Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can my work do this? Ah!

220 replies

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 16:16

So I have a new job, and gave notice (4 weeks) to my current job at the beginning of May, in writing to my manager over email. I wrote a letter of resignation and attached it and my manager wrote back and it was accepted etc.

I was told I would hear from HR regarding my left over annual leave/last day etc, but as I hadn’t heard from them I messaged today to ask if all was ok.

Well, it turns out that my manager never gave them my resignation or told them I was leaving- and HR have said that they can only accept my resignation from today’s date and if I was to leave before this, it would have to be out of my remaining annual leave balance.

I am due to finish on Friday, take a weeks annual leave and then start my new job. Can they really make me work four weeks if this wasn’t my fault? And will they take my annual leave balance from me if so?

Btw, our annual leave runs June- July and I’ve only take 3 days- so would be owed a bit I think.

OP posts:
Emdubz · 17/05/2023 19:07

This has got to be the most frustrating thread I have ever read (and not your fault OP, you explained it perfectly).

Yes, definitely take it to ACAS. They are taking the piss.

I’m off to lie down for a bit as the lack of understanding has given me a headache.

CornishAdventures · 17/05/2023 19:01

It’s worth reading your contract and company policy/handbook as to the giving notice. If it states in there that you need to inform HR directly then you may need to discuss further. If they have offered for you to use your annual leave then you merely finish at the same time and the annual leave payment replaces the salary, no emergency tax complications. If the policy states you give notice to your manager, then forwarding on the acceptance should be plentiful enough. They will need to pay your final salary and annual leave on top. This will inflate the tax you pay as the system thinks you’ll be earning this amount every month but the tax will correct itself within a month or two in your next job

fajitaaa · 17/05/2023 18:56

I am so surprised at how few people are getting this

coxesorangepippin · 17/05/2023 18:47

Definitely use some of the terminology in this thread, shit MN is good in cases of injustice!!

✊✊

Allergictoironing · 17/05/2023 18:44

I had a recent very similar situation. I resigned from my job as it was having an impact on my mental health - not the fault of the company, I just wasn't up to the very extreme pressures of that particular role.

My choices were to either work out my 1 month notice period (no chance, was virtually at breakdown), or to resign with immediate effect which would be considered breach of contract. I couldn't go on paid sick leave as I hadn't actually broken at that point, was just well on the way to it, and also things complicated by me still being in my probationary period.

The financial impact of this was not only was I not paid the 5 days annual leave I'd accrued as I was in breach of contract, but I had to pay THEM back 2 days worth of pay as we were paid (for the entire month) just before I left and there were 2 more days left in the month. Big local government organisation with big HR department that does everything by the book.

I think the most annoying part of it all was that they could give me 1 week notice during probation, but I was contracted to a full month notice.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/05/2023 18:32

briansgardenshed · 17/05/2023 18:23

I can't see that it makes any difference. OP will be paid for her holiday either way.

Oh my god. No.

Say the OP earns £300 per week. She also has 3 weeks annual leave (just using these numbers for example).

OP puts in her 4 weeks notice and expects to work for 4 weeks, earning £1200. She then expects to get a lump sum of £900 when she leaves.

However as this has not happened, her HR said she can still leave at the end of her 4th week and be paid £1200, but they will retain the £900 owed to her for AL in payment for the failure to work the notice period.

So in my example the OP would then be short £900 because her manager failed to do their job.

I'd push this straight back onto the manager tomorrow and not let it lie til they have sorted it with HR.

PlanningTowns · 17/05/2023 18:28

I would suggest you also look at the grievance process and submit one before you leave (talk to Ava’s about that). Your grievance is that you provided written notice to your manager that was accepted (provide the emails), and that you are now being told you have not served notice and to compensate then you will loose you’re accrued leave.

the solution that you want is for acknowledgment that notice was appropriately served and that they will honour the holiday pay in your final salary package (or whatever you are after).

Smineusername · 17/05/2023 18:27

Never mind ACAS, your fucking manager should sort it. Seriously.

HermioneWeasley · 17/05/2023 18:26

Suggest something along the following lines

dear HR
there seems to be a misunderstanding- I resigned in writing on date - see attached emails for your reference. Therefore in line with the notice I am required to give, my last day will
be x and I am owed y days for holiday accrued but not taken. Your suggestion that because your department was not informed by my manager, I am somehow in breach of my contract and therefore you are proposing to withhold my holiday pay is extremely heavy handed, bordering on harassment. It is outrageous that you have placed such unnecessary stress on me in my last few days with the company. Withholding my accrued holiday pay would be considered variously as a breach of contract, an unlawful deduction from wages, and/or a breach of the working time regulations which are of course a matter of health and safety law. I look forward to your confirmation that you agree my last working day is x and you will be paying my accrued holiday.

briansgardenshed · 17/05/2023 18:23

I can't see that it makes any difference. OP will be paid for her holiday either way.

Outdamnspot23 · 17/05/2023 18:19

I think you need to forward a copy of the reply to your notice email from your boss to both the boss and HR and say - here is evidence I gave notice on X date. As such I'm entitled to leave on Y date and receive my holiday pay.

If you continue to insist on not paying me what I am due I will be going to ACAS and consulting with lawyers.

Put the wind up them.

UniversalAunt · 17/05/2023 18:19

@Workdilemmma our posts have just crossed.

Many firms will not pay up cash for yet-to-use holiday, e.g. effectively buying your holidays days off you. Fair enough.

But at least you’d take your unused holidays up to your agreed leaving date, so that although your monthly pay would be the same, you’d get the time off.

JenWillsiam · 17/05/2023 18:17

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 17:07

Yes, sorry I think people are misunderstanding. Essentially HR are saying that if I leave on Friday, I’ll have jumped ship and they’ll be taken the annual leave accrued to cover the “loss” so essentially I won’t be paid for it.

They cannot do that.

HurryShadow · 17/05/2023 18:17

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 18:14

Hey all, sorry just got in.

they have strictly said that it will be to recoup the costs to cover me not working my notice and that I wouldn’t be paid for it. That’s what my dilemma is.

If as some were suggesting, that I take the remaining 3 weeks notice as holiday and get paid the holiday pay- fine, ends up the same money but could have emergency tax implications anyway.

For what it’s worth, our HR is two people outsourced from a larger HR company so they are not in house as such and one of them is on A/L so I can’t even get advice from the other.

but I am planning on calling ACAS tomorrow.

I think it's sensible to get clarity from ACAS OP and get HR to confirm, in writing, exactly what you're going to be paid for.

We have an outsourced "expert" HR company and I have had some very poor advice from them recently which has cost us time and money, so I would take what your HR people say with a significant pinch of salt.

HurryShadow · 17/05/2023 18:15

TallerThanAverage · 17/05/2023 18:00

I do love a spreadsheet!

Takes a bow

(I got to use colour shading and everything!)

UniversalAunt · 17/05/2023 18:14

Dear HR,

I am kindly disposed to let you know that I have discussed my situation with the ACAS Helpdesk & I am advised of X,Y & Z.

I hope that this helps clarify my claim that I resigned correctly on (date) by UK employment law, & I will be leaving on the date agreed at the time of my resignation. I expect to be paid for x days untaken holiday leave from pro rata my annual allowance based on ACAS advice. Copies of emails about my resignation attached below.

If it will help to clarify matters further, I will accept the ACAS offer to write directly to HR Director about this situation.

Yours for not much longer,
@Workdilemmma

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 18:14

Hey all, sorry just got in.

they have strictly said that it will be to recoup the costs to cover me not working my notice and that I wouldn’t be paid for it. That’s what my dilemma is.

If as some were suggesting, that I take the remaining 3 weeks notice as holiday and get paid the holiday pay- fine, ends up the same money but could have emergency tax implications anyway.

For what it’s worth, our HR is two people outsourced from a larger HR company so they are not in house as such and one of them is on A/L so I can’t even get advice from the other.

but I am planning on calling ACAS tomorrow.

OP posts:
peachicecream · 17/05/2023 18:09

Whichnumbers · 17/05/2023 17:15

That was going to happen in any case

Im confused as to what the issue is

yes your manager fucked up, but you'll be leaving Friday anyway and the annual leave will have to be paid to you

if your manager hadn't fucked up you'd be leaving anyway on Friday and annual leave would be paid anyway

The issue is that they are saying they will not pay the annual leave.

This is illegal, OP, and you could threaten legal proceedings if they don't pay it - assuming you gave notice as per your contractual requirements and weren't meant to go directly to HR.

rozzyraspberry · 17/05/2023 18:07

Hurrayshadow at 17.40 explains it perfectly.

MarkWithaC · 17/05/2023 18:02

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 16:22

I’ve forwarded them the email acceptance from my manager and I’ll be leaving no matter what, but I’m just annoyed at the possibility they might take my annual leave balance.

Have they contacted you since you forwarded this email? If so, what have they said?
If they're holding the line about withholding your annual leave pay, I would casually mention getting legal advice.

Reugny · 17/05/2023 18:02

Soapyspuds · 17/05/2023 18:01

If you do this make sure you first send yourself all the past and future emails and correspondence to a private email address because HR often will simply deactivate your work email and work account and then you have no evidence because you can’t access your work email

Exactly. I meant private email account as in a non work email address.

If this is a breach of your contract then print everything out including the email headers.

Soapyspuds · 17/05/2023 18:01

If you do this make sure you first send yourself all the past and future emails and correspondence to a private email address because HR often will simply deactivate your work email and work account and then you have no evidence because you can’t access your work email

Exactly. I meant private email account as in a non work email address.

Reugny · 17/05/2023 18:00

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 17:07

Yes, sorry I think people are misunderstanding. Essentially HR are saying that if I leave on Friday, I’ll have jumped ship and they’ll be taken the annual leave accrued to cover the “loss” so essentially I won’t be paid for it.

You have already been given good advice:

  1. Check who your contract says you should hand your resignation.
  2. If it is your manager as you suspect then forward the email you sent to the manager and your managers reply to HR. Also tell HR the date you are leaving as per your notice and state clearly you expect your 3 weeks holiday pay.
  3. If HR come back with any crap contact your union, if you are in one, ACAS or citizens advice.
TallerThanAverage · 17/05/2023 18:00

HurryShadow · 17/05/2023 17:40

OK... so I've just done some calculations and I think, weirdly, OP will end up being paid half a day more doing it the way HR want to!

On the assumption OP originally handed in her notice on 28/04/2023 resulting in a leaving date of 26/05/2023 and having 20 days annual leave per year.

They're saying she's effectively handed her notice in today, giving a leaving date of 14/06/2023. As a result, she's got closer to the end of the holiday year and actually accrued another half day's annual leave.

I've put the calendars in to Excel and noted the notice period under what OP thinks should happen, versus what HR are saying will happen.

They are suggesting her final date of employment is 14/06/2023, though at that point, based on a 20 day annual leave policy, the last 2 days would be unpaid.

However, OP was expecting to be paid until 25/05/2023 plus receive the balance of untaken holiday, which, again, based on 20 days annual leave, would have been a further 10.5 days. 10.5 days on top of 25/05/2023 takes her to the equivalent of half way through 12/06/2023.

It's long winded, and I apologise if I've bamboozled everyone, but I think, as long as they pay OP for the annual leave she's "taking", she'll be OK.

Yes, HMRC will get confused, but they would do anyway. You won't pay too much tax over the course of the year - it will all come out in the wash.

I do love a spreadsheet!

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 17/05/2023 17:58

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 17:46

@HurryShadow

I really wonder about some people.

You don't need the actual P45. You do need go have stopped working for Company A before you start working for Company B.

This will be reflected in your P45. I'm not saying you have to physically have it at the starting point of the new job.

People can and do have multiple concurrent jobs.

However, the new employer might have a contract clause prohibiting secondary employment, which the OP would be in breach of if she was still considered to be in the notice period and therefore employed by the previous employer.

Having more than one job at a time also causes income tax havoc. When I had two part-time jobs concurrently, I was on the emergency tax code for one of them and had to write to HMRC every year to get a refund of overpaid tax. The OP, if employed on emergency tax code by the new employer until the old employer's P45 arrives, would have to remember to do the same in May 2024.