Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find therapy totally overrated?

111 replies

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 20:39

I would love to hear any positive stories.

I am struggling. Kids with additional needs. And a DH who isn't awful but he is like a kid himself and I feel worn down and resentful. I am the breadwinner and find DH like a lodger.

I keep going to therapy and we talk about me doing everything for others, sometimes we even talk about my dad and how angry and unpredictable he was.

But although feels good to talk in the moment - I leave and everything continues. I still can't see the way through and have spent nearly £1000 over the last year.

Can i just not find the right person? Am i expecting too much?

Last session they tried to make me do a pie chart of my "priorities" and I just felt like I was in some bloody team building exercise

Any tips?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
minny80 · 25/05/2023 07:28

On and off therapy since ever. I sometimes find it useful, sometimes waste of time. In my experience the therapist is the main factor in the usefulness of the process. However therapy tends to be for the long run. I tried life coaching and tbh I feel I achieved much better results in shorter periods

speakout · 25/05/2023 07:10

I agree that the relationship with our therapist is crucially important. And yes the healing is done in relationship, but a lot of healing is done by the client themselves outside of the therapy room.
I need to apply a certain degree of conscious thought to my healing process- that's the way it works for me.
Becoming aware of how we are thinking and feeling in our day to day is important to me, that observation to notice if I am triggered, rumination, dwelling on negative thought processes, becoming angry or impatient.

For instance healthy boundaries has been /is an issue for me. When confronted with a situation I can recall conversations in therapy and make a counscious decision to set boundaries.
That takes courage and has an outcome- I will bring this to therapy to discuss. Athough important work is done in therapy, it's up to me to put my new realisations, ways of thinking into practice.
I understand why some psychotherapists use the word titration, and have read Levine's work.
I understand where he is coming from, but I am a chemist and not sure he has a real grasp of what titration means ( having carried out thousands of titrations in a laboratory myself). There is no risk of explosion during a titration, if there was another method of analysis would be chosen.

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 24/05/2023 23:16

Cannot stress this enough. If you feel like it's a waste of time, look for another therapist. It's taken me a long time to find one that fits and she's been such a help.
Before her, I was beginning to think it was a total waste of time/money

prooses · 24/05/2023 22:14

@gardendream thank you for this, your comment was really enlightening and has helped me think of it a bit differently.

gardendream · 24/05/2023 06:52

It’s the experience of the relationship between the client and therapist that’s healing. Not the earth shattering moments of realisation or the intellectual understanding. You can intellectually understand things like attachment theory and attraction, your past experiences and why you fall for similar partners. But the thing that stops you falling for similar partners again is the experience of a different kind of relationship - the one with the therapist - and experiencing things like emotional attunement, listening, validation etc from them.

CBT will help with the intellectual understanding, but even CBT is more effective when you build up a trusting relationship with the therapist. Personally I’ve found a lot of healing in a longer term psychotherapy relationship because I used to intellectualise and rationalise my feelings away as a coping mechanism, and psychotherapy has helped me let go of that and sink down into my body, my feelings.

The bad kinds of relationships you experience early on get encoded in your brain/nervous system and it takes the work of experiencing something different, feeling the feelings that brings up for you (which can be a lot of grief - sort of a bittersweet feeling of experiencing something healthy and the sadness that can bring up about the unhealthiness you’ve experienced before), having the therapist’s help to tolerate those feelings and sort through the grief bit by bit. And in my experience, doing that over and over again until you’ve gradually sorted through the grief til the point that those good experiences don’t spark so much pain and actually feel good and desirable. And the bad kinds of relationships begin to lose their draw because you feel them for what they are - unhealthy - and you’re not drawn to them anymore.

It’s slow work because the nervous system doesn’t like to change quickly and doesn’t cope with overwhelm, so it has to happen in baby steps. The neural pathways built so early in life are hard to break and it’s by repeated small experiences of change that you forge new pathways in your brain. It’s like treading a path through a field until the grass wears away and the path becomes established. Look up the concept of titration in trauma recovery (Dr Peter Levine).

speakout · 21/05/2023 13:07

iwillnotstaycalm · 21/05/2023 11:13

Have a read on attachment and the different styles, this might help. I'm training to be a therapist and to be perfectly honest a therapist isn't going to tell you why you are like you are, the work is in finding it out for yourself and then (should you wish to change it) finding ways of changing things that suit you and what you want in life Daffodil

I agree- it is up to the client to come to these realisations.

No point in being "told" by a therapist where our maladaptations come from.
A therapist may know or see, but it is up to the client to find the clarity. We can be steered towards those lightbulb moments, but ultimately the whole point in the therapy is for the client to work that out.
Then it is fully understood and healing can begin.

I laugh when I have thes lightbub moments, because I can see my therapist help me uncover all the pieces- laid bare in front of me , but still sometimes I struggle to fit it all together. When I do- and that happens frequently there is usually some humour because I imagine the therapist must be frustrated and holding herself back somewhat- like watching a 2 year old opening a sweet wrapper. So tempting to rush in and do it for them, but far more important they do it for themselves in order to learn.
My therapy is full of laughter, and often tears of sadness, grief and sorrow.

iwillnotstaycalm · 21/05/2023 11:13

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 21:07

I want to see a therapist to work out why I keep ending up with men who want me to mother them. And why I mother them all and am this awful people pleaser. And then I build up all this resentment and then go crazy or just leave and never speak to them agai.n

Have a read on attachment and the different styles, this might help. I'm training to be a therapist and to be perfectly honest a therapist isn't going to tell you why you are like you are, the work is in finding it out for yourself and then (should you wish to change it) finding ways of changing things that suit you and what you want in life Daffodil

Endoftheroad12345 · 21/05/2023 09:10

I’ve been going to a therapist once a month since ending my marriage in November. I’ve found it valuable but not earth shattering if that makes sense - possibly because I’d already made the big change I needed to make. So seeing the therapist helped me feel that yes, leaving was a valid choice/my ex really was abusive/my ex MIL really was vile.

I did get a few insights into why I ended up with my ex but no lightbulb moments. But I found it helped to talk to someone independent and I’m sure my best friend/sister/mum were glad of the break from me obsessing about my ex’s latest arsehole antics.

InchHighPrivateI · 21/05/2023 08:27

Not a therapist but I think going for useless men can be about insecurity and fear of abandonment. Picking someone who can’t cope without you is a way of making sure they stay (he can’t leave- who would wash his socks?) But because you’re also an intelligent and competent person this also doesn’t feel right for you.

Would your life be easier without your husband, do you think? Or do you think he could step up more if you asked him? Sorry about your panic attack- they really are scary. Any chance you can get signed off work for a bit? Sounds as if things are getting too much and it might be wise to take a break before you feel completely overwhelmed.

HarryViles · 21/05/2023 08:16

Thank you so much all for being so helpful. I will look up all the suggested approaches. I didn't realise there were so many types.

I did go to the GP recently as had my first full blown panic attack which seemed to come from nowhere. I thought I was having a heart attack it was so painful - arms going light and tingly, pain though my chest, sick. He referred me to CBT for anxiety which not sure about and I'm on a waiting list for that.

The last therapy session was with someone new and expensive and made me feel v upset and frustrated. But I do recognise I need something even if that wasn't right.

But I have to be willing to make the change I know. They can't fix my life for me!!

I feel like I have clarity on my relationship in the sense its hugely unequal and I'm taken for granted. I just want to know why I put up with that and always have. Every man in my life has been both seemingly obsessive and cruel and also almost childlike in their incompetence.

I want to find the strength to leave but I also need to stop the pattern somehow. Or just stay away from men forever which is pretty appealing.

OP posts:
PeloMom · 20/05/2023 17:40

It sounds like this is the wrong therapist for you. I remember the first time I saw a good for me fit therapist- I left the appointment feeling like I was floating and finally felt understood and validated. Please do yourself a favour and keep looking for a better fit

SparklyShoesandTutus · 20/05/2023 16:12

The modality of therapist you are using plays a huge part in this.
You are asking some pretty deep questions. As you want to understand why you do what you do rather than how to possibly change what you do so you are probably looking for a more psychodynamic approach than what you have now if they are asking you to complete a priority pie chart.
However saying this I'd guess something is changing as you have pretty successfully stated what you want here which is a huge step if you usually play a maternal role and always do things for others putting their needs before your own.
Good luck.

BCBird · 20/05/2023 16:07

I was having talking therapy for bereavement due to suicide of my partner and just felt like it was an hour to cry,but realistically it wasn't helping. My friend kept asking if we had come up with any strategies-nope.

InchHighPrivateI · 20/05/2023 16:03

How are you doing, @HarryViles

dimorphism · 19/05/2023 23:53

RedToothBrush · 18/05/2023 14:08

Ditch the husband you need to mother. THEN work that out!

What you are doing is trying to find ways to fix the DH who isn't going to change.

THAT'S what your issue is. Going for people you think you can fix. And then wondering why you can't.

Well @RedToothBrush saved the OP £1000 and many wasted hours of therapy (that could have been spent doing something else) there.

I tend to agree, and if you can't leave immediately either make a plan or at the very least accept he's not going to change. He is clearly not decent enough to step up when he can see his partner is struggling, it's highly unlikely he's going to change as he's selfish and the status quo suits him nicely.

RedToothBrush · 18/05/2023 14:08

HarryViles · 17/05/2023 21:07

I want to see a therapist to work out why I keep ending up with men who want me to mother them. And why I mother them all and am this awful people pleaser. And then I build up all this resentment and then go crazy or just leave and never speak to them agai.n

Ditch the husband you need to mother. THEN work that out!

What you are doing is trying to find ways to fix the DH who isn't going to change.

THAT'S what your issue is. Going for people you think you can fix. And then wondering why you can't.

speakout · 18/05/2023 14:05

women often think they're the ones who need 'fixing' when actually it's their external environment and other people that's causing the problem.

It isn't about "fixing" though.
Therapy can lead a woman to a place where she finds her self esteem, her voice, recognises her needs and the courage to act.
When we find our self worth we are less likely to put up with bad situations which cause further damage.
We all have options in life, it may seem financially impossible to leave a man who has no respect for others, but staying with him is not without cost.

Fiddlededeefiddlededoh · 18/05/2023 13:56

dimorphism · 18/05/2023 13:24

why you are allowing your husband to be such a dead weight in your life and why you have not done anything about it yet...and bring you to the realisation that you need to make some radical changes in your life.

Victim blaming and assumptions.

A lot of women can't financially afford to leave, no matter how much of a dick the man is, and you cannot force a man who is bigger and stronger than you to adult up. Some just won't. What are you supposed to do if he just refuses to do any housework or childcare?

Shelter spaces are few and far between and generally reserved for women facing more extreme forms of abuse.

OP has kids with special needs, I don't think she has the time or money that is being assumed - in that she can just try therapy after therapy and has the time to do so - by most of the posters on this thread.

Agree with PP who said that women often think they're the ones who need 'fixing' when actually it's their external environment and other people that's causing the problem.

Well said @dimorphism

dimorphism · 18/05/2023 13:24

why you are allowing your husband to be such a dead weight in your life and why you have not done anything about it yet...and bring you to the realisation that you need to make some radical changes in your life.

Victim blaming and assumptions.

A lot of women can't financially afford to leave, no matter how much of a dick the man is, and you cannot force a man who is bigger and stronger than you to adult up. Some just won't. What are you supposed to do if he just refuses to do any housework or childcare?

Shelter spaces are few and far between and generally reserved for women facing more extreme forms of abuse.

OP has kids with special needs, I don't think she has the time or money that is being assumed - in that she can just try therapy after therapy and has the time to do so - by most of the posters on this thread.

Agree with PP who said that women often think they're the ones who need 'fixing' when actually it's their external environment and other people that's causing the problem.

EducatingArti · 18/05/2023 13:19

Just chiming in here to say that I've also found Gestalt therapy incredibly helpful, although I'd love to know how to get it for free!

SparklyBlackKitten · 18/05/2023 13:05

Saying that therapy is useless and not beneficial just means you haven't spoken to the right therapist

There are 37385 different therapists and methods out there. And you have tried only 1.

It's like saying you never want to go out for dinner again because its gross, but the only place you have been to is MacDonalds

Find yourself a different therapist.
Because once you find the right fit; if will be like dining with the queen.

It will be a mouthwatering and eye opening experience.

unfor · 18/05/2023 12:51

I have seen quite a few therapists and am training to be one. In my experience there are more unsuitable therapists out there than suitable ones. You need somebody who is skilled AND that you have a good vibe with. In my experience the magic is either there or it is not. If you don't feel excited/hopeful after the first session, move on. I take the point made by a PP about this being expensive, but it's cheaper than spending months seeing a therapist who leaves you cold.

Mary46 · 18/05/2023 12:33

Hope u ok. Op I felt therapy was a neutral person not family so a positive. It gave me the pointers to put in place and better boundaries. But agree not a quick fix for people.

Greenfairydust · 18/05/2023 12:15

Therapy won't fix all your practical issues and is not an instant solution. That's not the point of it.

But it might help you work out why you are allowing your husband to be such a dead weight in your life and why you have not done anything about it yet...and bring you to the realisation that you need to make some radical changes in your life.

A therapist doesn't magically give you all the answers on how to fix your life, it is a team effort and you have to try to be clear about what you want to achieve and open with them.

I had therapy after a sexual assault to help me first deal with the trauma and then to look at my life in general and what I wanted to change.

It helped me looked at patterns and how I allowed toxic men/relatives and friends into my life. It helped me establish healthier boundaries and be clearer about what I wanted my life to be from then on.

It is difficult process that can take time but it is worth it.

It might also take a few trials for you to find the right therapist.

Also, it is not an easy process, if you discuss trauma for example you will also have a period when you start feeling worse, lost and so on which is completely normal because you are suddenly bringing to the surface really painful memories for example. It does take a while to see the benefits so it is not an instant fix.

Also, when you start becoming more assertive, having a better understanding of what is affecting you and so on, be prepared for all the negative and draining people in your life to not be happy with the ''new you'' but in the end I really found it incredibly helpful.

CareerQuestioner · 18/05/2023 11:38

Good post @dimorphism

OP has a lot on her plate and (by her own admission) a tendency to do everything for everyone. It’s a problem if therapy becomes just another task to do (at worst, doing everything for your husband and feeling you have to get therapy in order to feel ok about doing it). I do think women can sometimes feel that, if they’re not ok with how things are, they’re the one who needs to be “fixed”. Haven’t seen OP mention whether her husband is having therapy to try to be less of a waste of space.