Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Dog walker killed by her own XL Bully Breed dog.

421 replies

BethDuttonsTwin · 17/05/2023 18:30

NOT a pack of 8 dogs as was reported repeatedly with concurrent complete slating of all professional dog walkers.

Absolutely awful. So many of us who have worked with dogs knew this would be the outcome and that packs of 8 dogs do not behave in this way.

After investigations are complete we are now told that the only dog destroyed was the walkers own XL Bully Breed dog. Over and over again it is these dogs and still today I see a man strutting around my locale with two of these type dogs, both unneutered and off lead 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
GettingStuffed · 22/05/2023 09:59

The American Kennel Club recommends all American bulldog types as ideal family pets. Is it the breed itself or is it the way it's being bred in the UK.

I really want a dog but until there is more control over dogs in public I'm not trying to convince DH we should have one

WisherWood · 22/05/2023 09:47

And in fact yes, injuries are on the rise. You can't see the full article without a subscription, but the stats are quoted at the start https://www.bmj.com/content/381/bmj.p879.full

I mean, it's nowhere near the size of the problem of RTCs and I'd like to see more done about that, but it's not either/ or and given how closely we live with dogs, it is I think something that's worth taking measured action on.

Rising fatalities, injuries, and NHS costs: dog bites as a public health problem

Numbers of dog related injuries are rising in the UK, so should attacks be treated as a public health concern? Adele Waters considers what should be done to tackle the problem Last year saw a sudden jump in the number of people in England and Wales dy...

https://www.bmj.com/content/381/bmj.p879.full

WisherWood · 22/05/2023 09:43

Luckily fatal dog attacks are very rare. 2022 was a blip with 10 deaths, but they usually average about 3 a year, in a population of nearly 70 million.

I think it's too early to say it's a blip. There have been 4 deaths so far this year. To work out whether it's a blip or a part of a pattern with a definite cause, we may need more time. It has coincided with the end of lockdown, so many puppies bought during lockdown will be maturing into adolescent dogs and will have seen changes in the way they're looked after as their owners work outside the home more. So we may be seeing the results of that.

As I said above, fatal attacks will be the tip of a triangle. So if non-fatal dog bites have also seen this substantial rise, then there is a probably a pattern emerging.

izimbra · 22/05/2023 09:37

"Having an aggressive temperament isn’t enough in itself, it is the sheer ability to do damage"

My elderly mum was hospitalised by my sister's springer spaniel two years ago - savaged her hand. Dog bites can be really serious, even the non-fatal ones.

izimbra · 22/05/2023 09:35

Redebs · 21/05/2023 22:05

That's an American opinion piece. No factual basis.

'No factual basis'

Except the opinion in this piece refers to research and evidence - so there is a factual basis for it.

But if you want something else - this from the RVC https://www.rvc.ac.uk/vetcompass/news/english-cocker-spaniels-a-fairly-typical-but-potentially-moody-dog

Still doesn't change my view that the real problem with XL Bullies/pitbulls isn't their temperament but the fact that their strength makes them difficult to fight off in the event that they attack you, which is just one reason why they're over represented when it comes to fatal dog attacks.

Luckily fatal dog attacks are very rare. 2022 was a blip with 10 deaths, but they usually average about 3 a year, in a population of nearly 70 million.

English Cocker Spaniels – a fairly typical, but potentially moody, dog - News - VetCompass - Royal Veterinary College, RVC

https://www.rvc.ac.uk/vetcompass/news/english-cocker-spaniels-a-fairly-typical-but-potentially-moody-dog

Sarvanga38 · 22/05/2023 08:31

Lilacsbloominspring · 22/05/2023 03:55

It really isn’t about aggression.

Let’s say someone did a study on fish, and concludes all fish will bite humans. So there is no difference between swimming in the sea where minnows will nibble your toes and where a great white shark will bite you. They will both bite you! So what’s the difference?

Can people honestly not see how stupid this insistence that some types of dog are no more dangerous than others is? Maybe some Yorkies are nasty. I accept that, I’ve known some horrid ones. Maybe some minnows harbour a deep desire to eat human flesh. Having an aggressive temperament isn’t enough in itself, it is the sheer ability to do damage.

Excellent analogy. The wilful ignorance of the problems these breeds are causing - and the chances are that we are seeing the tip of the iceberg yet, with the increase in their numbers - is just mind boggling.

These dogs cannot be controlled by the average human if they decide they don't want to be, and they have the mental and physical make-up to do extensive damage ... and to kill. They have no place in domestic settings. (In fact, I can see no place for them at all.)

Diarea · 22/05/2023 07:50

Mirabai · 17/05/2023 19:51

I don’t think anyone knew it would be, it wasn’t one of the dog breeds mentioned at the time. Any type of dog can attack in a pack situation, surely everyone knows that.

Why do you think nobody mentioned the presence of an XL bully when the story first came out?

Because it would be fucking obvious from the start that yet another person had been killed by an XL Bully!

Diarea · 22/05/2023 07:42

Changethatnameagain2 · 17/05/2023 18:43

The leonberger was known to be problematic too so that may well be destroyed.

The Leonberger was not problematic. It featured on a puppy training program when it was a puppy … it chewed stuff and was bitey … because it was a puppy. It also had a useless owner who should have had a goldfish instead.

Diarea · 22/05/2023 07:41

Changethatnameagain2 · 17/05/2023 18:43

Are XL Bullies just a back door way of legalising American pit bulls?

Yes. They need banning along with American bulldogs and all the other “pit bull alternatives”

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/05/2023 05:54

LadyRos · 21/05/2023 17:29

UKC do register American Bullies as my dog has these papers and yes she is insured.

why people on this site spread lies or talk about things they don’t know.

Try upping your reading comprehension - UKC will register damn near anything if theres enough demand, which is why they're not considered a particularly reputable dog registry across the rest of the world. They register breeds no one else recognises as breeds (even in that types country of origin!).

I said the AKC do not recognised or register the APBT. Only the American Staffordshire Terrier.

AmStaffs reg with the AKC can be dual registered, as APBT with the UKC.

I did not discuss AKC registration of American Bulldogs at all as I was explaining that Pitbull/pitbull type ownership stats are skewed, because so many are not registered as such with the organisations that provide the data being used.

Lilacsbloominspring · 22/05/2023 03:55

It really isn’t about aggression.

Let’s say someone did a study on fish, and concludes all fish will bite humans. So there is no difference between swimming in the sea where minnows will nibble your toes and where a great white shark will bite you. They will both bite you! So what’s the difference?

Can people honestly not see how stupid this insistence that some types of dog are no more dangerous than others is? Maybe some Yorkies are nasty. I accept that, I’ve known some horrid ones. Maybe some minnows harbour a deep desire to eat human flesh. Having an aggressive temperament isn’t enough in itself, it is the sheer ability to do damage.

HaggisBurger · 21/05/2023 22:12

Sarvanga38 · 21/05/2023 18:34

Google is indeed your friend.

Moving past the fact that you've had to search the world for a pack of 'dachshunds' killing a woman several years ago, where Google can show various instances within the UK in very recent history have been killed by teh breeds in question here ...

Google will demonstrate, if you look further, that the dogs that killed Tracy Garcia might have had some mixed breeds in them, but they were predominantly pit bull. I recommend caution in Googling it though, mind, as the reports show photos of the deceased dogs which will leave no-one in any doubt that their primary genetic make-up didn't own much to Dachshunds or Collies.

Nice work, arguing the wrong side of the argument. Top marks.

Indeed @Sarvanga38 !

WisherWood · 21/05/2023 22:06

@izimbra I wasn't arguing that they're inherently more aggressive, but that they're more likely to bite, under current circumstances. The quotes you give don't contradict that. They acknowledge that there is no level playing field and that these breeds may be trained to bite more.

In terms of examining the stats on dog bites, I think there's a lot going on:
How many of each breed are there?
Is the breed correctly identified?
What's its socialisation and training been like?
Does its bite strength mean its more likely to turn up in the stats?

Part of the problem is that we don't really know how often dogs are biting. The numbers are probably a triangle, with a comparatively large number of minor bites at the bottom, that don't require treatment and so don't show up in that stats. That then rises through bites that do require treatment up the small number of fatalities at the top.

I don't think these are inherently bad dogs in some way. I've known some really lovely SBTs for example. But the thing with bull breeds and mastiffs is they are large and powerful and they do seem to attract owners who cannot cope with this. And I've had to split up fights between these dogs. It's a horrific thing to do. I don't know if you've witnessed those kinds of fights but you can hear the flesh ripping. It's fucking grim.

Redebs · 21/05/2023 22:05

izimbra · 21/05/2023 21:56

"You're a lot less likely to encounter a bully, but if you do, it's much more likely to bite"

I'm not sure there's good evidence to back this up. https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2011/aug/03/elaine-boyer/are-pit-bulls-more-aggressive-other-dogs/

"The two types of pit bulls (the American Pit Bull Terrier and American Staffordshire Terrier) they’ve studied have aggression scores that are not as bad as boxers, bulldogs, collies, Great Danes, Greyhounds and Shetland sheepdogs. They are in the same range as the German Shepherd and golden retriever. Labrador retrievers scored better than pit bulls.

"On an even playing field, a pit bull is no more dangerous than a collie," said Salliann Comstock, the society’s chief tester and director of operations.

Comstock contends pit bulls are trained to be aggressive and argues many people, including some animal shelter workers, mistake other animals for pit bulls."

That's an American opinion piece. No factual basis.

Redebs · 21/05/2023 22:03

My local news website has a feature on a dogs charity with adoption hopefuls. There are six dogs:
One imported stray
Two staffy- crosses
One xl bully
A greyhound and a saluki - both high prey-driven

What could possibly go wrong?

izimbra · 21/05/2023 21:56

"You're a lot less likely to encounter a bully, but if you do, it's much more likely to bite"

I'm not sure there's good evidence to back this up. https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2011/aug/03/elaine-boyer/are-pit-bulls-more-aggressive-other-dogs/

"The two types of pit bulls (the American Pit Bull Terrier and American Staffordshire Terrier) they’ve studied have aggression scores that are not as bad as boxers, bulldogs, collies, Great Danes, Greyhounds and Shetland sheepdogs. They are in the same range as the German Shepherd and golden retriever. Labrador retrievers scored better than pit bulls.

"On an even playing field, a pit bull is no more dangerous than a collie," said Salliann Comstock, the society’s chief tester and director of operations.

Comstock contends pit bulls are trained to be aggressive and argues many people, including some animal shelter workers, mistake other animals for pit bulls."

PolitiFact - Are pit bulls more aggressive than other dogs?

DeKalb County commissioners are considering a reversal of an ordinance that has tongues wagging in Georgia’s third highe

https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2011/aug/03/elaine-boyer/are-pit-bulls-more-aggressive-other-dogs

izimbra · 21/05/2023 21:49

I'm not aware that this breed (XL Bully) is especially aggressive. But I'm aware that their size and strength, and particularly the strength of their bite, makes them extremely dangerous if they do attack. Which is why I'd never, ever own one

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/05/2023 21:35

Olde English Bulldogge

Who, in the name of God, gives a "breed" of dog a name like this?

Stupid, pretentious twonks.

WhiteFire · 21/05/2023 19:18

Too many stupid people own dogs that they are ill equipped to care for properly, whether that is due to lack of capability, lack of money or inappropriate living conditions. Too many dogs live in terrible conditions with terrible owners, and many more are living in 'ok' conditions - not terrible but not really that good either.

The genie is well out of the bottle in terms of improving the situation though. So pp can wang on about how great they are, how wonderful their dog is and take personal affront at any suggestion that issues are more prevalent around particular breeds, but it doesn't change anything for the dogs living in terrible conditions.

SidekickSylvia · 21/05/2023 19:02

LadyRos · 21/05/2023 17:25

Is a bulldog and a bully the same breed? Did you miss the yorkie that bit me as well? Funny only the bulldog (which isn’t an XL bully) stuck out to you.

LadyRos, according to the United Kennel Club, the present day American Bully breed is a hybrid influenced by the American Bulldog, English Bulldog and Olde English Bulldogge.

As Sarvanga38 said, the dogs that killed Tracy Garcia were not Dachshunds, it just made a better story because it would be unusual. They were small, but clearly pit bull and pit mixes.

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/05/2023 18:59

oakleaffy · 21/05/2023 16:03

Akitas I’m wary of and Chows - plus some Huskies - Around other dogs.
Oldschool Staffies are normally good with people
Have mentioned before the first Imported APBT I saw
he was in an Antiques shop, the owner wasn’t there, so I sat and waited with the dog who had the hugest gape I’d seen at that time.
When the owner came in he was annoyed and said “ That dog should have had your arm off- I bought him to guard my shop”

He’d come out of 6 months quarantine- and had cost an absolute fortune- sold to the antiques guy as a “ Guard”

I was so say one of the first strangers the dog had seen-(Notting Hill)
The antiques dealer was not pleased that his dog didn’t even growl or bark.

He was a good natured dog- just ambled over -

I had no idea then how dangerous they could potentially be-

This one was a “ Red nose Pit”supposedly from a “ Game” line.

The guy was all about “ Status” and wanting to appear tough.

When the owner came in he was annoyed and said “ That dog should have had your arm off- I bought him to guard my shop”

Well . . . . that's reassuring . . . 😬

(Agree re: chows as well - powerful, short-tempered animals in my experience, and not particularly good with other dogs.

Huskies are a stupid dog to have for a pet. The vast majority of the lazy owners never run them. They're not meant to have a walk around a park. The poor things need to do what they were bred for.

@megletthesecond - That is exactly right. Bred to be guards, herders, whatever - independent, energetic, and courageous, then stuck indoors 23 hours a day, many of those hours on their own, bored, under-exercised, lonely, and quite literally quietly going mad. Dogs need company, they need exercise and they need mental stimulation.

Sarvanga38 · 21/05/2023 18:36

(God, we need an edit function on here, that post is part gibberish.)

Sarvanga38 · 21/05/2023 18:34

LadyRos · 21/05/2023 17:32

NEWYORK POST 2018:

A pack of vicious small dogs mauled an Oklahoma woman to death, according to reports.
Tracy Garcia was standing outside her home last week when what are believed to be her neighbor’s six standard dachshund and terrier mixes and one border collie mix suddenly attacked her — leaving her with injuries so severe, she later died.

google is your friend 😀

Google is indeed your friend.

Moving past the fact that you've had to search the world for a pack of 'dachshunds' killing a woman several years ago, where Google can show various instances within the UK in very recent history have been killed by teh breeds in question here ...

Google will demonstrate, if you look further, that the dogs that killed Tracy Garcia might have had some mixed breeds in them, but they were predominantly pit bull. I recommend caution in Googling it though, mind, as the reports show photos of the deceased dogs which will leave no-one in any doubt that their primary genetic make-up didn't own much to Dachshunds or Collies.

Nice work, arguing the wrong side of the argument. Top marks.

oakleaffy · 21/05/2023 17:46

Mirabai · 21/05/2023 16:27

Why would anyone leave a bully unattended in a shop? What if parents with kids had come in and annoyed it?

I completely agree with you.
It was very irresponsible to leave any dog unattended in a shop.
Had kids rushed over to him it could have been a different outcome.

Kids are small, fast and move in an erratic manner - and squeal depending on age.

A Jack Russell ( Elderly) was fallen on by a toddler who slipped on a magazine-
The child needed A&E from that snap.

Little children and dogs are a risky combo-

How often does one see social media vids of toddlers gleefully bouncing up and down on a “Good with kids” dog’s back?
The dogs often look long suffering- Also young children grabbing dog’s facial hair and ramming their face close to the dog-

Makes me wince.

The parents laugh it off “ Oh so and so is great with kids”

But why allow it to happen in first place-?
It’s all ok til it’s not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread