Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find therapy totally overrated?

111 replies

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 20:39

I would love to hear any positive stories.

I am struggling. Kids with additional needs. And a DH who isn't awful but he is like a kid himself and I feel worn down and resentful. I am the breadwinner and find DH like a lodger.

I keep going to therapy and we talk about me doing everything for others, sometimes we even talk about my dad and how angry and unpredictable he was.

But although feels good to talk in the moment - I leave and everything continues. I still can't see the way through and have spent nearly £1000 over the last year.

Can i just not find the right person? Am i expecting too much?

Last session they tried to make me do a pie chart of my "priorities" and I just felt like I was in some bloody team building exercise

Any tips?

OP posts:
speakout · 18/05/2023 11:25

crossstitchingnana · 18/05/2023 11:14

Because understanding yourself can be the first step to change. If you wish to please others because you grew up with a parent whose love was conditional on your emotions (ie will withdraw if you're sad for eg) then you learn to please to be loved. Knowing that means you can leave it in the past as it is not serving you now.

crossstitchingnana I agree. The whys can be very useful to understand.

I have tendancies towards codependancy, I want everyone to be happy, OK, and try to make that happen before I can relax.
I now know that came from issues of parentification in my childhood, feeling responsible for adults in my life who didn't parent me well. At a young age I felt resonsible for others, because their well being meant my own safety.

That strategy does not serve me in adulthood. Opening up that can of worms has given me huge relief from trying to fix people- their own well being is their responsibility- not mine.
I still love, care and help my family members, but I know how to do what I can or am prepared to do then reel things in, focus on my own well being, have self compassion and the resultant decrease in anxiety.

Understanding my maladaptations have been cruicial to my healing path.

prooses · 18/05/2023 11:21

@speakout that's very interesting, thank you. I will look into Gestalt, appreciate the recommendation.

speakout · 18/05/2023 11:17

prooses - I also struggle with the fact that most therapists are closed books - e.g. they tell you nothing about their own life and shut you down if you dare to make any kind of small talk with them. I realise they need boundaries, but I think in some instances sharing of personal life experience builds trust between therapist and client. Some clients need a bit of both ways to grow.

You may be interested in Gestalt therapy. It's all about healing within relationship between the client and therapist.
Although there are still boundaries the therapist will share some of their journey, their life, how my healing and that process affects them.
We have genuine affection for each other, talk about our feelings towards each other in context of the process. How my words land with them, how their words land with me. Having a good genuine bond allows trust.

I am in my second block of Gestalt therapy, I had 5 months of weekly sessions last year, and just started another block.
I agree having breaks between periods is helpful too.

I am fortunate to access free therapy, and it's local too, the therapist travels from the city to see me and others in her day.

crossstitchingnana · 18/05/2023 11:14

Mrsmillshorse · 17/05/2023 23:01

I don't think wanting to know "why" is very helpful though. Thinking instead of feeling. Talking instead of doing. You probably want to solve some problems? Take action towards improving your life, feeling happier or achieving lasting change for the better e.g. reducing clutter, setting clearer boundaries in your relationships? A life coaching approach would be more valuable?

Because understanding yourself can be the first step to change. If you wish to please others because you grew up with a parent whose love was conditional on your emotions (ie will withdraw if you're sad for eg) then you learn to please to be loved. Knowing that means you can leave it in the past as it is not serving you now.

muscularcooking · 18/05/2023 10:56

How many therapists does it take to change a lightbulb? Only one, but the lightbulb really has to want to change.

OP, it took me several goes to find the right therapist and to know how I wanted to work with her and to really have the muscle to be able to make the changes to my life that I wanted, and which we explored during my sessions with her. Do you want a more psychtherapeutic approach, which looks at the reasons and patterns which shape how you live your life, and/or do you want more practical help in finding ways to make the changes you need?

prooses · 18/05/2023 10:35

I think it's a mixed bag and shouldn't be seen as the be all and end all of treatment. I also think continuing endlessly with sessions isn't a good idea. I think maybe one should go through a few months worth then take a break to re-evaluate and see where they are at.

I also struggle with the fact that most therapists are closed books - e.g. they tell you nothing about their own life and shut you down if you dare to make any kind of small talk with them. I realise they need boundaries, but I think in some instances sharing of personal life experience builds trust between therapist and client. Some clients need a bit of both ways to grow. So talking to a closed book all the time isn't necessarily for everyone. Therefore I question the validity and usefulness of it for everyone.

That said I've had some valuable and helpful therapy myself. So I am not discounting it.

I do think people need to pursue a range of therapeutic exercises and styles. Anything from self educating about books on trauma, youtube videos, helpful resources.... to yoga, EMDR, hypnosis even spiritual stuff if you are so inclined. I don't think you necessarily need a fortune to pursue it, there's a lot online. And don't discount the value of speaking to a good friend or partner or family member - they can be as good as, or better than a therapist.

Keep searching people, keep trying new things, and keep learning. Sessions of £50 upwards on a weekly basis isn't necessarily the best or the only answer!!! That said a good therapist can be worth their weight in gold. Just remember to step back from it sometimes.

dimorphism · 18/05/2023 10:27

I also wonder given OP has kids with additional needs whether spending the next £1000 to be spent on therapy on some help for those children - perhaps providing some respite for OP from doing everything - might be money better spent?

It seems to me that OP has too much to do, and spending money on giving OP a bit more down time and feeling less overwhelmed might be a better use of money.

Everyone on this thread who's had therapy help them has talked about 'doing the work yourself' or some variant. I don't think OP is in a position to take on more 'work'. Obviously it might be ideal to be able to do this at some point in the future, but at the moment it sounds as if some respite from doing it all would be more useful.

dimorphism · 18/05/2023 10:23

Everyone who's saying 'you need to find the right therapist' sort of assumes a bottomless pit of money which I'm assuming OP, like most people, doesn't have.

How much would it cost to have endless first / second appointments until you find someone who can really help?

I think my take away from this is that therapy needs better regulation.

Righthandman · 18/05/2023 10:02

@HarryViles I’ve not read this whole thread but I read your other about your DS. That in itself is a lot to cope with and process.

I just wanted to say that you are not at all unreasonable for finding therapy overrated, nor for being unenthused about the priorities chart. Not all therapy works well for everyone.

Because of my own experience as a parent of DC with additional needs I wanted to ask whether you’ve considered how those suspected diagnoses might relate to yourself or to the DC’s dad? That might help you to understand something about your own relationship dynamics and about your experience of therapy.

ReadtheReviews · 18/05/2023 09:49

The two I've been to, between them, told me I was a good person, said how exciting something in my life was that really wasn't and was a mega source of drama at the time and proceeded to tell me their problems with their divorce etc.

Utterly pointless.

Theskylight · 18/05/2023 09:47

@HarryViles sorry meant to reply to your update but somehow didn’t!

Theskylight · 18/05/2023 09:46

I am wondering if there’s something in this message. Often in therapy you will mimic what’s happening in your life. Could it be possible that your annoyance with your husband/men is playing out with the therapist too? In terms of people pleasing and then resenting them/the therapy?

Whatever is happening I would speak to the therapist about how you feel in therapy, this might open up a conversation about what is happening. PPs are right, the therapist can’t change your life but they can help you understand why you feel the way you feel and from that you hopefully would get to a place of change.

Mountainpika · 18/05/2023 09:43

Saw a counsellor years ago when I had bad depression. He was excellent.
More recently another very low spell, mentally and physically - GP put me forward for phone counselling. One session was enough. She meant well, but it didn't work for me.
Then someone suggested hypnotherapy - and it's been a lifechanger. I'm a different person now. There are no doubt good ones and not so good ones - I hit the jackpot with my hypnotherapist. I was given the tools to deal with my problems and am continuing to use them, working with my subconscious. It's not a magic cure like an antibiotic which kills an infection. It's an ongoing thing which becomes a habit and part of everyday life.

YouAreNotBatman · 18/05/2023 09:40

It’s not the theraphy.
It’s your home setting.
Talking is good, but if you just keep on going back home, continue to do most of it, feel resentfull, of course your going to feel like crap.
You have to change stuff at home.
Venting helps, yes, but then you have to, and get your husband too, do the work.
Or leave him.

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/05/2023 09:30

the title counsellor is also not protected so anyone can use, that’s why it’s important to find someone who is BACP registered. Then you know that person has done, at a minimum, a bunch of short ish courses of increasing complexity/build on each other

The BACP require a minimum of 450 hours direct teaching, so not a few short courses.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 18/05/2023 09:17

HCPC is only required for clinical psychologists

Ingrowncrotchhair · 18/05/2023 09:17

Feelingss · 17/05/2023 22:00

I would hope that everyone practicing would have a minimum of a psychology degree and further training!!
i would say check the quals of the person you are seeing, they should be BACP registered or HCPC registered or at minimum be supervised by someone who is (if they are still training)
trainees are generally good as they have more time and space to think about you 😊

@Feelingss a psychology degree is not required to train as a counsellor. not sure about psychotherapy training.

the title counsellor is also not protected so anyone can use, that’s why it’s important to find someone who is BACP registered. Then you know that person has done, at a minimum, a bunch of short ish courses of increasing complexity/build on each other

Whydoievenbother · 18/05/2023 09:00

Gosh, I'd love a therapist. I'd feel so much better to have someone to vent to, a friend should only have to put up with so much.

