Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moan about reward systems at school - I know IABU really

109 replies

Howmuchdoyousleep · 18/05/2023 09:19

School has a merit system where for every 10 merits you get a certificate bronze, silver, gold, ruby etc that sort of thing.

DD was upset last night as most in the class are way ahead of her. Including DC who are not well behaved and in fact have been quite mean to DD this year. DD is quiet, well behaved, able and works hard and honestly I think gets overlooked. I've said all the right things to her that doing well is for her alone really and that merits are given to people who try to improve their behaviour etc. Having another child with additional needs, I know that DD is lucky to be able to work hard and do well.

But in all honesty I think it rubbish to not acknowledge the ones who work hard day in day out - it is very demotivating for them. DD has had a difficult year with a lot of medical problems this year and could do without this comparison as she really values school and wants to do well. Surely if you have a reward system it should be done to motivate all not just those at the top and bottom.

OP posts:
Libra24 · 18/05/2023 20:38

Definitely say something! I was your daughter and it was very hurtful seeing kids who managed to keep it together get awards and treats for things I did all day every day. I was in advanced classes with older children for some subjects and so I didn't get recognition in my peer group and I didn't get it in the older peer group either because, duh, I was much younger. It's so demotivating and I don't feel like it helps much at all.

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 18/05/2023 18:49

Howmuchdoyousleep · 18/05/2023 09:19

School has a merit system where for every 10 merits you get a certificate bronze, silver, gold, ruby etc that sort of thing.

DD was upset last night as most in the class are way ahead of her. Including DC who are not well behaved and in fact have been quite mean to DD this year. DD is quiet, well behaved, able and works hard and honestly I think gets overlooked. I've said all the right things to her that doing well is for her alone really and that merits are given to people who try to improve their behaviour etc. Having another child with additional needs, I know that DD is lucky to be able to work hard and do well.

But in all honesty I think it rubbish to not acknowledge the ones who work hard day in day out - it is very demotivating for them. DD has had a difficult year with a lot of medical problems this year and could do without this comparison as she really values school and wants to do well. Surely if you have a reward system it should be done to motivate all not just those at the top and bottom.

Playing devils advocate here but how do you know exactly that she is quiet, well behaved and working as hard as others? Are you there in the classroom watching her? Have you seen the other students work to compare how well she is doing amongst peers? Or are you just assuming that’s the case because teachers have never said otherwise? For all you know she could be quiet, but also a bit lazy and often daydreaming and not listening, but manages to do just enough work to get through without concerns. Unless you have actually watched her in class, you really do not know what she is really like there.

I can’t speak for other teachers, but I always make sure the quiet, well behaved and just get on with it students get my merits first (secondary though)

PonkyPonky · 18/05/2023 18:33

Totally agree with you. They’re using the rewards to motivate the most disruptive like ‘well done for going 45 minutes without violence, you get a kindness award’. But my DS who is always kind and has never once physically hurt another child… nothing. The one’s that are no trouble are always overlooked as they just aren’t on the teachers minds as much as the others. It’s completely flawed

CastleTurrets · 18/05/2023 18:26

For anyone interested in exploring this issue further I highly recommend, "Punished by Rewards" by Alfie Kohn.

It's a fantastic book about how damaging rewards systems are in school and is backed up by research.

If it were up to me I'd completely abolish rewards systems in schools (with the exception of some children with SEN).

YouWonJayne · 18/05/2023 18:04

I completely agree with you OP.

My DD isn’t very academic. She has to try really really hard to be clever, but her effort is amazing and her kindness and manners are second to none.

But these rewards are academic based and she never gets anything. It makes me seethe

Ringmaster27 · 18/05/2023 18:01

We had similar at my DCs old school.
A reward system where they’d earn “golden time” (30 mins on a Friday afternoon to do whatever fun activity they choose) after so many merit points earned.
There was a couple of kids in the class, no special needs (I was friends with one set of parents so I know this to be the case), just some pretty horrendous behaviour and violence towards other kids.
DD would come out and say stuff like “J got 5 merit points because he didn’t hit anyone today” 😑😑👍🏻
Whereas she or any other child in the class who behaves well majority of the time and completes their work etc would have to do something spectacular to earn 5 merit points in one fell swoop. Whereas this kid was earning points for behaving the same way every other child in the class manages to behave every day? 🤨 Rubbed quite a few parents up the wrong way because it seemed like one rule for one and another rule for everyone else resulting in a fair few DCs (my Dd included) feeling like “what’s the point in putting in extra effort when it’s not recognised anyway” 🤷🏻‍♀️
It’s crap.
I made a point of doing something special with DD at home instead when she’d done really well at something that wasn’t recognised by the school point system.

WheelsUp · 18/05/2023 17:49

I think that all kids need some recognition. When my kids were in infants, being the kid who doesn't even get their turn at Star of The Week made them feel like their teacher didn't even like them which is sad when they wanted to be liked by their teacher. Children might not need the certificate but hearing their teacher complement them on their work, effort or behaviour does them a lot of good.
I was that parent who had to tell the teacher that they'd forgotten my child this school year so that they'd get Star of the Week at least once. They went to a school where at least one boy and one girl received the award every Friday so my child should receive it at least once per school year.

longtompot · 18/05/2023 17:46

Yanbu. My yd used to be frustrated at the naughty kids getting rewards for behaving for a short period of time when she behaved like that the whole time, and she is now 23. Rewarding them for behaving how they should didn't seem to change their behaviour either, not in the long run. They were like it the whole time I knew of them at school.

Cloud9Super · 18/05/2023 17:35

Totally agree, I’ve got a mature, quiet, well behaved one. Guess who gets all the glory/merits/awards? Yep, the ‘less well behaved’ boys 😠

RelaxingClassics · 18/05/2023 17:12

At my kids school they have a merit and a demerit system. Kids get awards for most merits but the demerits don't cancel out a merit. So one kid gets 30 merits but 45 demerits and another kid gets 29 merits and no demerits and the kid with the 45 demerits still wins the prize. It's utter nonsense. The kids all laugh about it because they know it makes no sense.

RelaxingClassics · 18/05/2023 17:09

I hate reward systems...in case you couldn't tell. 😁

RelaxingClassics · 18/05/2023 17:09

It might actually be understandable if there was lots of evidence to show that giving awards, rewards etc to kids who struggle with behaviour, bullying etc had any impact in their behaviour but i can't seem to find anything that conclusively says it does. So for me the only purpose this serves is to make some children feel excluded and to cement the idea in other children that their self-worth and value is.wrapped.up.in external sources of reward.

The argument "but it's ok cos these kids are traumatised/learning disabled/ADHD/ASD/from shitty families" is rubbish.... Let's stop giving these kids pieces of paper saying star pupil ( because they're not stupid and they know they are being manipulated) and actually tackling the real issues that they face and the reasons that the education system and social services (where relevant) are failing them.

aSofaNearYou · 18/05/2023 16:47

@Eastie77Returns I know what you mean. Personally I think it can be hard to predict what the outcome will be until years later, but it can all have an effect on our psyche during those formative years.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/05/2023 16:27

I wouldn’t be shy to politely mention it to the teacher. They’ve got so many kids to think about, they can easily let one or two fly under the radar.

Eastie77Returns · 18/05/2023 16:09

aSofaNearYou · 18/05/2023 15:47

Hmm I can't fully agree with this. I think the attitudes we develop in school as kids can have profound effects on the trajectory our lives take. Ambivalence, demotivation, a sense of bitterness towards authority figures can have long lasting effects.

It's a bit of a minefield but I do think it matters.

I think if it’s offset by parental input and reassurance at home (and sounds as if OP is doing this) then it’s fine. I’d drive home the message that you may not always get recognition but it shouldn’t stop you doing your best. Well this is what I tell my kids anyway. They receive awards for attendance etc but the Good Behaviour type merits tend to go to the disruptive kids when they occasionally behave well. I don’t want them to walk around with a burning sense of injustice over it all.

No idea if it’s the right approach but I currently work with people whose sense of worth is aligned to the mentions they get from senior managers or if they receive ‘Colleague of the Quarter” and it’s not great. They seem genuinely distressed if they are not acknowledged.

MelonsOnSaleAgain · 18/05/2023 16:03

It is possible to do it right. Our school have a system of positive points for good behaviour and negative points for bad behaviour.

mat the end of each half term if you have only received positive points you get an award certificate. It captures all the consistent kids who just get on being decent. It works well.

