Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A moan about reward systems at school - I know IABU really

109 replies

Howmuchdoyousleep · 18/05/2023 09:19

School has a merit system where for every 10 merits you get a certificate bronze, silver, gold, ruby etc that sort of thing.

DD was upset last night as most in the class are way ahead of her. Including DC who are not well behaved and in fact have been quite mean to DD this year. DD is quiet, well behaved, able and works hard and honestly I think gets overlooked. I've said all the right things to her that doing well is for her alone really and that merits are given to people who try to improve their behaviour etc. Having another child with additional needs, I know that DD is lucky to be able to work hard and do well.

But in all honesty I think it rubbish to not acknowledge the ones who work hard day in day out - it is very demotivating for them. DD has had a difficult year with a lot of medical problems this year and could do without this comparison as she really values school and wants to do well. Surely if you have a reward system it should be done to motivate all not just those at the top and bottom.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LolaSmiles · 21/05/2023 07:53

The injustice certainly continued into my secondary. The feral kids who managed to keep their nose clean were taken out of lessons to go go-karting once a week.Those of us who were always well-behaved got nothing.
I've always said that those sort of things need to be clearly thought through.

When done well, it's possible to have some pastoral intervention that also includes mentoring and soft skills development to help prepare students for the real world. Part of that might involve a trip where they have to learn collaboration or how to disagree, and even a rewards trip because for some students they simply don't have the same social and emotional skills as their peers.

When it's not done properly it becomes a fun trip out for the students who are rude to staff, disrupt lessons, and are unpleasant to their peers. It's a horrible slap in the face to all the other pupils who do the right thing most days, and staff who have to endlessly deal with the poor behaviour.
It's totally demotivating when you repeatedly raise concerns about a student's behaviour, not much is done, and then one day the pupil bounds into your room saying "I'm not in on Friday. Mr Bloggs is taking us painballing if we don't get a detention all week".

DdraigGoch · 21/05/2023 07:42

HatchetJob · 18/05/2023 13:57

My experience is this doesn’t continue into secondary. If it worked it would. You get parents who are furious at having to come in and deal with their child’s behaviour as it’s not been tackled in primary.
Its not teachers fault, the system is wrong entirely.

The injustice certainly continued into my secondary. The feral kids who managed to keep their nose clean were taken out of lessons to go go-karting once a week. Those of us who were always well-behaved got nothing.

Howmuchdoyousleep · 20/05/2023 23:30

@Aonbheanach I think you are probably right about ditching the rewards all together. Then my DD would be content with a simple well done or knowing she has done her best etc.
My other DD is at secondary now. She gets lots of merits (partly because she has additional needs) half the time she has no idea why she has been awarded them. So they are fairly meaningless to her too although she gets a lot. A simple well done for X,y or z would have a far greater positive impact on her self esteem/confidence as then she would know what she has been praised for.

OP posts:
RelaxingClassics · 20/05/2023 00:44

Aonbheanach · 20/05/2023 00:14

I am a primary school teachers and don’t have any reward systems or weekly awards for this very reason. It is used to encourage children who need lots of help with behaviour but realistically does nothing to help overcome their difficulties - just teaches them to try to please and ignore what causes it. The other children who deserve it all the time are demoralised and feel unseen, I hate them and finally put my foot down this year and stopped doing them altogether. I would speak to the teacher about it, or send an email to the principal with your concern about the entire system- I am sure many parents feel the same way!

👏👏👏 Thank you.

Aonbheanach · 20/05/2023 00:14

I am a primary school teachers and don’t have any reward systems or weekly awards for this very reason. It is used to encourage children who need lots of help with behaviour but realistically does nothing to help overcome their difficulties - just teaches them to try to please and ignore what causes it. The other children who deserve it all the time are demoralised and feel unseen, I hate them and finally put my foot down this year and stopped doing them altogether. I would speak to the teacher about it, or send an email to the principal with your concern about the entire system- I am sure many parents feel the same way!

elliejjtiny · 19/05/2023 14:47

RelaxingClassics · 19/05/2023 09:49

So reward systems become another way of stigmatising and othering children who need extra support. So they create a situation where either -

The quiet, well behaved, more resilient children (who actually may also be neurodivergent, disabled, have shit home lives), are told to quietly look on at the "special" children who "NEED" the recognition more than they do.

