Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't parents correcting their DC?

394 replies

Meili04 · 18/05/2023 12:46

I just saw the DM article about an 11 year old boy being tasered for brandishing a knife over a tantrum in burger king. The mum said they were too harsh. I've seen this in my DDs school their child is a little angel and can do no wrong. If my child is mean to another child I correct the behaviour , if they rude I do the same.
My DC is a human being with faults and isn't perfect 100 percent of the time, no person is.

Why can some parents see no fault in their child? Our responsibility as parents is to bring up DC to be functioning adults who thrive. Treating DC as mini deities does them no favours. I think parenting is becoming too gentle. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
TheyAreMyBhunasPete · 18/05/2023 19:03

azimuth299 · 18/05/2023 18:46

I agree of course that this child's behaviour was unacceptable, but that doesn't make it okay for these officers to use a taser. The child is literally backing away in the video, trying to put space between him and the police. There is no threat to the police, so tasing him was completely over the top and unjustified.

It is sad that the child has ended up in that situation though, completely unable to handle his own emotions and no coping skills for even minor inconveniences. I would suspect an underlying issue combined with piss-poor parenting.

No threat to the police/public or himself? Clearly was as he was brandishing a knife. Presumably you wouldn't be saying that had it been your child hurt by this thug. In fact, I'm sure you would be saying "something should have been done to stop him!!!!"

TheyAreMyBhunasPete · 18/05/2023 19:01

Greensleeves · 18/05/2023 14:10

The number of posts defending the use of a potentially deady taser on an 11yo child is shocking, but one must remember that there is a persistent rump of opinion on MN in favour of bringing back public hanging/the birch/caning in schools/just about anything else that involves luridly violent retribution. These people are always with us.

Meanwhile, back in the real world, of course it was an outrageous overreaction and the officers involved should be disciplined. None of them should be allowed near a potentially lethal weapon again.

I agree that parents need to guide their children and correct them where necessary. It's socially irresponsible not to, and to the detriment of the individual child who needs to know how to behave and control his/her emotions appropriately. I think there is an equally serious problem, however, with adults who have not learned to think critically or respond proportionately. Anyone who thinks using a taser on an 11yo is acceptable needs to address their own issues before having children.

What else do you think they should have done that would have meant no risk of getting stabbed? How would you like your husband coming home cut to ribbons, having lost an eye, or even worse not at all? Wouldn't like that hey? Guess it's not your problem as its not your partner/child/parent. It's mine though, he doesn't deserve to be stabbed. I hope they do it twice next time.

tiggergoesbounce · 18/05/2023 18:49

If they touched him and he struggled the family would be yelling abuse and paedos, especially if his struggling left any mark on him. There is nothing the police could have done in this situation that would not result in the family complaining bitterly while failing to take any responsibility for their demonstrably poor parenting

I have to agree.
I believe the police absolutely did the right thing, noone should be threatening anyone with a knife.

azimuth299 · 18/05/2023 18:46

I agree of course that this child's behaviour was unacceptable, but that doesn't make it okay for these officers to use a taser. The child is literally backing away in the video, trying to put space between him and the police. There is no threat to the police, so tasing him was completely over the top and unjustified.

It is sad that the child has ended up in that situation though, completely unable to handle his own emotions and no coping skills for even minor inconveniences. I would suspect an underlying issue combined with piss-poor parenting.

MustGetOnNow · 18/05/2023 18:45

It’s just so depressing. Imagine how much has already gone wrong in this child’s parenting for him to be behaving this way now. I hope he has some decent role models in his life to help him turn things around.

RobertaFirmino · 18/05/2023 18:40

I once spent a week in a psychiatric hospital. All cutlery issued with your meals was counted. It's absolutely possible to kill someone with bog standard knives and forks.

Being tasered is far preferable to a five officer takedown or rapid tranquilisation (do they still use that dreadful Acuphase?). It's much safer, with no lasting side effects.

adriftinadenofvipers · 18/05/2023 18:38

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/05/2023 18:31

Police, presumably in stab vests, should be able to get a butter knife off a child.

If they touched him and he struggled the family would be yelling abuse and paedos, especially if his struggling left any mark on him. There is nothing the police could have done in this situation that would not result in the family complaining bitterly while failing to take any responsibility for their demonstrably poor parenting.

100%.

Perhaps those who are so vocal in their support for this child-thug should have a look at the figures for knife-crime in this country - and compare those statistics to the figures relating to people who have died after being tasered.

As for whether the police reacted proportionately or not - I don't know. I wasn't there, and neither were any of you. I'd rather let the investigation do its job.

microloewe · 18/05/2023 18:36

Honestly being a police officer myself. Tasering to me is far better than going hands on and having to use offensive techniques such as baton strikes and taking to the ground. It ends it quicker, minimal injuries and quite often a lesson learnt for the future. I of course realise mine may be a an unpopular opinion but it is lot better than punching a kid in the face because he tried to bite you when you try to grab 'only a butter knife' from them.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/05/2023 18:31

Police, presumably in stab vests, should be able to get a butter knife off a child.

If they touched him and he struggled the family would be yelling abuse and paedos, especially if his struggling left any mark on him. There is nothing the police could have done in this situation that would not result in the family complaining bitterly while failing to take any responsibility for their demonstrably poor parenting.

Testino · 18/05/2023 18:31

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 18/05/2023 15:14

It's been reported that the boy has learning difficulties ( no other details are given).

Usually posters on here are falling over themselves on here to diagnose any misbehaving child and excuse their behaviour. Why is this different? Some of the comments about him on here are disgusting

Learning difficulties doesn't make someone brandish a weapon. Learning difficulties doesn't make someone immune to self-defence tactics by attack when he's caused others to not feel safe.

This is a direct cause and effect situation that most people will understand and hopefully learn to avoid in the future, even some people with learning difficulties.

CMZ2018 · 18/05/2023 18:30

he got off lightly

MustGetOnNow · 18/05/2023 18:28

I do think it seems over the top behaviour from the police.

The problem with these situations is that the mother can say what she wants, but the police have to keep confidentiality and not give their side of the story at this stage.

So in this tabloid article, we never know what the facts really are.

Towelie · 18/05/2023 18:26

I think it's good if its being investigated, I'm not sure uploading a live stream of your vulnerable and distressed son on tik tok and then going on social media to give half the story is overly effective though. If the police were wrong in this then I hope they're brought to task through the appropriate channels and by people that know all of the facts.

I have a sibling who has GDD and they would have been distressed by being disarmed physically or tasered, there isn't really a perfect way for it to be handled that won't distress them. Crux is though that it's still not acceptable to be carrying a knife and raising it, not just for the sake of others (I don't think if people were to be harmed to have a loved one stabbed they'd say ah its fine they couldn't help it); but for their own sake- raise it around the wrong person and sadly it might be a huge and fatal mistake.

Something does need to be done about knife crime, for an 11 year old to be carrying a knife on their person (which going by what the mother has said be must have been to have it) and then to raise it to the police (appreciate with GDD it's not always as straightforward) that's also learned behaviour.

You can't have it all ways- want to cut knife crime, violent men and whatever else but be super lenient when they're young. I do agree the lack of support for children and for parents with GDD and other conditions is woeful, but again, I really don't think it's something people would just accept as fine if they were harmed.

Nicknacky · 18/05/2023 18:25

I’m gonna repeat. It has not been confirmed it was “just” a butter knife. The mum is saying that but it is not confirmed.

Testino · 18/05/2023 18:24

Gentle parenting is bollocks.

It's not gentle parenting. There's gentle parenting and there's 'permissive parenting' or

'take no accountability for your actions' parenting or

'the world revolves around you and must make all sorts of accommodations for you and nothing is your fault because you are/have x,y,z and it's too hard to teach you right from wrong because of it' parenting or

'I can't be arsed to do a thorough job of parenting so I'll let my child do whatever and say I'm gentle parenting' parenting.

They're not the same.

Oldnproud · 18/05/2023 18:24

SoTired12 · 18/05/2023 16:29

Of course, all bad behaviour must be down to being ND.

The gangs of children roaming around terrorising people must all be ND too.

That is not what I was saying at all.

There is a huge difference between gangs of children - or individual children - who set out (armed) to terrorise people, and a child who reacts so irrationally to a situation that would to the average NT child be at worst a bit upsetting. Add to that that his 'weapon' was just a butter knife, and without more details I think his profile is much closer to that of an ND child than either a spoilt, badly-parented or off-the-rails NT child.

Flufferblub · 18/05/2023 18:22

Lucky he wasn't in America, the police would have shot him.

Testino · 18/05/2023 18:18

takealettermsjones · 18/05/2023 14:38

You seem angry with me, I'm not sure why, but I'll answer anyway. Two separate occasions. I'm a martial artist, I used to be a special and I also used to volunteer with a charity that did outreach work with the homeless. Both incidents happened while doing work for the charity.

That wasn't the point, though, I was just saying that I'm surprised the taser was the first port of call here, that's all.

I doubt the police are generally trained in martial arts though, although I think they should be.

I agree with de-escalation tactics first before deploying lethal or potentially lethal weapons but that's not how it is.

Brandishing a dangerous or potentially dangerous weapon comes at a heavy price and the boy is lucky he isn't dead (out of self-defence). They did what they could and if he was holding a proper knife or a gun, he'd still have used it. Hopefully now he knows not to use anything as a weapon.

Garethkeenansstapler · 18/05/2023 18:17

Howdoidoit100 · 18/05/2023 17:47

I support the police on this. They need to come down hard. If he can't be controlled at 11, how will he be in a few years?!

Exactly. Mumsnet wants ‘zero tolerance’ for male violence and aggression, but how can this happen when all we do is tolerate and make excuses for teens or older children showing scary behaviour that would have them locked up if they were 5 years older?

Nothing magical happens the moment you turn 18 which suddenly means you’re capable of self control. It’s a learned process so lessons need to happen earlier on

Nicknacky · 18/05/2023 18:15

Gtsr443 · 18/05/2023 17:29

There were 5 large fully trained coppers in stab vests with extendable batons and PAVA spray but discharging the taser at an 11 year old with an intellectual disability in an empty space was their only option was it?

Please tell me you are not suggesting using a baton or pava would have been preferable in your eyes?

Garethkeenansstapler · 18/05/2023 18:15

I imagine this is a child with a lot of needs that are not being met

Burger King isn’t a ‘need’.

Regardless, I’m tired of ‘unmet needs’ being wheeled out for every act of poor behaviour. Everyone has needs. The officers. His mum. The public around him. We can’t solely focus on the individual especially when they pose a threat to others.

MushMonster · 18/05/2023 18:14

Sorry OP, but surely you cannot draw any conclusions on general parenting from someone who says they were too harsh on their 11 year old for tasering them when the showed a knife in a public place.
That one is a nut case. And that is why the child has gone rogue. Maybe there is more to the story and further reasons for them being this disfunctional and dangerous. Because they are dangerous.

LeonardBobby · 18/05/2023 18:10

8counts · 18/05/2023 18:05

A grown man with a machete though, not a boy with a butter knife.

Sure, a machete being used by a stronger person would be more likely to cause serious injuries, but not sure how a smaller knife would somehow be confined to the area covered by a stab vest.

CornishTiger · 18/05/2023 18:10

Can anyone link the video please?

Testino · 18/05/2023 18:07

He's lucky he wasn't shot. If it was the US, that would be likely.

Brandishing a knife comes with a price, for others' safety.

Swipe left for the next trending thread