LadyLucksters · 18/05/2023 08:59

There are so many charlatans out there.
As a clinical psychologist myself, you need to make sure as a minimum, a psychologist is accredited with the HCPC and a counsellor or psychotherapist with the UKCP or BACP.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 18/05/2023 08:57

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 21:07

I want to see a therapist to work out why I keep ending up with men who want me to mother them. And why I mother them all and am this awful people pleaser. And then I build up all this resentment and then go crazy or just leave and never speak to them agai.n

@harryviles Then you need counselling or psychotherapy. It takes a long time to work.
I went to therapy with one set of issues to unpick and ended up finding, and opening, the cans of worms that made me unhappy. Still dealing with it but am
much healthier, in myself, my behaviour towards myself and others and the choices I make. I’m on my third therapist, 5th year non consecutive

Dente · 18/05/2023 08:51

Kind of agree, but I guess it depends on your expectations.

I went to therapy as a teen after an accident - forced by parents. In my mind they were going to to give the answers, but after the first session I realised they weren’t! I realised that I could have just done what I was doing with her with a supportive family member.
Basically, you tell them stuff in your head and they say it back to you in a different way to evoke a different perspective so you treat yourself with more kindness.

Don’t think I got much out of it, but therapist felt after a couple of months I didn’t need anymore treatment.

I don’t think I would use one again.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/05/2023 08:41

Sorry just seen it's about relationships. Have you spoken about your childhood? Have they really dug deep?

You may need a psychotherapist.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/05/2023 08:39

Parisj · 17/05/2023 20:54

Therapy might help mental illness, over-valued ideas, self-esteem problems, or help you change or leave a relationship. Its not going to change life being shitty and unfair or you having too much on your plate (though prioritising and moving something for you further up the list could be good... Maybe your therapist is onto something). Its you that will make the changes with the support of therapy, they can't do it to you. Would you be better doing couples therapy or a parenting group maybe depending on your goals or priorities.

This I'm afraid.

Therapy has helped me unearth some deep issues I didn't know were there and process them. This in turn helped the maladaptive behaviours I was using to soothe them. But it's not failsafe and it's hard work.

If you're wanting it to make you feel happy about being overburdened or mistreated it simply won't. That's an external issue not an internal one.

LaurieFairyCake · 18/05/2023 07:20

Could you try couples therapy?

I'm a therapist and there are two parts to a session that scream out for me:

  1. Giving you a chance to express your resentment to your partner (safe space - blah blah)
  1. Making practical changes that we review week to week where chores/mental workload/work is balanced between you

A few sessions of that and if your partner refuses to make changes then you're much less STUCK - as you know where the exit is --->

I know you've been going a while but you're literally trying to undo a pattern you've spent a lifetime building Flowers

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 18/05/2023 06:57

I'm unfit, so I join a gym. I book a personal trainer. It's costing me a lot of money, but nothing changes. Somebody points out that I actually need to be getting on the machines or lifting the weights. At home, I need to go out for a walk instead of couch potatoing, eat an apple rather than chocolate cake, change my diet, shop differently, alter my habits. What??? Hell, no - why am I paying the gym membvership and the trainer???

That's how most people see therapy. They expect the therapist to fix them. Nope, doesn't work - ever. You have to face the challenge of changing yourself. Examine and understand how you relate to yourself and to the world; face up the pain you've experienced; accept the difficult challenge of modifying your behaviour when part of you is yelling to run away rather than brave your fear.

Deep therapeutic change is hard work. The question is: how hard are you prepared to work to change your life?

OP, how hard are you working in between sessions? Are you noticing how you're feeling and thinking in certain situations? Are you wondering why you think and feel that way? Are you seeing the patterns that repeat? Are you reflecting on how you might have behaved differently? What happens inside if you consider acting differently? What beliefs arise? You say you're a giver. What happens if you consider NOT giving? How do you feel? What do you believe will happen? What negative judgements about yourself appear? These are all things that should be under discussion in psychotherapy and that you should be doing in your everyday life in between sessions. If they're not under discussion then maybe find another therapist. If they are, then what are you doing to change?