Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't kids walk to school anymore

268 replies

Failingatthemoment · 19/05/2023 08:09

I'm obviously old. BUT, when I went to school the majority of kids walked to school on their own from around the ages of 7/8. Now it only seems that ( some) secondary school kids do this.

OP posts:
prooses · 19/05/2023 10:14

we live over a mile and there are so many busy roads. Not to mention my son isn't comfortable doing it himself and I would not be comfortable letting him do it himself. Instinctively we know it's not the right time (age 10 y5).

I don't see it as a bad thing, each child is different, you can't judge a parent for not joining in sending their child off at the first opportunity they get. Parents instinct always best.

CadburyDream · 19/05/2023 10:14

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/05/2023 10:12

Well, if the school wants to raise a safeguarding issue with social services I guess that’s their prerogative but I doubt they’d get far, assuming the child wasn’t ridiculously young. The fact that different schools have different rules proves this. Ours, for example, says children have to be handed over at the classroom door up to and including year 2. Others on here have said year 5, or even 6. There clearly isn’t one single rule, and unless the child was turning up at school aged 4 having crossed a dual carriageway alone, I seriously doubt social services would be interested.

I don’t care whether they will be interested or not, like someone said not every kid gets the local school we get the bus to ours and I’m not sending my children on the bus alone. Our school say year 6 and I think that’s the right age.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/05/2023 10:12

CadburyDream · 19/05/2023 10:07

Safeguarding issue and yes at our school due to the layout the reception absolutely will see who arrives alone.

Well, if the school wants to raise a safeguarding issue with social services I guess that’s their prerogative but I doubt they’d get far, assuming the child wasn’t ridiculously young. The fact that different schools have different rules proves this. Ours, for example, says children have to be handed over at the classroom door up to and including year 2. Others on here have said year 5, or even 6. There clearly isn’t one single rule, and unless the child was turning up at school aged 4 having crossed a dual carriageway alone, I seriously doubt social services would be interested.

Mrsjayy · 19/05/2023 10:10

I know our local primary have always had playground attendants in the morning so they see who comes and goes.

Mrsjayy · 19/05/2023 10:09

Not "allowing" young children to walk to school is making sure parents are being responsible for their children it is the dreaded by some on mn Safeguarding.

Flowerblooms · 19/05/2023 10:09

Not every child gets their local school. My child has been to 3 schools none were in walking distance.
I have always had to drive them to school.

CadburyDream · 19/05/2023 10:07

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/05/2023 10:05

I don’t get the whole ‘schools don’t allow it’ for walking TO school. Home, maybe, because they can refuse to release them (although I can imagine a school refusing to release an 8 year old year 3 to walk home alone and calling social services would get short shrift by social services). But TO school? What are they going to do, turn them away? Call social services to say ‘an 8 year old just walked themselves to school’?!

Safeguarding issue and yes at our school due to the layout the reception absolutely will see who arrives alone.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 19/05/2023 10:05

I don’t get the whole ‘schools don’t allow it’ for walking TO school. Home, maybe, because they can refuse to release them (although I can imagine a school refusing to release an 8 year old year 3 to walk home alone and calling social services would get short shrift by social services). But TO school? What are they going to do, turn them away? Call social services to say ‘an 8 year old just walked themselves to school’?!

IkaBaar · 19/05/2023 10:04

We live in a Scottish city and most kids walk with friends from P5. Not sure if all Scottish schools do it, but ours tracks how they travel to school and promotes active travel. My older one walked with friends from the beginning of P5 so just turned 9.

There seems a definite difference between England and Scotland.

SimonsCow · 19/05/2023 09:48

7/8 seems way too young to be walking to school alone. DD did it at 10/11 - a 15 minute walk. One road crossing (with lollipop ladies).

ActDottie · 19/05/2023 09:47

Secondary school mine will be walking.
Primary school I will walk them up to year 6.

CaveCanem · 19/05/2023 09:46

Most local people walk to our local primary school with their children. The school only allows pupils to walk alone from year 6 though and written permission has to be given by the parents first.

My dc walked on their own from year 6, but our house is only a three minute walk from the school gates.

For secondary, my eldest was on SN transport which took an hour to take him to the other side of the nearest city.

Middle dc walked until they became physically disabled and I was given permission to drive them and park on the school site and dd currently walks.

For some reason there seems to be far more parents driving the local secondary school pupils every day than there were at primary. For us it’s a 20/25 minute walk along a designated ‘safe route’ but my neighbour still drives their dc, despite them being super sporty and fit. The driving standards are appalling and parking ridiculously inconsiderate and entitled, which makes it more dangerous for all the pupils. I hated having to drive onto the school site in the morning and afternoon, first I had to try and avoid all the dreadful school-run parking/driving, then somehow navigate the school site through crowds of oblivious teenagers all staring at their phones or pushing each other about to reach the disabled parking spot. I have no idea why anyone who didn’t have to would want to drive on the school run.

Dd wants to walk and refused lifts even when she had a foot injury, because she meets all her friends along the way and they all walk together.

5foot5 · 19/05/2023 09:45

My DD walked to school by herself from Y6, before then I walked with her.

TBH I would have been quite happy for her to take herself from Y5 but by then I was working a bit further away so if she left the house when I did she would have got to school about 8:40 and they had a rule that only Y6 were allowed in the classroom unsupervised before the bell went, so she would have been hanging about outside. Hence, for that year, I paid for her to go to breakfast club and dropped her on my way to work.

Namechange828492 · 19/05/2023 09:41

Yes there's a lot of dangerous drivers, i was crossing the high st and carrying DD plus her scooter, i wasnt going fast enough so a driver sped up (it's a 20mph london high st) and drove at me

LauraPausini · 19/05/2023 09:38

We walk to and from school every day (just under a mile away).

Our school doesn't allow children to go walk unaccompanied until year 6.

There is a huge dangerous junction (essentially 3 sets of pedestrian crossings to cross the road to the school) and queuing traffic is oblivious as to when the signal is showing for pedestrians to cross so pedestrians end up weaving through cars moving over the crossing - driver behaviour is appalling and it is an accident waiting to happen. None of this traffic is school traffic as there is no parking for the school so everyone is on foot!

We teach our kids to be road safe but I see dangerous driver behaviour all the time with no consideration for pedestrians - that has definitely changed since I was a child walking to school.

ShimmeringShirts · 19/05/2023 09:34

More kids walk to our primary and academy than drive/take public transport there. For the ones that are driven or take transport it’s because they’re either too far to walk or there are no safe paths from their home to the school. Either way not sure why you’re bothered how kids get to school, surely the fact they’re going to school is more important than their method of transport.

Somanycats · 19/05/2023 09:34

When I was eight I walked to the bus stop with my six year old brother, took a two mile bus trip, got off and walked 10 mins to school. Public bus, not a school bus. It was absolutely fine. If I'm honest, my super confident ds could also have done this, but school wouldn't allow it. I actually don't even recognize the timid nature of lots of kids today. I'm 60. A generation before that my Dad was wandering east end bomb sites at the same age and living between his parents and his aunts houses, meaning none of them had much idea where he was. He's 86. Thing's change.

Badbudgeter · 19/05/2023 09:33

P5 for us , Scotland so about 10. I think children generally have less freedom nowadays. I’m rural and I suspect People will judge as my kids have quite a lot of it. I’m happy to padlock the bottom gate and let them ride bikes up and down, there’s a trampoline/ ninja line/ swings/ climbing tree/ hammock if you need to chill. I’ll go down and supervise if there’s a campfire but otherwise they play , build dens, gather sticks, draw, find interesting stuff in nature.

Sometimes they take a break for toasted crumpets with lashings of butter because I was a big fan of the famous five as a girl.

Red0 · 19/05/2023 09:31

My just turned 8 yr old walks the 20 mins to school, and I walk with her

Wicksytricksy · 19/05/2023 09:30

We walk pretty much every day, school is about half a mile away but nursery is in the opposite direction, I like the walk, DD usually scoots, she's only in reception though so I've got years of this to come!

The only exception is if DH is away and it's my office day so DD has to go to breakfast club. It takes 40 minutes to walk DS to nursery in one direction, then take DS to school (or vice versa) then for me to walk home - I am not hustling the kids out of the door at 7.25am at the morning when I could do the same trip in 10 minutes in the car and be on my way to work. I imagine plenty of parents are in a situation where they are then rushing off to work or appointments.

35965a · 19/05/2023 09:28

It really does depend where you live. I live in the outskirts of a city - not even a ‘bad’ area and there’s no way I’d let my children walk alone until year 6/7. There are so many more cars on the road now, so many more people around, there’s knife crime. Schools won’t allow it until year 6 here anyway. For us it’s nearly a half an hour walk and crossing the road, even at crossings with lights, is stressful.

RitaCrudgington · 19/05/2023 09:28

I think we as a society have reduced our tolerance of possibly fatal risks to children. Child road deaths have more than halved since the turn of the century because our calculation of the risk/benefit tradeoff has changed.

The number of child deaths and serious injuries on the road has decreased by over 90% since 1979 when I was in primary school. That's more than ten thousand children each year who don't get killed or seriously injured thanks to our nannying cotton-wool mentality.

Child road casualties peak at age 11/12 when they start walking to school by themselves.

Jonei · 19/05/2023 09:27

It depends where you are. Where I live, very young children walk to the local school independently. Age 6 plus. I must admit I was a bit shocked when I first saw it many years ago, but they do seem to be pretty safe / street wise. 🤷‍♀️ Other schools a bit further away are either year 5 or 6 before the school will let them go.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 19/05/2023 09:27

But once at secondary school bus picks them up outside the Door

Namechange828492 · 19/05/2023 09:25

I walked with my mum in the 90s at primary level so don't think it's a new thing not walking alone. School was close too.

I drive as it's 3 miles each way but wish I could walk as it's so much more pleasant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread