Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people cite Citizens Advise as the holy grail?

65 replies

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 14:51

The advisors are on a low wage and no formal legal qualifications.

AIBU to think they aren't the holy grail

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 18/05/2023 20:49

It's Citizens Advice, not "Citizens Advise".

It's a national organisation - actually a network of local organisations, each of them independent but affiliated to the national CA network. There are central systems and resources, and National projects, as well as a National/centralised quality control system, but such a large and varied organisation (actually a network of organisations) is going to vary hugely between offices/projects and even between advisers within them.

There isn't much point claiming that all of Citizens Advice is amazing, because there will be some offices/advisers that are crap. Equally there's no point writing off the entire organisation because your local office (or one adviser you spoke to one time) is crap.

WeakAsIAm · 18/05/2023 20:38

Don't rate CAB at all, went to them once, I was in 10's of thousands pounds of debt and about 7 months pregnant. The advisor looked at me like I was something nasty on the bottom of her shoe when I cried.

I was pushed onto a company to manage my debt who's main aim was to make as much money out of me as they could.

Very vulnerable people are at their mercy and the standard of advice is appalling.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 19:59

peachicecream · 18/05/2023 17:07

I don't think it's 'cited as the holy grail' but it's a decent service that is free at the point of access, certainly a good first port of call for a lot of things.

False advice?

OP posts:
peachicecream · 18/05/2023 17:07

I don't think it's 'cited as the holy grail' but it's a decent service that is free at the point of access, certainly a good first port of call for a lot of things.

Gingerkittykat · 18/05/2023 17:03

The problem is that people think CA can solve any problem, you often see people advise to go to CA for things they can't deal with.

I was a volunteer with them a few years ago, the training they provide is pretty thorough but they are not solicitors and can't deal with your divorce, get your parking ticket overturned after you have gone through the appeals process and there is a photo of you parked on double yellows or any other specialist matters. A lot of volunteers were trainee solicitors looking to get some experience and one was a retired solicitor.

They are very good with benefits and debt, there are a lot of people who need help navigating the system and talking to officials. My local office also had a paid employment advisor who took employment cases to tribunal and often won.

In my area, we sent most housing matters to a specialist housing charity.

feellikeanalien · 18/05/2023 16:51

excab · 18/05/2023 15:22

I used to be a volunteer generalist advisor. You have to be impartial and non-judgemental.
The training is very thorough and lasts over a long period of several months. They have an excellent database online, some of which is now available online to everyone: https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/

At all sessions there was someone senior to whom I could refer and the case notes on the system had to be in a set format to ensure issues were not left unaddressed.
You do not tell the client what they should do. Instead you establish a range of options and discuss the pros and cons of each, so they can make their own decision.
There was a check at a later stage as well, so other staff could intervene later if something had been missed.

This. Also a generalist adviser is not allowed to give legal advice. As others have said much of the work is helping those who struggle to deal with officialdom. Usually if legal advice is required clients will be referred to solicitors or a law centre. The trouble is that funding for law centres has been cut to the bone. CA have specialist teams e.g dealing with debt or benefits or will refer to other organisations. They can also refer clients to other sources of grants which may not be common knowledge.

Quality of advice will vary but this is also applies to qualified lawyers.

Experienced advisers, whether volunteers or not, can be very knowledgeable.

Perhaps if law centres were properly funded then there would not be such a need for people to use CA.

Bargellobitch · 18/05/2023 16:42

I don't think anyone claims they are the holy grail. But they are trained in the detail of very specific laws eg around benefits and divorce
So probably know than random people on the Internet. If you don't like them or the service don't use it.

Thelnebriati · 18/05/2023 16:40

Where have you seen people cite anything as the holy grail?

dizzydizzydizzy · 18/05/2023 16:37

My mum speaks to them often and sings their praises. The one time I phoned them, they refused to help and I burst into tears after I put the phone down.

Babyroobs · 18/05/2023 16:35

Jonei · 18/05/2023 16:24

I don't think they're particularly good. Maybe different branches do different things though.

Yes I think there's a huge variation between branches and probably between different teams at a branch.

fajitaaa · 18/05/2023 16:31

Because their advice is more likely to be correct than some randomer on the internet

Babyroobs · 18/05/2023 16:29

A lot of them are volunteers or just starting out. I worked as a benefits advisor with them and had zero experience, everything I knew I had taught myself. Within about a week of starting I was advising in a hospital setting to cancer patients ( CAB partnership with macmillan). Fortunately I knew my stuff mainly but other advisors I worked alongside were terrible and cost clients huge amounts in missed money when they failed to identify entitlement because they had little knowledge of the Uc rules. I left in the end because I couldn't sit by and watch vulnerable people misadvised and managers who were not prepared to do anything about it because they were too overworked to manage the capability process for incompetent staff.

Jonei · 18/05/2023 16:24

I don't think they're particularly good. Maybe different branches do different things though.

ohsotired2022 · 18/05/2023 16:19

I

tallsmallmum · 18/05/2023 16:04

my local one is absolutely rubbish, unsympathetic, ill-informed, gave me false information, didn't even offer me a tissue after their false information, didn't signpost me to anyone else that could help.... don't provide a 'service' if you have nothing to offer 🤦🏽‍♀️ made a complaint which they replied to pretty sharpish 😳

LakieLady · 18/05/2023 16:02

I'm a fan of Stepchange, too @Redannie118 , but their service is no use at all to people who can't cope with complex phone calls or have literacy or numeracy issues (which is most of my clients).

When I was working on a different project, we could do home visits and make the phone calls for/with them. But guess what? The funding for that service was cut several times, and they can't do that sort of work with clients any more. They have to signpost them to CAB.

LakieLady · 18/05/2023 15:55

In many areas, CAB are all there is now that there's minimal funding for advice work. They are the only organisation that delivers welfare rights advice in my entire district council area.

They are also one of very few agencies that can give advice on almost anything. This may mean that their advice on, say, housing or immigration matters isn't as expert as that of specialist agencies, but they still do a damn fine job imo.

My local CAB has a qualified solicitor working there, and some of their welfare rights workers are awesome. One at a town near me was responsible for a bit of very specific case law that is now cited by anyone in welfare rights who comes across the same issue. Their debt advisers have to be trained and accredited in order to apply for DROs and some other debt solutions (this is why my colleagues and I only do very basic debt work - we can't afford the time or the expense of training and accreditation).

There would be a lot more professionally trained advisers if the govt hadn't cut Legal Services Commission funding for a lot of advice work (loss of funding for welfare rights and housing advice led to the loss of 4 posts at one CAB I'm familiar with). And I don't think it's a coincidence that it happened at the same time as the Welfare Reform Act came in, which made everything a lot more complex and significantly disadvantaged claimants.

1offnamechange · 18/05/2023 15:54

I don't think anyone thinks of them as the Holy grail, just an accessible resource that can be fairly useful -which a majority of the time they are.

If you've got the confidence, education or knowledge to research things yourself, or the money to consult legal representation then you might not be the targeted audience. But for those that don't have those benefits there aren't many other free and comparatively accessible alternatives out there.

What would your alternative be? Avoid suggesting CA because they might not know everything or, as a first point of contact generalist be as highly trained as a specialist in whatever field? Solicitors, doctors, council workers etc are also not inflallible/all knowing and can also be wrong!

nwatty · 18/05/2023 15:36

People often come to me at my work having been directed to us by CAB having been given the completely wrong advice!

excab · 18/05/2023 15:32

squidgybits · 18/05/2023 15:28

I have found over the years that it is easier to find the information yourself rather than the faff of contacting citizens advice. They are hard to get hold of and do not have any magical information that can't be found elsewhere

This is probably true if you are an articulate person but they provide 'face to face' help for virtually anyone who turns up to ask for it.
There are many people who cannot easily cope with 'form filling'/'fighting their own corner' and CAB can and should directly help with that. They can draft letters for people as well or pick up the phone on the client's behalf. Not everyone has trusted friends or relatives who could help in this direct way.

squidgybits · 18/05/2023 15:28

I have found over the years that it is easier to find the information yourself rather than the faff of contacting citizens advice. They are hard to get hold of and do not have any magical information that can't be found elsewhere

GasPanic · 18/05/2023 15:26

gogohmm · 18/05/2023 15:23

Citizens advice are mostly well meaning volunteers, they are not geared up to deal with complex issues you need a solicitor for, they can give general advice on a wide range of issues and signpost you to specialists. If you don't like what they offer feel free to go elsewhere and pay for advice! Honestly some people here don't get that people are giving up their time to try and help.

Yes and it's always worth noting that the aim of citizens advice is not to get you to take more citizens advice.

Most of the lawyers I have spoken to have said, you need to spend more money on lawyers. I wonder why that is.

If you can use citizens advice to at least get you some idea of a situation and the outline of it before you go to see a solicitor it can save you money and be helpful in getting your thoughts straight.

twoshedsjackson · 18/05/2023 15:25

After her retirement from the Civil Service, my late DM volunteered to work for the CAB.
Mostly, she was playing to her great strength - filing! - but I remember her speaking highly of the information resources provided, and how they were updated.
Part of her training was knowing when to offer practical advice with matters such as form-filling, and when to steer clients towards an agency with more specialist knowledge.
She would have been the first to acknowledge that the advice they could give was not equivalent to a consultation with a specialist solicitor, for example.

AndTheSurveySays · 18/05/2023 15:24

Really are you sure ?

Yes .

gogohmm · 18/05/2023 15:23

Citizens advice are mostly well meaning volunteers, they are not geared up to deal with complex issues you need a solicitor for, they can give general advice on a wide range of issues and signpost you to specialists. If you don't like what they offer feel free to go elsewhere and pay for advice! Honestly some people here don't get that people are giving up their time to try and help.