Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think of suing LA for SEN school fees when they eventually give DC an ECHP?

109 replies

ehcpnightmares · 18/05/2023 23:53

DC 13 in state school which is not going well at all
He definitely meets criteria for EHCP but LA refusing to assess (we have appealed)
We can pay school fees for a couple of years (if we can find one that fits him with a place)
Hopefully in the future LA will pay school fees, but wondering if we'd be able to reclaim the fees for the next year, given they had no good reason to delay ECHNA?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lougle · 21/05/2023 21:12

ElfDragon · 21/05/2023 20:46

But surely at least some of that fantastic result is due to you having been through the process before? I’m not sure it would have been as straightforward if you hadn’t already known the SENCOP inside out and backwards, and already been well versed in holding LAs to account?

To be honest, it was the encouragement of the ladies on the Goose and Carrot thread in SN Chat that got me through it. Knowing the Code doesn't mean you necessarily find it easy to stand up for what is right.

I have been through it before with DD1 but that was largely when she was 3-4, so the old SEN COP with statements of SEN. I never had to fight for DD1 because she was so obviously delayed and, frankly, nightmarishly disruptive. She was offered state special school without even asking for it because even complete 1:1 at mainstream would have been disastrous.

ElfDragon · 21/05/2023 20:46

Lougle · 21/05/2023 19:53

Why would it be far from the norm? DD2 was attending school full time in December 2022, struggled after Christmas, and was out of school completely by March 2023. So her outcome was given after 3 months of serious decline. I just used the evidence I had to argue that it was the start of disaster.

But surely at least some of that fantastic result is due to you having been through the process before? I’m not sure it would have been as straightforward if you hadn’t already known the SENCOP inside out and backwards, and already been well versed in holding LAs to account?

ThomasWasTortured · 21/05/2023 20:28

Whilst it isn’t very common, it also isn’t unheard of. I have supported other parents in multiple LAs with similar outcomes.

hiredandsqueak · 21/05/2023 19:58

Lougle · 21/05/2023 17:24

Absolutely not true. DD2 had only evidence of declining attendance at school and ASD dx. I got statutory assessment, then argued that they needed to do a SALT assessment and sensory OT assessment. The OT assessment was commissioned privately by the LA because NHS OTs in our LA aren't commissioned to do sensory work. The SALT was also commissioned privately by the LA, at my insistence, because NHS SALT waiting lists would go beyond the SA period.

When the private SALT gave an awful assessment, I made a formal complaint and she admitted that she hadn't even heard of the SEN COP. Then a fantastic SALT that I'd been in contact with at the LA's specialist communication team offered to reassess to get the LA out of the hole that had been dug.

DD2 was then offered an independent specialist school - 3-4 students per class with a TA who trails them to all lessons. She has OT at school and the SALT who assessed her from the LA still sees her weekly.

You don't necessarily have to go to tribunal and I didn't spend a penny on assessments.

It wouldn't happen in our LA like that. I know many parents who have got to appeal and only then have Tribunal ordered LA to commission SALT and OT assessments adjourning the appeal until the reports are in. Our LA have a sensory checklist that they deem fulfils the OT assessment requirement and they stick by that until they are forced to commission an OT assessment. Dd last had a NHS SALT assessment age 3, every assessment since has been an independent assessment she's 20. Every OT assessment she has had have been independent assessments. She last saw an LA Ed Psych at 13, we've been to Tribunal twice since then again independent ed psych assessments needed but it didn't stop LA Ed Psych appearing as LA witness despite having never seen dd.

Lougle · 21/05/2023 19:53

OneTwoThreeFourFiveOnceI · 21/05/2023 19:31

That is a fantastic outcome but also one that is likely to be very very far from the norm. It is also risky in so far that the LA commissioned report may not fully reflect the required provision even if it not the normal situation where the LA/OT have limits to what they can say

Why would it be far from the norm? DD2 was attending school full time in December 2022, struggled after Christmas, and was out of school completely by March 2023. So her outcome was given after 3 months of serious decline. I just used the evidence I had to argue that it was the start of disaster.

OneTwoThreeFourFiveOnceI · 21/05/2023 19:31

Lougle · 21/05/2023 17:24

Absolutely not true. DD2 had only evidence of declining attendance at school and ASD dx. I got statutory assessment, then argued that they needed to do a SALT assessment and sensory OT assessment. The OT assessment was commissioned privately by the LA because NHS OTs in our LA aren't commissioned to do sensory work. The SALT was also commissioned privately by the LA, at my insistence, because NHS SALT waiting lists would go beyond the SA period.

When the private SALT gave an awful assessment, I made a formal complaint and she admitted that she hadn't even heard of the SEN COP. Then a fantastic SALT that I'd been in contact with at the LA's specialist communication team offered to reassess to get the LA out of the hole that had been dug.

DD2 was then offered an independent specialist school - 3-4 students per class with a TA who trails them to all lessons. She has OT at school and the SALT who assessed her from the LA still sees her weekly.

You don't necessarily have to go to tribunal and I didn't spend a penny on assessments.

That is a fantastic outcome but also one that is likely to be very very far from the norm. It is also risky in so far that the LA commissioned report may not fully reflect the required provision even if it not the normal situation where the LA/OT have limits to what they can say

ThomasWasTortured · 21/05/2023 17:35

And even if you do end up at Tribunal you don’t need representation, it’s more than possible successfully self represent.

Lougle · 21/05/2023 17:24

PocketSand · 21/05/2023 16:35

You will have to go to tribunal if you want specialist indi. You should have private EP, SALT and OT reports. Including EP and SALT assessment of LA named placement. All experts should be tribunal 'certified'. You should be represented at hearing.

The judge will seriously take into consideration if your child is currently out of education but willing to try to attend new setting if new setting can provide a different environment (like small school/small classes/SALT and OT onsite)) that LA placement can't provide.

No guarantee of success but worth a shot.

Absolutely not true. DD2 had only evidence of declining attendance at school and ASD dx. I got statutory assessment, then argued that they needed to do a SALT assessment and sensory OT assessment. The OT assessment was commissioned privately by the LA because NHS OTs in our LA aren't commissioned to do sensory work. The SALT was also commissioned privately by the LA, at my insistence, because NHS SALT waiting lists would go beyond the SA period.

When the private SALT gave an awful assessment, I made a formal complaint and she admitted that she hadn't even heard of the SEN COP. Then a fantastic SALT that I'd been in contact with at the LA's specialist communication team offered to reassess to get the LA out of the hole that had been dug.

DD2 was then offered an independent specialist school - 3-4 students per class with a TA who trails them to all lessons. She has OT at school and the SALT who assessed her from the LA still sees her weekly.

You don't necessarily have to go to tribunal and I didn't spend a penny on assessments.

PocketSand · 21/05/2023 16:37

OT can also provide a report of LA named placement in terms of sensory load.

PocketSand · 21/05/2023 16:35

You will have to go to tribunal if you want specialist indi. You should have private EP, SALT and OT reports. Including EP and SALT assessment of LA named placement. All experts should be tribunal 'certified'. You should be represented at hearing.

The judge will seriously take into consideration if your child is currently out of education but willing to try to attend new setting if new setting can provide a different environment (like small school/small classes/SALT and OT onsite)) that LA placement can't provide.

No guarantee of success but worth a shot.

OneTwoThreeFourFiveOnceI · 21/05/2023 12:02

AlantheDog · 21/05/2023 10:06

Final paragraph: agreed. However ironically, doing a one off EHCNA assessment reduces our certainty about recommendations. It's much harder to be certain whether this YP will need 30 min twice a week of a certain intervention, or 10-15 mins a day, or an hour a week, for example, when I only got to see them once for an hour and a half - compared with if I have had the chance to support them and the school over a couple of APDR cycles, honing the support and monitoring how the young person gets on.

I mean I try hard to specify and quantify but it's much more "make an educated guess" in cases where I am called in AFTER EHCNA has been agreed. I genuinely think the EHCPs produced are worse for it.

I think there should be much more pressure on (all, as many already do this) schools to follow C of P and do their statutory duty by their children.

Appreciate that it would make it much more difficult to be confident about recommendations when it is a one-off assessment but in the nicest possible way it is the worse of all words when vague language is used but the child is highly likely to end up with pretty much nothing at all.

MummyJ12 · 21/05/2023 11:13

Thank you @Butterflybutterflies 🤞🏼

Butterflybutterflies · 21/05/2023 11:09

@MummyJ12 i know people who have done that, sometimes it’s worthwhile and changes are made.

RedHelenB · 21/05/2023 10:54

ehcpnightmares · 19/05/2023 21:37

@Sirzy he won't consider them. i think we're headed for school refusal
I am not sure he can go back after half term, never mind in september

Would he at least go and look at them with you,

MummyJ12 · 21/05/2023 10:39

Hi @Lougle
Can I please ask, in our case, do you think it’s worth me emailing the EP to take another look at DS’ section f because what she has written isn’t SMART and she hasn’t taken enough account of her own professional opinion to fully reflect in section f? Or would I be wasting my time?
I’d really appreciate your thoughts.
Thanks.

Butterflybutterflies · 21/05/2023 10:29

I just want to wish you well OP. I have been in a similar situation.
DS has had an EHCP for years but where it was clear that mainstream was no longer working - years 7/8 - I really had to fight to get a specialist independent named.
We planned to pay ourselves from the start of year 9 but the LA conceded during the summer holiday. The fees were ‘only’ 18K per year so not all specialist independent schools cost a fortune.

mixedrecycling · 21/05/2023 10:23

It might be worth looking at other mainstream state schools to see if any have a more constructive attitude.

DD's school allows pupils to drop one subject and do 'Core support' in that slot - additional teaching in English and Maths - without any drama. Further subjects can be dropped, but that is more of a process because obviously there needs to be somewhere for them to go during the time others are in class.

Plus they have a quiet room where those who need it (e.g. DD) can go if they are overwhelmed by the class situation, they have support to self-regulate and then do their work in the quiet room.

So depending on your DS's need there maybe some mainstream state schools that could meet his needs.

AlantheDog · 21/05/2023 10:06

Lougle · 21/05/2023 09:57

It isn't best practice but I also can't stand it when posters (generally, not you) tell parents that they will fail in getting an EHCNA because they haven't got the evidence from an EP. If the school can't/won't buy EP time, then the parent is stuck.

I also think EPs should be banned from using 'access to', 'as the opportunity/need arises', 'up to' and all the other vague terms that allow LAs to completely ignore recommendations. The SEN COP is very clear that provision should be SMART. It's tedious.

Final paragraph: agreed. However ironically, doing a one off EHCNA assessment reduces our certainty about recommendations. It's much harder to be certain whether this YP will need 30 min twice a week of a certain intervention, or 10-15 mins a day, or an hour a week, for example, when I only got to see them once for an hour and a half - compared with if I have had the chance to support them and the school over a couple of APDR cycles, honing the support and monitoring how the young person gets on.

I mean I try hard to specify and quantify but it's much more "make an educated guess" in cases where I am called in AFTER EHCNA has been agreed. I genuinely think the EHCPs produced are worse for it.

I think there should be much more pressure on (all, as many already do this) schools to follow C of P and do their statutory duty by their children.

Lougle · 21/05/2023 09:57

AlantheDog · 21/05/2023 09:27

@Lougle
I am an EP.
We hate it when we get called in only after statutory assessment has been agreed. It is absolutely not best practice. Yes we must be involved during EHCNA, but if schools have done their job properly vis a vis the CoP we should be involved beforehand. The code recommends a graduated response via APDR.

It's possible you live in an area where your EP service has been cut back so much that all the LA EPs do is one-off assessments for children where EHCNA has already been agreed, but that isn't the best way of working for anyone concerned.

It isn't best practice but I also can't stand it when posters (generally, not you) tell parents that they will fail in getting an EHCNA because they haven't got the evidence from an EP. If the school can't/won't buy EP time, then the parent is stuck.

I also think EPs should be banned from using 'access to', 'as the opportunity/need arises', 'up to' and all the other vague terms that allow LAs to completely ignore recommendations. The SEN COP is very clear that provision should be SMART. It's tedious.

Lougle · 21/05/2023 09:57

AlantheDog · 21/05/2023 09:27

@Lougle
I am an EP.
We hate it when we get called in only after statutory assessment has been agreed. It is absolutely not best practice. Yes we must be involved during EHCNA, but if schools have done their job properly vis a vis the CoP we should be involved beforehand. The code recommends a graduated response via APDR.

It's possible you live in an area where your EP service has been cut back so much that all the LA EPs do is one-off assessments for children where EHCNA has already been agreed, but that isn't the best way of working for anyone concerned.

It isn't best practice but I also can't stand it when posters (generally, not you) tell parents that they will fail in getting an EHCNA because they haven't got the evidence from an EP. If the school can't/won't buy EP time, then the parent is stuck.

I also think EPs should be banned from using 'access to', 'as the opportunity/need arises', 'up to' and all the other vague terms that allow LAs to completely ignore recommendations. The SEN COP is very clear that provision should be SMART. It's tedious.

AlantheDog · 21/05/2023 09:27

Lougle · 21/05/2023 06:02

@AlantheDog at this stage (refusal to assess) the LA only need to consider whether the child has or may have SEN, and whether provision may need to be made through a Plan. The bar is very low. The EP comes in at the 'yes we must assess' stage.

@ehcpnightmares have you done a Subject Access Request? It will give you all the (redacted) internal emails with evidence of what the school has been discussing about your DS, etc., which can be fantastic evidence.

@Lougle
I am an EP.
We hate it when we get called in only after statutory assessment has been agreed. It is absolutely not best practice. Yes we must be involved during EHCNA, but if schools have done their job properly vis a vis the CoP we should be involved beforehand. The code recommends a graduated response via APDR.

It's possible you live in an area where your EP service has been cut back so much that all the LA EPs do is one-off assessments for children where EHCNA has already been agreed, but that isn't the best way of working for anyone concerned.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 21/05/2023 08:59

@AlantheDog You say his current school cannot reduce his number of GCSEs. Bollocks they can't (sorry, schools annoy me with this stuff). They choose not to because it will damage their progress 8 scores, whereas if your boy toddles off elsewhere their 10 GcSEs apiece cohort will be intact. Write to the SEN governor requesting that he be allowed a reduced GCSE timetable, dropping, say, history, MFL, RE and taking Eng Lit and Lang, combined science and maths. With access to the SEN dept to consolidate his learning in his "free" periods - this is wise.

Pretty much any school can do this.
All the schools we looked at had an SEN room where kids who couldn't deal with being in the classroom could withdraw to and work quietly. My own DC tends to spend at least one period a day there on average - I don't know if schools exist that don't have such a facility but it would be highly discriminatory not to have any kind of provision like this. It must be all about the statistics.

If your child could cope with the academic curriculum at their current school if they could reduce to 5 subjects then that will be a better solution than moving schools. The school may need to be forced to put the child's best interests over their own statistics but that will be a much easier fight to win than getting a place in a specialist school.

Lougle · 21/05/2023 06:02

AlantheDog · 20/05/2023 23:52

OP:

Why haven't you mentioned an LA EP? Surely if the school doesn't feel they can meet his needs to the point they are suggesting specialist then he should be a priority for their EP time? For an ehcp to be issued, the LA needs to consider whether the needs are outside what a school could reasonably be expected to support, and whether the school has coordinated advice and support (see image).

You say his current school cannot reduce his number of GCSEs. Bollocks they can't (sorry, schools annoy me with this stuff). They choose not to because it will damage their progress 8 scores, whereas if your boy toddles off elsewhere their 10 GcSEs apiece cohort will be intact. Write to the SEN governor requesting that he be allowed a reduced GCSE timetable, dropping, say, history, MFL, RE and taking Eng Lit and Lang, combined science and maths. With access to the SEN dept to consolidate his learning in his "free" periods.

Keep up the EHCNA assessment request but don't assume it's only the LA playing silly buggers, schools are more than capable of wide -eyed disingenuousness about their legal duty.

@AlantheDog at this stage (refusal to assess) the LA only need to consider whether the child has or may have SEN, and whether provision may need to be made through a Plan. The bar is very low. The EP comes in at the 'yes we must assess' stage.

@ehcpnightmares have you done a Subject Access Request? It will give you all the (redacted) internal emails with evidence of what the school has been discussing about your DS, etc., which can be fantastic evidence.

ehcpnightmares · 21/05/2023 00:20

@AlantheDog that's interesting, i'm not sure how these things are calculated but the school has a v high Progress 8 score (>0.8)

I assumed they were refusing to reduce the number of subjects he studies because of the cost of supervision if not in timetabled classes

We do have a report from the school EP but they couldn't do formal assessments because ds's anxiety level was too high (!) We went through all the recommendations line by line in our appeal doc outlining why they are not enough and how some will actually reduce changes of academic success (not that its the main problem for us, but i think it is for LA and SEND law)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread