Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find therapy totally overrated?

111 replies

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 20:39

I would love to hear any positive stories.

I am struggling. Kids with additional needs. And a DH who isn't awful but he is like a kid himself and I feel worn down and resentful. I am the breadwinner and find DH like a lodger.

I keep going to therapy and we talk about me doing everything for others, sometimes we even talk about my dad and how angry and unpredictable he was.

But although feels good to talk in the moment - I leave and everything continues. I still can't see the way through and have spent nearly £1000 over the last year.

Can i just not find the right person? Am i expecting too much?

Last session they tried to make me do a pie chart of my "priorities" and I just felt like I was in some bloody team building exercise

Any tips?

OP posts:
Feelingss · 17/05/2023 22:12

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/05/2023 22:08

I would hope that everyone practicing would have a minimum of a psychology degree and further training!!

A psychology degree isn’t the training route for a psychotherapist, they’re different disciplines with very different training processes.

I know 🙂 I’m currently in my clinical training at present. I think that’s one of the things that makes it so tricky though is that it can be difficult from the outside for people to understand who’s done what and appropriately trained etc

ImPrawnCrackers · 17/05/2023 22:09

All a therapist can really do is help you see what's happened and what changes you can make. They don't have a magic wand and can't make changes for you. They can't stop all you are going through. Only you can do that OP

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/05/2023 22:08

I would hope that everyone practicing would have a minimum of a psychology degree and further training!!

A psychology degree isn’t the training route for a psychotherapist, they’re different disciplines with very different training processes.

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/05/2023 22:07

Good therapy with the right person can be absolutely life changing, they can’t make a shit situation better but can help you find your way out of a shit situation. It sounds like you recognise a pattern in your relationships - a psychodynamic or humanistic therapist would help you figure out where that pattern comes from and what you want to change. CBT is more about tools and strategies which doesn’t seem like what you’re after.

I generally suggest people try a therapist out, if you don’t see any benefit after a few sessions change and try someone else. You’ll find the right fit - and therapy is one place where a good fit is essential. I found a fantastic person for me and the work we did changed every part of my life for the better, it was very hard going and I did a lot of work on myself between sessions but it’s honestly the best money I’ve ever spent.

speakout · 17/05/2023 22:06

Therapy can be life changing.
I have discovered a great deal about myself, and learned ways to live a joyful life. I see a therapist once a week
Many of us have maladaptive processes, often stemming from childhood.

Therapy allows me to untangle threads and learn healthier ways of dealing with life. It isn't work I could do on my own.

Batalax · 17/05/2023 22:00

The therapy might help you understand why you do things, but if you don’t actually change things then just understanding why, isn’t going to help.

If you keep on doing the same things at home, then you can’t expect anything to change. What physical changes can you make to make life easier?

Feelingss · 17/05/2023 22:00

JaneyGee · 17/05/2023 21:54

To be fair, they vary a great deal. Some are excellent, some ok, some utterly dreadful. Personally, I would never see a therapist who didn’t have a degree, ideally in psychology. I went through a therapy phase a few years ago, and one or two of them were, to put it politely, dim.

I would hope that everyone practicing would have a minimum of a psychology degree and further training!!
i would say check the quals of the person you are seeing, they should be BACP registered or HCPC registered or at minimum be supervised by someone who is (if they are still training)
trainees are generally good as they have more time and space to think about you 😊

Fiddlededeefiddlededoh · 17/05/2023 22:00

I have had 4 therapists. 1 shit told me I’d be at fault if my abuser abused someone else. 1 lovely but wouldn’t be someone I would go to long term but was excellent for a short period of time I was in crisis. 1 other pretty shit but ok I guess just not for me and 1 absolutely amazing, he has saved my life. I saw him weekly for over a year and then more recently I see him every 3 months and he has been an absolute life line.

Mamamess · 17/05/2023 21:57

I found therapy helpful along with my own research. I initially worked with an energy healer who works on releasing past trauma by going back to it. That was intense but life changing. I also worked with a cbt therapist who helped me to realise the negative behavioural patterns I learnt growing up and how it was effecting my life. I went on introductory day recently to see if I felt equine therapy would work and I’ve decided to train in it. I think you’ve got to find the right therapy for you, perhaps if there’s no trauma to work through you might be better off spending the time/money on a hobbie you love? That’s therapeutic

ItsCalledAConversation · 17/05/2023 21:57

ILikePizzas · 17/05/2023 20:45

They can't change your life.

This. Therapy isn’t about making your life less shit, it’s about helping you connect with yourself, your true needs wants and desires, and helping you see your way to getting there, however that looks for you, in the here and now.

I love therapy. Saying that, I think it’s important to do the work in reasonable chunks. It’s ok to take a rest and digest what you’re doing. A good therapist will talk through your concerns with you and discuss ending, too. Just bring up how you’re feeling with them.

SirenSays · 17/05/2023 21:54

I feel like I've tried every therapist and every type of therapy. Some have made me worse. Some have been ok but none really helped me.

gardendream · 17/05/2023 21:54

it's kind of bizarre that you have the same category of job for treating bereavement, relationship issues, anxiety, drug users, suicidal people, abuse victims etc etc etc.

well not really… all of those are varied symptoms you list but the root cause of all of them is emotional dysregulation. Therapists teach emotional regulation.

Yippeenewjob · 17/05/2023 21:54

talk to your therapist about his you feel. Maybe try a different therapist? (I’m a convert of ADs too but I know they’re definitely not for everyone). I wish you well x

JaneyGee · 17/05/2023 21:54

To be fair, they vary a great deal. Some are excellent, some ok, some utterly dreadful. Personally, I would never see a therapist who didn’t have a degree, ideally in psychology. I went through a therapy phase a few years ago, and one or two of them were, to put it politely, dim.

Youdoyoubabe · 17/05/2023 21:52

I've tried it twice. Didn't help once. Made it worse the second time.

I prefer to take a pill or just battle on.

Yippeenewjob · 17/05/2023 21:52

I don’t know. I’ve recently had counselling after 15y of AD and a bit of minimal CbT (online, v basic). I just didn’t rate counselling - couldn’t see that it would work - which I’d why it took me so long (and last resort) to actually properly try it.

For me at this point it’s been as life changing as ADs were initially. I feel like counselling has given me more insights and tools Into myself and my thoughts. I don’t know if it’s magic (!) but basically my counsellor just listens, offers validation that I’m feeling that way and reflects back what I’m saying without offering suggestions or solutions.

maybe my issues were easily solved but having someone listen and hear me gave me space to feel how I feel - take time to think about what I felt and explore why I felt it and then think what I wanted to do about it (and made those decisions seem more obvious and possible).

I don’t know though. I think it felt like the ‘right time’ for me. If it’s not working for you trust yourself. Maybe find

AlwaysOneMissing · 17/05/2023 21:50

Do you trust your therapist OP? Do you feel emotionally ‘safe’ in sessions?

This is the most important thing for getting results. If you do trust them, tell them how you’re feeling and work through this.

You are obviously resisting this worksheet. But why? What if you committed to doing it properly and discussed it in a session?

I sort of think you have to surrender to the process to get the most out of therapy - and then it can be truly life changing.

ShoesEverywhere · 17/05/2023 21:44

I have felt this way with previous therapists but have been working with a psychoanalytic (aka psychodynamic) one recently and it's changed my life. Everything that goes on in the room becomes a sort of mirror where all your patterns come out - and the therapist helps you identify them. Amazing stuff. I recommend trying one out if you haven't already - and there are no worksheets ever Grin

MMMarmite · 17/05/2023 21:42

I've had several therapists. One absolutely life-changing. Some meh. One who made things worse.

Its not a very well-regulated profession. And the reasons people see therapists are so varied, it's kind of bizarre that you have the same category of job for treating bereavement, relationship issues, anxiety, drug users, suicidal people, abuse victims etc etc etc.

I think it requires an awful lot of skill to do well. I'd look for someone who's highly trained, much more than just the basics.

SchruteShunned · 17/05/2023 21:42

Do you know what modality of therapy your counsellor practices, OP? Or are they a psychologist?
This is important, especially as you're looking for answers to specific issues.
When you had your first session, did your counsellor explain their model of therapy to you and ask what your expectations were?

It's very possible that whatever approach they practice isn't right for you. Are they BACP registered (British Association for Counsellors and Psychotherapists) or are they registered with another institution?

Apologies for all the questions but I firmly believe that identifying the right therapeutic approach for you will help you see the way through.

Creditcrunch2243 · 17/05/2023 21:34

Though*

Creditcrunch2243 · 17/05/2023 21:33

I’ve been referred by my daughters hospital. My daughter is very poorly and the hospital keep making massive mistakes, losing tests, giving her the wrong drugs etc. It’s been an absolute shitshow. I’m so resentful of them I’m not going. Half of my problems are caused by them and the other half isn’t going to go away by talking. I’ve accepted that I’m not ready to engage with it so I’m not doing it. I can see how it could work if you are open to it thigh. X

CharlotteRumpling · 17/05/2023 21:33

I found it overrated too. I already do enough work without having to do more worksheets at home.
I saved the money and went on a solo holiday instead. Far more helpful.

gardendream · 17/05/2023 21:21

do you build up the resentment with the therapist?

maybe this time instead of leaving, tell them about it and work through it?

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 21:07

I want to see a therapist to work out why I keep ending up with men who want me to mother them. And why I mother them all and am this awful people pleaser. And then I build up all this resentment and then go crazy or just leave and never speak to them agai.n

OP posts: