Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous

87 replies

WinterBree · 18/05/2023 11:30

Im jealous of a friend of mine and I really don’t know why.

We’re both mid twenties with 2 children of similar ages (all under 4) and met in work probably around 6/7 years ago now.

Me and my partner own our home and both work full time. We do opposing shifts to save on the childcare. We are slowly doing the house up and whilst I love it it’s been hard work. Money is a little tight, we’re not struggling as such but purchases definitely have to be considered/saved for. I also have a bit of debt built up from paying for home improvements (new windows etc as ours were really old)

My friend took voluntary redundancy after having her youngest, I did request this also but wasn’t allowed. She had a nice pay out. She was living in a council flat but got moved to a brand new 3 bed house and has done it up as well as the garden. She is also entitled to quite a lot of benefits and doesn’t need to go back to work. Her other half does work but doesn’t earn a massive wage (I only know as he works where my other half used to). She’s always buying new clothes. On about a brand new car etc.

I just feel like we get penalised for working and owning a house. I know we are lucky in so many ways and I am grateful my kids will be able to hopefully have some money from the house to make them comfortable when the time comes. It just seems unfair that we have to scrimp and save and miss out on time with the kids. She doesn’t have it easy in some ways, her other half is very unhelpful compared to mine and she lost her mum so I do feel bad for feeling this way as she has had a rough few years. It’s got to the point though where I don’t really want to be around her as all she does is talk about what new things she is buying and what she can spend money on. AIBU?

OP posts:
ADHDmam · 21/05/2023 11:37

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 19/05/2023 13:09

Brilliant, good on your parents! It is criminal that inheritances are taxed at all when income tax and NI has already been paid on those earnings. Plus savings interest will have been taxed.
It’s also criminal that when older people get sick and need care they have to use their slogged-for assets to pay for it, while those on benefit lifestyles from the age of 18 get everything handed to them.
Hopefully your parents will remain in full health but they should also transfer any assets over to you asap so they can claim state funded care if they need it. They’ve paid NI all their lives I’m sure, so it’s time to get something back.

Transferring all assets over to get state funded care is a role of the dice and not recommended.

You can be investigate for deprivation of assets, and if you need care, you’ll be classed as having notional capital, and it will NOT be funded.

and let’s be honest, when you’re in your 60s, mortgage free and about to reach your dotage with foreseeable care needs as you age… the LAs - who are working on threadbare budgets - WILL look at all ways to get out of funding care packages to ensure the meagre budget DOES go to those who need it most.

TwoManyKids · 21/05/2023 07:46

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 13:58

Lol at the uncanny “arts and crafts” reference - I think we must know the same people!

I had to distance myself from 2 particular friends who were living their best, jammiest lives on benefits while I slogged away.

Particularly when my children came on the scene. It was a bitter pill to swallow that I made the wrong choice in choosing a man who stuck about rather than running off into the sunset with big daddy government!

Ah so now we turn in single parents...

Shirty48 · 21/05/2023 07:34

Drivesafe · 18/05/2023 14:57

You are allowed to feel how you feel. She is entitled to the benefits she receives.

If you are not enjoying her company and her friendship anymore that is okay just distance yourself and get on with your life.

If she is too sick to work or has a very disabled child then yes I agree she is entitled to her benefits. If not then she needs to work, staying at home when your kids are little is a lifestyle choice and it’s not right that the govt fund it.

autienotnaughtym · 21/05/2023 07:27

TokyoStories · 18/05/2023 12:21

So she:

doesn't own her own home and might never

doesn't have a job so may be limited in any future career

A very unhelpful partner

A mum who died so she has limited support and is no doubt still grieving

Is entitled to 'quite a lot of benefits' despite her payout so I'm assuming it's something like PIP and she/her DC has/have a disability

Meanwhile you:

Have your own home in your mid 20s (more than most people that age and beyond could dream of)

A supportive partner

(Presumably) both your parents still alive so likely emotional, practical and financial support

A career

Enough money to do up your house

Financial security for your children

And you're jealous of her? Grow up.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

HepzibahSmyth · 21/05/2023 06:53

You should end the friendship. She deserves much better than a “friend” like you.

caringcarer · 20/05/2023 22:54

The hardest years are always the hardest OP. I really struggled when my children were all small. I couldn't afford to give them the things I wanted to and DH And I both worked full time. Now the mortgage is paid off, the children are grown up and I find I can afford more or less anything I want. I have friends where only one parent worked and the other stayed home or only worked a very few hours each week and are really worried now, about how they can afford to put their DC through uni because they never earned enough to save. You will be in a much more comfortable position when your DC are ready to go to Uni. Just focus on you and your little family.

Liorae · 20/05/2023 22:41

Ladysassy · 20/05/2023 22:35

Just think one day you will have payed for your house outright but she will for ever be paying rent.

OP might lose her house through circumstances, her friend/rival may buy. I don't have a crystal ball, do you?

Ladysassy · 20/05/2023 22:35

Just think one day you will have payed for your house outright but she will for ever be paying rent.

Liorae · 19/05/2023 16:41

LucyIoo · 18/05/2023 13:57

You're comparing chalk and cheese.

You will own your property. She will own new clothes.

If you'd rather own the new clothes and not the house then make that choice. I guarantee you won't though, in reality your friend is likely jealous of you owning your own home when she probably never will.

I know two couples who used the council house years to save a deposit for a house of their own. Most couples in their mid 20s are renting privately, making it harder to save and less secure. Renting in your 20s does equate to never owning your home.

They may have a plan about which the OP knows nothing.

Scottishskifun · 19/05/2023 16:13

I don't think your jealous as such more exhausted with the situation of caring for small children whilst working full time and currently money is not going as far as you would like it to. Plus the fact you put in for voluntary redundancy and didn't get accepted means you directly see "what could have been" with spending more time with your youngest.

Long term however its much harder to get back into the workplace and your still paying into a pension.

Comparison is a joy thief and you might find she is going on about new things to buy because she might be bored with day to day life!

readbooksdrinktea · 19/05/2023 15:58

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 18/05/2023 11:56

🙄These 'disguised' benefit bashing threads are so fucking tedious.

Aren't they just?

Holdontightly · 19/05/2023 15:57

It’s got to the point though where I don’t really want to be around her as all she does is talk about what new things she is buying and what she can spend money on.

Have a little think about why that might be.

I wonder what you talk about when you're with her, and if you engage in a lot of droning on about stuff she doesn't have. Like your living parents, or your decent partner, or your career.

SmashedApricot · 19/05/2023 15:55

But a council tenancy isn't for life anymore. Once DC leave him then I believe you have to downsize. How do you know she doesn't envy you ?

Holdontightly · 19/05/2023 15:54

She doesn’t have it easy in some ways, her other half is very unhelpful compared to mine and she lost her mum so I do feel bad for feeling this way as she has had a rough few years.

It's fairly disgusting OP that you just casually throw this bit in near the end of your post. As if it doesn't really count.

You are inhumane and massively emotionally immature if you do not realise how devastating it can be to lose a parent.

Holdontightly · 19/05/2023 15:51

It’s probably very raw right now because you’re in the trenches of life in general and managing work, kids and a house.

Having children is a choice. Buying a house is a choice too, and a nice one.

The friend didn't choose to have her mother die.

If she's getting DLA or PIP, as the OP said she gets a fair bit in benefits - she didn't choose for her kid or herself to be disabled.

The friend is going through parental bereavement with a shit partner who doesn't help and uncertain job prospects, but yes the OP is the one feeling raw and hard done by Hmm

Actually I think this thread is a stealth boast by OP to say "Wow look how well I'm doing! My life is great compared to the shitshow of my friend!" Except she can't say that to the friend, so she's coming here instead.

Wimpeyspread · 19/05/2023 15:24

Jealousy is always unreasonable

DrManhattan · 19/05/2023 15:19

Don't spend time with people who make you feel rubbish. I have zero time for people who go on about what they have bought/ showing off etc. Its as boring af

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 19/05/2023 13:09

towriteyoumustlive · 18/05/2023 16:00

My parents are doing something similar-ish.

They're SKI-ing: Spending Kids Inheritance!

Since their retirement age 61, they downsized their house to something cheaper, and have since been on extravagant holidays twice a year to see the world. Their aim is to reduce their assets below the inheritance tax threshold as they feel it is unfair to be taxed after their death on earnings that had already been taxed!

@WinterBree at least in 25 years time you can be rent and mortgage free and have plenty of free cash to do what you want once your kids are grown up, or have money to help the kids pay for university. So you may feel somewhat jealous now of your friend having enough money to live without working, but you need to see the bigger picture.

Brilliant, good on your parents! It is criminal that inheritances are taxed at all when income tax and NI has already been paid on those earnings. Plus savings interest will have been taxed.
It’s also criminal that when older people get sick and need care they have to use their slogged-for assets to pay for it, while those on benefit lifestyles from the age of 18 get everything handed to them.
Hopefully your parents will remain in full health but they should also transfer any assets over to you asap so they can claim state funded care if they need it. They’ve paid NI all their lives I’m sure, so it’s time to get something back.

towriteyoumustlive · 18/05/2023 16:00

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 14:09

If I had my time again I would love to do a social/personal experiment of exactly this.

I would liquidate all my assets, travel around the world in 5 star luxury until they ran out, come back to the UK and live the benefit lifestyle.

I think it would make a fascinating book and if I was in my 20s I do it in a heartbeat.

My parents are doing something similar-ish.

They're SKI-ing: Spending Kids Inheritance!

Since their retirement age 61, they downsized their house to something cheaper, and have since been on extravagant holidays twice a year to see the world. Their aim is to reduce their assets below the inheritance tax threshold as they feel it is unfair to be taxed after their death on earnings that had already been taxed!

@WinterBree at least in 25 years time you can be rent and mortgage free and have plenty of free cash to do what you want once your kids are grown up, or have money to help the kids pay for university. So you may feel somewhat jealous now of your friend having enough money to live without working, but you need to see the bigger picture.

Drivesafe · 18/05/2023 14:57

You are allowed to feel how you feel. She is entitled to the benefits she receives.

If you are not enjoying her company and her friendship anymore that is okay just distance yourself and get on with your life.

krustykittens · 18/05/2023 14:56

@CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption She was another mum at primary school, so we were not close friends but she seemed very depressed about it all. They had been living a lifestyle well beyond their means and was very down that it was all over. It did make me wonder if you are better off NOT knowing how the other half live? But her notion that her present, less salubrious circumstances was all down the council was very irritating. She kept saying that as they had children and a dog they should have been given a semi d with a garden in a nicer area. She certainly didn't have a philosophical attitude!

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 14:55

TokyoStories · 18/05/2023 14:40

@Throwncrumbs

If you own your own home you are forever spending out on repairs and maintenance. They also pay council tax and a mortgage which you get no help with if you become unemployed. People in council houses get all the repairs and maintenance free and if unemployed don’t pay council tax and get the rent paid for them.

So sell your home, give the money to charity and put yourself on the council house waiting list? 🤷‍♀️

I’m literally this close 🤏 to doing this. I made a huge mistake in buying my flat rather than going on the council waiting list.

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 18/05/2023 14:52

krustykittens · 18/05/2023 14:13

I do actually know someone who did this! They had a partner and two kids. Bought a house and had nightmare neighbours, so they sold the house, took the money and moved to Malta where they lived the high life for two years. They came back to the UK, potless, partner got a job as a bus driver. As a council worker, they were placed on the list for a council house. They waited seven years and just as they got to the top of the list, he quit! She begged for the council to house them anyway and they were offered a three bed flat in a local estate. She hated it but the council told them they could take it or leave it and if they left it, they would be off the list. She took it and hated it. The experience did not work out well for them but of course, it was the council's fault.

Very interesting! She should write a book about her experience.

I’d love to be offered a free/super cheap 3 bed flat. I don’t care about how shitty the estate is as I’ve seen and lived it all.

Colourfulpens2 · 18/05/2023 14:52

I think long term she will be in a much worse position than you.

She sounds a bit materialist and not beeing able to see what's coming.

What is her plan for retirement? How will she support financially her kids in their late teens/adulthood years?

I think you have nothing to be jealous of to be honest... especially her DP!

Alargeoneplease89 · 18/05/2023 14:50

Throwncrumbs · 18/05/2023 14:17

If you own your own home you are forever spending out on repairs and maintenance. They also pay council tax and a mortgage which you get no help with if you become unemployed. People in council houses get all the repairs and maintenance free and if unemployed don’t pay council tax and get the rent paid for them. It’s no wonder people who have a good work ethic get pissed off with the unfairness of the system that they pay into via tax deductions but get fuck all back when they need it! The whole system needs a good looking into and stopping the benefits lifestyle of certain individuals!

I dont expect people to pay for my house if I become unemployed because I have equity in my property therefore I have some form of money. It's crap I would have to sale and use that money to bridge the gap but I'm thankful I have something.

Most people don't have to sale and have something to give their children. People on low incomes/benefits (let's remember most people on benefits WORK) will never have anything to pass on.

Anyone thinking it's the life of luxury have every opportunity to life that way... it amazes me how people moan about the lifestyle never take it up.