Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes

241 replies

bunsaremybesties · 18/05/2023 21:08

I am from Northern Ireland, legally a part of the UK that uses sterling. I am currently on holiday in England. In a shop yesterday there were signs displayed saying "we cannot accept Scottish or Irish notes".

My problems with this are:
(a) the use of the phrase Irish notes - personally I don't really have a strong preference for calling myself either British or Irish, but to my ears, "Irish notes", due to the current real-life currencies used on the island of Ireland, would be euro notes, used in the Republic of Ireland. So of course a shop in England would not accept these, just as it would not accept American notes or Mexican notes. I would have thought Northern Irish notes would have been a more accurate description, as Northern Ireland uses the same currency as England.

(b) what is the reasoning for not accepting "Irish"/Northern Irish banknotes, when they're exactly the same currency as those used in England, Wales and Scotland? While in Northern Ireland we do print our own banknotes, we also regularly use and accept banknotes issued in other regions of the UK. I work in a shop and within any hour block at work, I deal with any number of notes from customers that were issued by the Bank of England, Clydesdale Bank, Bank of Scotland etc. The notes have exactly the same value as those issued by Northern Irish banks like Ulster Bank or Danske Bank, so why on earth wouldn't we accept them? It's not even a consideration in our minds to refuse them. Why is it different in England?

(c) if the justification is that Northern Irish notes are not "legal tender" in England, well then everyone who lives in Northern Ireland is in trouble because in Scotland and Northern Ireland no notes, not even ones issued in those countries, are "legal tender". They are, however, legal currency and so are perfectly acceptable to be used for trade.

Can anyone explain please?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
jcyclops · 19/05/2023 00:08

As somebody mentioned earlier, (N) Irish and Scottish notes are accepted and can be identified by machines such as at self-service tills in shops. The reason is simple. The supplier of the hardware/software and the purchaser (the shop) don't want to have different machines or different programming for their stores in N Ireland or Scotland.

A question for our posters in Scotland & Northern Ireland: Have you had problems exchanging your non Bank of England notes for local currency at Bureaux de Change while abroad?

TomPinch · 19/05/2023 00:00

Sissynova · 18/05/2023 22:05

And the reverse is also true and yet NI and Scotland don’t refuse Bank of England.

It still largely comes down to ignorance hence the shop having a sign that says “no Irish notes” 🙄 … well no one was expecting to use Euros I’m sure.

For Pete's sake! If you must get that technical, well, they are Irish notes because they come from Ireland! Just not from the state that covers the majority the island.

Have you complained to Bushmills Distillery because it markets its product as "Irish whiskey"? 😉

TomPinch · 18/05/2023 23:54

@MMBaranovathanks for the pics! I've never seen a NI note (like many other people)

Florenz · 18/05/2023 23:52

It'd be a lot easier if there weren't multiple banks in Scotland & NI all issuing their own notes. You can't expect shop staff to be experts in recognising forgeries of over 20 different banknotes that they might see once in a blue moon.

tommika · 18/05/2023 23:50

DorisParchment · 18/05/2023 21:38

Northern Irish and Scottish bank notes are not legal tender in England.

Legal tender has nothing to do with spending either

The refusal of an offer of legal tender to settle a debt renders the debt unenforceable in court

A purchase in any Sterling currency in the UK has nothing to do with debt or legal tender

TomPinch · 18/05/2023 23:50

I remember back in the 90s arriving in Glasgow to discover that lots of businesses wouldn't accept Bank of England £20 notes - exactly for the same reason - risk of forgery.

I don't remember any uproar. Perhaps it would be different now, if so, probably because of a certain degree of weariness of complaints from north of the border about the wicked English.

MMBaranova · 18/05/2023 23:42

Ulster Bank has the prettiest notes.

To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes
To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes
MMBaranova · 18/05/2023 23:38

Just who issues notes in N Ireland is curious. AIB (and some other outfits) dispense B of England notes at ATMs. The three banks with their own notes are Ulster Bank, Bank of Ireland and Danske Bank. BoI therefore has sterling issued by its NI subsidiary, but its Euros for all in the Republic. Danske? Yes, Northern Bank was bought by Danske and their name is on the notes.

To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes
MMBaranova · 18/05/2023 23:37

It's one of those things you live with, daft though it is. I to and fro between England and N Ireland a couple of times a year and just hang on to odd notes until the next time. Trying to use a NI note in London is asking for grief (and we tap so often anyway now).

To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes
NumberTheory · 18/05/2023 23:33

MegaManic · 18/05/2023 22:56

Because it has been set up to recognise them because the business or bank or happy to accept them. They are still not legal tender - I'm not sure how many ways I can say the same thing. Business are not required to accept a form of payment if it is not legal tender. It is not a slight against people from NI or Scotland, it is a business decision and presumably they feel they are not missing out on lots of business by doing this. Maybe if you didn't assume everything was based on ignorance and English arrogance and didn't have such a chip on your shoulder you would just accept it is a business decision.

It has nothing to do with it being legal tender or not. Businesses are not required to accept any notes in a shop transaction whether they are legal tender or not.

Legal tender is only relevant when settling a debt, not when deciding whether or not to accept an offer in exchange (which is what a shop transaction amounts to). So shops are just as entitled to turn down BofE notes if they want to as they are to turn down Scottish or NI notes.. And many do refuse higher value BofE notes.

When you use a machine to accept currency you can program it to recognise all sterling currency just about as easily as to recognise just one, so there's little cost to doing so. Whereas training up staff is ongoing and more costly, especially if they rarely encounter the notes.

OneTC · 18/05/2023 23:26

Legal tender is a non concept when it comes to spending money, there's no such thing really.

People don't take Scottish or Irish notes because they don't want to and they don't have to. They don't have to take sterling. I'll take euros, dollars, goats if it's a good enough deal.

multiple issuing banks are annoying from a counterfeit perspective

matisses6fingers · 18/05/2023 23:21

mynameiscalypso · 18/05/2023 21:19

(I should caveat that deposits of Scottish notes in English bank accounts are a red flag. Clearly they're not in Scotland)

Surely when someone is trying to pay for something in a shop it’s obvious that this is not the same as depositing large sums of cash into a bank account? And surely in places like Carlisle (close to the border) Scottish notes will be more prevalent?

Fangdango · 18/05/2023 23:19

RavenclawDiadem · 18/05/2023 23:08

I'm Scottish and feel your pain!

I think that the further south into England you go, the worse it gets. Never have an issue with notes on the M6 services, they see them all the time. But go to a small shop in the Cotswolds, you'll be trying to hand your note to someone who has probably never seen a Bank of Scotland (or Ulster Bank) tenner and does not recognise it.

Their immediate reaction is reject, then they start on about how they can only take "proper" notes or something similar and that's guaranteed to get the blood pressure rising. They absolutely CAN accept Scottish and N Irish notes but don't WANT to as it's a pain for them, and they are also not as familiar with the security features on N Irish and Scottish notes which are there, just as they are there on Bank of England notes.

Imagine what a stooshie it would cause if every shop in Edinburgh's Royal Mile made the same fuss and "i'll have to call the supervisor" pantomime every time someone tried to hand over a Bank of England £20.

It seems reasonable to me that they wouldn't want to. And yes it probably is worth shops near the Scottish border being more flexible. Shops near the Irish border have often been flexible in this way too - punts, euros, sterling accepted. It's worth it when enough customers are involved.

Shops in Scotland could refuse Bank of England notes if they wanted to - up to them to decide if they'd benefit from doing so. Since they're standardised, likely to be carried by international visitors, and apparently less liable to be forged than other sterling notes, it would be an odd choice, but their choice.

MrsMoastyToasty · 18/05/2023 23:17

When I worked in banking for an English branch of one the Scottish banks mentioned upthread we would return any paid in Scottish or N. Irish notes to the cash centre for onwards "repatriation" to the issuing country of origin.
I also heard that in the 80s some English bank cashpoints in wealthy places like Knightsbridge would issue Scottish £100 notes because ATM withdrawals were higher value.
I have only ever seen one £100 Scottish note and there isn't an English equivalent . I had to check it against a reference manual held in the branch!

AnonyMenOhPee · 18/05/2023 23:17

BakedTattie · 18/05/2023 21:50

On the note of Scottish notes not being legal tender, English notes technically are not legal tender in Scotland. According to the Bank of England. But Scotland accepts them no problem. Imagine the uproar if Scotland didn’t (dare!) accept English notes.

https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/explainers/what-is-legal-tender

I expect it would be much the same as this thread where people would be advised to obtain Scottish notes if they want to go to Scotland. Don’t let that get in the way of taking offence at an incredibly minor point though

WarningToTheCurious · 18/05/2023 23:16

I’ve seen NI notes refused in Scotland too.

Coxspurplepippin · 18/05/2023 23:16

PolliFlinders · 18/05/2023 23:05

I've worked in retail in the North of Scotland for over 30 years and have never known NI notes to be refused. Also the only forgeries we have ever had were bank of England £20s.

We've had NI notes refused in Edinburgh, Glasgow, Perthshire. In fact never had one accepted in Scotland. Visitors from NI quite surprised we accepted them as they'd been refused in pubs, restaurants, shops.

SusannaQ · 18/05/2023 23:15

tailinthejam · 18/05/2023 21:55

Scottish, NI, Channel Islands and Manx bank notes are not legal tender in England.

CI and IoM aren't in the UK, so that's no surprise, although the IoM accept all UK tender. But I thought Scottish and NI were acceptable in England, I've certainly had Scottish notes in change.

Sissynova · 18/05/2023 23:14

BitOutOfPractice · 18/05/2023 23:05

Can someone please explain for this English idiot (I see it’s ok to label all English people as morons in a rant about prejudice 🙄) what is the difference between legal currency and legal tender? Because the articles linked to have made my brain rattle.

this is just out of interest because I’ve not seen a Scottish note in about 30 years and never seen an Northern Irish note ever, despite visiting Northern Ireland many times. I feel I’ve missed out somehow.

NI lots are legal currency as in they are legitimate sterling notes but they are not legal tender in England.
The only legal tender in England is BOE notes and coins, however there are still rules around these. Technically it’s not legal tender to use more than 20p worth of coppers. So obviously retailers don’t often go by those rigid rules as ultimately £1 in coppers it £5 bank of Ireland is still legal currency so they can deposit it at the bank and it has real value.
Debit cards are not legal tender either so it’s a funny argument as people rarely pay in cash anyway so they aren’t using legal tender.

Tratjymp · 18/05/2023 23:14

You can't expect people to accept notes they don't recognise by sight.

Let's be reasonable.

belleager · 18/05/2023 23:13

Back in the day - the 1980s? Even the early 1990s? it used to be quite a regular occurrence to get a British coin in your change instead of an Irish one of the same shape, in Dublin.

So Sterling for Punt, 1p, 2p, 5p, 10p, 50p. Shops took them in, gave them out again - I don't think anyone ever bothered changing them.

The 1980s weren't exactly the heyday of Anglo-Irish relations. But the currency did the job - nobody cared. I really doubt there's anything political in notes from Scotland and NI not being accepted elsewhere. Shops want money. People want money that shops will accept. You get Scottish and Welsh and Northern Irish emblems on pound coins, don't you, and nobody refuses them?

WarningToTheCurious · 18/05/2023 23:11

Aberdeen airport had cash machines that gave you English notes (not sure if that’s still the case) because trying to use Scottish notes in London was pretty much impossible.

When you have several banks all producing their own notes with different designs, it’s hardly surprising that a separate country with its own standardised bank notes is going to be wary.

RavenclawDiadem · 18/05/2023 23:08

I'm Scottish and feel your pain!

I think that the further south into England you go, the worse it gets. Never have an issue with notes on the M6 services, they see them all the time. But go to a small shop in the Cotswolds, you'll be trying to hand your note to someone who has probably never seen a Bank of Scotland (or Ulster Bank) tenner and does not recognise it.

Their immediate reaction is reject, then they start on about how they can only take "proper" notes or something similar and that's guaranteed to get the blood pressure rising. They absolutely CAN accept Scottish and N Irish notes but don't WANT to as it's a pain for them, and they are also not as familiar with the security features on N Irish and Scottish notes which are there, just as they are there on Bank of England notes.

Imagine what a stooshie it would cause if every shop in Edinburgh's Royal Mile made the same fuss and "i'll have to call the supervisor" pantomime every time someone tried to hand over a Bank of England £20.

Simianwalk · 18/05/2023 23:07

Quveas · 18/05/2023 21:26

And English ones aren't?

Never heard such rubbish before.

When I worked in fraud it was Scottish £20s and English £50 to watch for as people don't know those notes as well. NI one's were so rare it wasn't am issue.

PolliFlinders · 18/05/2023 23:05

Coxspurplepippin · 18/05/2023 22:48

Many places, especially large companies and especially in the north of England accept Scottish notes no problem - they're reasonably familiar. The further south and the smaller the business not so much, because the notes aren't familiar.

It's got bugger all to do with 'English ignorance' - or if it has, 'Scottish ignorance' is just as prevalent. If you've ever tried paying for a coffee in Edinburgh using a Northern Irish bank note, you'll have exactly the same issue. People don't recognise them.

We used to run a business in rural Scotland and had many visitors from NI for sheepdog trials and ram sales Grin - we accepted NI notes but couldn't use them in Scotland as no businesses would accept them, so just paid them into the bank.

I've worked in retail in the North of Scotland for over 30 years and have never known NI notes to be refused. Also the only forgeries we have ever had were bank of England £20s.