Then they do a weekly award for most positive points earned by someone on each class as well.

aSofaNearYou · 18/05/2023 15:47

Eastie77Returns · 18/05/2023 15:15

“My life was ruined because I didn’t receive enough awards for good behaviour at school” Said no adult. Is this really that important?

And would you rather have a well behaved, hard working child who misses out on these rewards or a child who has behavioural issues, is frequently in trouble (which means you are constantly contacted by the school), cannot focus in class but gets merits?

Be careful what you wish for. Both my children fall into the former group btw and rarely receive recognition at school for their efforts. Plenty at home. They are 7 and 9. Primary school will be a distant memory soon enough so I can’t summon the energy to get upset about this.

Hmm I can't fully agree with this. I think the attitudes we develop in school as kids can have profound effects on the trajectory our lives take. Ambivalence, demotivation, a sense of bitterness towards authority figures can have long lasting effects.

It's a bit of a minefield but I do think it matters.

mumof2many1943 · 18/05/2023 15:18

I feel for you Howmuchdoyousleep it is the quiet and reserved children that get forgotten. We did get good treatment for DD who has Down Syndrome who was so lucky to attend mainstream school, she was quiet and a bit shy. The school went out of their way to include her and got several awards . Perhaps you should encourage your DD to be mischievous (joke😜) Good luck

Eastie77Returns · 18/05/2023 15:15

“My life was ruined because I didn’t receive enough awards for good behaviour at school” Said no adult. Is this really that important?

And would you rather have a well behaved, hard working child who misses out on these rewards or a child who has behavioural issues, is frequently in trouble (which means you are constantly contacted by the school), cannot focus in class but gets merits?

Be careful what you wish for. Both my children fall into the former group btw and rarely receive recognition at school for their efforts. Plenty at home. They are 7 and 9. Primary school will be a distant memory soon enough so I can’t summon the energy to get upset about this.

AlwaysTheGoodGirl · 18/05/2023 15:06

Oh OP this drives me mad. It is so frustrating when the quiet children get overlooked just because they get on with it and don't go round screaming and shouting.

@Unexpecteddrivinginstructor yes, Sam is completely correct! My ds has noticed this from day one, and when we read the newsletter at the end of the week, he always comments on Achiever of the Week as being 'previously shan, but slightly less shan this week.'

Very demotivating.

Daffodilmorning · 18/05/2023 14:17

I’d speak to the teacher about how their reward system is demotivating your child. Sometimes it’s good for children to see us challenge unfair systems.

Howmuchdoyousleep · 18/05/2023 13:59

@Unexpecteddrivinginstructor 🤣That is funny. Sam was clearly a very bright child to spot that and act on it🤣

@BridgetRandomfuck it's so unfair isn't it! This is what I told my daughter last night. Not to be mean to the others, but long term her hard work and aptitude will pay off and be a lot more worth it than a few stars on a chart. Hard for an 8 year old to look that far ahead though ☺️

OP posts:
HatchetJob · 18/05/2023 13:57

My experience is this doesn’t continue into secondary. If it worked it would. You get parents who are furious at having to come in and deal with their child’s behaviour as it’s not been tackled in primary.
Its not teachers fault, the system is wrong entirely.

BridgetRandomfuck · 18/05/2023 13:39

It's been going on for decades! I still remember coming bottom of the class star chart back in the 80s in primary. I was a quiet, well-behaved, clever girl who never caused any trouble - I was also had undiagnosed autism, which I'm pretty sure was why teachers overlooked me. It was a pattern throughout my school career. Still, my first class degree and MPhil from Cambridge more than makes up for the lack of a few stars. Not bitter, honest 😁

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 18/05/2023 13:29

When mine were little a teacher called me over and said that 'Sam' had been misbehaving recently, which was not typical and did I know why. I asked if she had asked Sam, who was standing right next to me. She said no, so I asked Sam who said it was because to get the reward (which by this time most others had got) you had to first be naughty for a while and then once the teachers had noticed that they then had to see you doing something good so they would reward you. Sam just hadn't had a chance yet to be good because they were still being naughty. Sam was the next child to get the reward.

I would talk to the teacher and say how demotivated she is by the reward system and is there anything else that they can suggest that she does to gain rewards because she is eager to please the teacher.