Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Missed rent payments. I can't pay it.

165 replies

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 12:20

Before this situation got to this point i posted in legal matters but didn't get a lot of traffic so shamelessly posting here. Sorry.

We rented a 2 bedroom house. Tenancy was up for renewal a last year. We renewed (with a rental increase) (blinded not knowing what was coming our way). 4 days after renewing our tenancy agreement we were told the house was going on the market. Obviously had we had known this was going to happen we wouldn't have renewed. In the mix of all of that, I was struck with a cancer diagnosis. Meaning out of work and no income. We told them after this, that we couldn't pay the rent due to the circumstances. I moved back to my parents annex. Because I was still under contract I am still liable for the rent. Because of how vulnerable my health is, I couldn't have viewings and people coming in and out as I had to, and still do, have to shield whilst having treatment. The landlord would not let us go. But we moved out. I know the advise is to stay until getting evicted but I tried to do the right thing and not hinder a sale as I doubt any non investors want to buy a house with sitting tenants. All viewings have been family viewings and AFAIK it's a family the house has now sold to.

We are now obviously months in arrears. The house is sold. The landlord has informed us he has claimed on his insurance to get the money back.

I'm just wondering what will happen next, what will the insurers do? I did speak to shelter and there are parts of the agreement that the landlord did not stick to which we were unaware of. I can't really say what they are as they're very specific and outing but the landlord did something outside the contracted agreement after he told us the house was going up for sale.

As you can imagine, it's an already stressful hard time. The cancer is here for the long run, but with the treatment and surgeries we are hoping for me to still have some time left. It's a cancer you sort of 'live with' as long as it stays stable after my initial treatment.

It's obvious that the landlord waited until renewing our tenancy before telling us so there's no gaps in the rent / sale. But due to it all happen in at once, we couldn't afford to stay. DX came days after the notice of selling the house. I needed to move back in with parents as I need help with DC at the moment after having treatment.

What happens now, will the insurer take me to court? Will they decline his claim for breaking the contract? Will I have to go to court?

Im expecting a battering for this. I know I've made some wrong decisions but I've had little to no choice. Not able to get social housing as DH earns too much. But without my wage, (main breadwinner) we simply could not do the rent. I tried and tried to come to a compromise but LL didn't want to know. Wanted the full rent (plus increase) and that was that. Didn't want to let us go. I just want to know what we'll expect in the next coming months now he has submitted a claim to the insurer. Deposit is in the correct scheme and the house was half managed by a letting agency.

Thank you.

OP posts:
imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:50

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 19:35

@imogeneration the landlord selling the property wouldn't have affected your decision to sign. You were happy with the rent (hence why you signed). Your diagnosis was a causation of you leaving.

As I've explained 20 times, you wouldn't be kicked out and there is something fishy as the new owner didn't buy with vacant possession.

I know you've explained, but I've explained that when we got given the information that the landlord was selling, it explicitly said the landlord is only happy for us to stay as long as he doesn't have a buyer. If a buyer was found before the tenancy was up, the landlord wouldn't let us be at the property. We have that in writing.

Whether he's allowed to do that is another thing, but I don't know the ins and outs of the law and took that information as face value.

So taking my illness out of the equation, had he told us 4 days prior we wouldn't have signed the tenancy agreement. Purely by the fact of if a buyer came along, we would have to leave and had no idea how or when that would be.
We can't afford the property now because we can't pay 2 rents at once. Plus my income is non-existent.

We signed the tenancy with the intentions of having a secure and liable home only to be told 4 days later otherwise.

Perhaps I'm missing something. My brain is fucking fried and I'm so mentally and physically exhausted.

OP posts:
RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 19:39

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 19:35

@imogeneration the landlord selling the property wouldn't have affected your decision to sign. You were happy with the rent (hence why you signed). Your diagnosis was a causation of you leaving.

As I've explained 20 times, you wouldn't be kicked out and there is something fishy as the new owner didn't buy with vacant possession.

They did. The property was vacant. Possession is a physical fact and OP had vacated. They bought with a tenancy in place but nobody was residing there.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 19:35

@imogeneration the landlord selling the property wouldn't have affected your decision to sign. You were happy with the rent (hence why you signed). Your diagnosis was a causation of you leaving.

As I've explained 20 times, you wouldn't be kicked out and there is something fishy as the new owner didn't buy with vacant possession.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 19:32

imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:03

I'm just going to have to wait until the insurance contacts me.
I have nothing to give them.
Nothing in savings.
I'm long term sick..

Take what they want. I've got nothing to give them.

Exactly.

imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:03

I'm just going to have to wait until the insurance contacts me.
I have nothing to give them.
Nothing in savings.
I'm long term sick..

Take what they want. I've got nothing to give them.

OP posts:
imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:02

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 18:49

This is why when buying a house mortgage that it's not a buy to let the mortgage company will make sure the tenancy has ended before the deal has been finalised. Or it's sold with a sitting tenant.

The new owners wouldn't have been able to buy the property with a sitting tenant who had just signed a new 12 month agreement if they needed to live there.

The buyer isn't an investor. It's a FTB family moving in.

I'm still currently under tenancy.
This is where the lines are blurring.

OP posts:
imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:01

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 18:47

@imogeneration you are blaming your poor financial situation on the landlord. You couldn't afford the rent so had to move out. That's nothing to do with the landlord selling the house. Had the landlord not been selling the house you wouldn't have moved neither would you not signed a new agreement for 12 months. You were happy to pay the rent increase..... it's just unfortunate the landlord sold because you can use that as an "excuse".

This is untrue. Of course we would've moved. My cancer diagnosis came in a matter of days of the news he was selling and I knew my income would be compromised...

So, of course I would've moved.

OP posts:
sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 18:49

This is why when buying a house mortgage that it's not a buy to let the mortgage company will make sure the tenancy has ended before the deal has been finalised. Or it's sold with a sitting tenant.

The new owners wouldn't have been able to buy the property with a sitting tenant who had just signed a new 12 month agreement if they needed to live there.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 18:48

Cant*

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 18:48

@imogeneration you can move from a property if you have a secure tenancy. Just because the landlord sold it doesn't mean anyone can end your tenancy - the new landlord has the same terms and conditions. You will not be forced to move.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 18:47

@imogeneration you are blaming your poor financial situation on the landlord. You couldn't afford the rent so had to move out. That's nothing to do with the landlord selling the house. Had the landlord not been selling the house you wouldn't have moved neither would you not signed a new agreement for 12 months. You were happy to pay the rent increase..... it's just unfortunate the landlord sold because you can use that as an "excuse".

SaveTheDeal · 18/05/2023 18:44

RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 09:10

Well yes, but that doesn’t prevent OP understanding exactly what her liability is - which is a pretty essential starting point when settling a debt.

Oh definitely. And I know she has started this post from the point of view of understanding that liability.

But that liability doesn’t change because of her (very unfortunate) health issue. I understand that OP has provided background information to explain now her circumstances changed, but she didn’t stop paying her rent because the landlord is selling, she stopped paying it because she was in a poorer financial position than she had been.

imogeneration · 18/05/2023 18:19

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 16:30

To all those saying he shouldn't have allowed her to sign a new tenancy - SHE WOULD BE HOMELESS. This tenancy gave her housing security for a year. Just because she couldn't afford it,

He should've given the option. Not tie us into a tenancy with the intention to sell. 12 months wouldn't have been secure as he would've given us notice when the buyers bought the house. (He has told us this.)

OP posts:
sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 16:30

To all those saying he shouldn't have allowed her to sign a new tenancy - SHE WOULD BE HOMELESS. This tenancy gave her housing security for a year. Just because she couldn't afford it,

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 15:52

I would say that by still pursuing you for the rental payments he is potentially committing insurance fraud.. If he's been paid out by his insurance company to cover the missing rent payment up to the end of your tenancy, there is no reason to still be pursuing you for it, you were unable to continue the tenancy because of illness and he has rightly used his insurance to cover the shortfall, it's there to cover you if your tenant doesn't pay. As far as I know the insurance company don't then pursue the tenant.

I'm sorry if I've misunderstood or if you've already answered but are you in any arrears for the time you actually lived there, or is it just for the unfulfilled contract? Did you give him any notice (even though he didn't accept it)?

How did he inform you the insurance has paid out, in person or in writing? If you have it in writing I'd be inclined to forward that to the estate agent sending you the reminders of arrears as proof that the matter has been dealt with and resolved.

He shouldn't have got you to sign a new tenancy agreement knowing full well he was going to sell in the first place, and he should have allowed you to surrender with a small notice period once you got your diagnosis, he's an utter prick, and he deserves to be out of pocket for being so bloody greedy.

Not sure on the deposit, it isn't held by the landlord (or it shouldn't be!) so if you know where it's being held you may be able to apply for it back. Shelter has a way of finding it and applying for it back if the landlord 'refuses', could be worth a try.

Check your tenancy deposit is protected - Shelter England

Shelter icon

Check your tenancy deposit is protected - Shelter England

How to check online to see if your tenancy deposit is protected by 1 of the 3 tenancy deposit protection scheme providers

https://england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/tenancy_deposits/check_your_tenancy_deposit_is_protected

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 14:13

@RedRosette2023 no they should knock on the door to get the actual situation, because these buyers have bought this house and the OP is liable for the rent. So at least get some evidence as well,

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 13:20

USSDefiant · 18/05/2023 13:05

OP what notice did the LL serve 4 days after the renewal? What is the name of the form? What notice period does it give you to vacate the property?

Or was it just mentioned in passing they are selling?

Nothing,

USSDefiant · 18/05/2023 13:05

OP what notice did the LL serve 4 days after the renewal? What is the name of the form? What notice period does it give you to vacate the property?

Or was it just mentioned in passing they are selling?

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 12:43

@RedRosette2023 stops the whole "your landlord is terrible for selling the house" when in fact it gave them housing security for a year and it's the fact the oP is unable to work which is why they are in this predicament

RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 09:10

SaveTheDeal · 18/05/2023 08:28

Very sorry to hear about your diagnosis, OP.

If the landlord hadn’t been selling, what would you have done?

It sounds like the catalyst here for not paying rent was your financial situation, not the sale.

Well yes, but that doesn’t prevent OP understanding exactly what her liability is - which is a pretty essential starting point when settling a debt.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 08:38

SaveTheDeal · 18/05/2023 08:28

Very sorry to hear about your diagnosis, OP.

If the landlord hadn’t been selling, what would you have done?

It sounds like the catalyst here for not paying rent was your financial situation, not the sale.

100.%

SaveTheDeal · 18/05/2023 08:28

Very sorry to hear about your diagnosis, OP.

If the landlord hadn’t been selling, what would you have done?

It sounds like the catalyst here for not paying rent was your financial situation, not the sale.

Greendoorsaremyfavourite · 18/05/2023 08:23

If his claim with the insurance company is successful, they'll probably pass the case to solicitors to pursue a recovery from you. They'll likely do an asset check on you (to see if you have the means to pay it) & if you don't they may well abandon the recovery as it won't be worth them forking out for the legal costs. Though, they may ask if you can pay anything at all.
Given your diagnosis, they may not pursue at all (I'm fairly confident that the insurance company I work for wouldn't pursue in these circumstances - contrary to popular belief, not all insurance companies are greedy money grabbers)

RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 08:19

@USSDefiant

^^ is right.

Also if you were now to pay him he’d have to refund his insurers, as it’s now their loss not his.

RedRosette2023 · 18/05/2023 08:17

DeeLasVegas · 17/05/2023 18:51

Knock on the door of the house & tell them you still have a tenancy. The property should not have sold. Huge mistakes made by solicitors/sellers/buyers. Guessing LL told fibs & told them it was vacant. Talk to Shelter, they are the experts.

Don’t do this. You’d look so stupid 😂

OP do contact shelter or citizens advise.

As usual I am astounded by the terrible faux legal advice on Mumsnet.