Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous

87 replies

WinterBree · 18/05/2023 11:30

Im jealous of a friend of mine and I really don’t know why.

We’re both mid twenties with 2 children of similar ages (all under 4) and met in work probably around 6/7 years ago now.

Me and my partner own our home and both work full time. We do opposing shifts to save on the childcare. We are slowly doing the house up and whilst I love it it’s been hard work. Money is a little tight, we’re not struggling as such but purchases definitely have to be considered/saved for. I also have a bit of debt built up from paying for home improvements (new windows etc as ours were really old)

My friend took voluntary redundancy after having her youngest, I did request this also but wasn’t allowed. She had a nice pay out. She was living in a council flat but got moved to a brand new 3 bed house and has done it up as well as the garden. She is also entitled to quite a lot of benefits and doesn’t need to go back to work. Her other half does work but doesn’t earn a massive wage (I only know as he works where my other half used to). She’s always buying new clothes. On about a brand new car etc.

I just feel like we get penalised for working and owning a house. I know we are lucky in so many ways and I am grateful my kids will be able to hopefully have some money from the house to make them comfortable when the time comes. It just seems unfair that we have to scrimp and save and miss out on time with the kids. She doesn’t have it easy in some ways, her other half is very unhelpful compared to mine and she lost her mum so I do feel bad for feeling this way as she has had a rough few years. It’s got to the point though where I don’t really want to be around her as all she does is talk about what new things she is buying and what she can spend money on. AIBU?

OP posts:
TokyoStories · 18/05/2023 14:40

@Throwncrumbs

If you own your own home you are forever spending out on repairs and maintenance. They also pay council tax and a mortgage which you get no help with if you become unemployed. People in council houses get all the repairs and maintenance free and if unemployed don’t pay council tax and get the rent paid for them.

So sell your home, give the money to charity and put yourself on the council house waiting list? 🤷‍♀️

Throwncrumbs · 18/05/2023 14:17

Alargeoneplease89 · 18/05/2023 12:37

Exactly this!

Why not give up your house, job and do the same ... nothing stopping you having the "life of luxury"

If you own your own home you are forever spending out on repairs and maintenance. They also pay council tax and a mortgage which you get no help with if you become unemployed. People in council houses get all the repairs and maintenance free and if unemployed don’t pay council tax and get the rent paid for them. It’s no wonder people who have a good work ethic get pissed off with the unfairness of the system that they pay into via tax deductions but get fuck all back when they need it! The whole system needs a good looking into and stopping the benefits lifestyle of certain individuals!

krustykittens · 18/05/2023 14:13

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 14:09

If I had my time again I would love to do a social/personal experiment of exactly this.

I would liquidate all my assets, travel around the world in 5 star luxury until they ran out, come back to the UK and live the benefit lifestyle.

I think it would make a fascinating book and if I was in my 20s I do it in a heartbeat.

I do actually know someone who did this! They had a partner and two kids. Bought a house and had nightmare neighbours, so they sold the house, took the money and moved to Malta where they lived the high life for two years. They came back to the UK, potless, partner got a job as a bus driver. As a council worker, they were placed on the list for a council house. They waited seven years and just as they got to the top of the list, he quit! She begged for the council to house them anyway and they were offered a three bed flat in a local estate. She hated it but the council told them they could take it or leave it and if they left it, they would be off the list. She took it and hated it. The experience did not work out well for them but of course, it was the council's fault.

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 14:09

krustykittens · 18/05/2023 12:39

You know the answer, OP, give up your job and the house you own and go on benefits. And if you don't want to, maybe ask yourself why?

If I had my time again I would love to do a social/personal experiment of exactly this.

I would liquidate all my assets, travel around the world in 5 star luxury until they ran out, come back to the UK and live the benefit lifestyle.

I think it would make a fascinating book and if I was in my 20s I do it in a heartbeat.

NadjaCravensworth1 · 18/05/2023 14:05

The comparison isn't helpful. Is she really a friend? There are millions of ppl in her situation, and I'm sure many many of them would be jealous of yours. You have worked hard and are incredibly lucky to own your own house at 24 and you will reap the rewards. If she is really a friend then stop judging her, if she isn't then cut her out and stop letting her lifestyle bother you.

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 13:58

CreationNat1on · 18/05/2023 11:53

Comparison is the thief of joy.

I m in mid 40s, bought young, had my kids in my 20s and am now financially stable and in 4 more years kids will be all uni age. In time they will be well provided for, there will be something available for them.

My friends who lived on benefits all their lives and never worked are now intensely bitter, they have nothing to provide for their children, never modelled a work ethic to them, spent their lives doing arts and crafts and at home DIY, have no pensions, have resentful partners, and have strained relations with their children. The lifelong SAHMs want their children to contribute to the home expenses, but the SAHMs of now adult children refuse to work themselves (mid 40s), and bitterly expect the world to provide for them.

Don't be jealous, your friend is living in a bubble, that won't last. Maybe distance yourself from her, if you need to.

Lol at the uncanny “arts and crafts” reference - I think we must know the same people!

I had to distance myself from 2 particular friends who were living their best, jammiest lives on benefits while I slogged away.

Particularly when my children came on the scene. It was a bitter pill to swallow that I made the wrong choice in choosing a man who stuck about rather than running off into the sunset with big daddy government!

LucyIoo · 18/05/2023 13:57

You're comparing chalk and cheese.

You will own your property. She will own new clothes.

If you'd rather own the new clothes and not the house then make that choice. I guarantee you won't though, in reality your friend is likely jealous of you owning your own home when she probably never will.

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 13:54

Same.

The government wants to push fathers out of the home and make life on benefits as attractive as possible.

They don’t want independent, free thinking, property owning citizens. So you get financially penalised.

Sissynova · 18/05/2023 13:48

@CreationNat1on
My friends who lived on benefits all their lives and never worked are now intensely bitter, they have nothing to provide for their children, never modelled a work ethic to them, spent their lives doing arts and crafts and at home DIY, have no pensions, have resentful partners, and have strained relations with their children. The lifelong SAHMs want their children to contribute to the home expenses, but the SAHMs of now adult children refuse to work themselves (mid 40s), and bitterly expect the world to provide for them.

Jesus with friends like you who needs enemies!
‘Spent their lives doing arts and crafts’ 🙄
All sahm’s have bad relationships with their children, have resentful partners and their children turn into 40 year olds who refuse to work?
What pile of shit are you spouting?
Such a depressing view of the worlds. Honestly it comes across as you being the bitter one to be so negative and judgemental about your so called friends.

FrownedUpon · 18/05/2023 13:40

You’ll be much better off when your mortgage is paid off. She’ll be paying ever increasing rent forever. You’ll own an asset worth 200k+ or however much.

You also have the freedom to move wherever you like & buy any house you choose within budget. She’s stuck in social housing. I’d much rather be you.

Surgarblossom · 18/05/2023 13:29

Never be jealous of others and what they have because you really do not know how they have acquired them.

Whatiswithallthisracket · 18/05/2023 13:18

They say comparison is the thief of joy but it doesn't make the feelings go away. I have a similar situation at the minute. I hate my job, I'm constantly broke, seem to be in an endless cycle of bad luck whereas my friend, who I do love dearly (so feel like a cow for feeling like this and do realise I'm being unreasonable) has drifted from job to job and has had a huge payout and always seems to land on her feet. I'm trying so hard to focus on the positives in my life but I'm so depressed at the moment that I can't seem to do so and just focus on what is going wrong for me but right for her and, like you, I'm finding it difficult to be around her.
I don't know what to do or what advice to give you. You are being unreasonable, you know this. So am I. I don't know how to stop it though.

GalileoHumpkins · 18/05/2023 13:13

Virtually the same income

Well, seeing as everyone on MN is on 6 figures I'd like to know how you've come up with this bollocks.

TokyoStories · 18/05/2023 13:10

@onefinemess

I have always thought that "benefits" should be conditional, you should have to "earn" your payout. For example, one year of work gets you one month of benefit payments.

You do realise there are benefits for different things, right? Many claimants have disabilities or complex, long-term health problems that limit their ability to work.

Virtually the same income, but without the hassle of a job.

Do you have a job? And if so may I ask why if you can receive the same income without the hassle of one?

onefinemess · 18/05/2023 13:04

Unfortunately OP, living on benefits is usually more comfortable than working.

Virtually the same income, but without the hassle of a job.

I have always thought that "benefits" should be conditional, you should have to "earn" your payout. For example, one year of work gets you one month of benefit payments. Something like that. But your "benefit" could also be claimed whenever you want, even while you are working, you could trade your time "earned" for the cash instead, you would decide when your benefit entitlement is paid.

It would provide an incentive for those claiming benefits to find a job in order to build up more "time", also, those who are working wouldn't mind people claiming benefits as the workers would be entitled to the same thing.

But, being able to live permanently on benefits is just taking the piss.

strawberryandcreams · 18/05/2023 12:57

Not working for me is the worst.
Boring repetitive and no purpose.
No pension contributions.
Don't own their own home
Benefits aren't massive if it's a 2 person household and one is in work.
Who wants to rely on the government for hand outs.
You have no idea how they will pay for a brand new car. They didn't have new windows to pay for etc etc.
You have no idea about other people's finances so you can't comment.
If you don't want to work as much, ask for part time. If you can't afford it, it's nothing to do with your 'friend'. Her getting benefits doesn't change your finances.

HatchetJob · 18/05/2023 12:51

I think it must be hard to be working all the time and see people living in a similar situation with similar disposable income and not having to work. I think it’s understandable.

however, their life won’t improve, your life will change. Your children grow up, work changes, you get more money/freedom.

DD went to a primary where I’d say a huge percentage didn’t work. I’ve been called a ‘mug’ for working, even though - I wasn’t entitled to benefits/was significantly better off than them.

One mum I knew had never really worked. She still doesn’t (I don’t know how) she does a few hours a week to top up her benefits. She was really unhappy when her eldest left as she had to pay bedroom tax. Her life seems incredibly small, she does so little. She is so bored all the time and fills her days wandering about town. I don’t know what she will do if her youngest leaves home as she will have to leave her 3 bed house then. I think her friendship group has shrunk as children go to secondary more of them are working. Her life is not enviable in the end.

Whiteroomjoy · 18/05/2023 12:50

HowDoYouDoWhatYouDoToMeIWishIKnew · 18/05/2023 12:09

They really are.

All SAHMs have shit relationships with their unemployed children who don't know what work ethic is. Ffs I've read some shit on here but that one is reaching for sure.

She won't get heaps in benefits, if she has over a certain amount left from her payout she won't get anything at all. If her husband is on a crappy wage then she isn't buying new clothes and a new car on his wages and benefits, it would likely be from the redundancy money.

Her home is rented, you can easily move into a nice rental property and sell your house if you think it's so great.

Do her a favour and stop being friends with her.

This. If she had a nice redundancy package it’s all pretty much gone now if she’s now getting benefits.
I would assume she’s using store cards, buying stuff on the never never and building up debt, if she can afford all this new stuff on benefits .
id be much more likely to be just rolling my eyes at friends silly spending habits then being jealous.

MammaTo · 18/05/2023 12:49

It’s probably very raw right now because you’re in the trenches of life in general and managing work, kids and a house.

However you are setting yourself up for a secure future. The council could move your friend into a smaller house at their own will. God forbid anything happened to her or her partner they would probably have to move to a smaller house to free up this one.

You have security.

Your kids also see you working day in day out and it gives them a solid work ethic.

krustykittens · 18/05/2023 12:39

You know the answer, OP, give up your job and the house you own and go on benefits. And if you don't want to, maybe ask yourself why?

Alargeoneplease89 · 18/05/2023 12:37

TokyoStories · 18/05/2023 12:21

So she:

doesn't own her own home and might never

doesn't have a job so may be limited in any future career

A very unhelpful partner

A mum who died so she has limited support and is no doubt still grieving

Is entitled to 'quite a lot of benefits' despite her payout so I'm assuming it's something like PIP and she/her DC has/have a disability

Meanwhile you:

Have your own home in your mid 20s (more than most people that age and beyond could dream of)

A supportive partner

(Presumably) both your parents still alive so likely emotional, practical and financial support

A career

Enough money to do up your house

Financial security for your children

And you're jealous of her? Grow up.

Exactly this!

Why not give up your house, job and do the same ... nothing stopping you having the "life of luxury"

AllIeveknewonlyou · 18/05/2023 12:34

She might be putting up a brave front to feel better about herself. I really think you are reacting like this as you're tired and believe she has it easier.

beachcitygirl · 18/05/2023 12:32

Stop benefit bashing. You are a miserable person and with your attitudes, always will
be.
Nothing that your 'friend' has in any way,shape or form takes away from you. I feel sorry for you.

TokyoStories · 18/05/2023 12:31

I'm so sick of benefit bashing. Started the day with an article in the Times about applications for sickness benefits rising. Regrettably read the comments section 100% of which, at the time I read it, was people complaining they were milking the system, lazy and simply didn't want to work. It pissed me off so much that I phoned the Times' customer service and cancelled my subscription, making it clear why.

Every day there seems to be a new thread on here about recipients of benefits and how unfair it all is, or someone wanting to report a 'friend'.

I'd love to see these people walk in the average benefits claimants' shoes. They wouldn't last a month.

fajitaaa · 18/05/2023 12:25

This is ridiculous