shops but walking to school alone? Nope. If he had a mate maybe nearby to walk with but he doesn't.

LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 23:10

@Cottagecheeseisnotcheese are you OK?

RockyReef · 20/05/2023 20:41

At my youngest children's primary school the school rules are that only year 6s are allowed to walk home alone, and that has to be authorised by a parent or guardian at the start of the year. Yes of course i'm sure if a you get child's parents kicked up a stink then there's nothing the school can do to stop the child being allowed to walk home alone, but really why send your child to a school where you don't agree with the rules? Their school is a tiny rural primary and no pavements around, few cars but sometimes idiots driving too fast on the country lanes. I was happy to comply with the school rules as they have clearly thought carefully about them. At my eldest's private secondary they still ask at the start of the year who will be walking to catch a train or cycling home and who will be being picked up by parents in cars. Again it's rural and most are collected. These are clever children, and most are very capable of looking after themselves on a school journey but the school just want to know how they will be travelling so they can be aware I suppose. Again, I knew the rules before he joined so that's fine by me.

MyNDfamily · 20/05/2023 20:04

YouWonJayne · 19/05/2023 09:32

I agree

i don’t live near enough to my kids school for them to walk but DD is in Year 5 and one of her friends literally lives round the corner. She ‘isn’t allowed’ to walk home alone and her parents have to juggle pick ups.

Im amazed at how much people allow schools to parent their children. Asking to take them out for grandparents funerals etc. I just TOLD my kids school I’d be collecting them at a certain time for their great grandads funeral and they kicked up a massive fuss about ‘cANt allow that’ and ‘unauthorised absence’. I just said I’m coming at 1pm have them ready, this is far more important than anything school has on and it’s my decision. They did - and I’m furious that control freak Headteachers think they can behave this way.

My friend chose to homeschool after COVID when she had a successful experience in lockdown and her children were much happier than they were at their school where they were bullied. The total fuss she had to go through, the ‘missing in education’ team got in touch and all sorts. She had a lot of pressure to send them back in. It’s scary and too many people are willing to hand over their liberties because heaven forbid you’re ‘that parent’.

I totally agree with you.

How dare they try to stop you from taking your own children to a family members funeral. Wtaf is that

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 20/05/2023 19:14

@LovelyIssues I agree being a dickhead is a bad move but headteachers can be dickheads too by digging their heels in over a policy which is actually causing distress, take a simple example John is in Y4 ( as it's now May almost y5 when he'd be allowed to walk home anyway) his mother has broken her leg and is housebound, his father is a truck driver and works away all week. john's family live relatively close on what would noramlly be called a very safe walking route. John's mother rings School. I am unable to collect John or bring him to school as I've broken my leg, unfortunately his Dad works away so I am informing you he will be arrving on his own and leaving on his own, until my leg heals which will be the end of July at the earliest. I have no concerns about John walking home or to school, he frequently walks from our house to his friends or the shop which is a bit further. I can't afford to put him in after school care as i'm only on SSP and even then I still can't collect him. lots of children from the school walk this way so he won't be completely alone. I am sure you understand that this is necessary and reasonable. I do not think the school could ultimately refuse this request as if Johns mother involved Social services herself they would find it reasonable too. You could not remove John's school place for this reason the LA would not back you up and it is not a safeguarding risk it's just a policy and like all policies it should be reviewed and account taken of circumstances and concluded that in this case John's mother request is reasonable and though against general school policy it would be on this occasion the right thing to do to help John and his family to agree the request.

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 19:13

For the most part I think that people tend to go by what the majority do, which isn’t a bad thing. As I’ve said, I personally think ten is about right, but I do think what is important is people recognise this is their choice and not the schools.

I am a bit surprised (and I mean that genuinely, not in a PA MN ‘surprised’ way) that so many people believe that the school do have this right - ‘because we said so!’

I don’t think it’s to do with a litigation culture really. In the event of something horrible happening I don’t think many people would seek to apportion blame on the school. I think it’s more that schools will say something like ‘this is our policy’ and no one thinks ‘hang on!’

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/05/2023 19:08

The UK appears to have handed parenting decisions to schools wholesale.

Scottish schools don’t have fines, and it’s very common for children to walk home.

English schools don’t represent the Uk as a whole.

shammalammadingdong · 20/05/2023 19:05

LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 18:01

I'm sorry but that is incorrect. I have worked in 2 different schools who both have the policy a child will not be released without a parent/Carer etc until year 6.

Its not incorrect. Parents don't have to care about the policies of the school, is the point.

OP, I'm often agog at what I read on here...FINES for taking your kid out of school for a day? WTF? Not in my country. Needing permission from the school for a family funeral or wedding? Insanity. School telling you what age they can walk home at....I think fucking NOT.

The UK appears to have handed parenting decisions to schools wholesale. Ironic when your schools are doing a worse job all the time, you keep giving them more power.

So weird.

wellstopdoingitthen · 20/05/2023 19:02

At my dc school the Y5&6 children are allowed to leave on their own at the end of the day with parental permission. If they take younger siblings the parent has to write a letter to explicitly say that they accept responsibility for the children's leaving the school site.

I don't believe it's the power struggle some people think it is, schools have a duty of care for the children in their care.

I've heard of some parents contacting the school because little Billy was called names on the bus home. You can't have it both ways.

shammalammadingdong · 20/05/2023 19:02

Needmorelego · 19/05/2023 09:34

If that's the rule of the school then that's the rule.
The same if the rule is your child has to be there by 8.50 am and be wearing a red sweatshirt.
Don't like the rules either don't send your child to that school or just suck it up.

I can't bear people that think like this. "rules are rules and that is that and you will follow them".....it's pathetic. You never got past the thinking of a 9 year old.

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 18:44

@LovelyIssues this was the point of the thread, informative.

It does go to show how ingrained that assumption is that ‘the school won’t allow’ when it’s not a decision the school can or should be making. Schools cannot set policies that tell parents how to parent and say find another school if they refuse.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/05/2023 18:36

LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 18:33

@YetMoreNewBeginnings wow those schools are very soft compared to the ones I've worked at. Our policy is Our policy. Parents know it before enrolling their child.

Not soft. They just knew when challenged and taking advice from SS they didn’t have a leg to stand on.

Schools, other than private ones perhaps, will generally accept when they’ve overstepped and revise policies when needed. Decent HT’s will in my experience.

And this is definitely one that they mostly realise isn’t their call so once they stop getting away with pretending it is they just accept it.

LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 18:33

@YetMoreNewBeginnings wow those schools are very soft compared to the ones I've worked at. Our policy is Our policy. Parents know it before enrolling their child.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/05/2023 18:32

LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 18:01

I'm sorry but that is incorrect. I have worked in 2 different schools who both have the policy a child will not be released without a parent/Carer etc until year 6.

And in at least 6 schools I’ve worked in that policy has had to be changed when parents have challenged it…

They only stand because parents accept it.

LovelyIssues · 20/05/2023 18:29

@Itisuptoyou our response would be quite simple. This is the school policy. This is the school your child attends. Follow the policies or find a new school. We still wouldn't let the child go home alone under year 6. Simple and very much enforceable

Itisuptoyou · 20/05/2023 18:06

So this is my point @LovelyIssues , it is their policy, it is not enforceable. The schools policy does not override the wishes of the parent(s).

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread