Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find therapy totally overrated?

111 replies

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 20:39

I would love to hear any positive stories.

I am struggling. Kids with additional needs. And a DH who isn't awful but he is like a kid himself and I feel worn down and resentful. I am the breadwinner and find DH like a lodger.

I keep going to therapy and we talk about me doing everything for others, sometimes we even talk about my dad and how angry and unpredictable he was.

But although feels good to talk in the moment - I leave and everything continues. I still can't see the way through and have spent nearly £1000 over the last year.

Can i just not find the right person? Am i expecting too much?

Last session they tried to make me do a pie chart of my "priorities" and I just felt like I was in some bloody team building exercise

Any tips?

OP posts:
speakout · 18/05/2023 06:53

I don't think therapy is for everyone.

I have therapy, and it is life changing, but I can think of two people in my close family that could be helped, but would not engage with a therapist.
One is a narcissist who wouldn't consider that they even need help.
The other is a childhood abusee survivor who has pushed everything so far down they would not want to undergo any talking that encourages them to examine the impact.

Therapy can be challenging, and you have to be prepared to do the homework. There is no point in talking about boundaries in therapy if you are not going to try to engage them in your everyday life.
Learning abut yourself alone can only go so far.
Work with a therapist can be far deeper. I have weekly Gestalt Therapy, hard work is done in relationship with my therapist.

Therapy can absolutely change your life and can impact everything- your own disregulation or dysfunction, your relationships, your work, where you live.

The OP is carrying the can in the family. She feels resentful, she is worn thin, coping with a child who has additional needs. Her OH isn't doing his share- she sounds tired and unhappy.

That situation can absolutely be changed by therapy.

Srin · 18/05/2023 06:26

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 21:07

I want to see a therapist to work out why I keep ending up with men who want me to mother them. And why I mother them all and am this awful people pleaser. And then I build up all this resentment and then go crazy or just leave and never speak to them agai.n

It sounds like this is going to happen with the therapist as well.

PinkRobotDuck · 18/05/2023 06:26

You could read The Dance of Anger by Harriet Lerner - it was published a while ago but it had scenarios where you feel serously put upon - good read

peachicecream · 18/05/2023 06:23

Therapy can take a really long time to work, and there are always ups and downs on the way. It's normal to question the process - that is part of it. Speak to your therapist about how you are feeling.

wheresmymojo · 18/05/2023 06:19

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 21:07

I want to see a therapist to work out why I keep ending up with men who want me to mother them. And why I mother them all and am this awful people pleaser. And then I build up all this resentment and then go crazy or just leave and never speak to them agai.n

I've had a lot of therapy and would really recommend finding someone who specialises in Schema Therapy.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 18/05/2023 06:12

They really are a mixed bag. I've had two when I had PND. The first one was absolutely terrible, when she told me I had a wonderful purple aura I sacked her. The second one was absolutely fantastic, took absolutely no bullshit, and probably saved my life. I found out a few years later she was considered to be the best in the area. So maybe you just aren't seeing the right person. Also you have to 'do the work' as they say, and its certainly no magic bullet. Good luck with it all, life can be very hard sometimes. I was lucky enough to make a complete recovery and haven't had a relapse in over twenty years.

Bonelly · 18/05/2023 05:55

A therapist can help your perspective, see boundaries that need set, show you how to improve your sleep, help you gain self esteem, see abuse and help you apportion blame to the abuser and not yourself, encourage you to improve connections and start doing enjoyable things for yourself. They can calm you down and help rebuild you.

They can be ineffective and I don't personally think a psychologist is better than a psychotherapist but it does depend on the person. It's good to change them until you find the right one. You'll probably get something different but useful from each one you try.

Divorcedalongtime · 17/05/2023 23:29

My first therapist was ok, made me see some things in a new light but I felt I had to guard myself with him. My next therapist slowed my world down. I had felt my world spinning faster and faster and after just a session or two it was back to a manageable speed.

I love therapy and I tell everyone they ought to try it

needsomefuninthesun · 17/05/2023 23:25

It sounds like you might be looking for something like cognitive analytical therapy OP. You can read more about it and find locally trained therapists on the ACAT website. It's a wonderful therapy for those who want to explore relational stuff, to break patterns and do things differently.

It's definitely a case of finding the right kind of therapy and the right therapist! Or it may be that therapy just isn't for you. That doesn't mean it's your fault-therapy just doesn't work for everyone unfortunately! X

Ihatepickingausername3 · 17/05/2023 23:19

You can’t keep doing the same thing and expecting different results. Changes need to be made too. Perhaps couples counselling? Sending many good wishes your way as you deserve to feel better 💐

Shelkie · 17/05/2023 23:12

OP I might be you. I did counselling years and years ago, someone good but I stopped as I wasn’t ready / couldn’t deal with the very poignant questions.

On the face of it I had a very normal, average childhood - except when I really think about it so many things about my family dynamic have hugely impacted me, how I deal with things and interact with people. It’s actually quite messed up what I normalised.

I now know all this so the next thing is what am I going to do about it. That bit is even scarier and I’m not there yet.

I suspect you know why you end up with men and that dynamic? I do. You just don’t have a therapist who challenges you and asks what you want or are going to do about it if you don’t like it?

CareerQuestioner · 17/05/2023 23:09

Mrsmillshorse · 17/05/2023 23:01

I don't think wanting to know "why" is very helpful though. Thinking instead of feeling. Talking instead of doing. You probably want to solve some problems? Take action towards improving your life, feeling happier or achieving lasting change for the better e.g. reducing clutter, setting clearer boundaries in your relationships? A life coaching approach would be more valuable?

Agree with this. “Why do I keep ending up with guys like this” seems like a question for if you were between relationships. You’re married with kids so presumably unless you’re planning to get divorced you won’t be ending up with any more guys like anything. Maybe asking “why” has been a way to avoid thinking about the harder questions, like “what do I do now?”

Hawkins0001 · 17/05/2023 23:05

@HarryViles

I talk to the mirror so to speak, alot cheaper and eventually it helps

Mrsmillshorse · 17/05/2023 23:01

I don't think wanting to know "why" is very helpful though. Thinking instead of feeling. Talking instead of doing. You probably want to solve some problems? Take action towards improving your life, feeling happier or achieving lasting change for the better e.g. reducing clutter, setting clearer boundaries in your relationships? A life coaching approach would be more valuable?

Okisenough · 17/05/2023 23:01

I think therapy with the right person can be really helpful but it has to be the right person and you also have to be ready to accept and if necessary act on what you learn about yourself. I have just started therapy after decades of thinking I didn't need it and it was not for me. And I have found it helpful, it has helped me clarify things in my head and it's calming to talk through things with someone who really listens and doesn't just chime in with their issues and experiences. I think I still have a long way to go but it is helping me to cope with difficulties in my life and look at things from a different perspective. I would say don't give up on the idea that therapy can help just yet.

Heartsnrainbows · 17/05/2023 22:56

I've had both good and bad therapists and honestly the difference is like night and day.

My current therapist is a real force for change in my life, managing to be validating and dole out the tough love at the same time. He pushes me to make positive changes, always asking why. Why can't I take up a sport that I'm really too fat for? You'll lose weight once you start, do the lessons. Why can't I make more friends? Join the class, you'll make friends once you're there. And he has so far been right.

He encourages me to set boundaries and enforce them. Tells me that I am being perfectly reasonable and not to fall for guilt trips.

Previous ones have been crap. One had an obsession with jars. She wanted me to make big decisions by writing them on bits of paper and pulling them out of jars. Like I was really going to quit my job and end a relationship because that was what came out of the jar.

CareerQuestioner · 17/05/2023 22:55

The only therapist I ever saw who was any good was a qualified clinical psychologist- she was really great. Have seen two therapists (both well qualified and registered) who I found completely unhelpful to the point that I felt vaguely embarrassed for them. I’ve found reading (both psychology stuff and fiction) gave me far greater insights.

Ultimately, however, the only person who has the answers is you. From your post I wonder whether you might also think again about your questions, wonder whether some more focus on whether you need to make practical changes might yield more results.

beeskipa · 17/05/2023 22:48

A therapist can't change your life - they help you change it.

If you're going in there and realising why you do everything for everyone and then coming out and not putting work in to try and change that, you won't get results. As PPs have said, the work comes from you - they're just there to guide you.

Putting boundaries in for yourself with the support of your therapist and then sticking to them is what will change your life. Not doing everything for DH even when it feels impossible or scary or like things will go wrong is what will make it habit and change how you think. Letting yourself be scared of doing things differently but doing them differently is what will shift your mindset. Your therapist is there to help you unpick those patterns of behaviour but you have to change them.

Stuff like the priorities pie chart will have been to get you to see where you place yourself on the priority list and talk about how you can put yourself higher (i.e. not put everyone else's needs above yours). If the modality they're using isn't working for you, definitely try someone else - you have to gel with your therapist for it to work well! - but maybe it's worth reflecting on whether you're making changes outside of the therapy room or whether you're hoping talking about it will fix things without you having to do the scary part, which is doing things differently.

dimorphism · 17/05/2023 22:39

I think there is a trend these days to see 'therapy' as the solution to everything, and it's not. It's the go to when everything else is so broken, that it's the only solution offered and in some cases it can make things worse because of course in doesn't solve a lot of practical problems. E.g. talking about not having enough money isn't going to help you have more money (the opposite if you're paying for it yourself).

I've had therapy several times and in only one case did it help (and even then not much) - and that was in relation to a specific problem (grief). Really it was mostly just helpful in that I had someone to talk to outside of my normal life.

In terms of therapy being offered / suggested inappropriately, I have a friend who is severely disabled and in constant pain. She needs an operation that would ease her symptoms. She is on a 3 year waiting list. The NHS have sent her to counselling. She is depressed, but the reason she is depressed is that she's in constant pain and on a 3 year waiting list. It seems to me an earlier operation would be much more useful than therapy and no matter how much therapy, it's not going to change the constant, horrendous pain she has and the pain medication she has to take daily to (try and) manage the pain, which has significant side effects. There's nothing she can do about any of that. I'd argue she'd be better off with really decent physio, acupuncture, some kind of water-based physio (being in water eases the pain but she can't swim and finds getting in and out of public swimming pools or changed by herself basically impossible - so some kind of support doing this and a private area in a pool where she's not going to be jostled etc). There is so much they could be doing that might actually help her ease the chronic pain but no it's 'you're depressed' and off to a therapist. What a waste of money.

OP, I think the big problem here is you do have too much on, like many women. I wonder if the time spent in therapy might be better spent giving yourself a real break and doing something you really enjoy? Your H doesn't seem to contribute much, and therapy isn't going to change him. Your choices there are try and get him to contribute more, leave him or accept this is the way it is and work around him. What I would say is you absolutely shouldn't be doing anything for him that he can do himself (so no laundry, cooking etc if he doesn't pull his weight). However, sometimes easier said than done, I know myself from experience.

£1000 would give you a decent holiday. Do you think a proper break might do you more good than talking about things with a therapist?

Greetingsfellows · 17/05/2023 22:35

I've seen 4/5 different therapists.

The first, when I was 16, essentially told me that I didn't need to deal with my feelings about the abuse I had suffered. I'm not sure of this was useful at the time or not. My issues around the abuse I suffered resurfaced repeatedly but I'm not sure if I was ready to deal with the emotions then.

The second, when I was 25, repeatedly told me that I needed to do something I didn't want to and in fact something that would have put me back in an emotionally damaging place. I then had CBT, which many people find helpful, and I understand why, but at the time it was completely wrong for me. I also saw a 'life coach' who had their own agenda and was no help at all.

Finally at the age of 30, I had a mental health crisis. I ended up seeing two therapists. One was on the NHS and they gave me a limit of 6 sessions. The therapist actually listened to me and understood the complexity of issues I was dealing with. So much so that they gave me 12 sessions and then offered me various options about how to continue therapy. I then started seeing a different therapist, who I saw for 3 and a half years. She completely transformed my life but it did take time.

The point being, you may well not have found the right therapist for you. It's a relationship like any other - you have to build it and invest in it. If you don't like what's happening in your sessions, it doesn't necessarily mean therapy isn't right for you.

I get that some people don't like the idea of 'homework' and I can't say that my helpful therapists ever gave me a worksheet or anything like that. However, I think it's still a type of 'homework' to go away and reflect on the conversations you've had or to think about things from the week that you'd like to discuss in the next session. For therapy to be successful, YOU have to take it outside the therapy room otherwise you're just compartmentalising.

Lastly, you have to be invested in making the changes that you can. A therapist can't fix your problems, they can only help you learn to manage them differently/better. However, if you have no intention of changing your behaviour or thought processes, you are wasting your money.

Good luck with whatever you decide to do next. I hope life starts to get easier.

SpringingSpring · 17/05/2023 22:35

Having therapy changed my life, I have had bad experiences with crap therapists but well qualified, experienced specialists can improve your life beyond measure.

Whilst in therapy for the first time, I had a number of random people comment on how “self aware” I was. It really did open my eyes.

MajesticWhine · 17/05/2023 22:30

I'm a therapist myself. So a bit biased. It has worked for me.
I have seen 3 therapists for about 3 years each at various times in my life. None of it was dramatic with huge quick results, but all were helpful in different ways and the cumulative effect has helped me deal with a lot of issues and recurrent depression.
It's slow and painstaking.
I suggest you talk about how you feel with the therapist. That can be really powerful. If you don't want worksheets or pie charts then you need to say so.
A type of therapy called DIT - dynamic interpersonal therapy - is very good for the kind of problems you describe OP.

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/05/2023 22:29

I know 🙂 I’m currently in my clinical training at present.

Im confused then about why you said you’d hope the therapist would have a minimum of a psychology degree? Particularly given an BA/BSc in psychology isn’t a clinical qualification.

Mummadeze · 17/05/2023 22:18

I have seen seven in my life and one was life changing. One other was good and the rest didn’t help at all. It is very hit and miss.

speakout · 17/05/2023 22:17

OP a therapist should be guiding you through issues in your life.

Why are you with an unsupportive man?
Can you set boundaries, why do you set your bar low, how is your self esteem, do you have codependancy issues and if so why.

All stuff you can explore in therapy.