Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to provide childcare

182 replies

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 08:27

I have 1 DS who’s about to start full time school in September.

Since my DS was born, I have had very little help with childcare. We’ve spent a fortune reducing hours, paying nursery fees and DH and I have managed reasonably well to juggle things.

Im a civil servant and will be changing to working term time only from September.

I have one sister who has 4 children. 2 teens and 2 younger. My sister has always managed to work full time, has never had to pay for any childcare and has always relied on help from our parents, her in laws and whoever else will help her. Their joint income is a lot higher than ours.

She announced yesterday that she’s glad I’m going to be working termtime as it means she won’t have to worry about childcare in the school holidays.

I told her that I won’t be providing childcare during the school holidays and now she’s not speaking to me. Am I being mean?

OP posts:
Bunnycat101 · 20/05/2023 08:10

Well done for standing your ground. Term time working comes at a financial cost and you are doing that to spend more time with your own child at the expense of flexibility in term-time. She is an absolute CF to assume that is a path to free childcare especially when she has older teens who can help her out.

Zanatdy · 20/05/2023 08:08

Definitely not. Maybe one day, but taking her kids all school holidays? No. You’re taking a pay cut for that and want to spend time with your own child. Your sister can pay for childcare like many others have to

Farcis · 20/05/2023 08:04

Don’t help out in an ‘emergency!’ There’ll be one every other day if you start that. YANBU

vdbfamily · 20/05/2023 07:07

I would tell her that may you have had to significantly reduce your income to manage school holidays by taking a term time contract, so whilst you might be available to help out on occasion, you would expect a to be recompensed in some way. If the cousins enjoy each others company and could keep each other entertained, it might be a way of boosting your income and helping her out too.
There used to be rules about paid childcare if you are not a registered childminder. I am not sure if that has changed more recently but there are ways round it. I did not work many hours when the kids were at primary school and had a couple of friends I helped out regularly and they always found ways to recompense me without direct payment.

pictoosh · 20/05/2023 06:55

And actually, the angle she's going for, easing 'the burden' for the grandparents, would have me digging my heels in even more. How manipulative can you be? When you consider that she is the only person who has burdened the grandparents, you understand that she is all for herself and expects you to be all for her as well.
Get fucked sis.

pictoosh · 20/05/2023 06:50

Oh god no. The odd day for the pleasure of it, sure - holiday childminder, no fucking way.
You are absolutely right to say no. Your sister's sense of entitlement is off the scale. Like you say, four kids, her choice and her responsibility, certainly not yours.

WaltzingWaters · 20/05/2023 06:49

She’s being massively cheeky. An absolute no way. If it were the odd day she were asking for that’s fine, but regular care throughout the holidays, no!
Looking after 3 kids is very different to looking after your one and will restrict what you can do, and how enjoyable it will be.

ZekeZeke · 20/05/2023 06:03

Why can't the 16 year old look after the siblings?

I would say, is t it great Johnny/Mary is 16 and can look after the younger ones for you.

T1Dmama · 20/05/2023 02:41

The fact she’s now not speaking to you suggests how little she respects you.

I wouldn’t agree to having my brothers 2 kids every day/13 weeks a year either… not even for money! The odd day here and there of course, but I’d never commit to looking after anyones child during holidays… I like doing my own stuff with my DD… having to please someone else’s kids would be a nightmare!

Shinyandnew1 · 19/05/2023 21:44

In similar circumstances

They aren’t very similar, really-are they?

LookItsMeAgain · 19/05/2023 20:49

Motheranddaughter · 19/05/2023 20:46

In similar circumstances I looked after by niece and nephew in the school holidays
Am very close to my sister and her family and love spending time with them

All due respect here but that worked for you.

It doesn't work for the OP.

Motheranddaughter · 19/05/2023 20:46

In similar circumstances I looked after by niece and nephew in the school holidays
Am very close to my sister and her family and love spending time with them

Hesma · 19/05/2023 20:43

No, she is a CF

LuckyPeonies · 19/05/2023 20:41

Wow, she has a massive sense of entitlement and sounds like a nasty, selfish person. Just say NO and ignore her nonsense.

Winnipeg23 · 19/05/2023 20:38

99% say ur not being unreasonable. That's pretty unanimous. How cheeky of her. She's not someone I'd be worried about offending with a great big fat NO.

fatsdominospizza · 19/05/2023 20:09

Don't you dare OP, she is taking the piss! The neck of her! Stand strong on this.

billy1966 · 18/05/2023 18:26

CantGetDecentNickname · 18/05/2023 18:16

If she starts to annoy you, you could just ask her why doesn't she want to parent her own children?

I'd certainly rather be working than trying to keep 3 children, of different familys, happy for the holidays.

Much easier to work!

CantGetDecentNickname · 18/05/2023 18:16

If she starts to annoy you, you could just ask her why doesn't she want to parent her own children?

CantGetDecentNickname · 18/05/2023 18:14

I'm surprised so many are suggesting that OP looks after her DSis's DC and gets paid for it. At no point has OP expressed a wish to become a child-minder. Many of us love our own DC but don't want to spend our days taking care of other peoples; it's not a job for everyone and we should get to choose our own career.

Your DSis knows exactly what she is doing in trying to manipulate you and she isn't even offering to do childcare in return. OP is changing her working hours and most likely taking a pay cut so she can be there for her DC and spend quality time with them. This is to benefit her DC and OP herself. DSis doesn't wish to make any such sacrifices which is her choice along with it being her choice to have 4. OP is not obliged to do anything for someone who wouldn't do similar for her.

I'd recommend being blunt here and telling her that she'll just have to pay for childcare like everyone else does or reduce her hours etc. Say it loud and clear and just keep repeating it. You could also point out that you don't get any help from parents/in-laws whereas she has had years of help and that you are making sacrifices to benefit your DC and perhaps she should do so for hers. Repeat this every time she tries it on.

billy1966 · 18/05/2023 17:44

The cost of childcare for 4 children is expensive and that is why lots of people stop and less than that, the sheer cost.

Your sister has influcted the childcare care of 4 children on her mother and MIL, real CF in my opinion.

Would she have had 4 children if she actually had to pay for childcare?.

She certainly has made sure that her parents are too worn out to help out anyone else.

Reugny · 18/05/2023 17:24

OP I have a suggestion for her - she can pay her 16 year old to look after their younger 2 siblings as it is cheaper than paying an adult.

Unfortunately while you are off over the school holidays you will be going out a lot with your one child including around the country visiting places and friends so you are unavailable.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/05/2023 16:33

Exactly - she has put the burden on your mother and her MIL!

It’s for her to relieve it by booking holiday clubs like everyone else, taking her leave separately to her husband if needs be (or at least in part). I’d be miffed if I was a grandparent, and I was asked to do holiday childcare if my Dd/ds then took leave all to themselves in term time, or if the couple took two weeks together, rather than taking at least one separately to cover as much of the hols as possible.

My favourite reply on her thought is “oh good, you’ve got a high full-time salary! That means I don’t have to worry about paying my bills this month, paying for our family holiday etc”

SearchIsTakingTooLong · 18/05/2023 16:15

Fluffyfluffs · 18/05/2023 14:40

Definitely a super-CF. What did she say when you told her no, @Fluffyfluffs

She tried guilt tripping about easing the burden on the grandparents and how families should help eachother out. I pointed out that I’ve had very little help with my DS. She told me that having just 1 child is easier and cheaper than having 4. I did point out that it was her choice to have 4 which didn’t go down too well.

It would only be the two younger ones that she would want help with as the older two are 16 and 13. I don’t mind helping anyone out occasionally if it’s really needed, in an emergency etc. but I don’t want a regular commitment and want to enjoy the school holidays with my DS.

I did feel a bit bad that I’m in a position where I could help and wondered if I was being selfish by not helping. Glad you agree I’m not.

The answer to this is that she created the burden on your mother by making your mum do regular childcare, and you have never placed such demands on your mum, therefore it's not your problem to fix. If your sister is so worried about the childcare burden on your mum, she can start paying for childcare rather than shunting it onto you.

Also, one child is not cheap if you have zero family help and have to pay for all childcare and babysitting. We have just one DC, and our nursery bill is almost a second mortgage and a night out costs over £50 for a babysitter. I would be fuming at that comment if I were you.

Anecdotally, I have noticed that it is mainly people who have shedloads of family help who go on to have more than one child. She chose to have 4 because she's never had to do it all by herself or pay for the childcare.

You have been very restrained so far OP.

Odile13 · 18/05/2023 16:11

Oh my goodness, what is your sister thinking?! 😂 There is no way in a million years I would do this either and she is being incredibly cheeky thinking that you would do it.

DysmalRadius · 18/05/2023 16:08

michymommy · 18/05/2023 13:33

I think it’s rude she just assumed you would without even asking first.

HOWEVER if I was in a position to help my sister I would absolutely do it without question.
When I was a lot younger and in college I used to pick up my niece from nursery and take her home, feed her and look after her until my sister came from work at around 9pm all free of cost.
In my opinion it takes a village and I wouldn’t feel comfortable making my sister pay for something I could do for free.

I guess it also depends on the relationship you have with your sister as well, would she do it for you?

Looking after a small child voluntarily when you are young and at college is quite different to sacrificing a full-time salary to spend school holidays with your child and being expected to care for two extra kids all day for free for weeks at a time!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread