Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be furious about sudden change?

139 replies

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 12:08

I have a lovely SIL who lives in Canada and visits every few years. After Christmas she let us know she'd be over here in May and June, catching up with family and friends before her partner comes over and they embark on six weeks in Europe.

She's due to arrive here (south coast) on Sunday after several days in London. She'll spend two nights here, then take off with DH and his other DS to various points in Devon and Cornwall, ending up staying with friends in their holiday home in Fowey for four nights. A trip to Lundy has been booked and paid for, overnights in three nice hotels have been booked. They're all getting older and they want to have a really great week together.

DH is under a lot of pressure at work and has been moody and fed-up in the last few months. He went into dither mode at the point we needed to start preparing for SIL's visit so I've been slowly getting on with it on my own, including redecorating the spare bedroom, buying new linen and towels, getting a leaking en suite tap replaced etc. I've paid a local handywoman to sand down and paint garden furniture and we have a gardener coming in on Friday to mow the lawns and do a little weeding and trimming. The window cleaner's coming tomorrow. I'm planning to valet the car on Friday. I just want the place to be as clean, fresh and as comfortable as possible — for her, but also for us when she's gone.

I've been really looking forward to seeing her again but am also longing for the moment when they all pile into the car and head west and I have the house to myself. I've got a lot of freelance work piling up and DH and I really need a short break from each other: he's been bringing his work home too frequently.

Then last night, as we were going to bed, he announced that he thought it would be far better if, instead of doing a road trip, they all just stayed here for most of the week and then went to Fowey for a couple of days. That would mean having guests for five or even six nights: extra dinners: extra days trying to work with them around the house, extra days walking the tightrope of trying to be hospitable while also finding a bit of space for me. I said no, everything was booked and they'd have a great time. This morning he's had a conversation along the lines of he doesn't understand me, I've made such a ridiculous fuss about his DS coming to stay and I didn't need to, she'd have taken us as she found us and anyway what difference would it be having him and his sisters around all week, they'd go off for a few hours each day exploring and walking and all it really meant was two extra for dinner each evening...

AIBU? It's really come home to me how desperate I am to have a week's break away from him and the domestic duties that come with hosting. I'm tempted to say I'll go on the road trip and they can stay here and look after themselves.

OP posts:
LaurieFairyCake · 17/05/2023 14:30

Nah.... FUCK THAT!

He goes or you go !

Start eyeing up a nice quiet B and B by the sea where you can work in peace

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 17/05/2023 14:25

🚨🚨 if DH wants to work on the days she's here 🚨🚨

No.
Just no.
His sister is visiting.
He'll be too busy to work.
She's staying at his as well as your home.
He has the honour of ferrying her around and cooking for her entertaining her.

MarkWithaC · 17/05/2023 14:17

Hmm I wonder if people who on paper are all cool and welcoming to guests- the more the merrier, take us as you find us, stay as long as you like ..are like this in reality.
Sorry to disappoint ,but I for one really am.

Op could have welcomed her sil into her home and said “Sorry you’ve got no towels, I didn’t buy any you’ll have to share with dh Come on, that's just silly. There is a middle ground between buying new towels and making people share existing ones.

Wilkolampshade · 17/05/2023 14:14

I'd be pissed off too OP. And I totally get the amount of effort you've put in, it's exactly what we would do - using the deadline to spruce things up. Perfectly normal. At least that effort won't be wasted, it'll still look lovely when they're gone.

Sounds a bit like your DH has gone rogue. Is his head too far up his own arse with work atm? Mine gets like this very occasionally and needs a reminder of where his priorities should be. Has your DH run the change of plan past his siblings? Could you possibly 'get in there first' and see what they want to do? Unless there's been some massive miscommunication I would think they're very much looking forward to their trip?!?

MarkWithaC · 17/05/2023 14:13

We had someone unexpectedly stay over on Coronation weekend and my partner was all 'Why haven't we got olives? Why isn't the spare bed made up?'
This is the problem, isn't it, not the guests themselves or the change per se.
Make it clear to him that you've planned, work-wise and mentally/in terms of being in 'guest mode', for the original agreed days. Any more than that and you will be unavailable due to being busy with work and will not be catering and hosting. I wonder if he'll change his tune if he hears that?

As an aside, and in the nicest way, it does sound as though you're adding to your stress by holding yourself to very high standards. If your SIL is as lovely as you say, she won't care (or even notice maybe) your 'greying wooden table that has been hastily wiped of bird poo, lichen and general grot'. My guests sit at that sort of table if they come to mine and sit outside Grin and no one minds; you're there to spend valuable time together, not to judge an interiors competition.

And there is no 'of course' about what you cook or if you do puddings, or provide cake or snacks. Again, 'lovely' guests won't mind/notice and will even contribute by bringing cake back from their day out for everyone, or making/buying in a pudding, or offering to cook sometimes or to be sous chef.

I reiterate, though – you need to make clear to your DH that you have not planned for this sudden change of mind and that you are not the cook cum housekeeper, which seems to be how he treats you.

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 14:03

which means I get stuck with bored houseguests stalking about the house while I'm trying to work because he's over-promised that he'll actually have time for them. It really is much easier if they all go somewhere else. Even if he still needs to work, I don't have them sat in my kitchen looking bored and wanting to be entertained.

Yes, this. Canadian SIL won't have her own transport and will be with us for two nights before UK SIL turns up. So if DH wants to work on the days she's here I strongly suspect I'm going to feel the pressure to take her out. Which will be fine for a day or two, but I'm not going to do it every day if they decide to stay here. In fact I'm even more certain that if they decide to stay here, I'll find somewhere else to go.

OP posts:
pussycatinfluffyslippers · 17/05/2023 14:02

@purplevipersgrass Chuck him the pinny and the pans and he can cook. Can they go out during the day without you?
🤞
Good luck - I'd put a limit of 4 nights and he cooks for 2 of them, and more than that and he'd be going with them for the rest of their trip or permanently Wink

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 17/05/2023 14:01

Calm down Hyacinth! Why are you doing so much work for a SIL? Run the hoover round and put some wine in the fridge!

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 14:01

Lcb123 · 17/05/2023 13:50

It's annoying but your preparation for her stay is excessive. Just run the hoover round, change bedding and make sure there's food in. Tell you have to work in the day, she can help herself or go out to eat. Sorry but sounds like this is more a problem between you and DH, rather than the SIL.

Hmm I wonder if people who on paper are all cool and welcoming to guests- the more the merrier, take us as you find us, stay as long as you like ..are like this in reality.

Op could have welcomed her sil into her home and said “Sorry you’ve got no towels, I didn’t buy any you’ll have to share with dh, the tap doesn’t work in the en suite either and be careful of splinters and birdshit if you use the garden table.
Ive cooked for dh and I, you can rustle up your own meal.

DollyParkin · 17/05/2023 13:58

He needs to do the planning, shopping, catering, and clearing up for his siblings, and you need to set some boundaries to get on with work.

If your DH's work has been stressful the last few months, he may just want a bit of a holiday at home - I know that's what I like to do, as well as travel, on my rare opportunities for holidays.

But you can't be the caterer this time!

Gerwurtztraminer · 17/05/2023 13:57

@purplevipersgrass I totally get the tidying and refreshing they house & garden before her visit It's normal to use deadlines like people coming to stay to get long delayed jobs finally done. And my SiL is like yours - her house is always immaculate and I feel like a slob in comparison so I do make extra effort in cleaning & decluttering etc when some people like her are coming. My best friend gets clean sheets and some dusting of the spare room and that's it.

And needing a 'respite break' from DH doesn't necessarily mean your marriage is in trouble either. It sounds like the past few years have been tough and with DH bringing work problems home you are worn down. Of course you need a break - living together can be hard and surely even the posters criticising you need time out occasionally from their partners.

Just tell him that you think his sisters will be disappointed if he cancels and it's letting them down. because it's really mean of him to do that in my view). He's asked for your opinion and you've given it; you think he should go. Then back off and don't discuss or debate it again.

If he does cancel then be clear he is the co-host and you expect him to pull his weight with food & wine ordering and cooking and NOT to be working whilst sisters are here. (and like others suggested I'd then book some time away somewhere on your own after they leave, even if working whilst there).

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 13:56

FreestyleInTrance · 17/05/2023 13:39

YANBU. I would be gutted if I was expecting a week to myself and instead I got a week with my husband and two house guests, even house guests I really like! It's not just 'two extra for dinner', it's three, and the kind of things I'd eat alone are nothing like the kind of thing I'd serve guests.

Thank you for making the point about food. DH and I eat well enough but usually just the standard chillies and curries and stir fries and pasta bakes that most people do. I try to do something a notch up the scale from our usual everyday meals when we have guests. And of course when you've got guests you have to do puddings too. And cake or snacks to offer when people have been out all day and pile in at 4.30pm, hungry.

OP posts:
mindutopia · 17/05/2023 13:55

Actually, yes, I'd be annoyed in your situation. Because even if you 'refuse to host', you do have to tolerate people's presence in your house. BIL and his partner come to stay usually twice a year. It's a real pain. I do make sure that dh does the bulk of the prep, but it's still having 2 extra people in your house and all the chaos that causes. If I refused to engage with them or do things with them, it would be seen as rude. They are a pretty laidback family, but it would be odd as a partner to avoid your houseguests for a week. Frankly, I'd love nothing more than if they went off and did something for the week and left me home alone with/out dc and with all the animals to care for. It would be wonderful.

I do wonder though, if your dh is suggesting they all stay home, will it just mean that he works and pushing hosting duties off on you? It sounds like he is struggling to have healthy work-life balance. I know in our case, dh (who runs his own business) regularly invites people to come stay and swears that he will do things with them, but it's not unusual to have to spend some time working while they are here which means I get stuck with bored houseguests stalking about the house while I'm trying to work because he's over-promised that he'll actually have time for them. It really is much easier if they all go somewhere else. Even if he still needs to work, I don't have them sat in my kitchen looking bored and wanting to be entertained.

OopsAnotherOne · 17/05/2023 13:53

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 13:40

He might get another attack of “dither mode” though 😂

Honestly I do agree, but that becomes DH's problem. His suggestion puts more work onto the OP, if he expects her to do it, I'd suggest she goes into "dither mode" too!

Lcb123 · 17/05/2023 13:50

It's annoying but your preparation for her stay is excessive. Just run the hoover round, change bedding and make sure there's food in. Tell you have to work in the day, she can help herself or go out to eat. Sorry but sounds like this is more a problem between you and DH, rather than the SIL.

LauderSyme · 17/05/2023 13:47

YANBU. In your shoes I'd be gutted too; I need to spend time alone to relax and recuperate from too much other people, and I'd have been treasuring the thought of an upcoming oasis of space and peace.

Tell DH no, that any change of plans is absolutely off the table. I can't see DSIL's being too chuffed about it and it's not fair of him to flip-flop after so many arrangements have been made.

Well done for attacking so many items on your to-do list. Being motivated by impending visitors is neither here nor there, despite what some pp's said. I salute you!

Goodoccasionallypoor · 17/05/2023 13:43

Op, do you like your husband? Do you want to remain married?

I understand the need for alone time, I need it too, but this sounds like the issue is your relationship with your husband, not the guests.

purplevipersgrass · 17/05/2023 13:40

Thank you for understanding, viques.

Which would you rather sit down to eat at on a lovely May day, in the sunshine?

A greying wooden table that has been hastily wiped of bird poo, lichen and general grot or a table that's been washed down thoroughly, sanded and painted or varnished to make it easier to wipe down and keep clean?

OP posts:
diddl · 17/05/2023 13:40

Can't see the other sisters agreeing tbh.

Could you go with them if husband doesn't want to?

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 13:40

OopsAnotherOne · 17/05/2023 13:37

"No worries DH, but as that obviously requires them to stay for longer at ours, meaning they'll need more breakfasts and dinners cooking for them etc plus the additional cleaning to do during and after their stay, as long as you're prepared to take on the extra workload, I have no problem with the last minute request!"

He might get another attack of “dither mode” though 😂

FreestyleInTrance · 17/05/2023 13:39

YANBU. I would be gutted if I was expecting a week to myself and instead I got a week with my husband and two house guests, even house guests I really like! It's not just 'two extra for dinner', it's three, and the kind of things I'd eat alone are nothing like the kind of thing I'd serve guests.

SmileyClare · 17/05/2023 13:39

Dh went into dither mode

That just sounds like he didn’t bother spending any time or energy thinking about the logistics until now (3 days before they arrive).

He expects you to pick up the slack

OopsAnotherOne · 17/05/2023 13:37

"No worries DH, but as that obviously requires them to stay for longer at ours, meaning they'll need more breakfasts and dinners cooking for them etc plus the additional cleaning to do during and after their stay, as long as you're prepared to take on the extra workload, I have no problem with the last minute request!"

Aprilx · 17/05/2023 13:36

beeskipa · 17/05/2023 13:30

'Oh, you'd got respite care planned and now they've cancelled.' That's how I feel.

That you feel like this about your marriage is the bigger problem here, I think.

I agree that there seems to be some quite serious marital problems here. I cannot imagine needing “respite” from my husband. And we are not joined at the hip and in fact I went in holiday without him earlier this year but that is because I wanted to go somewhere he didn’t, I certainly didn’t need respite from him.

Justalittlebitduckling · 17/05/2023 13:35

Tell him as long as he does all the meal prep and cooking, by all means they can crack on.