Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can my work do this? Ah!

220 replies

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 16:16

So I have a new job, and gave notice (4 weeks) to my current job at the beginning of May, in writing to my manager over email. I wrote a letter of resignation and attached it and my manager wrote back and it was accepted etc.

I was told I would hear from HR regarding my left over annual leave/last day etc, but as I hadn’t heard from them I messaged today to ask if all was ok.

Well, it turns out that my manager never gave them my resignation or told them I was leaving- and HR have said that they can only accept my resignation from today’s date and if I was to leave before this, it would have to be out of my remaining annual leave balance.

I am due to finish on Friday, take a weeks annual leave and then start my new job. Can they really make me work four weeks if this wasn’t my fault? And will they take my annual leave balance from me if so?

Btw, our annual leave runs June- July and I’ve only take 3 days- so would be owed a bit I think.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 20:15

I cant imagine any HR dept HERE sending an email saying what you belueve to be saying.

No, I read your 'here'.

I'm also not in the UK.

In no jurisdiction should a company be trying to do what they are telling OP, but that's what they are saying.

Regardless of where you are, if a HR dept used 'in lieu' in the way they did with OP, they would mean exactly that - in place of notice, annual leave would be used. It's just language.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 20:12

whilst talking absolute shite?

Because I'm not.

It's not possible to have two jobs that require the same working hours, on the same days, taking the same time

Of course it isn't!

Is it possible to have two jobs concurrently or two roles that are worked at different parts of the day / week / month?

Of course. However that is NOT what the poster who raised this said - if OP was still employed f/t, they could not commence another f/t job.

It's not legality or tax just the laws of physics (and yes, has legal / tax implications).

Really unsure what's going on with basic reading comprehension on this thread. 😩

Sapphire387 · 17/05/2023 20:11

Hi, I work for a trade union. If you have handed your notice in as required in your contract (and it would normally be to your manager, that's how it works in most places)... the fact that your manager has not passed that on is NOT YOUR PROBLEM. You have done your bit, stand your ground, you don't need to atone because your manager fucked up. You are owed your outstanding holiday pay. Forward them your resignation and be very firm - you resigned in time.

Solonge · 17/05/2023 20:09

wildfirewonder · 17/05/2023 16:24

You mean you wanted to be paid? You'll be paid anyway as an employee, won't you effectively have two jobs?

Or is this an internal transfer?

Op is leaving with holiday owing so wishes for the holiday pay to be put in her leaving cheque.

MILLYmo0se · 17/05/2023 20:08

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:44

in lieu' would definitely not mean 'you are not getting paid for any AL!',

It would if they were arguing notice was not given so their accrued leave serves as notice (in lieu of 💁🏻‍♀️)

While reading my post you missed the very important word 'HERE'. Reread it with that word this time and you will realise I am saying that the fact I am not in the UK may be influencing my reading of the situation, and that I cant imagine any HR dept HERE sending an email saying what you belueve to be saying.
Yes I am able to fully read the OPs posts, and yours, and I understand that the word 'in lieu' fits just as well into the scenario I painted as it does yours. That doesnt mean your scenario isnt correct, if HR are very stupid.

Gothambutnotahamster · 17/05/2023 20:05

UniversalAunt · 17/05/2023 18:14

Dear HR,

I am kindly disposed to let you know that I have discussed my situation with the ACAS Helpdesk & I am advised of X,Y & Z.

I hope that this helps clarify my claim that I resigned correctly on (date) by UK employment law, & I will be leaving on the date agreed at the time of my resignation. I expect to be paid for x days untaken holiday leave from pro rata my annual allowance based on ACAS advice. Copies of emails about my resignation attached below.

If it will help to clarify matters further, I will accept the ACAS offer to write directly to HR Director about this situation.

Yours for not much longer,
@Workdilemmma

Agree with this. Good luck Op as it sounds to me like you're just changing their arm!

Batalax · 17/05/2023 20:05

I really think there has been a miscommunication. No reputable company would suggest what you think they are saying.

Schoolchoicesucks · 17/05/2023 19:59

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 17:39

I doubt she will be able to start her new job as working for two employers at the same time may be an issue, especially with tax

Exactly.

In order to get paid by the new firm, she needs tax evidence of cessation of her previous role. A P45 usually.

Why are you berating posters for not being clear about a confusing (and quite possibly misunderstood) report about the OP losing their accrued holiday pay whilst talking absolute shite? Of course you can have 2 jobs, you'll just be taxed more in the one that HMRC thinks is your 2nd one.

OP, talk to your Manager and HR again. Your Manager has messed up. Your employer could only make a deduction from your wages if it is written into your contract and they can demonstrate a loss (ie they'd have to pay someone else to work for those 3 weeks). Most employers would do as many posters here have assumed and make you "take" your holiday for those 3 weeks (so pay you until the end of that period).

lavagal · 17/05/2023 19:59

Absolutely not you can evidence the resignation and the original date it's nit your fault it wasn't passed on !!!!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:44

in lieu' would definitely not mean 'you are not getting paid for any AL!',

It would if they were arguing notice was not given so their accrued leave serves as notice (in lieu of 💁🏻‍♀️)

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:42

@MILLYmo0se

They are not. OP had bloody confirmed this multiple times.

Are they correct?

No.

Is this what they are saying?

Yes.

Should OP be able to sort it?

Also yes, with a firmly written email giving details of her notice being given.

Are you unable to read the OP's posts?

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:41

@Caulidop

You are missing every salient point.

What you have described is a normal situation where a worker decides to use up their leave as part (or in full) of their notice period.

But they have still given notice correctly and with sufficient time.

What OP's HR are trying to claim is that no notice has been given, and her leaving date is the equivalent of OP just walking in & saying 'I'm leaving tomorrow'. In which case, they argue that retention of the leave entitlements serves as notice.

They are incorrect in their interpretation but your post is missing all the key points that are making this a problem for OP.

Scaredtobegin · 17/05/2023 19:40

No they must accept when you put it in originally, if they deduct AL then it’s unlawful. Check your contract resignation procedures though.

MILLYmo0se · 17/05/2023 19:39

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 17:19

the annual leave will have to be paid to you

No. It. Won't.

That's the point - they will not pay that as they are using it in lieu if notice (they argue).

Do some people not know what 'in lieu' means?

I know what it means and in this instance I would understand it to mean that the company will be paying her 3 weeks ( or however long it is) of money labelled as AL in her wageslip (as she obviously wont be physically doing any work for them after Friday) instead of 3 weeks labelled as wages. In my head she d actually end up accuring a few hours extra AL because she ll technically be employed by them for 3 weeks longer. The only other difference I see is her not get a lump payment of last weeks wages and AL all together as she would have with her original plan, and thered be tax implications for getting a wage in her new place and this AL, but equally she d be heavily taxed if she got that lump payment from her current place so probably not much difference.
BUT having said all that Im not in the UK, here 'in lieu' would definitely not mean 'you are not getting paid for any AL!', Im very surprised to hear of any HR person putting that in writing in the UK if they really mean what most of you think they mean.

Caulidop · 17/05/2023 19:33

OP, the employer cannot withhold holiday pay. This really shouldn't (lawfully) end up affecting you in any other way to what you planed, regardless of how they word it.

I'm going to assume you have 4 weeks annual leave left. You were originally planning to finish on date x and take 1 weeks annial leave, plus be paid 3 weeks left over holiday pay. Let's say that was finish this Friday (19th), be still in employment with current employer until 26th, then receive 3 weeks holiday pay owed to you.

If HR are saying you need to give notice now as they haven't received it, and you need to give 4 weeks notice, then give 4 weeks notice and take your annual leave in lieu of notice. This would still mean you can finish on Friday as you are essentially booking your left over 4 weeks leave in now. Your official end date would be June 16th, but your last working day would be this Friday 19th May.

In lieu literally means instead of. Taking annual leave in lieu of notice means taking annual leave instead of working your notice period. If HR have suggested otherwise they are wrong/mistaken.

The financial calculations/implications are the same. Whether you are paid for 3 weeks extra at the end of your current employment, or the payment overlaps with your new employment, income tax owed will still be the same. Being put on an BR/emergency tax code will mean you pay tax on all of your new job salary at 20% for that month. This is correct as you will have used your tax allowance in the same period/month as your last payment from previous employer. If you had 3 weeks owed annual leave paid on your last payment from current employer, it would be taxed at 20% too.

As previously poster said upthread, if anything you may be due extra holiday as you are officially working for longer.

towriteyoumustlive · 17/05/2023 19:29

Workdilemmma · 17/05/2023 18:14

Hey all, sorry just got in.

they have strictly said that it will be to recoup the costs to cover me not working my notice and that I wouldn’t be paid for it. That’s what my dilemma is.

If as some were suggesting, that I take the remaining 3 weeks notice as holiday and get paid the holiday pay- fine, ends up the same money but could have emergency tax implications anyway.

For what it’s worth, our HR is two people outsourced from a larger HR company so they are not in house as such and one of them is on A/L so I can’t even get advice from the other.

but I am planning on calling ACAS tomorrow.

If you have checked your contract and it says to give notice to your line manager, then HR are wrong and your notice has been given and your last day is on Friday.

You need to write back to HR informing them again that notice was given on X date which was accepted and agreed with your manager as per your contract, so your last day will be Friday 19th May 2023.

You should then get paid a pro-rata amount of salary (depending on when you leave vs when you get paid) along with all outstanding unused holiday, again on a pro-rata basis depending when the holiday year falls.

HR are probably pooping their pants because they now need to work out your final pay and holiday in a short period of time!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:26

they PAYYOU for the two weeks holiday. You don't have two weeks of unpaid holiday ,it gets PAID. Money DOES change hands. It just doesn't get paid as a lump sum, it gets paid as if it was regular salary

NORMALLY. For usual holiday leave.

Not here, where HR are saying they are retaining it in lieu ie INSTEAD OF notice.

How is that so hard to comprehend??????

Pottedpalm · 17/05/2023 19:25

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 17:42

as long as they pay OP for the annual leave she's "taking", she'll be OK.

That. Is. Not. What. They. Are. Saying. They'll Do.

Dear God.

😂
a lot of dense people on Mumsnet!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:25

OP will be paid for her holiday either way

This has become the latest 'cancel the cheque' hasn't it.

I can understand posters not getting it initially. The inability to read the numerous posts explaining it, including OP's, is just incredible.

adriftinadenofvipers · 17/05/2023 19:23

I don't understand why so many posters just don't get it?!!

Definitely speak to ACAS. You are legally entitled to be paid your outstanding annual leave, and you have the evidence that your resignation was accepted. Surely HR's role here is only processing? Stand your ground. Make it clear that you will pursue this all the way to an ET if need be.

That dick of a manager should 'atone' for his failure to forward this to HR by sorting this out directly! All he had to do was cc them into his email accepting your resignation. What a dick!

EarringsandLipstick · 17/05/2023 19:22

People can and do have multiple concurrent jobs.

Yes. But not ones that require someone to work at the exact same time, in two roles. That being a physical impossibility.

Greenfairydust · 17/05/2023 19:22

You still have the email you sent to your manager as proof?

Then all you need to do is forward this to HR and stand your ground.

It is not your issue that your manager is incompetent...

They don't have a leg to stand on as you correctly gave your notice in writing to your line manager.

Lizzt2007 · 17/05/2023 19:13

sandyhappypeople · 17/05/2023 17:56

But they don't actually PAY YOU if they are using your holiday entitlement.. no money changes hands. So you are down two weeks pay.

You only get paid back your holiday entitlement if you haven't USED them, if you USE them (to serve a notice period for example), you don't get paid back for them, it just means you don't have to actually attend work for those two weeks, then leave with nothing.

Yes they do , they PAYYOU for the two weeks holiday. You don't have two weeks of unpaid holiday ,it gets PAID. Money DOES change hands. It just doesn't get paid as a lump sum, it gets paid as if it was regular salary. As many others have said, the only financial difference would be possibly in tax. But then the lump sum would be taxed as well so minimal implications financially.

DoraDee · 17/05/2023 19:13

Just tell them ok take it from today then. “I’ll be taking all my annual leave and I hope you realise that by doing this naturally I will accrue more than if I left on x date”. They need to pay you your annual leave anyway and there’s nothing to stop you starting your new job during your annual leave.

GodSaveTheClean · 17/05/2023 19:11

Oh lord help us. How are posters not getting this?!

So sorry OP. Very sensible to contact ACAS. I would also raise a grievance against your manager. That’s a pretty huge oversight on their part.