Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want my parents to be more involved grandparents?

110 replies

callhermum · 17/05/2023 21:40

I’ve been pretty much independent from my parents since I was 16 and have never made a habit of leaning into them for support. My relationship with them is pleasant enough and has had many moments of fun, but it has never been one where I’d garner nurturance or guidance necessarily.

I’m 34 and have been with my partner for 15 years. We have a 3 year old son and another due in a matter of weeks. One of the most surprising, and frankly sad, realities of becoming a parent for me has been the lack of enthusiasm and/or interest my parents exhibit.

I’d like to caveat this by saying they’re always very loving and welcoming to my son, and by no means uninviting when we pop to see them. I just can’t help but think if it wasn’t for me making the effort to facilitate visits, they wouldn’t see him very often. They never offer to babysit or ask for time with him exclusively (i.e without me there too.)

For some context, my dad runs a steady business from home which he manages on reduced hours and my mum isn't officially employed but cares part-time for her 87 year old mum. She helps mainly with keeping the house in order and bits of personal care. It’s by no means a full-time job.

For further context, my parents aren’t exactly old — dad is 55 and mum is 5 years his senior. It’s not like they have busy social lives, activities or commitments that take up their time. They are pretty antisocial and stay in most of the time, and live a pretty simple life.

Anecdotally I know of many people who have a lot of support from their parents. Support which they are massively reliant upon, support which seems to form an essential part in their family system as a whole. From child care throughout the week, to regular overnight stays, and even times the children are taken away on extended breaks.

And I have spoken to grandparents over the years who are thrilled to talk about how much pleasure they take in spending time with their grandchildren. People who light up when they relay stories about their children and grandchildren.

I think I’m mourning what the relationship could be like.

This isn’t me demanding that my parents be of service to my family in a way which just benefits us. However, I can’t help but feel like I’m missing out on having more involved parents and my son is missing out on having grandparents who take a demonstrable interest in his life.

If it wasn’t for me popping over their house occasionally, I don’t think we'd see them very often at all - and that makes me sad.

So, I guess I’d love to know AIBU to want more from my parents?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beenalongwinter · 19/05/2023 09:56

What sort of relationship did you parents have with their own Grandparents?
I recall my older and old fashioned DF stating it was a parents responsibility to take grandchildren to visit grandparents . I think he recalled weekly visits to his own Grandparents all dressed up and on best behaviour, enjoying tea and cake.
Times have very much changed and it takes effort on both sides but in years gone buy Granny would of term be in rocking chair knitting and exhausted with life at 65.

feralunderclass · 18/05/2023 21:43

What sort of involvement are you wanting? You detached from them at 16, and you say they are kind and loving to your ds. They aren’t the usual disinterested grandparents that you read about. Maybe you need to suggest some things and see if they are interested?
Caring for an elderly relative is extremely draining btw, you seem to really want to minimise that.

Tooclosetodanger · 18/05/2023 21:18

Totally understand this OP.

Mine (father and step mother) don’t bother at all unless the kids are right under their nose (i.e. taken to them). Then it’s a case of them plying DDs with sugar for 30 mins. End of entertainment. They know nothing about DDs, don’t talk to them, no efforts to engage. So that’s a twice yearly interaction 🤦🏼‍♀️

MIL thinks she helps us, but her help is monopolising one weekend every month when she comes to visit. No idea why she can’t come during the week instead (she’s been retired 13 years, perfectly healthy, has no other responsibilities) and for a few days a month she could actually help us with school drop offs and pick ups. Instead she comes here to be fed and entertained and to talk non stop at me and DH. She’s exhausting and we’re already exhausted from work/commute/looking after our DDs 🤦🏼‍♀️

DH’s grandparents were self-interested. I remember when his grandmother died and suddenly his grandfather (at age 88) expected to be included in everything and he regularly and loudly questioned why no one was visiting him. He seemed to have forgotten the fact he hadn’t actually spent any time with DH and his siblings and didn’t have any relationship with them. When he died at age 92, there was a big funeral and then literally no one has ever mentioned him or the grandmother again. They aren’t missed. I find that sad. The same will happen with our parents (DDs’ grandparents). I doubt our DDs will care or notice when their grandparents die 🤷🏼‍♀️

OutsideLookingOut · 18/05/2023 19:36

Maybe mum is tired with elderly care? Can you help with that?

saraclara · 18/05/2023 18:59

TedMullins · 18/05/2023 18:44

Why does her choosing to care for her own mother mean she’s entitled to have her daughter do the same? A daughter she doesn’t seem to have made much effort with to all intents and purposes. I don’t think parents have a right to expect their children will look after them in old age

Why does her choosing to care for her own mother mean she’s entitled to have her daughter do the same?

It doesn't. It's as illogical as the usual 'my mum got childcare from my grandparents so she should give it to me' which is trotted out constantly. I was simply pointing out the mumsnet hypocrisy.

TedMullins · 18/05/2023 18:44

saraclara · 18/05/2023 16:09

That's a bit rich, when OP's mother is busy caring for her own 87 year old mother.

It's often trotted out here that if one's parents got childcare help from their parents, they should offer it to their own children.
But OP's mother shouldn't get help in her old age, despite giving it to her mother?

I'm on my 60s. I appear healthy and fit, but looking staff my DGD, though it's a joy, it's entirely knackering. I no longer have that kind of energy.

Caring for a very elderly parent will also be tiring, and a lot more stressful and less pleasurable. It's not surprising that OP's mum hasn't got a lot left over for childcare after doing so.

Why does her choosing to care for her own mother mean she’s entitled to have her daughter do the same? A daughter she doesn’t seem to have made much effort with to all intents and purposes. I don’t think parents have a right to expect their children will look after them in old age

CurlewKate · 18/05/2023 18:16

I do think grandparents are in a no win situation. They are either "trying to take over" or "never want to get involved". Well, on Mumsnet anyway. In RL most people seem to rub along OK!

Coolhand2 · 18/05/2023 18:08

I would expect my parents to help out too, take the child for a few hrs or a day. But it's important to be honest and ask them. "Mom I really need help, can you take my DC on this day"

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 17:50

'Yes, I do indeed think it’s a good thing that individuals are at liberty to decide for themselves what they want to do, over being beholden to anyone else’s ideals. if that means they want to help, then cool. If it means they don’t, then cool.

and my initial point was that the people moaning about selfishness are often doing so because they consider themselves entitled to the generosity of others, regardless of the wishes of the others in question.'

I don't think it's a question of one sided selfishness or entitlement. Often, parents are simply upset and hurt that their parents are not terribly interested in their own grandchildren (not childcare as I have already said). Presumably you think ageing adults also have no entitlement to their adult children's time and would be selfish to complain when they are in a position where they might benefit from support. Fair enough but then we obviously disagree about the best way for society to function.

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 17:30

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 17:23

Not a straw man at all , responding to your point about some people (the parents) wanting to dictate grandparents/ wanting other peoples lives to revolve around them. When you say 'people' should decide, you therefore appear to be referring to grandparents deciding what suits them.
I am saying that it is a shame that we are not a more generally supportive society as we have been in the past and as many other cultures are today.

Yes, I do indeed think it’s a good thing that individuals are at liberty to decide for themselves what they want to do, over being beholden to anyone else’s ideals. if that means they want to help, then cool. If it means they don’t, then cool.

and my initial point was that the people moaning about selfishness are often doing so because they consider themselves entitled to the generosity of others, regardless of the wishes of the others in question.

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 17:23

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 17:03

Throwing up a straw man there. I haven’t presented it as a binary choice between a slave to family or being completely self interested. What I have said is that people deciding for themselves is a good thing, rather than some sign of social decay. You may not like the choices some people make, but who said you needed to?

Not a straw man at all , responding to your point about some people (the parents) wanting to dictate grandparents/ wanting other peoples lives to revolve around them. When you say 'people' should decide, you therefore appear to be referring to grandparents deciding what suits them.
I am saying that it is a shame that we are not a more generally supportive society as we have been in the past and as many other cultures are today.

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 17:03

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 16:51

That's not what I am saying at all. I have twice mentioned the large grey area between being a general slave and showing no interest. Most families manage to find somewhere in between that works for everyone. I have said nothing about one person dictating what everyone else does. That's your assumption entirely.

Throwing up a straw man there. I haven’t presented it as a binary choice between a slave to family or being completely self interested. What I have said is that people deciding for themselves is a good thing, rather than some sign of social decay. You may not like the choices some people make, but who said you needed to?

padsi1975 · 18/05/2023 17:03

My parents seemed interested in my children for awhile and it was wonderful. Then covid happened. They no longer visit much and seem generally disinterested. They were never all that interested in me and I accepted it. I find this more hurtful. They had a great relationship with my kids but just seemed to lose interest and now my kids never talk about them. It makes me sad (I LOVED my Grandparents). I sympathise.

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 16:56

thecatsthecats · 18/05/2023 16:08

But for the OP, as far as we know she has a routine of taking her kid around, and they engage with their grandchild positively every week.

They might not see any problem with that - one could reasonably assume that OP wanted to get out of the house once a week for a change of scene.

My parents live about 200 miles away, in a highly desirable rural area. I love going there, and they're a bit nervous of cities - and we all like to get out and walk when we meet up. Makes sense to meet at theirs or in lovely locations inbetween.

But now I'm pregnant I'm knackered and have so much to sort out at home. So I told them that, and they've made the effort to come to me. And my sister is jealous because she only ever made shady allusions to asking them to come, she didn't just... Ask them.

It is possible that is a communication issue, yes. From what the OP has said though, they haven't generally been warm parents who give good advice/ emotional support so they may not be like your own at all.

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 16:51

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 16:10

of course you don’t. I didn’t expect you to. What you’re saying though is ‘don’t live by your desires, live by mine’, and presenting it as a virtuous alternative.

I have no opinion on what people decide when it comes to their own families. That’s up to them. My idea of ‘the right way’ is relevant only to me and mine, and I don’t expect anyone else to be beholden to it.

That's not what I am saying at all. I have twice mentioned the large grey area between being a general slave and showing no interest. Most families manage to find somewhere in between that works for everyone. I have said nothing about one person dictating what everyone else does. That's your assumption entirely.

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 16:10

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 16:01

We will have to disagree then. I don't see it as selfish to hope that your parents would be interested in spending time with their children/ grandchildren and to feel sad that they do not (not talking about regular childcare). As I said, there is a very large grey area between the two approaches. On the other hand, I would see what you said about 'focusing on their actual desires' as being entirely selfish. Presumably you feel exactly the same about people helping elderly/ frail parents only if it is their actual desire to do so which would at least be not hypocritical but doesn't represent a great philosophy for society which was @Betterbear's and my initial point.

of course you don’t. I didn’t expect you to. What you’re saying though is ‘don’t live by your desires, live by mine’, and presenting it as a virtuous alternative.

I have no opinion on what people decide when it comes to their own families. That’s up to them. My idea of ‘the right way’ is relevant only to me and mine, and I don’t expect anyone else to be beholden to it.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 18/05/2023 16:10

if they don't improve you will have to cut them off fully

What terrible advice. The OP described her parents as "very loving and welcoming" to her son. Why should she "cut them off fully"? How does her child benefit from that? Bizarre.

saraclara · 18/05/2023 16:10

Looking AFTER my DGD, even

saraclara · 18/05/2023 16:09

TedMullins · 18/05/2023 15:35

Surely that depends on what the individuals in your family are like though. Your parents clearly didn’t foster a very close relationship with you or give you much guidance as a teen or adult so why try and force something that isn’t there? Families can be lovely, supportive and enriching when the people in them are genuinely nice to and care about each other and make reciprocal effort. They can be burdensome when they’re the cause of upset or resentment. If I were you I certainly wouldn’t be looking after your parents in old age, they made their bed, they deserve the same detachment from you

That's a bit rich, when OP's mother is busy caring for her own 87 year old mother.

It's often trotted out here that if one's parents got childcare help from their parents, they should offer it to their own children.
But OP's mother shouldn't get help in her old age, despite giving it to her mother?

I'm on my 60s. I appear healthy and fit, but looking staff my DGD, though it's a joy, it's entirely knackering. I no longer have that kind of energy.

Caring for a very elderly parent will also be tiring, and a lot more stressful and less pleasurable. It's not surprising that OP's mum hasn't got a lot left over for childcare after doing so.

thecatsthecats · 18/05/2023 16:08

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 15:07

Can't you imagine any grey areas between living together and doing full time childcare and being uninvolved and disinterested unless someone else makes the effort? It isn't hard to achieve some kind of balance.
You talk about 'actual desires'. That is exactly my point and the other poster's point about selfishness. As I said, it is a sad that some grandparents don't see to want to spend time with their children/ grandchildren and see it is a huge burden.

But for the OP, as far as we know she has a routine of taking her kid around, and they engage with their grandchild positively every week.

They might not see any problem with that - one could reasonably assume that OP wanted to get out of the house once a week for a change of scene.

My parents live about 200 miles away, in a highly desirable rural area. I love going there, and they're a bit nervous of cities - and we all like to get out and walk when we meet up. Makes sense to meet at theirs or in lovely locations inbetween.

But now I'm pregnant I'm knackered and have so much to sort out at home. So I told them that, and they've made the effort to come to me. And my sister is jealous because she only ever made shady allusions to asking them to come, she didn't just... Ask them.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 18/05/2023 16:03

These posts pop-up a lot on Mumsnet and invariably the poster will insist that their parents have "no health issues, plenty of free time and few social obligations". So why not be more enthusiastic about spending time with grandchildren?

I'd point out that you really don't know what goes on behind closed doors, even when it comes to your parents. Just because they haven't shared it with you doesn't mean there aren't health problems (including cognitive concerns), marital discord, mental health issues, insomnia...the list is endless.

Before writing it off as "selfishness" consider that it's very likely there are things going on that you are unaware of.

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 16:01

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 15:45

I understood your point perfectly, I just disagree that decrying selfishness because it doesn’t manifest in ways that would suit you isn’t, in fact, selfish in its own right.

For some it is a huge burden? One persons supportive is another’s burden, same as one persons missing out is another’s dogged bullet. There’s no one size fits all that works for everyone, and trying to force people into any one ideal of what they should think and should do isn’t preferable to people deciding for themselves.

We will have to disagree then. I don't see it as selfish to hope that your parents would be interested in spending time with their children/ grandchildren and to feel sad that they do not (not talking about regular childcare). As I said, there is a very large grey area between the two approaches. On the other hand, I would see what you said about 'focusing on their actual desires' as being entirely selfish. Presumably you feel exactly the same about people helping elderly/ frail parents only if it is their actual desire to do so which would at least be not hypocritical but doesn't represent a great philosophy for society which was @Betterbear's and my initial point.

whumpthereitis · 18/05/2023 15:45

rainingsnoring · 18/05/2023 15:07

Can't you imagine any grey areas between living together and doing full time childcare and being uninvolved and disinterested unless someone else makes the effort? It isn't hard to achieve some kind of balance.
You talk about 'actual desires'. That is exactly my point and the other poster's point about selfishness. As I said, it is a sad that some grandparents don't see to want to spend time with their children/ grandchildren and see it is a huge burden.

I understood your point perfectly, I just disagree that decrying selfishness because it doesn’t manifest in ways that would suit you isn’t, in fact, selfish in its own right.

For some it is a huge burden? One persons supportive is another’s burden, same as one persons missing out is another’s dogged bullet. There’s no one size fits all that works for everyone, and trying to force people into any one ideal of what they should think and should do isn’t preferable to people deciding for themselves.

TedMullins · 18/05/2023 15:35

callhermum · 18/05/2023 08:09

Yes I agree with this, resentment gets us no where and having children is incredibly insightful. Some of the responses here reveal to me that this is a wider social issue. It is no surprise that the rates of loneliness are so heightened when some people see family as burdensome as opposed to systems of enrichment and support.

Surely that depends on what the individuals in your family are like though. Your parents clearly didn’t foster a very close relationship with you or give you much guidance as a teen or adult so why try and force something that isn’t there? Families can be lovely, supportive and enriching when the people in them are genuinely nice to and care about each other and make reciprocal effort. They can be burdensome when they’re the cause of upset or resentment. If I were you I certainly wouldn’t be looking after your parents in old age, they made their bed, they deserve the same detachment from you

marblemad · 18/05/2023 15:27

I think unfortunately I would just not make the effort for a while and see if they decide to voluntarily communicate or make some kind of effort. If it goes more than a couple of months without hearing from them or seeing them, be quite direct in your feelings about this towards them, if they don't improve you will have to cut them off fully.