Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to provide childcare

182 replies

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 08:27

I have 1 DS who’s about to start full time school in September.

Since my DS was born, I have had very little help with childcare. We’ve spent a fortune reducing hours, paying nursery fees and DH and I have managed reasonably well to juggle things.

Im a civil servant and will be changing to working term time only from September.

I have one sister who has 4 children. 2 teens and 2 younger. My sister has always managed to work full time, has never had to pay for any childcare and has always relied on help from our parents, her in laws and whoever else will help her. Their joint income is a lot higher than ours.

She announced yesterday that she’s glad I’m going to be working termtime as it means she won’t have to worry about childcare in the school holidays.

I told her that I won’t be providing childcare during the school holidays and now she’s not speaking to me. Am I being mean?

OP posts:
Grumpyfroghats · 18/05/2023 15:50

I wouldn't get involved in explaining yourself, she will keep coming up with arguments but it's your time, your decision. And I wouldn't even offer the odd day or if an emergency because it's clear she will take advantage

Grumpyfroghats · 18/05/2023 15:42

How old are her younger ones? She is almost at the point where her 16 year old could look after them some of the time - e.g. for a couple of hours at the end of the day to take the strain off the grandparents

michymommy · 18/05/2023 15:37

aloris · 18/05/2023 13:36

I would also do quite a bit for my sister. But let's be honest, my sister would never ask me to look after 4 kids for a whole summer vacation because my sister is not a user. The fact that she's not a user, is why I would do stuff for her, because I know she would try to reciprocate and I know she would respect my time and effort.

That is not what's happening here. This sister has known CF tendencies, is asking WAY over what's reasonable, and is unlikely to ever reciprocate even a small amount of it.

From what I read in the original post and the subsequent comments I read where people were saying she should pay etc. that was my conclusion. I don’t believe in charging to help with childcare UNLESS it’s going to be a financial burden for me for example we were going abroad and taking the extra kids or going on days out that cost more than a few quid.

I would also look after my sister’s kids for her to go on Holiday or for her to go to an event etc because we have that relationship.
If my sister called me today and said “Hey I’m going to France could you have the kids Friday to Sunday” (she did this in in April because her friend got discounted Eurostar tickets) I would say sure no problem.

I work from home and both my SIL and Sister work in child protection so don’t get school holidays off and I regularly have 6 kids on top of my 4 in my house on school holidays, it’s manic but it’s family and I wouldn’t have it any other way.

Our system works because it’s fully reciprocated if it’s not then hell to the bloody no I wouldn’t do something for someone who is a selfish AH.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 18/05/2023 15:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Funkyslippers · 18/05/2023 14:57

You're completely in the right here. Don't let her make you feel guilty. If she'd asked politely you possibly could have helped out occasionally but I can not bear people who assume things instead of asking. Cheeky cow

Fruitful82 · 18/05/2023 14:53

We’re quite close

😐

Allhailkingcharlie · 18/05/2023 14:49

Say no. Even if she offers to pay you. Which I doubt she will

FlamingoQueen · 18/05/2023 14:42

Please don’t say about being paid, she may decide that’s okay and then you have no comeback. Just say no. The reason you are term time is for your own benefit - say you are really looking forward to the freedom - being able to get up one morning and go out for the day or just spend the day in pj’s if you want.
Perhaps offer one day at Christmas so she could do some Christmas shopping and then have another day when she does the same for you. Just make sure you have your day first, otherwise it won’t happen.

aloris · 18/05/2023 14:42

Sounds like she's an expert at mental mind-games. Beware because in the next few days she may think up some ideas to counteract the boundary you have just set.

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 14:40

Definitely a super-CF. What did she say when you told her no, @Fluffyfluffs

She tried guilt tripping about easing the burden on the grandparents and how families should help eachother out. I pointed out that I’ve had very little help with my DS. She told me that having just 1 child is easier and cheaper than having 4. I did point out that it was her choice to have 4 which didn’t go down too well.

It would only be the two younger ones that she would want help with as the older two are 16 and 13. I don’t mind helping anyone out occasionally if it’s really needed, in an emergency etc. but I don’t want a regular commitment and want to enjoy the school holidays with my DS.

I did feel a bit bad that I’m in a position where I could help and wondered if I was being selfish by not helping. Glad you agree I’m not.

OP posts:
WhatFlavourIsIt · 18/05/2023 14:37

I actually don't think it's that cheeky. If I was off for the summer I would definitely help my sister out and she would do the same for me.

Bedtimemode · 18/05/2023 14:34

1104 votes and 100% yanbu! That has to be a record

TeeBee · 18/05/2023 14:11

Shinyandnew1 · 18/05/2023 10:20

My sister did similar. She was even thinking of moving closer to me so I could help them with childcare

Blimey-CF!!

