Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes

241 replies

bunsaremybesties · 18/05/2023 21:08

I am from Northern Ireland, legally a part of the UK that uses sterling. I am currently on holiday in England. In a shop yesterday there were signs displayed saying "we cannot accept Scottish or Irish notes".

My problems with this are:
(a) the use of the phrase Irish notes - personally I don't really have a strong preference for calling myself either British or Irish, but to my ears, "Irish notes", due to the current real-life currencies used on the island of Ireland, would be euro notes, used in the Republic of Ireland. So of course a shop in England would not accept these, just as it would not accept American notes or Mexican notes. I would have thought Northern Irish notes would have been a more accurate description, as Northern Ireland uses the same currency as England.

(b) what is the reasoning for not accepting "Irish"/Northern Irish banknotes, when they're exactly the same currency as those used in England, Wales and Scotland? While in Northern Ireland we do print our own banknotes, we also regularly use and accept banknotes issued in other regions of the UK. I work in a shop and within any hour block at work, I deal with any number of notes from customers that were issued by the Bank of England, Clydesdale Bank, Bank of Scotland etc. The notes have exactly the same value as those issued by Northern Irish banks like Ulster Bank or Danske Bank, so why on earth wouldn't we accept them? It's not even a consideration in our minds to refuse them. Why is it different in England?

(c) if the justification is that Northern Irish notes are not "legal tender" in England, well then everyone who lives in Northern Ireland is in trouble because in Scotland and Northern Ireland no notes, not even ones issued in those countries, are "legal tender". They are, however, legal currency and so are perfectly acceptable to be used for trade.

Can anyone explain please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
10
Oakbeam · 21/05/2023 15:54

I still have it. It's very worn, unfortunately, because even back then it would have been worth lots more than 10p in good nick.

The Victorian florins had a relatively high silver content, so it may be worth more than you think.

SerendipityJane · 21/05/2023 10:40

It's simply the tyranny of the majority.

NI: population = 2 million (generously rounded up)
England population = 56 million (rounded down)

SinnerBoy · 21/05/2023 10:14

Tender simply means an offer to pay.

I'm in the Newcastle area and have rarely been refused service over a Scottish note. Go South, however... visiting relatives round Huntington and London, shop workers give you a look as though you've tried to give them a dog turd!

I remember a lot of shops refusing Scottish fivers, in the late 90s and early 2000s, as there was a spate of forgeries, done locally.

I found that in Dumfries and Galloway & Glasgow, there was little trouble with Northern Irish notes, but away from there, no dice.

I used to have a Northern Bank £100 note, from 1996 (?). I found it amusing to offer to pay rounds with it and the replies usually involved the words "Monopoly money" and "fucking."

DownNative · 21/05/2023 07:45

elephantmarchingin · 21/05/2023 04:48

From my bank training although it's a legal currency it's not actually legal tender (seems to also be backed up by a quick Google search). Therefore there is no legal standpoint to have to accept them.

It's hard for staff to know what they can and cannot accept as at the end of the day if they get it wrong it can have a big impact on their job whereas most will know exactly what they are looking for with English notes.

Legal tender does NOT mean a business has to legally accept Bank Of England and/or other notes at all. Your statement ".....although it's a legal currency it's not actually legal tender....Therefore there is no legal standpoint to have to accept them" implies this, incorrectly.

From the Bank Of England website:

"You might have heard someone in a shop say: “But it’s legal tender!”. Most people think it means the shop has to accept the payment form. But that’s not the case."

And:

"If your local corner shop decided to only accept payments in Pokémon cards that would be within their right too. But they’d probably lose customers."

And:

"Legal tender has a narrow technical meaning which has no use in everyday life."

elephantmarchingin · 21/05/2023 04:48

From my bank training although it's a legal currency it's not actually legal tender (seems to also be backed up by a quick Google search). Therefore there is no legal standpoint to have to accept them.

It's hard for staff to know what they can and cannot accept as at the end of the day if they get it wrong it can have a big impact on their job whereas most will know exactly what they are looking for with English notes.

Qazwsxefv · 21/05/2023 02:39

english peeps thoughts - “bank notes are a thing issued by the government just like the coins and have nothing to do with a “bank” I can actually visit on the high street and do “banking” at, what’s this weird note saying “royal bank of Scotland” on it, that’s a high street bank isn’t it - don’t they own NatWest- why are they making bank notes, this is not right”

ni/Scots peeps thoughts “bank notes are issued by normal high street banks and so look different because they come from different banks, this is all normal and why are the English not getting it”

in England/wales the only bank that can issue notes is the Bank of England who are not a “normal” bank that people bank with therefore in the average English/Welsh persons brain money as in a “banknote” is only issued by the state bank and the idea of a high-street bank is just as weird as the idea of each high-street bank making its own coins. For me it’s not that they’re Scottish/NI but that is from a random bank. If the notes used usually in England/wales were printed by HBSC or NatWest then it would seem a lot less strange to see variation in notes.

fyi: I do know that the Scottish/ni banks notes are just as good as the BOE notes and just as valid but it’s the whole getting your head round the fact that commercial banks make their own notes that’s the brain fuzzer, and having seen only a few Scottish notes and never having seen a NI one if someone gave me one I wouldn’t know if it was a real one or not so I’d be less keen to accept it (I’d be happier to take euros or dollars tbh at correct exchange obvs because I have a passing familiarly with what the are supposed to look like)

Florenz · 21/05/2023 01:15

I have seen Gibraltar currency - in Gibraltar. I brought some home as a kid but I don't know what happened to it.

TomPinch · 21/05/2023 01:10

Question: has anyone seen a banknote for the Gibraltar Pound, the Falklands Islands pound or the St Helena pound?

On a tangent, before UK currency was shrunk I had a Victorian Gothic florin turn up in my change. I still have it. It's very worn, unfortunately, because even back then it would have been worth lots more than 10p in good nick.

Piglet89 · 20/05/2023 18:57

I’m also Northern Irish and my mum has been known to send me cash in the post: always English notes tho!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/05/2023 18:42

DownNative · 20/05/2023 09:51

No.

Danske Bank took over Northern Bank about 20 years ago.

Both Danske Bank and Bank Of Ireland notes are in Sterling which is your clue. IRCC, Bank Of Ireland was the main bank during the years of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. To all intents and purposes, it IS a British Bank.

There is no mutual exclusivity in Britishness and Irishness which is why ROI citizens are treated as de facto part of the British family in the UK. They aren't regarded as foreigners at all.

Bank of Ireland sounds very similar to Allied Irish Bank if you don't deal with them daily. OR if you did deal with the latter until they withdrew from the SME market in GB and closed your business account.

DownNative · 20/05/2023 18:18

tommika · 20/05/2023 17:24

Should I have refused to accept this today in Basingstoke ?

You were correct to refuse to accept this one because Scottish paper £5 notes went out of circulation on 1st March 2018.

The Scottish £5 note is now polymer which is perfectly fine.

tommika · 20/05/2023 17:24

Should I have refused to accept this today in Basingstoke ?

To not understand why English businesses won't accept Northern Irish banknotes
NumberTheory · 20/05/2023 16:34

DownNative · 20/05/2023 10:51

Exceptions can always be found and these would tend to be tourist type businesses. I wouldn't be surprised to see a few of these around London accepting some foreign currencies. I know in Belfast Titanic centre will take Euros in addition to Sterling due to the cross border and EU tourists.

But these are obviously not the norm anywhere in the UK since they're not legal currency.

However, we're told that "Channel Island sterling is not accepted in the UK" because Westminster has not authorised it as legal currency. This seems unfair, yes?

Channel Islands currencies are not officially recognised or supported in the UK because the British Government has no regulatory control over then (which is a contrast to Scottish and NI notes). The Bailliwicks’ currency decisions are independent. They choose how much they issue and how they back it. They could change this if they wanted and unlink it from GBP.

Oakbeam · 20/05/2023 15:22

I wouldn't be surprised to see a few of these around London accepting some foreign currencies. I know in Belfast Titanic centre will take Euros in addition to Sterling due to the cross border and EU tourists.

I used to live in a UK town next to a very large US air force base. Many local businesses happily accepted US dollars in payment.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 20/05/2023 15:21

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/05/2023 10:35

Morons?

What about not seeing them frequently enough to have any idea whether they are counterfeit or not?

When staff are held responsible for accepting dodgy notes, they're not being stupid for refusing them, as only an idiot would willingly say 'don't worry random woman of mumsnet, I've never seen or handled a northern Irish twenty before, considering that we are in a village shop in Deepest Kent, but I'll happily take the chance that they're real and refund the company out of my minimum wage zero hours contract because you might pull a cats' arse at me if I don't gamble £165 of my own money on you not being a scamming shite'.

👏🏻

DonnaBanana · 20/05/2023 14:58

How is it "bigoted" to not accept cash from banks I am totally unfamiliar with? I wouldn't accept special edition £5 coins made by the Bank of England either because I would not be sure they are legitimate, even if they are legal tender. Scottish and NI money is relatively speaking "weird" and unusual to see. Unless you're going to wait while I Google every unusual form of currency I am offered, I ain't taking it.

WhatsitAlfie · 20/05/2023 13:11

The banking systems are different though (same as taxes) A bank note is a cheque written by the bank who wrote it..I promise to pay the bearer etc. Providing the note is good and proper and still valid (we all know banks recall them from time to time) Sterling means the note is in the same currency so there is no conversion rate although I do recall a antique dealing friend of mine telling me a few decades ago that you could buy Scottish notes a little cheaper because they were less easy to spend (so therefore hide). The facts remain

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 11:55

However, we're told that "Channel Island sterling is not accepted in the UK" because Westminster has not authorised it as legal currency. This seems unfair, yes?

In practice though, what's to stop a shop keeper choosing to accept them? Maybe the ferry terminals in Poole or Portsmouth allow you to spend them there.

There was a "Bristol Pound" in circulation (available from a number of ATMs) that as well as participating retailers could be used when paying council tax. It got killed off when covid struck and people stopped using cash.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bristol_pound

Bristol pound - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bristol_pound

DownNative · 20/05/2023 10:51

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 04:26

My employer (public transport) used to accept Euros, Dollars and Yen. Only notes, and change had to be given in sterling of course. I'm pretty sure that a shop keeper can accept or refuse any form of payment they like, some refuse cards, some refuse £50 notes etc. If a shop decided to only accept Zimbabwe dollars as payment, it might not be good business but surely there's no law against it - it's only where a debt already exists that you are obliged to accept sterling if offered.

Exceptions can always be found and these would tend to be tourist type businesses. I wouldn't be surprised to see a few of these around London accepting some foreign currencies. I know in Belfast Titanic centre will take Euros in addition to Sterling due to the cross border and EU tourists.

But these are obviously not the norm anywhere in the UK since they're not legal currency.

However, we're told that "Channel Island sterling is not accepted in the UK" because Westminster has not authorised it as legal currency. This seems unfair, yes?

DownNative · 20/05/2023 09:51

sashh · 20/05/2023 08:24

Danske - doesn't exactly sound like a British bank though does it?

Bank of Ireland - Again doesn't sound like a British bank.

No.

Danske Bank took over Northern Bank about 20 years ago.

Both Danske Bank and Bank Of Ireland notes are in Sterling which is your clue. IRCC, Bank Of Ireland was the main bank during the years of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. To all intents and purposes, it IS a British Bank.

There is no mutual exclusivity in Britishness and Irishness which is why ROI citizens are treated as de facto part of the British family in the UK. They aren't regarded as foreigners at all.

sashh · 20/05/2023 08:24

DownNative · 19/05/2023 10:38

Weird system?!

There are only three note issuing banks in Northern Ireland.

Danske Bank.

Ulster Bank (part of the Natwest group)

Bank Of Ireland.

Exactly the same as in Scotland which you did not call "weird system"!

  • Bank of Scotland plc.
  • Clydesdale Bank plc.
  • The Royal Bank of Scotland plc

All are legal currency in all parts of the UK.

Danske - doesn't exactly sound like a British bank though does it?

Bank of Ireland - Again doesn't sound like a British bank.

WhatsitAlfie · 20/05/2023 07:40

Getting back to the currency subject...after almost 3 decades working as a cashier in a bank and dealing with all the notes businesses had taken from customers of other sterling nations (to sort and return to the respective nation in the next bullion run because that's what has to get done) I found myself as an employee in a shop being offered a note issued by that well known British institution Danske Bank, I said oops sorry we don't take these...boy did I feel silly after all those years of not recognising it as a Sterling note at first sight. On closer inspection I decided it was probably OK to take but I chastised myself for not reading the memo that would have definitely been placed on my desk by my previous employer.
I had also fallen into the trap of giving some paper bank of England notes that my late father had squirreld away that turned out to be the previously recalled version, they were not accepted in the petrol station despite me giving them as petrol money...how weird is that? I hadn't got a later paper one to compare it to because all the 20s I had used recently were plastic... hardly any to be honest because I don't use cash myself.
Carry on arguing about dna though ;)

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 04:36

Itwasnaeme · 19/05/2023 13:50

I suppose to me it suggests quite an insular approach, that you haven't made the (relatively small, compared to visiting everywhere in Europe) effort to go to see the other parts of the country you actually live in.

I've been to fourteen other European countries. I've been to Scotland and the Isle of Man. I haven't yet been to NI. While I've handled Ulster Bank notes in a previous job (hotel at a major UK theme park, you could tell which parts of the UK were on half term that week by what notes you were being handed), I doubt that I'll ever spend one myself - after all, when I finally get around to visiting NI I'll probably be using contactless everywhere.

Come to think of it, after my most recent European holiday I got a bank card that you can pre-load with foreign currency so I'll be using far less cash on the continent than I used to too.

DdraigGoch · 20/05/2023 04:26

DownNative · 19/05/2023 13:30

Sorry, but you ARE fixated on the term legal tender.

If you actually knew the difference between legal tender and legal currency, you would not have stupidly stated, "Should they also be expected to take Euro's and USD or is that English arrogance too"!

Why would ANY shop in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland accept US Dollars or the Euro banknotes as payment?!,

They're simply NOT legal currency, i.e., you cannot legally spend foreign currency in ANY part of the UK which is why they must be exchanged at the daily rate!

Shops in England absolutely DO accept Northern Irish and Scottish banknotes. I've not had a problem since 1995, personally.

For those sitting at the back - you - legal tender is a completely different thing to legal currency!

The difference in numbers in how easily UK banknotes are forged is essentially negligible as well. It is not widespread.

My employer (public transport) used to accept Euros, Dollars and Yen. Only notes, and change had to be given in sterling of course. I'm pretty sure that a shop keeper can accept or refuse any form of payment they like, some refuse cards, some refuse £50 notes etc. If a shop decided to only accept Zimbabwe dollars as payment, it might not be good business but surely there's no law against it - it's only where a debt already exists that you are obliged to accept sterling if offered.