Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Missed rent payments. I can't pay it.

165 replies

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 12:20

Before this situation got to this point i posted in legal matters but didn't get a lot of traffic so shamelessly posting here. Sorry.

We rented a 2 bedroom house. Tenancy was up for renewal a last year. We renewed (with a rental increase) (blinded not knowing what was coming our way). 4 days after renewing our tenancy agreement we were told the house was going on the market. Obviously had we had known this was going to happen we wouldn't have renewed. In the mix of all of that, I was struck with a cancer diagnosis. Meaning out of work and no income. We told them after this, that we couldn't pay the rent due to the circumstances. I moved back to my parents annex. Because I was still under contract I am still liable for the rent. Because of how vulnerable my health is, I couldn't have viewings and people coming in and out as I had to, and still do, have to shield whilst having treatment. The landlord would not let us go. But we moved out. I know the advise is to stay until getting evicted but I tried to do the right thing and not hinder a sale as I doubt any non investors want to buy a house with sitting tenants. All viewings have been family viewings and AFAIK it's a family the house has now sold to.

We are now obviously months in arrears. The house is sold. The landlord has informed us he has claimed on his insurance to get the money back.

I'm just wondering what will happen next, what will the insurers do? I did speak to shelter and there are parts of the agreement that the landlord did not stick to which we were unaware of. I can't really say what they are as they're very specific and outing but the landlord did something outside the contracted agreement after he told us the house was going up for sale.

As you can imagine, it's an already stressful hard time. The cancer is here for the long run, but with the treatment and surgeries we are hoping for me to still have some time left. It's a cancer you sort of 'live with' as long as it stays stable after my initial treatment.

It's obvious that the landlord waited until renewing our tenancy before telling us so there's no gaps in the rent / sale. But due to it all happen in at once, we couldn't afford to stay. DX came days after the notice of selling the house. I needed to move back in with parents as I need help with DC at the moment after having treatment.

What happens now, will the insurer take me to court? Will they decline his claim for breaking the contract? Will I have to go to court?

Im expecting a battering for this. I know I've made some wrong decisions but I've had little to no choice. Not able to get social housing as DH earns too much. But without my wage, (main breadwinner) we simply could not do the rent. I tried and tried to come to a compromise but LL didn't want to know. Wanted the full rent (plus increase) and that was that. Didn't want to let us go. I just want to know what we'll expect in the next coming months now he has submitted a claim to the insurer. Deposit is in the correct scheme and the house was half managed by a letting agency.

Thank you.

OP posts:
sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 15:15

booktokbear · 17/05/2023 14:05

@sillyonehelps You'd think not disclosing he was selling would be but I guess it's just another way renters get screwed over.

No it's not. Because it doesn't affect anything.

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 15:14

Crazycrazylady · 17/05/2023 14:36

Honestly he'd be mad to chase you through the courts for this.

  1. legal fees would be more than he would get
  2. judges would look down their nose at his behaviour as well so no guarantees he would get it all.

Just ignore him

  1. no they wouldn't
honeylulu · 17/05/2023 14:51

The insurer may try to bring a subrogated claim but they won't just issue proceedings. They will write to you first. You then write back making all the points you can including your cancer and that you simply can't afford to pay and that your landlord's conduct (whilst legal) was underhand. It would be a PR disaster for the insurers to be seen to "bully" you and that may well see them off. But they may not contact you at all. Loss of rent insurance comes with a pricey premium which landlord has already paid so they may not feel too badly off all things considered.

fyn · 17/05/2023 14:47

There is a specific type of insurance that you can take out with referencing companies that pay out in the case of non payment of rent, they then usually do chase the rent from the tenant.

Winter2020 · 17/05/2023 14:39

If you are asked to pay this debt you would need to write out a budget and offer to pay an affordable amount e.g. £5 a week. If the organisation took you to court you would only be ordered to pay an affordable amount. You could also choose to dispute the debt and see if they choose to take it to court.

You should be able to claim your deposit back. The rent arrears are separate I believe.

The "renting, buying, selling" forum on MSE has knowledgeable people as does the "debt free wannabe" forum if this becomes a debt you are chased for.

Please try to stop worrying. You need to concentrate on your health. If you have to pay this make a small affordable payment plan.

Crazycrazylady · 17/05/2023 14:36

Honestly he'd be mad to chase you through the courts for this.

  1. legal fees would be more than he would get
  2. judges would look down their nose at his behaviour as well so no guarantees he would get it all.

Just ignore him

Banned4life · 17/05/2023 14:36

i would guess it would cost far more than £3000 to trace and pursue you. If they do, you immediately let them know you’re a vulnerable individual and they have an obligation under fca rules to consider this. Then you ask them to right it off.

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 14:21

Just over £3000 is outstanding.

OP posts:
Banned4life · 17/05/2023 14:18

How much are we talking? If the landlord has successfully claimed on the insurance then the insurer may have the right to come after you, but it would cost them to do it and it would be very bad PR for them. Plus, would they even know how to find you?

I wouldn’t worry, if it comes to it, speak to McMillan or cab.

booktokbear · 17/05/2023 14:05

@sillyonehelps You'd think not disclosing he was selling would be but I guess it's just another way renters get screwed over.

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 14:02

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 14:00

@imogeneration
Make a claim for the deposit. You've moved out.
Have you been given the new landlords details?

It's also not 1/2 anything. On the contract who's it signed by?

We don't have a new landlord, the house has been sold to a family AFAIK.

I'll make a claim on the deposit. I didn't think you could with missed payments :(

OP posts:
mcmooberry · 17/05/2023 14:02

Sorry no advice but am appalled by his disgraceful behaviour. He can't have it both ways, get the rent and sell it with viewings when you were gone. Hope it gets resolved in your favour soon and that is one big thing off your mind. xx

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 14:01

booktokbear · 17/05/2023 13:32

We were unintentional landlords for a couple of years while selling our property.

We had a tenant who didn't pay, trashed the place and left.

We managed to claim through "rent guarantee" policy. We were never asked for details of tenant. So from this experience I do not believe they do come after the tenant op.

Hope this helps somewhat op. I'm so sorry you have been treated this way at such a horrible time.

I'd try and find a way of challenging that he rented to you under false pretences in a bid to get your deposit back.

There is no false pretences.

Calmdown14 · 17/05/2023 14:01

I agree with writing everything out in regard to timeframes and ensuring you have any evidence.

How much is your deposit relative to rent arrears?

If the house is sold, the landlord has claimed on his insurance and knows he failed to follow correct procedure, I'd have thought chasing you is not worth the effort (though that perhaps depends if the property you were renting was £500 a month or 10k)

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 14:00

@imogeneration
Make a claim for the deposit. You've moved out.
Have you been given the new landlords details?

It's also not 1/2 anything. On the contract who's it signed by?

onefinemess · 17/05/2023 13:58

Doubt anything will Happen OP. The LL got what they wanted. I can't see why they would be interested.

For those of you saying the LL was awful, it's a business, not a housing charity!

Just forget about it. Obviously renting privately in the future will be practically impossible for you, but that's just a small price to pay for walking out on a contract.

booktokbear · 17/05/2023 13:32

We were unintentional landlords for a couple of years while selling our property.

We had a tenant who didn't pay, trashed the place and left.

We managed to claim through "rent guarantee" policy. We were never asked for details of tenant. So from this experience I do not believe they do come after the tenant op.

Hope this helps somewhat op. I'm so sorry you have been treated this way at such a horrible time.

I'd try and find a way of challenging that he rented to you under false pretences in a bid to get your deposit back.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/05/2023 13:28

Cross post. You’re still tenants. You need to contact the CAB.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/05/2023 13:26

What date did you leave the house?
What date approximately was the house sold subject to contract?
What date were you supposed to pay rent until?

Reading between the lines, I am presuming the landlord gained access to the property for viewings whilst you were still legally tenants. Is this the case?

Legally, you didn’t have to allow any viewings at all. If the landlord allowed viewings whilst you were still legally tenants, this is also illegal unless you gave them permission. And I mean even during the period when you had moved out.

Idk if the insurance company will pursue you. But I’d try to put as many facts together as you can so that if something happens you have information. You basically had to leave the property as this was the only way you could survive as the landlord wasn’t willing to allow you quiet enjoyment of the property.

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 13:21

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 13:10

@gamerchick it can't be half managed, there is a contract and with who.

Also oP have you made a claim on your deposit?

It's half managed.
That's all that's on the contract.

The rent gets paid to the EA, I'm guessing they take their fees and send the rent to the LL.

I'm what I gathered the rent and deposit etc was done through the agent but any repairs etc were with the landlord. We had communications with them both.

We haven't tried to claim
Our deposit back yet as we're technically not at the end of the tenancy.

I'm just worried sick.

OP posts:
sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 13:10

@gamerchick it can't be half managed, there is a contract and with who.

Also oP have you made a claim on your deposit?

gamerchick · 17/05/2023 13:09

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 13:07

@imogeneration answer me this:

  1. did you rent via landlord or agent?
  2. have you paid a deposit and was it protected
  3. has the house been sold?

If you click on the bit that lets you read just the OPs posts, that might help a bit.

MachinesOfGod · 17/05/2023 13:09

I guess the insurance technically could try to recover the cost of the claim from you, but realistically the cost of a few months rent is probably not worth the legal expense they’d have to go to in order to do that. They’d probably just write it off. Do you, your partner or your parents have any kind of policy through work or home insurance that has a legal advice line? Could be worth speaking to them for general theoretical advice.

If the landlords rent claim is paid out - at least you’d be totally done with needing to deal with him, although I’m not sure how you’d find out that information, and if he’s a dickhead, he could well have the money from the insurance company already safely tucked away in his bank account, whilst still using it all as a stick to beat you with.

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 13:07

@imogeneration answer me this:

  1. did you rent via landlord or agent?
  2. have you paid a deposit and was it protected
  3. has the house been sold?
Reugny · 17/05/2023 13:07

Will the insurance company come after us for the money? That's what I'm worried about.

If they do and you are liable then you can only pay what you can afford after you have done a budget. So if you can only afford to pay £5 a month until it is paid off then that's what you need to agree to pay.

However I would seek advice from a charity like Shelter to find out if you are likely to be liable to pay the insurance company. I would also post on the MSE forums as there tends to be people with specific knowledge who post on there.

It could be that if you can prove your situation they actually chase the landlord because his claim is fraudulent. However as you missed out details on here for good reason people can't tell you.