Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Missed rent payments. I can't pay it.

165 replies

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 12:20

Before this situation got to this point i posted in legal matters but didn't get a lot of traffic so shamelessly posting here. Sorry.

We rented a 2 bedroom house. Tenancy was up for renewal a last year. We renewed (with a rental increase) (blinded not knowing what was coming our way). 4 days after renewing our tenancy agreement we were told the house was going on the market. Obviously had we had known this was going to happen we wouldn't have renewed. In the mix of all of that, I was struck with a cancer diagnosis. Meaning out of work and no income. We told them after this, that we couldn't pay the rent due to the circumstances. I moved back to my parents annex. Because I was still under contract I am still liable for the rent. Because of how vulnerable my health is, I couldn't have viewings and people coming in and out as I had to, and still do, have to shield whilst having treatment. The landlord would not let us go. But we moved out. I know the advise is to stay until getting evicted but I tried to do the right thing and not hinder a sale as I doubt any non investors want to buy a house with sitting tenants. All viewings have been family viewings and AFAIK it's a family the house has now sold to.

We are now obviously months in arrears. The house is sold. The landlord has informed us he has claimed on his insurance to get the money back.

I'm just wondering what will happen next, what will the insurers do? I did speak to shelter and there are parts of the agreement that the landlord did not stick to which we were unaware of. I can't really say what they are as they're very specific and outing but the landlord did something outside the contracted agreement after he told us the house was going up for sale.

As you can imagine, it's an already stressful hard time. The cancer is here for the long run, but with the treatment and surgeries we are hoping for me to still have some time left. It's a cancer you sort of 'live with' as long as it stays stable after my initial treatment.

It's obvious that the landlord waited until renewing our tenancy before telling us so there's no gaps in the rent / sale. But due to it all happen in at once, we couldn't afford to stay. DX came days after the notice of selling the house. I needed to move back in with parents as I need help with DC at the moment after having treatment.

What happens now, will the insurer take me to court? Will they decline his claim for breaking the contract? Will I have to go to court?

Im expecting a battering for this. I know I've made some wrong decisions but I've had little to no choice. Not able to get social housing as DH earns too much. But without my wage, (main breadwinner) we simply could not do the rent. I tried and tried to come to a compromise but LL didn't want to know. Wanted the full rent (plus increase) and that was that. Didn't want to let us go. I just want to know what we'll expect in the next coming months now he has submitted a claim to the insurer. Deposit is in the correct scheme and the house was half managed by a letting agency.

Thank you.

OP posts:
RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 08:12

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 15:57

4 months of missed payment to sale of the house. But he's trying to tell me I still need to pay rent until what would be the end of our tenancy.

No, they denied our notice.
Keys given back a few months ago

You absolutely don’t need to pay him until the end of the tenancy. He has to be able to show “actual losses” and claimants have a responsibility to mitigate their losses too. The time from when the house was sold is not an actual loss as he didn’t have a house available.

RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 08:10

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 15:50

@RedRosette2023 I assume they renewed because the rent was reasonable for the area, if not they would have looked elsewhere and gone month to month.

Just because your landlord sells it means nothing. Your contract is still valid and the new landlord can't kick you out before the end of the tenancy.

Housing security at the moment is non existent.

I know. I wasn’t asking why they renewed but responding to someone else asking why they might not.

USSDefiant · 17/05/2023 20:16

sorry also wanted to add, if the LL is advising that his insurers paid the outstanding rent under a policy, then subject to the terms of the policy he would get the rent he would have been entitled to. Assuming he has been paid £3,000 (amounting to the rent up to completion of the property), then that is what he would have been paid via a court judgement. So even his insurers do not believe he is entitled to anything after the sale of the property. Please be rest assured, under English law, you can only claim for losses you suffered for and/or what you have obtained has the other party not broken the contract. Seeing as after completion he would not have been paid rent, everything he is saying about rent continuing to accrue is utter BS. It is a bluff and he is playing you. The agent should not be engaging in such BS either and if part of a chain, I would report them to their head office.

USSDefiant · 17/05/2023 19:59

Apologies if I have misunderstood, and previously addressed by other posters: (1) If the property is occupied by a new owners, at most, AT MOST, the previous owner (your landlord) could argue to be entitled to rent up to the date of completion, which I understand to be about 4 months rent. (2) You say that your landlord is claiming that rent is still due until the minimum contractual period runs out. Seeing as he could not have earned this rent due to selling the property, his argument has no leg to stand on. Under contract law, he has suffered no loss. He cannot claim what he could not have earned (3) insurers in law have subrogated rights so can in theory pursue the debtor/person at fault - you will just have to see how that goes, but please concentrate on your health and deal with that aspect as and when it happens.🌺

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 19:44

@Whitebeamtreelover Indeed it is perfectly legal to market and sell a tenanted property.

However if, as the OP says, she was not been given proper notice before the sale was completed then the new owner is her landlord.

Skodacool · 17/05/2023 19:27

sillyonehetpes · 17/05/2023 13:05

Very false about the 30 min consult and very false about the new tenancy despite wanting to sell the property

Also very false about landlords not being reasonable.

Kangarude · 17/05/2023 19:22

Nordicrain · 17/05/2023 18:17

And what angle is that?

That there may be a case for unfair dismissal?

DeeLasVegas · 17/05/2023 18:51

Knock on the door of the house & tell them you still have a tenancy. The property should not have sold. Huge mistakes made by solicitors/sellers/buyers. Guessing LL told fibs & told them it was vacant. Talk to Shelter, they are the experts.

Naddd · 17/05/2023 18:47

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 12:20

Before this situation got to this point i posted in legal matters but didn't get a lot of traffic so shamelessly posting here. Sorry.

We rented a 2 bedroom house. Tenancy was up for renewal a last year. We renewed (with a rental increase) (blinded not knowing what was coming our way). 4 days after renewing our tenancy agreement we were told the house was going on the market. Obviously had we had known this was going to happen we wouldn't have renewed. In the mix of all of that, I was struck with a cancer diagnosis. Meaning out of work and no income. We told them after this, that we couldn't pay the rent due to the circumstances. I moved back to my parents annex. Because I was still under contract I am still liable for the rent. Because of how vulnerable my health is, I couldn't have viewings and people coming in and out as I had to, and still do, have to shield whilst having treatment. The landlord would not let us go. But we moved out. I know the advise is to stay until getting evicted but I tried to do the right thing and not hinder a sale as I doubt any non investors want to buy a house with sitting tenants. All viewings have been family viewings and AFAIK it's a family the house has now sold to.

We are now obviously months in arrears. The house is sold. The landlord has informed us he has claimed on his insurance to get the money back.

I'm just wondering what will happen next, what will the insurers do? I did speak to shelter and there are parts of the agreement that the landlord did not stick to which we were unaware of. I can't really say what they are as they're very specific and outing but the landlord did something outside the contracted agreement after he told us the house was going up for sale.

As you can imagine, it's an already stressful hard time. The cancer is here for the long run, but with the treatment and surgeries we are hoping for me to still have some time left. It's a cancer you sort of 'live with' as long as it stays stable after my initial treatment.

It's obvious that the landlord waited until renewing our tenancy before telling us so there's no gaps in the rent / sale. But due to it all happen in at once, we couldn't afford to stay. DX came days after the notice of selling the house. I needed to move back in with parents as I need help with DC at the moment after having treatment.

What happens now, will the insurer take me to court? Will they decline his claim for breaking the contract? Will I have to go to court?

Im expecting a battering for this. I know I've made some wrong decisions but I've had little to no choice. Not able to get social housing as DH earns too much. But without my wage, (main breadwinner) we simply could not do the rent. I tried and tried to come to a compromise but LL didn't want to know. Wanted the full rent (plus increase) and that was that. Didn't want to let us go. I just want to know what we'll expect in the next coming months now he has submitted a claim to the insurer. Deposit is in the correct scheme and the house was half managed by a letting agency.

Thank you.

Sad u thought you'd get a hard time your landlord sounds a right knobhead

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 17/05/2023 18:44

He can try to claim for unpaid rent from when you stopped paying to when you left the house. However his court costs are likely to be more than that. You have now left and are entitled to your deposit back.

Whitebeamtreelover · 17/05/2023 18:43

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 18:35

Hmm - i suspect he hasn't a leg to sand on. He has tried to keep you on the hook for the tenancy and sell it as vacant possession.

Get some advice form Shelter though as IANAL - just someone who had a lot of shitty landlords in the past.

That’s perfectly legal as long as he gives notice in line with estimated completion dates. Landlords are allowed to sell their homes with a tenant in and then give notice as a sale proceeds

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 18:35

Hmm - i suspect he hasn't a leg to sand on. He has tried to keep you on the hook for the tenancy and sell it as vacant possession.

Get some advice form Shelter though as IANAL - just someone who had a lot of shitty landlords in the past.

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 18:34

@Ginmonkeyagain

We also have no idea who the new owners are.
They are a family and are occupying the property themselves.

OP posts:
imogeneration · 17/05/2023 18:33

• even if you weren't living at the property if you had a tenancy you still had right to quiet enjoyment of the property - meaning that the landlord should have requested permission for viewings, entry etc..
• Has the sale happened during the 12 month tenancy period he says you are liable for? If so and he says your tenancy to is still valid he would have to have sold the house with the tenancy in place and the new owner will now be your landlord. If he sold it with vacant possession then he has illegally evicted you.
• Has he issued a s8 noticed for rent arrears?

@Ginmonkeyagain

We weren't living at the property. I did raise the quiet enjoyment of the property but was pressured into allowing viewings as it was 'in our favour' of the property were to sell. We now know that favour doesn't exist.
The sale of the property went ahead before our 6 month break clause. That break clause is in 2 months time.
He has said, multiple times (today included) that our tenancy is still valid, so we are legally obliged to pay the rent until the break clause.
The buyers as far as we know, are family first time buyers.
No section 8 received. Just weekly reminders through the EA that the rent is in arrears.

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 18:32

I had a landlord who tried a lower level but still annoying version of having his cake and eating it. We were on a periodic tenacy so only had to give one months notice. We bought a flat and nearing completing we gave him the required months notice. We completed a week later and moved out.

Our landlord came round on move day and asked for the keys back as he wanted to get the decorators in straight away. I said we would be happy to surrender the keys for him to start the decorating if he repaid us rent for the three weeks we could not have access to the flat. He refused.

Reader - I changed the locks and made use of the empty flat I was paying for every day of those three weeks.

Why yes, I am a petty bitch.

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/05/2023 18:25

So you signed a 12 month tenancy.

Your landlord then put the house on the market. All above board as you can sell a property with a tenant in place, the new owner simply becomes you landlord.

You then became unable to work due to illness and moved out as you could not pay the rent.

You landlord continued to market the house and now it has been sold. He says you owe him rent for the full 12 month period.

So - unless there has been a mutual surrender of the contract (which is what you should have asked for IMO) you still have a tenancy and still owe rent for that period.

However - there are a few things to consider here

  • even if you weren't living at the property if you had a tenancy you still had right to quiet enjoyment of the property - meaning that the landlord should have requested permission for viewings, entry etc..
  • Has the sale happened during the 12 month tenancy period he says you are liable for? If so and he says your tenancy to is still valid he would have to have sold the house with the tenancy in place and the new owner will now be your landlord. If he sold it with vacant possession then he has illegally evicted you.
  • Has he issued a s8 noticed for rent arrears?
Nordicrain · 17/05/2023 18:17

Kangarude · 17/05/2023 18:15

Coming a this from a different angle - why were you out of work following your diagnosis? You say you had a good, well paying job, so surely you would have gone onto sick pay? Were you dismissed for having cancer?

And what angle is that?

Kangarude · 17/05/2023 18:15

Coming a this from a different angle - why were you out of work following your diagnosis? You say you had a good, well paying job, so surely you would have gone onto sick pay? Were you dismissed for having cancer?

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 17/05/2023 18:14

OP - Where you on a rolling tenancy agreement?

If he’s sold the property, he can’t expect you to pay until the end of the tenancy agreement, making money on a sold property.

Oysterbabe · 17/05/2023 18:10

Possession claims and pursuing rent arrears is part of my job. What will probably happen is nothing.
The insurer might instruct solicitors to go after you. They would use various tools to try and track you down and assess your financial position. If you don't own property or have a highly paid job it would not be worth issuing court proceedings. The chance of getting the money back is very low. Insurers aren't interested in getting a judgment that's paid back at £5 a month, which is what usually happens in my experience.

Whitebeamtreelover · 17/05/2023 18:03

Crazycrazylady · 17/05/2023 14:36

Honestly he'd be mad to chase you through the courts for this.

  1. legal fees would be more than he would get
  2. judges would look down their nose at his behaviour as well so no guarantees he would get it all.

Just ignore him

Did you not read the op? He is not chasing her through the courts. He has claimed in his landlords insurance for the non paid rent. The question she’s asking is will the insurer come after her for it.

the truth is they might.

op let your partner deal with this. You really don’t need to be stressing about it. Yes 3k Is a lot of money, but it’s not massive and even if they did you would likely have a repayment plan and it could take years. Let it go

honeylulu · 17/05/2023 17:52

I would say that by selling the house BEFORE the end of what would have been your tenancy period, the landlord HAS accepted your notice as valid as at that date at the latest. If landlord wants to insist the tenancy period could not be curtailed, he would have had to accept he was unable to sell the house either. The law provides that a claimant cannot be put in a better position than that he would have been had the contract not been breached. So he potentially has a claim for lost rent between you leaving and the house being sold but not after that point because he has mitigated his own loss by benefiting from an earlier definite sale than he would otherwise have done. What would the rent value be for that period? If its less than £10k his insurers won't bother their arses for it as its small claims track value and they won't recover any legal fees they'd incur. plus the risk if negative PR - nasty big bully insurer suing a hard up cancer victim.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 17/05/2023 17:15

A quick Google of the shelter website suggests you may have some recourse if you were misled at the point of signing a fixed term let - you have 90 days to submit a formal notice.

And you're certainly not liable for any rent once the property is sold! Pah, he's a chancer!

Unless you've heard any of this directly from the EA or insurance I wouldn't give it much weight op.

Freddiefox · 17/05/2023 17:06

Has the sale of the house gone through? Contract exchanged? Or has he found a buyer and the selling process is on hand?

Swipe left for the next trending thread