Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to provide childcare

182 replies

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 08:27

I have 1 DS who’s about to start full time school in September.

Since my DS was born, I have had very little help with childcare. We’ve spent a fortune reducing hours, paying nursery fees and DH and I have managed reasonably well to juggle things.

Im a civil servant and will be changing to working term time only from September.

I have one sister who has 4 children. 2 teens and 2 younger. My sister has always managed to work full time, has never had to pay for any childcare and has always relied on help from our parents, her in laws and whoever else will help her. Their joint income is a lot higher than ours.

She announced yesterday that she’s glad I’m going to be working termtime as it means she won’t have to worry about childcare in the school holidays.

I told her that I won’t be providing childcare during the school holidays and now she’s not speaking to me. Am I being mean?

OP posts:
feralunderclass · 18/05/2023 11:46

"That's great Tracey, I'll be needing extra money now that I've reduced my hours. Going rate is £30 per day but I'll accept £25 seeing as we are family".

Send her this text, she'll never ask you again.

Crucible · 18/05/2023 11:44

Sounds like you really care about your Mum OP. Good on you. I really do admire your stance and your sacrifices. Stand firm. X

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 11:41

Thanks for all your replies. We’re quite close but she has form for CF behaviour. I wouldn’t say she’s the golden child but everyone tends to tip toe around her for an easy life.

She doesn’t like not getting her own way and she has a tendency to throw her toys out of the pram.
I think she assumed I would help to relieve the pressure on our mum and her mil who currently do all her childcare.

I don’t have a mil, and my mum doesn’t drive so she wouldn’t be able to help me out with school runs etc which is why I’ve gone term time only. My sister lives closer and my mum lives within walking distance of her younger kids school.

I haven’t had any help as I didn’t want to burden my mum with anymore children. She does let my sister walk all over her though.

If there was a reciprocal agreement then I’d maybe be a bit more open, but I’m not prepared to make sacrifices for my family and help her out when she wouldn’t do it for me.

OP posts:
intakeofanaverage · 18/05/2023 11:39

Her time at work is worth money and is valuable. Your time is also valuable. So unless she wants to share some of her wages with you then no, YANBU to say no. She is being unreasonable to ask.

Queenfreak · 18/05/2023 11:38

Wow! Your sister is very presumptuous!
Helping someone out occasionally, or 1 day a week if you feel like it!, is a kind gesture. Having 2-4 kids dumped on you working hours 5 days a week is a piss take.
I had 1 child, and I wouldn't want another now. She's 6, and I absolutely love the time we get together. No way would I have someone dump their kids on me and spoil that!

ZuckerwatterMaus · 18/05/2023 11:34

No way ! I am a teacher so have holidays with ds 7 . We spend our days doing things that interest him , going places he likes and watching films for his age group .Add 4 kids of different ages into the mix and the quality time with your own child will be gone . I would not even do it for money . Time is more valuable to me .

towriteyoumustlive · 18/05/2023 11:31

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 08:27

I have 1 DS who’s about to start full time school in September.

Since my DS was born, I have had very little help with childcare. We’ve spent a fortune reducing hours, paying nursery fees and DH and I have managed reasonably well to juggle things.

Im a civil servant and will be changing to working term time only from September.

I have one sister who has 4 children. 2 teens and 2 younger. My sister has always managed to work full time, has never had to pay for any childcare and has always relied on help from our parents, her in laws and whoever else will help her. Their joint income is a lot higher than ours.

She announced yesterday that she’s glad I’m going to be working termtime as it means she won’t have to worry about childcare in the school holidays.

I told her that I won’t be providing childcare during the school holidays and now she’s not speaking to me. Am I being mean?

YANBU!

Your sister sounds rather entitled, so you might need to have to spell this out to her.

I'd contact her and say something like "sorry if you're disappointed that I won't be able to help with childcare in school holidays, but I have taken a huge salary sacrifice to be able to work term time only so that I have can quality one to one time with my child which I wouldn't be able to do if I had another 4 children in the house. I'm sure I'll be able to help occasionally if you cannot find an alternative and we have no plans. x"

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 11:24

Fruitful82 · 18/05/2023 10:38

Odd that the sister asked given clearly not close. Clearly these are sisters aren’t exactly spending afternoons chatting over coffee together.

odd that the op even cares that her sister isn’t talking to her

Not odd at all on the first one. That’s classic cheeky fucker cheeky fucker-ing. Being close to someone isn’t a requirement for attempting to take advantage.

but yes, I would encourage OP not to worry about it and enjoy the silence.

JaneBeyre · 18/05/2023 11:17

No, you're not being mean.

Darling sister needs to realise that you are not there to support her family, and she is not there to support yours. They are two separate households and any time you have off work is yours to enjoy. How would it even work having kids over during the holidays - fights, constant food requests, monitoring screens, getting everyone out of the house. Nightmare.

She needs to understand the concept of boundaries.

And well done for saying no. Let her sulk.

TheChoiceIsYours · 18/05/2023 11:11

Mari9999 · 18/05/2023 11:03

OP, your sister was quite presumptuous; however I can't imagine refusing to help my sister simply because no one ever helped me.

You honestly can’t imagine not volunteering to look after four children for free every school holiday? It wouldn’t occur to you that this is now your time to spend with your son and enjoy the fruit of your hard work that has got you to this point? It wouldn’t occur to you not to give that up and spent 13 weeks a year wrangling four kids for your sister who apparently goes through her life scrounging from others?

If that’s true then sorry but that would make you a bit of a doormat!

Riverlee · 18/05/2023 11:08

Stick to your guns. Don’t even say you’ll have them in ‘an emergency’ because that gives her a get-out for not finding suitable cover.

sueelleker · 18/05/2023 11:05

Tell her you'll provide exactly as much childcare as she did for you.

Mari9999 · 18/05/2023 11:03

OP, your sister was quite presumptuous; however I can't imagine refusing to help my sister simply because no one ever helped me.

JudgeJ · 18/05/2023 11:01

She announced yesterday that she’s glad I’m going to be working termtime as it means she won’t have to worry about childcare in the school holidays.

I know a few teachers who have had this problem, family, friends thinking Whoopee, free summer childcare! A friend's son was told by his sister that she was so pleased he was marrying a teacher, That's holiday childcare sorted!
When we were both teaching we would often offer to have our niece and/or nephew for days out etc but it was always on our invitation, not their parents' demand.

Beautiful3 · 18/05/2023 10:56

If they're on a high income then they can afford holiday club. I would have said the same as you. You've sacrificed your pay to spend time with your child, not for theirs!

ModestMoon · 18/05/2023 10:52

Absolutely insane. My holidays with my children are so I can spend quality time with my children. I miss them so much during the regular working day. There is no way that I would want to divide my attention between them and someone else's child, let alone 4 of them. If she had massively helped out with childcare so that you could keep working I'd see her point, but it doesn't sound like that's the case. Tell her to jog on.

purplecorkheart · 18/05/2023 10:51

What a major CF. Glad that you nipped this in the bud now. Be wary of her asking you to do the odd day at short notice as other child care has fallen through. I can see her trying that tack.

mincedtart · 18/05/2023 10:49

Far too many people think they for some reason shouldn’t have to pay for childcare like the rest of us. Maybe you could also pay her mortgage and bills?

fajitaaa · 18/05/2023 10:44

There are ways of asking and this isn't one of them

Meeting · 18/05/2023 10:44

Classic CF behaviour

WomanUnknown · 18/05/2023 10:43

She’s a CF

Enabled on all sides. Good on you for standing your ground- I wouldn’t put up with that.

Fruitful82 · 18/05/2023 10:41

Bloomin heck… a journalist?! Quiet day on the news front if that’s the case! 😂

Chiccaletta · 18/05/2023 10:41

Unbelievably entitled cheeky assumption.
Leave her stew, she'll come around eventually when she realises her expectations are ridiculous and how lucky she's had it so far. (Just might take a year when she gets bitter about holiday club fees)
And prepare to also fight off pleas from grandparents who also desperately want to get rid of the summer holiday childcare burden now they are getting older and tired.
Similar issue with our family as older "entitled" sister had her kids when my parents were younger and more capable of babysitting so she had 100% free childcare and used hem as much as she could. Now the rest of us have had our first kids, my parents are older, tired, grandbaby novelty worn off and cant keep up one of my toddlers let alone take on all the grandkids so we've never used them for any childcare whatsoever, they're done, that's it.
It's not fair but can't be helped.
Hold steady through this.

(Extra ammunition if needed: you can't EVER book cheap last minute holidays if you are committed to sisters brood's childcare, you'll have lost all flexibility. And it's not fair on your partner, they didnt sign up to this either. They could never WFH/relax on their annual leave/early finishes. And you dont own a mini bus to take everyone out everyday)

Shinyandnew1 · 18/05/2023 10:40

TheOrigRights · 18/05/2023 10:26

Is this another post where the OP (journalist?) just wants to create a bit of a frenzy and won't come back?

If it's true then the OP is a bit dim if she thinks one single person will say "yes you are being mean"

Oh, I hope not!

@Fluffyfluffs any context about your relationship here?

piedbeauty · 18/05/2023 10:38

What a CF! No, you're not being mean at all.

She has all the kids - she needs to sort childcare for them. Some people are just unbelievable.