Or

They are just lead to believe throughout their whole school experience that nothing they did was good enough to be recognised.

No one is served well in that system. True empathy is not about rewarding children with difficulties for coping better in a challenging environment. True empathy is about recognising what makes the environment challenging for the child and changing it.

In theory (I know this doesn't always work) the teachers should be aware of the quiet well behaved children who are working hard despite being disabled, living in temp accommodation, being a young carer etc and award points accordingly.

ChekhovsMum · 19/05/2023 12:25

Encourage a culture of self-appraisal, both at home and at school. No rewards, and no taking notice of rewards when they are given out. The children who grow up really self-motivated are the ones who don’t need an adult opinion or praise - they know when they’re learning and improving without it.

The children who are constantly up in the teacher’s face with ‘is this picture good, Sir?’ or ‘can I have reward points for opening the door for you?’ become the adults who only ever do anything good when someone’s watching, or there’s something immediately in it for them.

Justanotherrandomusername · 19/05/2023 11:57

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 19/05/2023 06:47

sense of bitterness towards authority figures this definitely describes Sam now, but it will all be fixed when Sam is prime minister 🤣. Sam has also been very intrinsically motivated from then on, which is not necessarily a bad thing.

I like the sound of Sam. I was one of the naturally gifted kids at school and realised very early on I wouldn't get house points because none of my work required enough effort so effectively opted myself out of the system 🤣. By 8 years old when I told my mum I only got 18/20 got my spelling test and she offered to help me, I replied "I got 2 wrong on purpose because if you get them all right they give you 25 words next week". I agree these reward systems are demotivating for the majority, but my academic record of maximum achievement gradings and minimum effort gradings became a matter of pride, and has transitioned perfectly to the workplace where I get paid a very good salary for a relatively easy job.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 19/05/2023 11:54

Well behaved children can be fighting all kinds of battles too. This is a lazy excuse for rewarding the naughty children

Exactly this. I grew up in a naice MC home but both parents were abusive alcoholics and my life was miserable. I worked my arse off to avoid bringing attention to myself and to the situation.

Never got recognised for anything - the merits, stars, rewards all went to the boys who’d managed not to thump someone for 13 minutes, and had “difficult home lives”.

It reminds me of the way that women internalise anger and trauma and hurt themselves whereas men externalise and hurt others. Possibly because boys are raised to think slightly less thumping other people is worthy of celebration, whereas girls can seethe quietly for years and nobody pays a damn bit of notice.

Florin · 19/05/2023 10:50

The house points motivated him but that has quickly moved over to the reward being his result so it has worked. For example they do times table tests every week, 60 questions every week he was getting in the 20’s so they motivated him with house points to do better. He worked on them to get better now every single week he get 60 out of 60, and it’s the score and his running streak that motivates him just last night he was telling me how proud he was of the number he has got full marks in a row while he studied hard for his science test next week which he is also determined to do well in. They were just a kick start.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 19/05/2023 10:43

It's so tough for the quiet, we'll-behaved kids. My DD was overlooked throughout primary school while we watched really badly behaved kids racking up merit points for award certificates.

It was obvious to all that the badly behaved kids were being given merit points just to sit down and be quiet. Anyway... it's clearly never changed. Just keep boosting your DD and definitely say something to the teacher.

RelaxingClassics · 19/05/2023 10:35

musixa · 19/05/2023 10:23

On the positive side, it prepares the children excellently for the world of work, where systems of reward vs performance are even more arbitrary.

I don't think this true at all. It's not preparing the children who struggle. I would not hire someone or keep someone in employment because they tried hard for a couple of weeks. I need people who are excellent, focussed and able and consistent. So the child who got lots of praise and rewards at school despite poor behaviour or ability are just not going to see that continue in the real world.

The punitive stuff is also not carried through to real life. Children who are punished for things like lateness, wrong uniform, disorganised belongings often thrive outside the school system because they can access employment in creative industries or can work for themselves. They can still also go to whatever parties or outings they like. So showing children what the natural consequences of their behaviour are is probably much more effective.

RelaxingClassics · 19/05/2023 10:29

@Florin but what is the longer effect of this kind of motivation? What happens when the points and weekly certificates stop? They are not helping with his underlying inability to focus. Many children with ADHD/ASD become very focussed because of reward charts but sometimes (and you know your child better than anyone) what we see as success in terms of improved behaviour, better focus is actually coming at a cost to the child in terms of their mental health and underlying stress levels. What is it about the environment of the classroom, or the subject matter or how it is being taught that makes it more or less difficult for a child to cope with? Making learning as easy and enjoyable and safe for all children should be the priority.

musixa · 19/05/2023 10:23

On the positive side, it prepares the children excellently for the world of work, where systems of reward vs performance are even more arbitrary.

Florin · 19/05/2023 10:21

I am the Mum of that kid that gets all the house points. He has adhd and struggles to focus. He lives for house points and they have turned him around he is top of the league and he now works hard studies hard to get full marks in tests, focuses and looks for things he can do to be helpful and be kind to others which helps him and the rest of the class. For some kids they do really work however I am under no illusion that he is the best in the class because of the house points. However we also do have to accept he isn’t picked for the big part in the play, when only a few kids are picked for something it is never him etc which is hard on him and us.

bingbangbongding · 19/05/2023 10:20

Yeah these kind of systems are designed to incentivise the kids who are normally troublesome. What it leads to is the average kids feeling disenfranchised. I get it.

brunettemic · 19/05/2023 10:15

Things like this are really difficult and I sometimes wonder if schools should just do away with these things. No matter what they do someone will always be left out of it. Completely understand where you’re coming from. DH is a teacher and has said being a “middle of the road kid” is almost the worst position to be as they get the lease attention. I’m not saying your DD js middle of the road!

RelaxingClassics · 19/05/2023 10:09

Reward systems are used in secondary schools. And they are just as arbitrary, demotivating and nonsensical as the primary school equivalents.

Merits and demerits are common in high schools. The problem being that only some teachers (usually the ones who struggle with classroom control) use them more frequently than others. There is no consistency to their allocation. So at the end of the year when the whole year is measured against each other, children who have teachers who throw them about like confetti are rewarded but the children who have teachers who don't buy in to it don't.

High schools often have less rewards but more punitive scoring systems. Things like lateness, or having the wrong p.e. kit can result in not being allowed on a school trip or not being allowed access to the school prom. So children and young people who have poorer organisational skills (sometimes as a result of undiagnosed neurodivergence) are punished in a way that children who have poorer language or mathetic skills are not.

If we start to see ALL behaviour through the lens of ability, skill and learning you start to see how ridiculous behaviour rewards and punishment systems are.

RudsyFarmer · 19/05/2023 10:07

I can still remember the Effort Cup awarded at my primary and the upset it caused when I tried my hardest every week/month/term and it went to someone else. I did win it once though!!

My advice is explain to your daughter that merit points will be given out for all sorts of reasons. Some children have more of a struggle to attain results or sit still and some of those points will be awarded for behaviour that your daughter finds easy. Then go on to say how proud you are of her and maybe even set up your own reward system at home where you can control her stars and make sure great behaviour or academic successes get rewarded.

My children understand a lot of the house points are given as carrots for good behaviour and sometimes the more unruly children have the most points. I think this stuff is accepted more readily by my older child than my younger child as a sense of injustice is felt more strongly by the little ones.

Having said ALL of that I will say of you genuinely feel your child is being overlooked and it’s really making her feel terrible please talk to the teacher. No teacher/school is setting out to upset children and I’m sure a quiet word would see the situation resolved.

HatchetJob · 19/05/2023 09:58

Also it just doesn’t seem to work. It’s why it’s not continued into secondary school.

It sets some children up to failure. I was involved in the permanent exclusion of a year 7 boy, early in the term. They had been told in class numerous times, in assemblies, about not doing something. He did it anyway. He didn’t understand there was a consequence to his actions and kept asking about going on a trip the next week. One of the schools I was in used to be extra hard on year 7 as they were so entitled and not used to getting in trouble for anything.

The worst behaved child in DDs class (lovely parents, lovely home life) just ran wild as there was no consequences (including from his mum to be honest who spoiled him). He was very violent to my friends child and they were going to do nothing until my friend said she would go to the police/governors. He was then picked to go to a special event out of school a week only a few children were going to, got sent home after a few hours because of his behaviour. It does them no favours.

RelaxingClassics · 19/05/2023 09:49

elliejjtiny · 19/05/2023 08:57

This exactly.

So reward systems become another way of stigmatising and othering children who need extra support. So they create a situation where either -

The quiet, well behaved, more resilient children (who actually may also be neurodivergent, disabled, have shit home lives), are told to quietly look on at the "special" children who "NEED" the recognition more than they do.

Or

They are just lead to believe throughout their whole school experience that nothing they did was good enough to be recognised.

No one is served well in that system. True empathy is not about rewarding children with difficulties for coping better in a challenging environment. True empathy is about recognising what makes the environment challenging for the child and changing it.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 19/05/2023 09:27

Based on this thread, I’m going to tell my dc that actually I’d be worried if they started coming home with awards.

elliejjtiny · 19/05/2023 08:57

mumarooni · 19/05/2023 08:44

When I was a teenager, I moaned to my mum about why the naughty kids got more good behaviour rewards than the good kids once. My mum told me 'fair' isn't everyone getting the same, or even everyone getting what they have earned. 'fair' is everyone getting what they need. Some kids had higher needs for behaviour rewards, maybe not getting praise at home, maybe not self-awarw of the value of good behaviour, maybe impulsive behaviourscaused by SEND, past trauma or learned habits that I didn't have to overcome. She told me I had no right to be jealous because the fact my behaviour was already ok meant I had a huge headstart for an easy happy life, in the scheme of life, let them keep the gold stars and good luck to them. It really stuck with me.

This exactly.

aSofaNearYou · 19/05/2023 08:55

mumarooni · 19/05/2023 08:44

When I was a teenager, I moaned to my mum about why the naughty kids got more good behaviour rewards than the good kids once. My mum told me 'fair' isn't everyone getting the same, or even everyone getting what they have earned. 'fair' is everyone getting what they need. Some kids had higher needs for behaviour rewards, maybe not getting praise at home, maybe not self-awarw of the value of good behaviour, maybe impulsive behaviourscaused by SEND, past trauma or learned habits that I didn't have to overcome. She told me I had no right to be jealous because the fact my behaviour was already ok meant I had a huge headstart for an easy happy life, in the scheme of life, let them keep the gold stars and good luck to them. It really stuck with me.

This is the reality and it sounds like your mum put your mind at ease, but I think with primary aged kids parents might be reticent to tell their kids the truth about the awards in case they blab to the recipients, telling them the award doesn't really count and is just because they're usually rubbish. As a result, the well behaved kids often go years not realising that and thinking their teachers genuinely like those kids best and think they have done the best.

FluffMagnet · 19/05/2023 08:51

It has been going on decades. I recall complaining to my mum about the very same thing when I was in Yr 5. She was a teacher in the same school and was very open with me about the utter ridiculousness of the whole thing and how it means diddlysquat in the long run. I'd say be honest with your child - she probably already "gets" the system and just wants you to acknowledge it is silly and she is not less deserving than her peers.