Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Missed rent payments. I can't pay it.

165 replies

imogeneration · 17/05/2023 12:20

Before this situation got to this point i posted in legal matters but didn't get a lot of traffic so shamelessly posting here. Sorry.

We rented a 2 bedroom house. Tenancy was up for renewal a last year. We renewed (with a rental increase) (blinded not knowing what was coming our way). 4 days after renewing our tenancy agreement we were told the house was going on the market. Obviously had we had known this was going to happen we wouldn't have renewed. In the mix of all of that, I was struck with a cancer diagnosis. Meaning out of work and no income. We told them after this, that we couldn't pay the rent due to the circumstances. I moved back to my parents annex. Because I was still under contract I am still liable for the rent. Because of how vulnerable my health is, I couldn't have viewings and people coming in and out as I had to, and still do, have to shield whilst having treatment. The landlord would not let us go. But we moved out. I know the advise is to stay until getting evicted but I tried to do the right thing and not hinder a sale as I doubt any non investors want to buy a house with sitting tenants. All viewings have been family viewings and AFAIK it's a family the house has now sold to.

We are now obviously months in arrears. The house is sold. The landlord has informed us he has claimed on his insurance to get the money back.

I'm just wondering what will happen next, what will the insurers do? I did speak to shelter and there are parts of the agreement that the landlord did not stick to which we were unaware of. I can't really say what they are as they're very specific and outing but the landlord did something outside the contracted agreement after he told us the house was going up for sale.

As you can imagine, it's an already stressful hard time. The cancer is here for the long run, but with the treatment and surgeries we are hoping for me to still have some time left. It's a cancer you sort of 'live with' as long as it stays stable after my initial treatment.

It's obvious that the landlord waited until renewing our tenancy before telling us so there's no gaps in the rent / sale. But due to it all happen in at once, we couldn't afford to stay. DX came days after the notice of selling the house. I needed to move back in with parents as I need help with DC at the moment after having treatment.

What happens now, will the insurer take me to court? Will they decline his claim for breaking the contract? Will I have to go to court?

Im expecting a battering for this. I know I've made some wrong decisions but I've had little to no choice. Not able to get social housing as DH earns too much. But without my wage, (main breadwinner) we simply could not do the rent. I tried and tried to come to a compromise but LL didn't want to know. Wanted the full rent (plus increase) and that was that. Didn't want to let us go. I just want to know what we'll expect in the next coming months now he has submitted a claim to the insurer. Deposit is in the correct scheme and the house was half managed by a letting agency.

Thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ginmonkeyagain · 19/05/2023 09:43

Your landlord sounds like a dick who wanted to squeeze every bit of rent he couls out of the property until it was sold.

It was in neither of your interests to continue the tenancy - through no fault of your own you found you could no longe afford to live there, he wanted to sell the property and it is always easier to sell with vacant possession.

He should be grateful that you surrendered the property as soon as you realised you could not afford the rent as you were entitled to say put until evicted by the courts.

sillyonehetpes · 19/05/2023 09:34

OP are you going to make a claim on your deposit?

Antisocialfluffmonster · 19/05/2023 07:51

This sounds like an awful situation all round. Only MN though would have someone pounding OP about just not being able to afford rent or asking why they aren’t working whilst being in treatment.

honestly let your partner get some legal advice and talk to shelter etc, and you just forget about it. You’ve got FA that they can take, you’re going to be living with no cured of cancer and frankly they can do one.

yes you broke the contract but you also made everyone’s life a lot easier, your first thought was, move out we can’t afford it, not let’s squat here until we get turfed out. You did things on your own terms. No point worrying about it, just concentrate on your health

imogeneration · 19/05/2023 07:13

Thanks everyone. Some really good advise on here.
The landlord has 12 properties up and down the country. All of them are for sale /sold. I just hope to god none of the other tenants are being treated this way.

I'll await to see if the insurance company get in touch.

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 23:37

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 23:24

Yes, a business decision that may have helped both parties.

It may also explain why he was in such a hurry to get a signed 12 month agreement in place 4 days before announcing he was putting the house up for sale too. He knew if it was all going to go tits up it would be after he told them about the house sale, some tenants would have refused to move and stopped paying rent immediately, the insurance he's referring to covers you for missed contractual rent and it also covers you to evict tenants if they refuse to leave, and ALL subsequent legal fees, he was never going to be out of pocket.

He still should have let them surrender though, or at least given them a, "no I can't possibly let you leave" .. wink, wink. Would have saved them a lot of aggro.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 23:28

The thing is, going via an agent you don't know what the landlord has told them. The landlord may have lots of properties and don't know if he was asked to renew your tenancy.

Regardless, OP without reading all the correspondence, it just seems weird the property was sold with sitting tenants.

I would however get proof that there are people living there - can you take photos?

It doesn't sound like the landlord is going to come after you.

But make sure to get the deposit released.... and I would be having words with the estate agent which you signed the contract with.

Personally I would be knocking on the door of the new owners but I know you might not want to do that.

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 23:24

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 23:22

oh I see what you mean, they asked to surrender but the landlord refused so not a mutual surrender as such, but in practice it has now been resolved. The landlord being paid out has fulfilled the tenants obligation to pay.

It could be the case that instead of being a heartless bastard he knew if he surrendered the agreement he wouldn't be paid out by the insurance for the full term of the contract, and it made more sense for him to claim on his insurance so he could get full 'missed' rent payments up to when the house was sold.

Yes, a business decision that may have helped both parties.

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 23:22

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 23:12

The property has been sold. The tenant moved out. Those two actions together indicates both parties consider the tenancy over. Once the landlord went into the property after the tenant moved out, had viewings without giving notice to the tenant, he was acting as if the tenancy was over. The actions of both parties indicate implied surrender agreed by subsequent actions.

There's one main issue here. A fixed term tenancy is exactly that and notice cannot be given during the fixed term to end the tenancy within the fixed term unless there is a valid break clause exercised in accordance with the terms of the tenancy agreement or by mutual agreement. Op doesn't give an accurate timescale as to this so it's difficult to assess. But the landlord's actions are a bit odd.

If the ll successfully claims from the insurance that will be the end of the matter as the landlord cannot enrich themselves by being paid twice. The insurance company is unlikely to seek to indemnify themselves by going after the op. People very rarely stop paying rent for no reason. It's usually either they can't budget or they don't have the money and often a combination of both. Why would the insurance company issue proceedings against someone with no money. They don't bother ime.

oh I see what you mean, they asked to surrender but the landlord refused so not a mutual surrender as such, but in practice it has now been resolved. The landlord being paid out has fulfilled the tenants obligation to pay.

It could be the case that instead of being a heartless bastard he knew if he surrendered the agreement he wouldn't be paid out by the insurance for the full term of the contract, and it made more sense for him to claim on his insurance so he could get full 'missed' rent payments up to when the house was sold.

Goodread1 · 18/05/2023 23:18

Get in touch with Shelter charity which is connected to Citzens Advice bureau agency,

they act as a go between your Landlord and yourself,
they are pretty good, I have had support a few times with them in the past,

also get financial budget advise , with a good charities, that deals with low income issues for e.g citizens Advice bureau,
they can also act as a go between landlord and yourself, to sort out a reasonable payment plan offer ,grounded in reality , to put in place too.

Also they will find out on your behalf if you are entitled to any social security benefits Allowance,

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 23:17

To anyone reading, Mcmillan caseworkers are usually pretty good so self refer if you have cancer and are in financial difficulties. They can get grants to help to pay rent and other expenses, help with benefit applications including uc and pip, and help with budgeting.

DyslexicPoster · 18/05/2023 23:15

That's horrible OP. I would have let you give a month's notice in your circumstances. Time to pack up and leave without rush.

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 23:13

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 23:02

@sandyhappypeople the oP needs to clarify the break clause

With all due respect, the OP hasn't got to clarify shit, but:

The sale of the property went ahead before our 6 month break clause. That break clause is in 2 months time.

This is what I was referring to, it's in one of her replies, some tenancy agreements have them, some don't, this one obviously did so they could have been served notice to leave after 6 months anyway.

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 23:12

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 22:54

How so?

The property has been sold. The tenant moved out. Those two actions together indicates both parties consider the tenancy over. Once the landlord went into the property after the tenant moved out, had viewings without giving notice to the tenant, he was acting as if the tenancy was over. The actions of both parties indicate implied surrender agreed by subsequent actions.

There's one main issue here. A fixed term tenancy is exactly that and notice cannot be given during the fixed term to end the tenancy within the fixed term unless there is a valid break clause exercised in accordance with the terms of the tenancy agreement or by mutual agreement. Op doesn't give an accurate timescale as to this so it's difficult to assess. But the landlord's actions are a bit odd.

If the ll successfully claims from the insurance that will be the end of the matter as the landlord cannot enrich themselves by being paid twice. The insurance company is unlikely to seek to indemnify themselves by going after the op. People very rarely stop paying rent for no reason. It's usually either they can't budget or they don't have the money and often a combination of both. Why would the insurance company issue proceedings against someone with no money. They don't bother ime.

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 23:09

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 23:00

OP you need to make a claim for your deposit. It doesn't matter that you won't get any better but you need to make a claim.... and surely that will offset rent money owed?

She definitely should try claim it from the estate agents.

The landlord has been paid by his insurance so she doesn't owe any more money though.

The landlord tenant default insurance is specifically for when tenants are made redundant or are ill or 'fall on hard times' it pays out from the month the stopped paying to the end of the agreement (up to £50,000). The contract has been fulfilled by the insurance so there is nothing more to pay.

The only option the landlord would have is to take the tenant to small claims court over the loss of rent, but why would they pay out to do that when the tenant has got no money and the landlord has already been paid, it's fraudulent to try and now obtain that money from OP so wouldn't even make it through court, it's all bluster.

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/05/2023 23:04

I don’t think anyone in their right mind would give you a battering OP. You’ve had a horribly tough time.

I would get CAB (or Shelter if they offer a service) to help you with any written responses.

Other than that, I wouldn’t worry about it, what will happen you will agree a small payment each month that you can afford.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 23:02

@sandyhappypeople the oP needs to clarify the break clause

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 23:00

OP you need to make a claim for your deposit. It doesn't matter that you won't get any better but you need to make a claim.... and surely that will offset rent money owed?

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 22:58

imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:50

I know you've explained, but I've explained that when we got given the information that the landlord was selling, it explicitly said the landlord is only happy for us to stay as long as he doesn't have a buyer. If a buyer was found before the tenancy was up, the landlord wouldn't let us be at the property. We have that in writing.

Whether he's allowed to do that is another thing, but I don't know the ins and outs of the law and took that information as face value.

So taking my illness out of the equation, had he told us 4 days prior we wouldn't have signed the tenancy agreement. Purely by the fact of if a buyer came along, we would have to leave and had no idea how or when that would be.
We can't afford the property now because we can't pay 2 rents at once. Plus my income is non-existent.

We signed the tenancy with the intentions of having a secure and liable home only to be told 4 days later otherwise.

Perhaps I'm missing something. My brain is fucking fried and I'm so mentally and physically exhausted.

You're not missing anything OP, you're always going to get a mixed bag of responses on here, don't take any of it to heart.

I've had a look through all my landlord paperwork, I can't find anything that says the insurance company would look to recoup costs from you, the insurance is there for when tenants fall on hard times, due to redundancy or illness, change in circumstances and can no longer pay, a lot of tenants would stay in the property till they are removed, as they'd have no where to go, so you've done right by him by leaving straight away, he should have let you surrender anyway, but he's actually better off this way as he will have back claimed from when you stopped paying to the end of the term in the contract, best case scenario for him.

I mentioned it before up thread but if you have it in writing that the landlord has claimed from his insurance, then forward that to the letting agent to show resolution and that they should stop chasing you for payment, it may be automated on their end rather then them actually chasing you.

I wish you well OP, I hope things improve for you.

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 22:55

imogeneration · 18/05/2023 19:02

The buyer isn't an investor. It's a FTB family moving in.

I'm still currently under tenancy.
This is where the lines are blurring.

The tenancy has ended. This is not a blurred line.

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 22:54

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 22:49

This is rubbish. The property was surrendered by agreement.

How so?

PrincessofWellies · 18/05/2023 22:49

This is rubbish. The property was surrendered by agreement.

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 22:41

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 22:03

Ffs banging my head again.

Had the OP been told the house was being sold and not offered a contract thd new owners would very easy be able to end the tenancy.

The oP was given a fixed term agreement and this has a secure tenancy for a year. The new owners couldn't kick her out.

However the oP was no longer able to afford the rent and that's now "bad landlord".

Fucks sake

No wonder you're grumpy with all that head banging.

Had the OP been told the house was being sold and not offered a contract thd new owners would very easy be able to end the tenancy.

Agreed, assuming the new owners were landlords not residential owners you can't just 'end' a tenancy though, they would have to give notice (of whatever is stated in the agreement).

The oP was given a fixed term agreement and this has a secure tenancy for a year. The new owners couldn't kick her out.

The new owners wouldn't have been able to buy the property with a tenant in situ, without specialist conveyancing or a buy to let mortgage, which they obviously wouldn't have applied for because they cost more, you need more deposit and they are a family who want to live there, so it's a bit of a moot point, it would never have gotten that far.

Besides that, the contract contained a 'break clause' as the OP has mentioned that above, it's normally 6 months in and tenant and landlord can then give notice to leave. I assume that is what the landlord was planning, it takes a good 3 months to complete on a house purchase plus extra time to sell it, so that was probably why he got them to sign, so he had 6 months guaranteed rent.

However the oP was no longer able to afford the rent and that's now "bad landlord".

Can't it be both? Greedy landlord and unfortunate tenant, I'm sure the tenant would rather have stayed in the house and not have cancer, she has stated that that is the reason for the move.

I'm actually wondering, given that tenant default insurance isn't part of standard landlord insurance (it's an added extra), whether he had her sign a new contract JUST so he could claim off the insurance for loss of rent for the full 6/12 months anyway.

The reason he's being pegged as a bad landlord, at least by me, is that he's been paid by his insurance for the loss of rent, due to unforseen circumstances (the situation here is EXACTLY what you pay that for, tenants falling on hard times) and he's STILL pursuing the tenant.. even though he's already been paid out and she doesn't owe anything now. I still think he's committing insurance fraud by trying to reclaim the money from her.. I wonder if he'll give it back to the insurance company??

I can't feel sorry for the landlord, he's not out of pocket, he's not had any drama, he's got his house back clean and tidy and now sold, the only added thing he's had to do is put a claim into his insurance, who have paid, best case scenario for him to be fair.

I do however feel for the OP, she's got cancer, her world's falling to bits and she's got this shit now hanging over her head.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 22:03

Ffs banging my head again.

Had the OP been told the house was being sold and not offered a contract thd new owners would very easy be able to end the tenancy.

The oP was given a fixed term agreement and this has a secure tenancy for a year. The new owners couldn't kick her out.

However the oP was no longer able to afford the rent and that's now "bad landlord".

Fucks sake

sandyhappypeople · 18/05/2023 21:47

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 16:30

To all those saying he shouldn't have allowed her to sign a new tenancy - SHE WOULD BE HOMELESS. This tenancy gave her housing security for a year. Just because she couldn't afford it,

But she wouldn't BE homeless if she hadn't have signed the new contract. Written into a standard (1-2 year etc) tenancy agreement is that at the end of the term it will automatically move on to a 'rolling contract', normally giving landlord or tenant 1 or 2 months to give notice at any time after the initial tenancy period.

Signing a NEW contract for 1-2 years at that point only gives you security that the landlord isn't going to sell, and gives the landlord security that the tenant isn't going to up and leave within a couple of months, it makes sense for both parties assuming that they are in it for the long term.

As a landlord myself, he should NEVER have made them sign a new agreement knowing that he was immediately going to sell up. He also should have allowed them to surrender on the tenancy (with a 1-2 month notice period of course) because of her diagnosis, only a hard hearted bastard would make them pay for a property that they no longer can afford to live in. ESPECIALLY as he's already been paid out by the insurance for loss of rent and the property has now been sold! A tenancy agreement is only valid if one or both sides choose to enforce it.

I feel for the OP here, she didn't know he was selling up when they signed and she didn't know she was going to get cancer, she said she couldn't afford the rent and that's why she left? If she was someone you knew in real life would you be talking to her with such disdain?

What was the alternative? She could have chosen to stay there, not paid rent at all and wait until he dragged her through the courts to kick her out, house sale would have to be on hold until the matter was resolved, it takes months and months and costs thousands to get a tenant out who doesn't want to go.. he got off lucky when all things considered.

As a landlord.. and a human being.. I'd have let her walk straight away on her diagnosis alone.

sillyonehetpes · 18/05/2023 21:16

Jesus it's like banging my head against a brick wall.

You signed a tenancy which guarantees A tenancy.

Your landlord selling means nothing. Stop using it as an excuse. You can't afford the rent.