How did that conversation go?!

I laughed at her and said 'you've got to be fucking joking!!!'

mistlethrush · 18/05/2023 14:04

As she's got 4 children, a more even share might be for you to take her children for one day after she's had yours for 2 days - and then not take them again until she's looked after yours for 4 days... I mean, you only have one child, so 1/4 of the work (based on her reasoning).

aloris · 18/05/2023 13:36

michymommy · 18/05/2023 13:33

I think it’s rude she just assumed you would without even asking first.

HOWEVER if I was in a position to help my sister I would absolutely do it without question.
When I was a lot younger and in college I used to pick up my niece from nursery and take her home, feed her and look after her until my sister came from work at around 9pm all free of cost.
In my opinion it takes a village and I wouldn’t feel comfortable making my sister pay for something I could do for free.

I guess it also depends on the relationship you have with your sister as well, would she do it for you?

I would also do quite a bit for my sister. But let's be honest, my sister would never ask me to look after 4 kids for a whole summer vacation because my sister is not a user. The fact that she's not a user, is why I would do stuff for her, because I know she would try to reciprocate and I know she would respect my time and effort.

That is not what's happening here. This sister has known CF tendencies, is asking WAY over what's reasonable, and is unlikely to ever reciprocate even a small amount of it.

michymommy · 18/05/2023 13:33

I think it’s rude she just assumed you would without even asking first.

HOWEVER if I was in a position to help my sister I would absolutely do it without question.
When I was a lot younger and in college I used to pick up my niece from nursery and take her home, feed her and look after her until my sister came from work at around 9pm all free of cost.
In my opinion it takes a village and I wouldn’t feel comfortable making my sister pay for something I could do for free.

I guess it also depends on the relationship you have with your sister as well, would she do it for you?

PeopleAreShit · 18/05/2023 13:32

I love that you have 100% YANBU votes!

She can pay you the going rate for all 4 kids or take your kids for half the time too.

ShoesoftheWorld · 18/05/2023 13:24

Seeing as you're still working this summer, what I might do (if it suits you and your plans) is to agree to a reciprocal arrangement for odd days, one day you, one day her - that means for every day you do for her, she does a day for you BEFORE she gets another. And she helps you out in term time (if you need it) and gets half a day in the holidays for every pick-up (or whatever) she's done. Somehow I think she probably won't go for that, though.

MeridianB · 18/05/2023 13:09

Definitely a super-CF. What did she say when you told her no, @Fluffyfluffs

aloris · 18/05/2023 13:09

"it would be classic CF behaviour for her to act like you would be doing your mum a favour by helping out with childcare over the holidays. She can position you as a bit selfish for not helping your mum if you refuse to help look after her kids!"

I would just escalate this right back with telling sister that if she weren't too selfish to pay for her own childcare, her mother would be able to rest and enjoy her free time because sister's kids would be in formal childcare. It's not on OP to subsidize sister's budget by taking up any of the unreasonable load that sister has placed on her own mother's back.

Cakeandcardio · 18/05/2023 13:09

I've got one of those SILs. Wants to use my annual leave / part time working to watch her child as she doesn't want to lose the money herself. Cheeky fuckery of the highest order. Show her this thread

Fercullen · 18/05/2023 13:04

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 11:41

Thanks for all your replies. We’re quite close but she has form for CF behaviour. I wouldn’t say she’s the golden child but everyone tends to tip toe around her for an easy life.

She doesn’t like not getting her own way and she has a tendency to throw her toys out of the pram.
I think she assumed I would help to relieve the pressure on our mum and her mil who currently do all her childcare.

I don’t have a mil, and my mum doesn’t drive so she wouldn’t be able to help me out with school runs etc which is why I’ve gone term time only. My sister lives closer and my mum lives within walking distance of her younger kids school.

I haven’t had any help as I didn’t want to burden my mum with anymore children. She does let my sister walk all over her though.

If there was a reciprocal agreement then I’d maybe be a bit more open, but I’m not prepared to make sacrifices for my family and help her out when she wouldn’t do it for me.

it would be classic CF behaviour for her to act like you would be doing your mum a favour by helping out with childcare over the holidays. She can position you as a bit selfish for not helping your mum if you refuse to help look after her kids!

Hankunamatata · 18/05/2023 13:04

Wow I thought u were going to say she asked you to do all childcare in holidays and thought that was CF but to just assume omg

Galast · 18/05/2023 12:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DysmalRadius · 18/05/2023 12:53

If there was a reciprocal agreement then I’d maybe be a bit more open, but I’m not prepared to make sacrifices for my family and help her out when she wouldn’t do it for me.

Not just that, but she has chosen not to make career/salary sacrifices to care for her own children, but expects to financially benefit from your choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread