Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think of suing LA for SEN school fees when they eventually give DC an ECHP?

109 replies

ehcpnightmares · 18/05/2023 23:53

DC 13 in state school which is not going well at all
He definitely meets criteria for EHCP but LA refusing to assess (we have appealed)
We can pay school fees for a couple of years (if we can find one that fits him with a place)
Hopefully in the future LA will pay school fees, but wondering if we'd be able to reclaim the fees for the next year, given they had no good reason to delay ECHNA?

OP posts:
AlantheDog · 20/05/2023 23:52

OP:

Why haven't you mentioned an LA EP? Surely if the school doesn't feel they can meet his needs to the point they are suggesting specialist then he should be a priority for their EP time? For an ehcp to be issued, the LA needs to consider whether the needs are outside what a school could reasonably be expected to support, and whether the school has coordinated advice and support (see image).

You say his current school cannot reduce his number of GCSEs. Bollocks they can't (sorry, schools annoy me with this stuff). They choose not to because it will damage their progress 8 scores, whereas if your boy toddles off elsewhere their 10 GcSEs apiece cohort will be intact. Write to the SEN governor requesting that he be allowed a reduced GCSE timetable, dropping, say, history, MFL, RE and taking Eng Lit and Lang, combined science and maths. With access to the SEN dept to consolidate his learning in his "free" periods.

Keep up the EHCNA assessment request but don't assume it's only the LA playing silly buggers, schools are more than capable of wide -eyed disingenuousness about their legal duty.

to think of suing LA for SEN school fees when they eventually give DC an ECHP?
Hankunamatata · 20/05/2023 23:29

Is there a local state mainstream that would allow the number of subjects to be dropped? May be worth changing while appealing ehcp?

ehcpnightmares · 20/05/2023 22:31

oh, i just saw this https://chng.it/9DPWDcWVBY

Sign the Petition

Reform the SEND education in the uk

https://chng.it/9DPWDcWVBY

OP posts:
Pinkpears · 20/05/2023 21:57

We appealed for my son’s college place. He’s had a statement/EHCP since he was 4. The LA had no case, never submitted any evidence, and conceded 2 weeks before tribunal. We spent 10’s of thousands on professional reports and legal fees. Our solicitor told it was pointless trying to reclaim any of our costs from the LA. I imagine in your case the advice would be the same.

hiredandsqueak · 20/05/2023 17:51

It's really difficult and empathise with you. LA conceded the day before hearing just a fortnight ago for us, they made no case and offered no evidence but benefitted by making no provision during the ten month wait for a hearing. Although they haven't really benefitted at all as they refused the small EOTAS package I requested then conceded to one costing four times as much ten months later so will now be funding the equivalent to the independent specialist school fees dd previously attended.
Be prepared for the long haul, you may well have to appeal at each stage. You will definitely need to appeal the final EHCP issued as it won't be fit for purpose and may well name the current school that has said it can't meet needs as they do it all the time. Get the evidence, independent ed psych, SALT and OT reports are vital IME and consider a solicitor or advocate to handle Tribunal. I've used both (appealed three times now) and have recommendations if you want them.

Lougle · 20/05/2023 17:41

gogohmm · 19/05/2023 08:01

They are unlikely to pay for private school for a child who has made it to age 13 without a ehcp. Yes he needs one but to stipulate help in his existing school eg my dd had a private study space set aside in her school and work set by her teachers because she couldn't cope with the classrooms. They are never going to refund fees you have paid

Not necessarily true. DD1 was 14 when she was awarded her EHCP and independent special school place, and 15 (just) when they agreed to pay for an extra year to allow her to repeat year 10.

ElfDragon · 20/05/2023 17:39

Ah, probably a bit too far away. Had a school possibly in mind. Will PM you.

ehcpnightmares · 20/05/2023 17:19

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

ElfDragon · 20/05/2023 17:16

Whereabouts in the country are you, OP?

MummyJ12 · 20/05/2023 14:21

I’ve heard about the long wait times for a private EP, it’s indicative of the sea of additional need out there. Along with a broken and under funded system. Unfortunately though LA EPs have pressure put on them by the sound of it to be vague and non specific so provision is then limited. DS’ draft EHCP states currently in section f “embedded in education”. It means nothing and like a pp said, it’s not worth the paper it’s written on.

MummyJ12 · 20/05/2023 14:15

RSA is a Request for Statutory Assessment, it’s the form that DS’ school used when they had their arm twisted following DS’ suicide attempt and CAMHS again got involved and said in a letter copied to the school that the process should look at being started. I had to go in and fill the form out with the SENCO because they were so reluctant. They said that they were giving him all the support they could, which makes me more cross that they’re now claiming that they can meet his needs.

ehcpnightmares · 20/05/2023 14:05

@MummyJ12 situation sounds very similar but what does RSA stand for?

I think it is actually really hard to get a private Educational Psychologist report. I've yet to find one with availability anytime soon. I haven't even managed to join a waiting list.

OP posts:
MummyJ12 · 20/05/2023 13:34

Not in any way I meant to put with regards section f. Sorry! I’m so tired I can’t type a post properly nowadays!

MummyJ12 · 20/05/2023 13:32

I agree with others that it’s one long haul of many fights.
We had to fight DS’ school to put the RSA in, they said we wouldn’t be successful. We were, they assessed and we were given the go ahead for an EHCP about 4 weeks ago.
The school are now saying that they’re able to meet his needs, even though they’re clearly not as DS’ mental health is deteriorating further. CAMHS have helped as much as they can but even a letter from his psychiatrist saying that specialist provision is the only way forward. They won’t accept because it’s not from the EP and not in the remit of his mental health care team.
The EP report stated that
-He is struggling to attend and remain in lessons (because he is becoming overwhelmed as he did in the observation lesson). It is also noted that he finds the complexities of school life significantly overwhelming and anxiety producing.
-His mental health needs are having a significant impact on his ability to access the curriculum.
There is no reflection of this on his section F. It’s a complete farce. (A doodle book FFS!) Section F is a complete farce, it’s in any way specific, quantifiable or enforceable.
I’m currently fighting it at draft stage but it’s hard. I wish we had gotten a private EP report done.
SOS!SEN have been brilliant.
CAMHS have been brilliant (we’re lucky)
The LA are awful.
We’re going to end up at tribunal.

ehcpnightmares · 20/05/2023 12:53

@ArdeteiMasazxu I'm looking for a school that would do about 5 subjects at gcse/btec levels. Current school can't reduce the number of subjects and he can't keep up with them all. He could do well at 5 or 6 I think. Also looking for smaller classes or individualised tuition. There are some people in some of his classes in current school with 1:1 support but apparently they're mostly reminding the children they're supporting to sit still etc. DS needs something closer actual 1:1 tuition to make sure he's processing the content of lesson.

Also needs really specialised SALT and maybe OT too, but not ABA type training.

I am also looking at tutors at home (LA funded and otherwise) but with full blown GAD levels of anxiety, complete social withdrawal and isolation already i don't think its best for him, as an only child, long term.

I have seen a couple of schools that offer that on paper, and nice nurturing inclusive environments that would offer all that. I have seen school fees presented at a couple closer to 40-50k. It would involve an hour travel in each direction so commute not ideal. Fees are not really sustainable for us longterm, but possible in short term.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 20/05/2023 10:24

Exactly. Not all schools are made equal.

i was sure Ds would need a specialist school for secondary but when I visited all the local options (including an independent one) I realised that they wouldn’t be right for him. He is now in a reasonably small mainstream with full 1-1 and he is thriving as it’s the right setting for him with the right support

OutDamnedSpot · 20/05/2023 10:17

Excellent post @ArdeteiMasazxu This is what I meant too, but you said it much better.

OP, think very carefully about what would really work for your son and then focus on finding that, with or without the EHCP. Specialist schools aren’t necessarily what you expect them to be (ie not specialist for your son if that makes sense?) The fact that you can afford private will open more options for you, but there are also some excellent state schools that might meet his needs better than his current one.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 20/05/2023 08:00

I'd like to get a better understanding of what you are aiming for @ehcpnightmares

Near to us there are:
A couple of different private SEN schools where there are about 6 kids to a class, very high adult to child ratio and highly personalised curriculum. In one of these the kids typically come out with no qualifications at all, or perhaps some functional skills certificates, but the focus of the educational effort is entirely on helping them to cope with the basic complexities of life, not getting qualified. At the other there is a bit more academic content in the curriculum and some of the kids do manage to get 5 passes at GCSE with a curriculum that just has 5 subjects of study - no where near a mainstream timetable.

  • these schools are both massively full and oversubscribed with many more children needing them than could possibly be helped. Theoretically there could be self-funded pupils without an EHCP there - the fees are around £80,000 per year, due to the very high resources needed, but in reality when places are available the school will always offer the places to the state-funded pupils with and EHCP whose needs have been assessed, rather than a pupil whose parents want them to go there but who have not been through that process.

There is also a really nice, nurturing and non academically selective private school which has a "middle school" for years 4-8 and a main senior school that starts from year 9. Class sizes are about 22-24. a lot of the pupils have no SEN and are just from wealthy families but not likely to pass rigorous entrance exams, but every year they intake a significant number of "refugees" from the state system into their year 9 - enough that there are additional classes added to the cohort for year 9 compared to year 8. The education is mainstream, full curriculum but without the pressure to perform that there would be at an academic mainstream private school, and they get good GCSE results- not stellar, but decent. I don't think there are any pupils there who are state-funded to be there though, or if there are it would be a temporary arrangement for someone who really needed one of the SEN schools while they waited for a space. But fees there are only around £20,000 per year so you could do the whole of y9-y13 for not much more than the cost of one year at an SEN specialist.

There are also a few normally academically selective private schools, offering a very challenging curriculum and mostly full of very academically able children without SEN but some do have a few pupils with EHCPs who named that school as the only one that could meet their needs.

Which of these very different kinds of private schools are you talking about for your DC? And whereabouts in the country are you?

ThomasWasTortured · 19/05/2023 21:41

If DS can’t attend school the LA must provide alternative arrangements to provide him with a suitable, full time education. You can force them to if they refuse.

If you secure an EHCP the good thing is it can continue until 25, or 26 in some circumstances, so even if DS doesn’t complete GCSEs at the typical time they can be sat later.

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 21:37

@Sirzy he won't consider them. i think we're headed for school refusal
I am not sure he can go back after half term, never mind in september

OP posts:
Sirzy · 19/05/2023 19:40

In year 8 realistically the chances of getting an ehcp and being accepted into an independent specialist school intime to start gcse syllabus is slim.

have you looked at other mainstream options locally to see if they can better meet his needs? Not all mainstream (or specialist!) schools are made the same

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 19:36

@MillieMollieMandy1 he is really not happy at all at school. it's wearing him down and he's mentally ill now with anxiety on top of all the ND issues and learning difficulties. He's in year 8. Lots of children have difficulties that only become apparent when they start secondary school. He's one of them. It's taken 18 months to get diagnosis, and gather enough evidence for an ehcp request.

I do understand appreciate special schools aren't all great!

I didn't have much luck with SENDIAS either. SOSSEN/IPSEA are great though. Actually some of the best tips i've had are from mumsnet. There are some great people on here who really know SEN, and offer an out of hours service ;)

OP posts:
OutDamnedSpot · 19/05/2023 19:35

Are there any other state schools near you (or even not near you?) that are worth trying? As you’re obviously aware, getting the EHCP is going to be difficult, and even if you get it, it doesn’t guarantee the school you want. If you have funds available for specialist private school, could you consider using that money to relocate instead?

MillieMollieMandy1 · 19/05/2023 19:22

The situation is difficult/impossible for all young people requiring additional support. My DD has a diagnosis and an EHCP and we have had to fight every inch of the way. You say school 'isn't going well' - that's a bit vague but you have every right not to share. I guess your son is going into year 10 in September and you think that he will struggle. Unfortunately I the LA will think this is all a bit late and will stall. If he is happy at school I would get him supported outside school rather than putting funds into an independent school. My DD has direct experience of SN provision - contrary to what you might read on MN it isn't always the magic answer - choose very carefully. Finally people are recommending SENDIASS - just don't (all employees of the LA).

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 17:38

@OneTwoThreeFourFiveOnceI as far as I can tell this is the legal test for qualifying for an EHCNA is set out in section 36(8) of the Children and Families Act 2014.

If a local authority (“LA”) is requested to carry out an EHC needs assessment by a parent, young person, school or college, they must consider:

whether the child or young person has or may have special educational needs (“SEN”); and
whether they may need special educational provision to be made through an EHC plan.
If the answer to both of these questions is yes, they must carry out an EHC needs assessment.

It's a low bar. There's not good reason for an LA to refuse when these criteria have been met

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread