Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think of suing LA for SEN school fees when they eventually give DC an ECHP?

109 replies

ehcpnightmares · 18/05/2023 23:53

DC 13 in state school which is not going well at all
He definitely meets criteria for EHCP but LA refusing to assess (we have appealed)
We can pay school fees for a couple of years (if we can find one that fits him with a place)
Hopefully in the future LA will pay school fees, but wondering if we'd be able to reclaim the fees for the next year, given they had no good reason to delay ECHNA?

OP posts:
OneTwoThreeFourFiveOnceI · 19/05/2023 17:18

The thing is that the decision about whether to assess is a legal judgement and the LA is entirely allowed to deem that DC has not meet the legal test. You would presumably need to prove that the LA acted illegally in how it reached that conclusion via JR. And also that what you child requires is the school of your choice despite the statutory assessment process having not taken place at the time you started incurring the fees. The SENCO saying that the school cannot meet needs doesn't mean that a specialist school is required, versus say other less expensive special educational provision.

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 17:03

@Tygertiger i refuse to do EHE - that literally involves legally signing away any responsibility that the LA to provide education, health and social care etc. I'm sure that's exactly what LA want. Anyway, it's important for DS to build relationships outside family, being home alone will not help.

There are other kinds of alternative education provision that the LA can offer. I'm chasing those too. Current setting is doing DS more harm that good and I have that in writing from several professionals involved.

OP posts:
Irritateandunreasonable · 19/05/2023 17:00

Sue them? Why would any court give you the money? That would just give the green light to any other parent wanting to do the same.

Also, you can’t go to a specialist school without an EHCP in place first.

You’ll probably just have to wait your turn like everyone else I’m afraid. I know it’s so shit, try and look for support outside school and keep advocating for your DC. Sorry this is hard for you.

Good luck.

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 16:57

@Spendonsend thanks for that suggestion of doing a second ehcp request. i had not considered that. I am expecting a new OT report and some other new info. I guess there's nothing to stop me doing a new request while the last one sits in the appeal queue

OP posts:
ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 16:52

we're in London and there are at least a couple of special schools that cater for children capable of passing GCSEs/BTECx but with SEND issues that mean they can't succeed in mainstream schools. I'm sure there's loads of competition for spaces but we can at least try.

I have found two schools who, while most of their pupils have EHCP's, they could allow a privately funded place too. Yes it is horribly expensive.

@gogohmm i am aware that chances are slim, but feel like i have to aim for the best. Did your DD learn well in isolation without a teacher? I'm not sure DS would manage it. My actual preference would be for him to be in a special state school and there's an ideal one really quite close. You can't access those at all without an EHCP though.

@Sirzy from what i hear mediation rarely goes that well. I am still trying to engage with the LA now while we wait for the appeal to be processed but its really hard getting a response from them.

OP posts:
YouHeardTheRumoursFromInes · 19/05/2023 11:00

OP : raise merry hell. Complain complain complain. They automatically refuse to assess everyone. We went mad when we got that stupid letter and didn't let it go. We are now getting DS assessed without even going to the tribunal; the LA agreed to overturn it after we re- sent a shedload of evidence and told them they were acting unlawfully by ignoring the clear needs of our child. Ring, email, ring, email. Demand they explain their decision (they can't). Complaining works and keep doing it!!

caringcarer · 19/05/2023 10:55

If you have some money consider getting a SN tutor. We found an excellent one who managed to teach DC more in 3 hours each week than he learned in the entire week of school. Because he was quiet and well behaved he got overlooked and all resources seemed to go on badly behaved violent and aggressive children who on were allocated a 1-1 helper to stop them attacking other children.

lanadelgrey · 19/05/2023 10:53

Go to all the SeND charities and first thing to know is that the current school/LA have to do everything they can to avoid paying for any specialist provision. Ignore posters who argue that you are taking resources. SEND money is supposed to be ringfenced and handed down from central government.
We didn’t get money back except for a week or so to cover from start of a half term to the day the EHC plan was actually signed off - LA tried not to pay that but too but relented after an argument ie me threatening to push for judicial review and that court would cost more.
We got a small amount of compensation from LGO but equivalent of paying for private Ed psych, so not much in scheme of things.
It was expensive but worth it as DD had been out of school for a year and when LA’s Ed psych visited she basically said she had no evidence to counter that placement was appropriate and LA had nothing equivalent to offer.
Be prepared to fight incredibly hard, get very stressed and spend some money - assessments, courses, time off work - but my DD is now about to sit her finals at uni so it is very much worth it. My main aim was for her to be able to function independently and be able to get a job, but the right school did an amazing amount

caringcarer · 19/05/2023 10:52

Even if you get the EHCP it does not mean you will get a SN school. They might just make some provision in the school the child is already in unless very severe. My Foster son went to a SN school and the children had to have moderate to sever learning disabilities eg IQ under 75 to attend.

ThomasWasTortured · 19/05/2023 10:45

When you say “not going well” what do you mean? If you mean DC isn’t able to attend school full time the LA must provide alternative arrangements to ensure DC receives a suitable, full time education under s.19 of the Education Act 1996. Often this isn’t forthcoming but you can force the LA’s hand, via judicial review if necessary.

Be careful with SENDIASS, some are good, but too many repeat the LA’s unlawful policies.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/05/2023 10:44

Unfortunately councils prefer to spend on fighting against giving children the provision they are legally entitled to over spending it on properly educating our children.

https://www.specialneedsjungle.com/70million-council-costs-parents-send-tribunal/

I've had 2 successful LSCGO claims for failure to meet legal obligations but the 'compensation' in no way pays for the real loss in terms of education.

You are in the long haul OP. Many children get no education for long periods because their kids reach the point they can't attend school and STILL the LAs refuse to assess or refuse to award EHCPs and where they do they are inadequate.

The £70 million council costs of fighting - and losing - against parents at the SEND Tribunal - Special Needs Jungle

The shocking new SEND Tribunal figures are out and we have also analysed just how much it costs LAs to take parents to an appeal

https://www.specialneedsjungle.com/70million-council-costs-parents-send-tribunal

FrownedUpon · 19/05/2023 10:33

Good luck with that. You’re being ridiculous.

HecticHedgehog · 19/05/2023 10:31

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 00:37

@ElfDragon the SENCO has said in meetings that the school don't have the specialist skills and my son's education is not progressing. What other evidence do LA need?

None. Get this in writing if it's not already and appeal to tribunal.

Get on the Ipsea website and clue yourself up. You're going to need too unfortunately :(

HecticHedgehog · 19/05/2023 10:29

Sadly, a senco saying this will sadly count for very little (I am a senco) and they will want huge amounts of evidence before doing anything at all. Good luck with it though. Have you sought advice from IPSEA?

Don't underestimate how valuable a sencos views are. The
LA may ignore them but if you support a parent to appeal a tribunal absolutely will not. We got full time 1-1 in an EHCP after a senco told a judge that's what she needed. I bet the LA were livid but hey ho.

HecticHedgehog · 19/05/2023 10:26

I doubt that would work and I doubt the LGO,would touch it either. Are you appealing the refusal to assess? That's the legal process you need to follow.

Adarajames · 19/05/2023 10:19

I was under the impression that parents could start the process to get an ehcp, it didn’t have to be the school, is that not the case?

a special school place can be far more expensive than Eton! Day places can be as much as £80,000 a year; residential £200,000 a year, so would be a massive commitment op ok

Spendonsend · 19/05/2023 08:26

I am very sympathetic to your desire.
But in reality, you will have limited funds and limited energy to 'fight' so think carefully if you want your gighting energy to go on this and not something else.

Just as an aside, you dont have to appeal. We got turned down, then submitted the request again with new evidence, literally two weeks later and it was approved. I wasnt appealing there previous decision i was asking them to make a new decusion based on new stuff.

Lilacsbloominspring · 19/05/2023 08:19

@midgemadgemodge i think that was a rhetorical question Hmm maybe not the best thread for statements like that.

I hope you can resolve it, Op.

x2boys · 19/05/2023 08:17

Sheselectric88 · 19/05/2023 08:05

I don’t have anything to add about the process or anything but I feel I need to say that LA do have the money. It would not be coming from other children. I previously had a job that included some work with LA budgets and let me tell you the amount of money they waste is eye watering. The amount of money passed around just to be wasted, used on unnecessary projects and the waste on wages of people who literally have some made up title and do absolutely nothing would make your eyes pop out. We think the LA are counting the copper but trust me they are not. Google the wages of the top dogs in your LA. Having worked in many I can honestly say I have not come across a single one that was worth that wage. I couldn’t name what any of them actually do apart from spend days in meetings that lead to nowhere.
Sorry op I know it’s unhelpful but it just pisses me off so much.

Doesn't surprise me I worked for the NHS,for years and there was a huge amount of waste there too.

Tygertiger · 19/05/2023 08:15

I work in an LA (not in SEN, but I have a lot of involvement with them). Special schools generally don’t admit without an EHCP. And then, maintained special schools charge around £50k a year, and independent ones typically around £80k. I think without an EHCP you might need to look at EHE with alternative provision as part of your child’s plan, plus tuition.

x2boys · 19/05/2023 08:13

Sweetpeel · 19/05/2023 07:47

Why should it be such an exhausting, expensive fight to get your kids needs met? This country is so barbaric.

Well it's a bit more complex than that SEN private specialist school,s can cost,upwards of £100,000/ year depending on 'the needs of the child and even then placement,s break down LEA ,will.always go for the least expensive option ,even if it's not the best option for he child .

ArdeteiMasazxu · 19/05/2023 08:08

No you will not be able to claim anything back because you will never be able to prove what "would have happened" if you stuck with state provision.

The private SEN-specialist schools are full too, and you may not have much luck getting a self-funded place. However, in the event that both a place exists and LA funding exists for a place at the school, there will already be half a dozen kids who have already got their EHCPs having been delayed and mucked about for just as long as your child but eventually got through the process, who clearly and demonstrably need that place and who have been out of education for a year or 2 waiting for a place to be available. They will have to identify the child most in-need and it is unlikely to be your child.

It's definitely really bad how much effort it takes to get a child's educational needs met. I am not saying it's a good system. But the kids further ahead in line than your child have already been through the same shitty process. The fact that your child's needs aren't being recognised or met is not evidence that those other kids are receiving any kind of favouritism.

A podcast I listened to recently described working to support children with mental health and additional needs as being in a small rowing boat in a sea full of crying children who are all struggling to stay afloat. Every single one of them needs to be pulled out and looked after properly but you are one boat, you can help maybe 3 kids at a time. So you grab the ones that are closest to slipping under and drowning and leave the rest struggling, get those 3 ashore and then come back and see which of the struggling kids are closest to drowning. It's relentless and heartbreaking but that's all you can do.

Your child is lucky - they have you. You clearly have some resources and the strength to champion your child's needs.

Spend some of your money on a private Educational Psychologist assessment so you have a better idea of what your child needs. Do everything in your power to get those needs met. Don't expect rescue to come from the LA.

Sheselectric88 · 19/05/2023 08:05

I don’t have anything to add about the process or anything but I feel I need to say that LA do have the money. It would not be coming from other children. I previously had a job that included some work with LA budgets and let me tell you the amount of money they waste is eye watering. The amount of money passed around just to be wasted, used on unnecessary projects and the waste on wages of people who literally have some made up title and do absolutely nothing would make your eyes pop out. We think the LA are counting the copper but trust me they are not. Google the wages of the top dogs in your LA. Having worked in many I can honestly say I have not come across a single one that was worth that wage. I couldn’t name what any of them actually do apart from spend days in meetings that lead to nowhere.
Sorry op I know it’s unhelpful but it just pisses me off so much.

Sirzy · 19/05/2023 08:05

The whole system is rubbish but as it’s often hard enough to get an independent specialist school placement agreed with an ehcp I don’t think you stand any chance of getting it funded retrospectively. Realistically it will be a fight to get a place funded in one at all.

did you do mediation or just get the certificate? I am currently helping a family member through the process and we where amazed that at mediation they agreed to assess